Supernatural Survival Game

[Demented Daisy]

We've been voting this round for 6 weeks.  Yikes.  

[catrox14]

+Frontierland

-- Changing Channels

--Weekend at Bobby's

 

11 - Bad Day at Black Rock

10 - Hollywood Babylon

10 - Fan Fiction

08 - Mystery Spot

07 - Frontierland

06 - Changing Channels

05 - Weekend at Bobby's

04 - Tall Tales

 

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...

Swap Meat

Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!

Fallen Idols

Slumber Party

Clap Your Hands If You Believe

Party On Garth

The Curious Case of Dean Winchester

How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters

LARP and the Real Girl

Ghostfacers

Out with the Old

Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie

The Usual Suspects

Wishful Thinking

The Real Ghostbusters

Nightshifter

Hammer of the Gods

Yellow Fever

Everybody Hates Hitler

Hunteri Heroici

Monster at the End of This Book

Hell House

Ask Jeeves

Monster Movie

It's a Terrible Life

Hibbing 911

Reading is Fundamental

The French Mistake

About a Boy

Slash Fiction

Dog Dean Afternoon

Folsom Prison Blues

[SueB]

+ Mystery Spot
-- Bad Day at Black Rock
-- Hollywood Babylon


10 - Fan Fiction

09 - Bad Day at Black Rock

09 - Mystery Spot
08 - Hollywood Babylon
07 - Frontierland
06 - Changing Channels
05 - Weekend at Bobby's
04 - Tall Tales

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...
Swap Meat
Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!
Fallen Idols
Slumber Party
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Party On Garth
The Curious Case of Dean Winchester
How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
LARP and the Real Girl
Ghostfacers
Out with the Old
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
The Usual Suspects
Wishful Thinking
The Real Ghostbusters
Nightshifter
Hammer of the Gods
Yellow Fever
Everybody Hates Hitler
Hunteri Heroici
Monster at the End of This Book
Hell House
Ask Jeeves
Monster Movie
It's a Terrible Life
Hibbing 911
Reading is Fundamental
The French Mistake
About a Boy
Slash Fiction
Dog Dean Afternoon
Folsom Prison Blues

[AwesomO4000]

-- Frontierland

+ Fan Fiction

-- Tall Tales

 

11 - Fan Fiction

09 - Bad Day at Black Rock

09 - Mystery Spot
08 - Hollywood Babylon
06 - Changing Channels

05 - Frontierland

05 - Weekend at Bobby's
02 - Tall Tales

 

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...
Swap Meat
Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!
Fallen Idols
Slumber Party
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Party On Garth
The Curious Case of Dean Winchester
How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
LARP and the Real Girl
Ghostfacers
Out with the Old
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
The Usual Suspects
Wishful Thinking
The Real Ghostbusters
Nightshifter
Hammer of the Gods
Yellow Fever
Everybody Hates Hitler
Hunteri Heroici
Monster at the End of This Book
Hell House
Ask Jeeves
Monster Movie
It's a Terrible Life
Hibbing 911
Reading is Fundamental
The French Mistake
About a Boy
Slash Fiction
Dog Dean Afternoon
Folsom Prison Blues

[Demented Daisy]

Bad Day at Black Rock +

Fan Fiction --

Frontierland --

 

10 - Bad Day at Black Rock

09 - Fan Fiction

09 - Mystery Spot
08 - Hollywood Babylon
06 - Changing Channels
05 - Weekend at Bobby's

03 - Frontierland

02 - Tall Tales

 

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...
Swap Meat
Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!
Fallen Idols
Slumber Party
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Party On Garth
The Curious Case of Dean Winchester
How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
LARP and the Real Girl
Ghostfacers
Out with the Old
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
The Usual Suspects
Wishful Thinking
The Real Ghostbusters
Nightshifter
Hammer of the Gods
Yellow Fever
Everybody Hates Hitler
Hunteri Heroici
Monster at the End of This Book
Hell House
Ask Jeeves
Monster Movie
It's a Terrible Life
Hibbing 911
Reading is Fundamental
The French Mistake
About a Boy
Slash Fiction
Dog Dean Afternoon
Folsom Prison Blues

Edited August 8, 2015 by Demented Daisy

[DittyDotDot]

-- Fan Fiction
-- Mystery Spot
-- Frontierland
 

 

