Gilmore Girls Elimination Game

[ghoulina]

6, 7,8

[elang4]

6, 12, 19

[Guest]

50 minutes ago, Taryn74 said:

Oooh, I'm intrigued!  What do you like/love about it??  (And the gif is cracking me up, too.)

I just do.  I think everyone acts ridiculous in it - completely ridiculous. Lorelai for not attending a single FND and then thinking she can just decide to attend this one, Rory for not speaking up when Logan tried his prank, and Emily with the maid and L's drink, etc.  But I love anytime it's Richard and Yale. Like, there is something so charming to me.  Hearing him defend Kropogs when Lorelai tries using it as a measure of volume always makes me laugh. I also love Rory trying to memorize everything about Mitchum (it's one of the last times we see Rory being super dedicated to something) and eventually leveraging her knowledge of his coffee habits to succeeding a little at her internship. Also, I like Logan.  We've all argued before about the prank he tried and I don't want to rehash it in this thread, but overall, he was a charming guest.  The look on his face when he realized his prank was going awry, etc.  Plus just the fact he was there for Rory and did his best to please her grandparents to please her.

[Guest]

12, 15, 22

[lulu1960]

6, 8, 18

There are parts I love in all of these, (Like "my own cheesecake?"), but then TJ ruins it.

[Bumblebee Tights]

1 hour ago, deaja said:

I also love Rory trying to memorize everything about Mitchum (it's one of the last times we see Rory being super dedicated to something) and eventually leveraging her knowledge of his coffee habits to succeeding a little at her internship. Also, I like Logan.  

Sorry about Kropogs! I can actually agree with this much (although I think I more appreciate Logan than like him? I'm not even sure..I do enjoy Rory/Logan for the most part ..I like him least in S5 though)

I just haaaate the dinner start to finish. I almost feel uncomfortable watching it because I dislike it so much.

Like @lulu1960 says, I can find parts to like in most of these episodes. For me, there's still a lot to like in S5, although it's definitely easier to eliminate from than any of the first four seasons.

 

8,17,22.

[Kohola3]

10, 17, 19

[Taryn74]

6, 8, 19 gone!

Season 5

1.  Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller

2.  A Messenger, Nothing More

3.  Written in the Stars

4.  Tippecanoe and Taylor, Too

7.  You Jump, I Jump, Jack

9.  Emily Says Hello

10.  But Not As Cute As Pushkin

11.  Women of Questionable Morals

12.  Come Home

13.  Wedding Bell Blues

14.  Say Something

15.  Jews & Chinese Food

16.  So . . . Good Talk

17.  Pulp Friction

18.  To Live and Let Diorama

22.  A House is Not a Home

[Kohola3]

10, 11, 17

[elang4]

4, 9, 12

[lulu1960]

9,(I do love the porch kiss, though), 13, (Grrrrr, Chris) 18

[ghoulina]

4, 7, 13

[Bumblebee Tights]

9,17,22

[Guest]

12, 15, 22

[Taryn74]

4, 9, 17 out!

Season 5

1.  Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller

2.  A Messenger, Nothing More

3.  Written in the Stars

7.  You Jump, I Jump, Jack

10.  But Not As Cute As Pushkin

11.  Women of Questionable Morals

12.  Come Home

13.  Wedding Bell Blues

14.  Say Something

15.  Jews & Chinese Food

16.  So . . . Good Talk

18.  To Live and Let Diorama

22.  A House is Not a Home

[lulu1960]

12, 13, 18

[Kohola3]

10, 11, 18

[ghoulina]

7, 13, 18

[elang4]

12, 13, 15

[Guest]

12, 15, 22

[Bumblebee Tights]

11,18,22

[Taryn74]

Diorama!  Noooo!  :(  12, 13, and 18 are gonesies.

Season 5

1.  Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller

2.  A Messenger, Nothing More

3.  Written in the Stars

7.  You Jump, I Jump, Jack

10.  But Not As Cute As Pushkin

11.  Women of Questionable Morals

14.  Say Something

15.  Jews & Chinese Food

16.  So . . . Good Talk

22.  A House is Not a Home

[elang4]

10, 15, 22

[Bumblebee Tights]

11,15,22

[Guest]

15, 22 for the third round in a row. 14 for my new entry. :)

[lulu1960]

1,11, 22

[Kohola3]

10, 11, 22

[ghoulina]

1, 7, 22

(Bracing myself to lose 11, which is arguably one of my favorite of the entire series, simply for the dog storyline. Sigh....)

[Taryn74]

20 minutes ago, ghoulina said:

(Bracing myself to lose 11, which is arguably one of my favorite of the entire series, simply for the dog storyline. Sigh....)