10 - Bad Day at Black Rock
08 - Hollywood Babylon

07 - Fan Fiction
07 - Mystery Spot
06 - Changing Channels

05 - Weekend at Bobby's
02 - Tall Tales

01 - Frontierland

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...
Swap Meat
Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!
Fallen Idols
Slumber Party
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Party On Garth
The Curious Case of Dean Winchester
How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
LARP and the Real Girl
Ghostfacers
Out with the Old
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
The Usual Suspects
Wishful Thinking
The Real Ghostbusters
Nightshifter
Hammer of the Gods
Yellow Fever
Everybody Hates Hitler
Hunteri Heroici
Monster at the End of This Book
Hell House
Ask Jeeves
Monster Movie
It's a Terrible Life
Hibbing 911
Reading is Fundamental
The French Mistake
About a Boy
Slash Fiction
Dog Dean Afternoon
Folsom Prison Blues

[SueB]

08 - Bad Day at Black Rock
08 - Fan Fiction
07 - Mystery Spot

06 - Hollywood Babylon
06 - Changing Channels
05 - Weekend at Bobby's
02 - Tall Tales
01 - Frontierland

 

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...
Swap Meat
Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!
Fallen Idols
Slumber Party
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Party On Garth
The Curious Case of Dean Winchester
How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
LARP and the Real Girl
Ghostfacers
Out with the Old
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
The Usual Suspects
Wishful Thinking
The Real Ghostbusters
Nightshifter
Hammer of the Gods
Yellow Fever
Everybody Hates Hitler
Hunteri Heroici
Monster at the End of This Book
Hell House
Ask Jeeves
Monster Movie
It's a Terrible Life
Hibbing 911
Reading is Fundamental
The French Mistake
About a Boy
Slash Fiction
Dog Dean Afternoon
Folsom Prison Blues

[AwesomO4000]

For some reason, I feel ruthless tonight, so I'm gonna go ahead and eliminate the bottom two.

 

Despite some potentially questionable humor, "Tall Tales" had some truly funny moments. RIP "TT." Go have a purple nurple in celebration of making the top 10.

 

And goodbye, "Frontierland." You had some truly funny bits. I loved the whole Clint Eastwood movie exchange, "That poor horse," and Dean being a posse magnet. I agree though with whoever it was above who said that having the Phoenix be sympathetic was a bit of a downer aspect of the episode.

 

-- Tall Tales

- Frontierland

+ Hollywood Babylon

 

08 - Bad Day at Black Rock
08 - Fan Fiction
07 - Mystery Spot

07 - Hollywood Babylon
06 - Changing Channels
05 - Weekend at Bobby's
 

 

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...
Swap Meat
Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!
Fallen Idols
Slumber Party
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Party On Garth
The Curious Case of Dean Winchester
How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
LARP and the Real Girl
Ghostfacers
Out with the Old
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
The Usual Suspects
Wishful Thinking
The Real Ghostbusters
Nightshifter
Hammer of the Gods
Yellow Fever
Everybody Hates Hitler
Hunteri Heroici
Monster at the End of This Book
Hell House
Ask Jeeves
Monster Movie
It's a Terrible Life
Hibbing 911
Reading is Fundamental
The French Mistake
About a Boy
Slash Fiction
Dog Dean Afternoon
Folsom Prison Blues

Tall Tales

Frontierland

Edited August 9, 2015 by AwesomO4000

[catrox14]

Changing my votes since Awesome posted right before me

RIP Frontierland. I will surrender and mercy kill you. I love you. You're my favorite episode of s6 Dean in his silly cowboy clothes and a blanket....to hilarious... And the SO HOT in his actual awesome cowboy clothes and a Stetson...and Sam on a horse. Posse magnet will never not be funny to me.

Yippee-ki-yay motherf....

+Hollywood Babylon

--Fan Fiction

--Bad Day at Black Rock

08 - Hollywood Babylon

07 - Mystery Spot

06 - Bad Day at Black Rock

06 - Fan Fiction

06 - Changing Channels

05 - Weekend at Bobby's

 

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...

Swap Meat

Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!

Fallen Idols

Slumber Party

Clap Your Hands If You Believe

Party On Garth

The Curious Case of Dean Winchester

How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters

LARP and the Real Girl

Ghostfacers

Out with the Old

Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie

The Usual Suspects

Wishful Thinking

The Real Ghostbusters

Nightshifter

Hammer of the Gods

Yellow Fever

Everybody Hates Hitler

Hunteri Heroici

Monster at the End of This Book

Hell House

Ask Jeeves

Monster Movie

It's a Terrible Life

Hibbing 911

Reading is Fundamental

The French Mistake

About a Boy

Slash Fiction

Dog Dean Afternoon

Folsom Prison Blues

Edited August 9, 2015 by catrox14

[AwesomO4000]

Crap, sorry catrox... I changed my votes, because I missed SueB's...

 

So then I changed my votes, because her votes changed how I wanted to vote. So sorry about that, yours are likely off now. I would change them for you, but you might also want to change yous after my change in vote.

[catrox14]

LOL I'll change my votes awesome

OKAY I think it's sorted out now.

+Hollywood Babylon
--Fan Fiction
--Bad Day at Black Rock

08 - Hollywood Babylon
07 - Mystery Spot
06 - Bad Day at Black Rock
06 - Fan Fiction
06 - Changing Channels
05 - Weekend at Bobby's

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...
Swap Meat
Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!
Fallen Idols
Slumber Party
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Party On Garth
The Curious Case of Dean Winchester
How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
LARP and the Real Girl
Ghostfacers
Out with the Old
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
The Usual Suspects
Wishful Thinking
The Real Ghostbusters
Nightshifter
Hammer of the Gods
Yellow Fever
Everybody Hates Hitler
Hunteri Heroici
Monster at the End of This Book
Hell House
Ask Jeeves
Monster Movie
It's a Terrible Life
Hibbing 911
Reading is Fundamental
The French Mistake
About a Boy
Slash Fiction
Dog Dean Afternoon
Folsom Prison Blues

Edited August 9, 2015 by catrox14

[DittyDotDot]

+ Hollywood Babylon
-- Mystery Spot
+ Bad Day at Black Rock

 

09 - Hollywood Babylon
07 - Bad Day at Black Rock
06 - Fan Fiction
06 - Changing Channels
05 - Weekend at Bobby's

05 - Mystery Spot

 

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...
Swap Meat
Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!
Fallen Idols
Slumber Party
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Party On Garth
The Curious Case of Dean Winchester
How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
LARP and the Real Girl
Ghostfacers
Out with the Old
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
The Usual Suspects
Wishful Thinking
The Real Ghostbusters
Nightshifter
Hammer of the Gods
Yellow Fever
Everybody Hates Hitler
Hunteri Heroici
Monster at the End of This Book
Hell House
Ask Jeeves
Monster Movie
It's a Terrible Life
Hibbing 911
Reading is Fundamental
The French Mistake
About a Boy
Slash Fiction
Dog Dean Afternoon
Folsom Prison Blues
Tall Tales
Frontierland

[Demented Daisy]

Fan Fiction --

Hollywood Babylon -- (I hate to do this, but....)

Bad Day at Black Rock +

 

08 - Bad Day at Black Rock

07 - Hollywood Babylon

06 - Changing Channels

05 - Weekend at Bobby's
05 - Mystery Spot

04 - Fan Fiction
 

 

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...
Swap Meat
Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!
Fallen Idols
Slumber Party
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Party On Garth
The Curious Case of Dean Winchester
How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
LARP and the Real Girl
Ghostfacers
Out with the Old
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
The Usual Suspects
Wishful Thinking
The Real Ghostbusters
Nightshifter
Hammer of the Gods
Yellow Fever
Everybody Hates Hitler
Hunteri Heroici
Monster at the End of This Book
Hell House
Ask Jeeves
Monster Movie
It's a Terrible Life
Hibbing 911
Reading is Fundamental
The French Mistake
About a Boy
Slash Fiction
Dog Dean Afternoon
Folsom Prison Blues
Tall Tales
Frontierland

[SueB]

+ Mystery Spot
-- Hollywood Babylon
-- Bad Day at Black Rock 

06 - Bad Day at Black Rock
06 - Changing Channels

06 - Mystery Spot

05 - Hollywood Babylon

05 - Weekend at Bobby's
04 - Fan Fiction


Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...
Swap Meat
Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!
Fallen Idols
Slumber Party
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Party On Garth
The Curious Case of Dean Winchester
How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
LARP and the Real Girl
Ghostfacers
Out with the Old
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
The Usual Suspects
Wishful Thinking
The Real Ghostbusters
Nightshifter
Hammer of the Gods
Yellow Fever
Everybody Hates Hitler
Hunteri Heroici
Monster at the End of This Book
Hell House
Ask Jeeves
Monster Movie
It's a Terrible Life
Hibbing 911
Reading is Fundamental
The French Mistake
About a Boy
Slash Fiction
Dog Dean Afternoon
Folsom Prison Blues
Tall Tales
Frontierland

[AwesomO4000]

Crap.