I'd have saved it if I could!  I wouldn't say it's a favorite of the entire series for me, but certainly of S5.

Alas, 11, 15, and 22 are gone!

I don't think there's any reason to drag out Season 5, heh.  Go ahead and vote OUT the FOUR you don't want moving on.

Season 5

1.  Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller

2.  A Messenger, Nothing More

3.  Written in the Stars

7.  You Jump, I Jump, Jack

10.  But Not As Cute As Pushkin

14.  Say Something

16.  So . . . Good Talk

[Guest]

1,7,14,16

[elang4]

1, 10, 14, 16

[lulu1960]

1, 7, 14, 10

[ghoulina]

1, 7, 14, 16

[Bumblebee Tights]

This is actually a decent group of episodes, for me.

1,2,14,16

[Kohola3]

1, 2, 7, 10

[Taryn74]

Moving on from Season 5: 

A Messenger, Nothing More; Written in the Stars; But Not As Cute As Pushkin

I'm going to try to find time (and remember, heh) here in a bit to come back in and add Season 6, but I'm leaving for a vendor event after lunch and I still have to do my nails (which is what I sell, so I can't let that slide, ha!) plus a ton of other things before I leave, so no promises.  Somebody comment on the thread so it will show up as unread though, in case I forget!  Thanks!

[Kohola3]

I'll be off the grid in AK for a couple of weeks so carry on.  Unless I can vote out all of 6 and all but the last of 7 as an absentee ballot.

[Taryn74]

1 hour ago, Kohola3 said:

Unless I can vote out all of 6 and all but the last of 7 as an absentee ballot.

Ha ha ha, noted!

 

Season 6:

New and Improved Lorelai

Fight Face

The UnGraduate

Always a Godmother, Never a God

We've Got Magic to Do

Welcome to the Dollhouse

21 is the Loneliest Number

Let Me Hear Your Balalaikas Ring Out

The Prodigal Daughter Returns

He's Slippin' 'Em Bread, Dig?

The Perfect Dress

Just Like Gwen & Gavin

Friday Night's Alright for Fighting

You've Been Gilmored

A Vineyard Valentine

Bridesmaids Revisited

I'm Okay, You're Okay

The Real Paul Anka

I Get a Sidekick Out of You

Super Cool Party People

Driving Miss Gilmore

Partings

[Guest]

Where to start.....

Bridesmaids Revisited

Vineyard Valentine

Driving Miss Gilmore

Unless we can start by voting for like.... ten?  ;)

[Bumblebee Tights]

He's Slippin 'em Bread, Vineyard Valentine (which is absolutely my least favorite in the entire series), Bridesmaids Revisited.

[ghoulina]

Ugh, yea, this is hard for the opposite reason of previous votes. 

 

New and Improved

Vinyard Valentine

Bridesmaids

[lulu1960]

Bridesmaids, Partings, Driving Miss Gilmore

[Taryn74]

Bridesmaids, AVV (arguably the WORST ep of the entire series!) and Driving Miss Gilmore are all out, not surprisingly.

Also, I forgot to number the episodes yesterday, sorry!

Season 6:

1.  New and Improved Lorelai

2.  Fight Face

3.  The UnGraduate

4.  Always a Godmother, Never a God

5.  We've Got Magic to Do

6.  Welcome to the Dollhouse

7.  21 is the Loneliest Number

8.  Let Me Hear Your Balalaikas Ring Out

9.  The Prodigal Daughter Returns

10.  He's Slippin' 'Em Bread, Dig?

11.  The Perfect Dress

12.  Just Like Gwen & Gavin

13.  Friday Night's Alright for Fighting

14.  You've Been Gilmored

17.  I'm Okay, You're Okay

18.  The Real Paul Anka

19.  I Get a Sidekick Out of You

20.  Super Cool Party People

22.  Partings

[ghoulina]

1, 10, 12

[Guest]

4, 11, 22

[lulu1960]

4, 10, 22

[Bumblebee Tights]

10,12,22

[elang4]

2, 12, 22

[Lady Calypso]

2, 10, 22

[Taryn74]

10, 12, 22 gone!

Season 6:

1.  New and Improved Lorelai

2.  Fight Face

3.  The UnGraduate

4.  Always a Godmother, Never a God

5.  We've Got Magic to Do

6.  Welcome to the Dollhouse

7.  21 is the Loneliest Number

8.  Let Me Hear Your Balalaikas Ring Out

9.  The Prodigal Daughter Returns

11.  The Perfect Dress

13.  Friday Night's Alright for Fighting

14.  You've Been Gilmored

17.  I'm Okay, You're Okay

18.  The Real Paul Anka

19.  I Get a Sidekick Out of You

20.  Super Cool Party People