 

- Bad Day at Black Rock

+ Fan Fiction

- Weekend at Bobby's

 

06 - Changing Channels

06 - Mystery Spot

05 - Bad Day at Black Rock

05 - Hollywood Babylon

05 - Fan Fiction

04 - Weekend at Bobby's
 

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...
Swap Meat
Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!
Fallen Idols
Slumber Party
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Party On Garth
The Curious Case of Dean Winchester
How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
LARP and the Real Girl
Ghostfacers
Out with the Old
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
The Usual Suspects
Wishful Thinking
The Real Ghostbusters
Nightshifter
Hammer of the Gods
Yellow Fever
Everybody Hates Hitler
Hunteri Heroici
Monster at the End of This Book
Hell House
Ask Jeeves
Monster Movie
It's a Terrible Life
Hibbing 911
Reading is Fundamental
The French Mistake
About a Boy
Slash Fiction
Dog Dean Afternoon
Folsom Prison Blues
Tall Tales
Frontierland

[catrox14]

 

--Changing Channels

+ Hollywood Babylon

--Weekend at Bobby's

06 - Hollywood Babylon

06 - Mystery Spot

05 - Bad Day at Black Rock

05 - Fan fiction

04 - Changing Channels

02 - Weekend at Bobby's

 

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...

Swap Meat

Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!

Fallen Idols

Slumber Party

Clap Your Hands If You Believe

Party On Garth

The Curious Case of Dean Winchester

How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters

LARP and the Real Girl

Ghostfacers

Out with the Old

Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie

The Usual Suspects

Wishful Thinking

The Real Ghostbusters

Nightshifter

Hammer of the Gods

Yellow Fever

Everybody Hates Hitler

Hunteri Heroici

Monster at the End of This Book

Hell House

Ask Jeeves

Monster Movie

It's a Terrible Life

Hibbing 911

Reading is Fundamental

The French Mistake

About a Boy

Slash Fiction

Dog Dean Afternoon

Folsom Prison Blues

Tall Tales

Frontierland

[DittyDotDot]

+ Hollywood Babylon
-- Mystery Spot
+ Bad Day at Black Rock
 

 

07 - Hollywood Babylon
06 - Bad Day at Black Rock
05 - Fan fiction
04 - Changing Channels

04 - Mystery Spot
02 - Weekend at Bobby's

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...
Swap Meat
Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!
Fallen Idols
Slumber Party
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Party On Garth
The Curious Case of Dean Winchester
How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
LARP and the Real Girl
Ghostfacers
Out with the Old
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
The Usual Suspects
Wishful Thinking
The Real Ghostbusters
Nightshifter
Hammer of the Gods
Yellow Fever
Everybody Hates Hitler
Hunteri Heroici
Monster at the End of This Book
Hell House
Ask Jeeves
Monster Movie
It's a Terrible Life
Hibbing 911
Reading is Fundamental
The French Mistake
About a Boy
Slash Fiction
Dog Dean Afternoon
Folsom Prison Blues
Tall Tales
Frontierland

[Demented Daisy]

Bad Day at Black Rock +

Weekend at Bobby's +

Fan Fiction --

 

07 - Hollywood Babylon
07 - Bad Day at Black Rock
04 - Changing Channels
04 - Mystery Spot
03 - Weekend at Bobby's

03 - Fan Fiction

 

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...
Swap Meat
Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!
Fallen Idols
Slumber Party
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Party On Garth
The Curious Case of Dean Winchester
How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
LARP and the Real Girl
Ghostfacers
Out with the Old
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
The Usual Suspects
Wishful Thinking
The Real Ghostbusters
Nightshifter
Hammer of the Gods
Yellow Fever
Everybody Hates Hitler
Hunteri Heroici
Monster at the End of This Book
Hell House
Ask Jeeves
Monster Movie
It's a Terrible Life
Hibbing 911
Reading is Fundamental
The French Mistake
About a Boy
Slash Fiction
Dog Dean Afternoon
Folsom Prison Blues
Tall Tales
Frontierland

[7kstar]

We've been voting this round for 6 weeks.  Yikes.  

Well no one was in a hurry on this one, clearly.  lol

 

Bad Day at Black Rock +

Changing Channels --

Fan Fiction --

 

08 - Bad Day at Black Rock

07 - Hollywood Babylon

04 - Mystery Spot

03 - Weekend at Bobby's

02 - Changing Channels

01 - Fan Fiction

 

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...

Swap Meat

Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!

Fallen Idols

Slumber Party

Clap Your Hands If You Believe

Party On Garth

The Curious Case of Dean Winchester

How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters

LARP and the Real Girl

Ghostfacers

Out with the Old

Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie

The Usual Suspects

Wishful Thinking

The Real Ghostbusters

Nightshifter

Hammer of the Gods

Yellow Fever

Everybody Hates Hitler

Hunteri Heroici

Monster at the End of This Book

Hell House

Ask Jeeves

Monster Movie

It's a Terrible Life

Hibbing 911

Reading is Fundamental

The French Mistake

About a Boy

Slash Fiction

Dog Dean Afternoon

Folsom Prison Blues

Tall Tales

Frontierland

 

Bye Frontierland - Dean in western gear is a riot.  Sam having to ride the horse was fun.  IA the ending was a downer,

 

Bye Tall Tales, the boys fighting really was funny. 

 

Understand I'm voting against ones I like, there isn't any other solution though cause I like them all.  Which is why this round has lasted so long.  :)

[SueB]

-- Bad Day at Black Rock

-- Hollywood Babylon

+ Mystery Spot

 

06 - Bad Day at Black Rock

05 - Hollywood Babylon
05 - Mystery Spot
03 - Weekend at Bobby's

02 - Changing Channels

01 - Fan Fiction

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...
Swap Meat
Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!
Fallen Idols
Slumber Party
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Party On Garth
The Curious Case of Dean Winchester
How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
LARP and the Real Girl
Ghostfacers
Out with the Old
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
The Usual Suspects
Wishful Thinking
The Real Ghostbusters
Nightshifter
Hammer of the Gods
Yellow Fever
Everybody Hates Hitler
Hunteri Heroici
Monster at the End of This Book
Hell House
Ask Jeeves
Monster Movie
It's a Terrible Life
Hibbing 911
Reading is Fundamental
The French Mistake
About a Boy
Slash Fiction
Dog Dean Afternoon
Folsom Prison Blues
Tall Tales
Frontierland

Edited August 11, 2015 by SueB

[catrox14]

-- Bad Day at Black Rock

+ Hollywood Babylon

-- Weekend at Bobby

06 - Hollywood Babylon

05 - Mystery Spot

04 - Bad Day at Black Rock

02 - Changing Channels

01 - Fan Fiction

01 - Weekend at Bobbys

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...

Swap Meat

Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!

Fallen Idols

Slumber Party

Clap Your Hands If You Believe

Party On Garth

The Curious Case of Dean Winchester

How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters

LARP and the Real Girl

Ghostfacers

Out with the Old

Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie

The Usual Suspects

Wishful Thinking

The Real Ghostbusters

Nightshifter

Hammer of the Gods

Yellow Fever

Everybody Hates Hitler

Hunteri Heroici

Monster at the End of This Book

Hell House

Ask Jeeves

Monster Movie

It's a Terrible Life

Hibbing 911

Reading is Fundamental

The French Mistake

About a Boy

Slash Fiction

Dog Dean Afternoon

Folsom Prison Blues

Tall Tales

Frontierland

Edited August 11, 2015 by catrox14

[Demented Daisy]

Fan Fiction --

Weekend at Bobby's +

Bad Day at Black Rock +

 

05 - Mystery Spot
05 - Bad Day at Black Rock

04 - Hollywood Babylon

02 - Changing Channels
02 - Weekend at Bobbys

 

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...

Swap Meat
Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!
Fallen Idols
Slumber Party
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Party On Garth
The Curious Case of Dean Winchester
How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
LARP and the Real Girl
Ghostfacers
Out with the Old
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
The Usual Suspects
Wishful Thinking
The Real Ghostbusters
Nightshifter
Hammer of the Gods
Yellow Fever
Everybody Hates Hitler
Hunteri Heroici
Monster at the End of This Book
Hell House
Ask Jeeves
Monster Movie
It's a Terrible Life
Hibbing 911
Reading is Fundamental
The French Mistake
About a Boy
Slash Fiction
Dog Dean Afternoon
Folsom Prison Blues
Tall Tales
Frontierland

Fan Fiction

[DittyDotDot]

-- Mystery Spot
+ Bad Day at Black Rock
+ Hollywood Babylon

 

 

06 - Bad Day at Black Rock
05 - Hollywood Babylon

03 - Mystery Spot
02 - Changing Channels
02 - Weekend at Bobbys

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...
Swap Meat
Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!
Fallen Idols
Slumber Party
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Party On Garth
The Curious Case of Dean Winchester
How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
LARP and the Real Girl
Ghostfacers
Out with the Old
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
The Usual Suspects
Wishful Thinking
The Real Ghostbusters
Nightshifter
Hammer of the Gods
Yellow Fever
Everybody Hates Hitler
Hunteri Heroici
Monster at the End of This Book
Hell House
Ask Jeeves
Monster Movie
It's a Terrible Life
Hibbing 911
Reading is Fundamental
The French Mistake
About a Boy
Slash Fiction
Dog Dean Afternoon
Folsom Prison Blues
Tall Tales
Frontierland
Fan Fiction

[7kstar]

-- Weekend at Bobbys
+ Bad Day at Black Rock
-- Changing Channels

 

07 - Bad Day at Black Rock
05 - Hollywood Babylon

03 - Mystery Spot

 

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...
Swap Meat
Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!
Fallen Idols
Slumber Party
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Party On Garth
The Curious Case of Dean Winchester
How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
LARP and the Real Girl
Ghostfacers
Out with the Old
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
The Usual Suspects
Wishful Thinking
The Real Ghostbusters
Nightshifter
Hammer of the Gods
Yellow Fever
Everybody Hates Hitler
Hunteri Heroici
Monster at the End of This Book
Hell House
Ask Jeeves
Monster Movie
It's a Terrible Life
Hibbing 911
Reading is Fundamental
The French Mistake
About a Boy
Slash Fiction
Dog Dean Afternoon
Folsom Prison Blues
Tall Tales
Frontierland
Fan Fiction

Changing Channels

Weekend at Bobbys

 

Bye Weekend at bobby's and Changing channels they are kind of tied so I took them out together.  I love so many parts of them.  I guess the ones left I just love a bit more. 

[AwesomO4000]

+ Mystery Spot

-- Bad Day At Black Rock

- Hollywood Babylon

 

05 - Bad Day at Black Rock
04 - Hollywood Babylon

04 - Mystery Spot

 

 

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...
Swap Meat
Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!
Fallen Idols
Slumber Party
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Party On Garth
The Curious Case of Dean Winchester
How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
LARP and the Real Girl
Ghostfacers
Out with the Old
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
The Usual Suspects
Wishful Thinking
The Real Ghostbusters
Nightshifter
Hammer of the Gods
Yellow Fever
Everybody Hates Hitler
Hunteri Heroici
Monster at the End of This Book
Hell House
Ask Jeeves
Monster Movie
It's a Terrible Life
Hibbing 911
Reading is Fundamental
The French Mistake
About a Boy
Slash Fiction
Dog Dean Afternoon
Folsom Prison Blues
Tall Tales
Frontierland
Fan Fiction

Changing Channels

Weekend at Bobbys

 

RIP "Fan Fiction,"  probably my favorite episode in the last 3 seasons. I loved all the little touches, and the characters were surprisingly likeable (SPN doesn't generally have teen characters I enjoy unless they are teen Sam or Dean). I especially loved how Dean was drawn to substitute Sam (Marie), and vice versa (Sam with Maeve). Some of my favorite moments "There's no singing in Supernatural," Sam noticing the actresses showing their badges at the same time he and Dean were in the same way, Dean complaining that he'd need "50 jello shots and a hose down to get the stink off" and Sam having to keep Maeve from jumping on Dean in response, the explanation of the "BM" scene, Dean's aside to the camera after Marie explains the Cas/Dean "subtext." Even the guy who put on his poncho... just so many things I loved here.

 

"Changing Channels" has too many things I loved to mention them all, so I'll just say "Should I honk?" (One of the biggest laugh out loud moments I had ever from this show) and please pass the shrimp chips.

 

"Weekend At Bobby's" - love. So good to see Rufus. RIP: I hope Bobby's finally getting to eat that home cooking, and that he always remembers, nothing beats wood chipper.

[SueB]

+ Mystery Spot

-- Bad Day At Black Rock

- Hollywood Babylon

 

Because the math works, I presume you really meant to give just a single "-" to Hollywood Babylon.  Right? Just checking.

 

+ Mystery Spot

-- Bad Day At Black Rock

-- Hollywood Babylon

 

05 - Mystery Spot

03 - Bad Day at Black Rock

02 - Hollywood Babylon

 

 

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...

Swap Meat

Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!

Fallen Idols

Slumber Party

Clap Your Hands If You Believe

Party On Garth

The Curious Case of Dean Winchester

How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters

LARP and the Real Girl

Ghostfacers

Out with the Old

Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie

The Usual Suspects

Wishful Thinking

The Real Ghostbusters

Nightshifter

Hammer of the Gods

Yellow Fever

Everybody Hates Hitler

Hunteri Heroici

Monster at the End of This Book

Hell House

Ask Jeeves

Monster Movie

It's a Terrible Life

Hibbing 911

Reading is Fundamental

The French Mistake

About a Boy

Slash Fiction

Dog Dean Afternoon

Folsom Prison Blues

Tall Tales

Frontierland

Fan Fiction

Changing Channels

Weekend at Bobbys

[AwesomO4000]

Because the math works, I presume you really meant to give just a single "-" to Hollywood Babylon.  Right? Just checking.

 

Yes, I sometimes reserve the right to just do one "-". I didn't want to knock it down too far. I like the episode too much.

 

And it warms my heart to see two Sam-heavy episodes left in the last few comedic episodes left. He so often gets the "straight man" role.

[catrox14]

I think Hollywood Babylon is a good Sam episode too. I think what I like about all 3 final entrants is IMO they are evenly balanced for straight man and humor man for both Sam and Dean.

[AwesomO4000]

This is true. Good point.

 

Even though we have the whole hotel / on fire air conditioner scene and  "I lost my shoe" for Sam for example for "Bad Day..." we also have "I'm Batman." (hee). And also Dean's final "Son of a bitch!" when he finds out Bella stole his tickets. Oh and also Jensen/Dean's "wow, you suck" which he somehow manages to make sound affectionate as well as exasperated and insulting.

 

"Hollywood Babylon" is a little more Dean heavy - doesn't mean I don't love it - but we still get the subtle, but funny, Sam line about maybe the ghosts are haunting the set, because they think the movie sucks (also hee) and the gold scene in the cemetery with Sam asking Dean if he wants to dig up Joey Ramone next, and Dean's response of "heathen" (yet again hee.)

 

And as black comedy as it is, "Mystery Spot" is just chock full of both of their comedy gold, interestingly one of Sam's is offscreen with his whole fight with Dean and the hatchet ending with Dean's head going "thud" and an "uh oh" expressing "Dean?" And of course their simultaneous exchange of dialogue, Sam describing the town's goings on, and his "Doris, what I'd like is for you to log in some more hours at the archery range. You're a terrible shot." (hee), Sam's "You'll thank me when it's Wednesday" and Dean's "whatever that means," (I love Jensen's delivery there). And of course Dean head bopping to "Heat of the Moment" (a lot of people wouldn't be able to pull that off and make me believe it, but Jensen - and Jared/Sam's reaction - make me buy it.)

[catrox14]

I think one of my favorite Sam/Jared line readings is "Yesterday was Tuesday. But today is Tuesday too" And he's so earnest.

 

I have to say Jared's befuddled face never ceases to make me laugh. He just nails that. I especially loved his reactions to Audrey in Wishful Thinking and his discussion with Dean on whether they are going to kill a stuffed teddy bear... And his perfect "I don't think that's really, you know,  our core problem here".  I just crack up so hard at that. 

[AwesomO4000]

Oh I agree, hee. I think it's one of his befuddled faces that he uses on that maybe the ghosts are haunting the movie because they think it sucks line. That and some of his bitch faces. That one in "Nightshifter" is so perfect. (And I can almost hear his befuddled expression in the "Should I honk?" line.)

[catrox14]

Sorry I won't kill Hollywood Babylon. I love this as a meta episode and a skewering of the network suits with the brilliant Gary Cole as much as like Bad Day at Black Rock, I don't like it as much as HB or MS

+ Hollywood Babylon

-- Mystery Spot

-- Bad Day At Black Rock

03 - Hollywood Babylon

03 - Mystery Spot

01 - Bad Day at Black Rock

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...

Swap Meat

Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!

Fallen Idols

Slumber Party

Clap Your Hands If You Believe

Party On Garth

The Curious Case of Dean Winchester

How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters

LARP and the Real Girl

Ghostfacers

Out with the Old

Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie

The Usual Suspects

Wishful Thinking

The Real Ghostbusters

Nightshifter

Hammer of the Gods

Yellow Fever

Everybody Hates Hitler

Hunteri Heroici

Monster at the End of This Book

Hell House

Ask Jeeves

Monster Movie

It's a Terrible Life

Hibbing 911

Reading is Fundamental

The French Mistake

About a Boy

Slash Fiction

Dog Dean Afternoon

Folsom Prison Blues

Tall Tales

Frontierland

Fan Fiction

Changing Channels

Weekend at Bobbys

Edited August 12, 2015 by catrox14

[Demented Daisy]

Hollywood Babylon --

Mystery Spot --

Bad Day at Black Rock +

 

02 - Bad Day at Black Rock

01 - Hollywood Babylon

01 - Mystery Spot
 

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...

Swap Meat
Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!
Fallen Idols
Slumber Party
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Party On Garth
The Curious Case of Dean Winchester
How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
LARP and the Real Girl
Ghostfacers
Out with the Old
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
The Usual Suspects
Wishful Thinking
The Real Ghostbusters
Nightshifter
Hammer of the Gods
Yellow Fever
Everybody Hates Hitler
Hunteri Heroici
Monster at the End of This Book
Hell House
Ask Jeeves
Monster Movie
It's a Terrible Life
Hibbing 911
Reading is Fundamental
The French Mistake
About a Boy
Slash Fiction
Dog Dean Afternoon
Folsom Prison Blues
Tall Tales
Frontierland
Fan Fiction
Changing Channels
Weekend at Bobbys

Edited August 12, 2015 by Demented Daisy

[DittyDotDot]

+ Bad Day at Black Rock
-- Hollywood Babylon
-- Mystery Spot

 

AND THE WINNER IS:

03 - Bad Day at Black Rock

Sent off with a rimshot and a bowchickawowow...
Swap Meat
Season Seven, Time for a Wedding!
Fallen Idols
Slumber Party
Clap Your Hands If You Believe
Party On Garth
The Curious Case of Dean Winchester
How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters
LARP and the Real Girl
Ghostfacers
Out with the Old
Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie
The Usual Suspects
Wishful Thinking
The Real Ghostbusters
Nightshifter
Hammer of the Gods
Yellow Fever
Everybody Hates Hitler
Hunteri Heroici
Monster at the End of This Book
Hell House
Ask Jeeves
Monster Movie
It's a Terrible Life
Hibbing 911
Reading is Fundamental
The French Mistake
About a Boy
Slash Fiction
Dog Dean Afternoon
Folsom Prison Blues
Tall Tales
Frontierland
Fan Fiction
Changing Channels
Weekend at Bobby's

Hollywood Babylon
Mystery Spot

 

 

 

So, what should we do next?

[Demented Daisy]

Good question, Ditty.  Wanna do the opposite of the last round?  I would recommend:

 

In My Time of Dying

Heart

What Is and What Should Never Be

A Very Supernatural Christmas

Dream a Little Dream of Me

Jus in Bello

No Rest For the Wicked

Lucifer Rising

Abandon All Hope

Dark Side of the Moon

Death's Door

Goodbye Stranger

Do You Believe In Miracles?

The Prisoner

 

Those are the episodes that left me feeling like I got punched in the gut.  Just brutal.  But I understand if no one else wants to wallow in the hellatus misery.  ;-)

[DittyDotDot]

I'll vote on whatever you guys want. I can wallow just as easily as I can giggle. ;)

 

But, maybe instead of episodes, which we've voted on and discussed quite a bit already, we could do a round of something musical? Perhaps, best musical moments? We could each nominate a few to make the list?

 

ETA: I would add to the Demented One's misery list: At Death's Door and maybe the episode where Kevin died (sorry, I can't remember the title of the episode right now.)

Edited August 12, 2015 by DittyDotDot

[Demented Daisy]

But "Carry On (Wayward Son)" is automatically disqualified, right?

[DittyDotDot]

I don't know if it should be disqualified, but I wouldn't be one to nominate it or vote for it. I think we need to specify the episode and the scene, so whoever nominated it would need to choose which Carry On they wanted to be included. I might be inclined to nominate to the Carry On from Fan Fiction.

 

For instance, I'd nominate:

• Back in Black with Baby's triumphant return in Bloodlust
• Renegade from the end of Nightshifter
• Rooster from the end of Folsolm Prison Blues
• A Well-Respected Man from the beginning of It's A Terrible Life
• Spirit in the Sky from Good God, Y'all
• Knockin' on Heaven's Door with the fireworks in Dark Side of the Moon
• The Gambler from Weekend at Bobby's
• Play with Fire from The Man Who Knew Too Much

 

That's all I got off the top of my head, but I'm sure there's quite a few more I'm forgetting about right now.

Edited August 12, 2015 by DittyDotDot

[Demented Daisy]

I don't know if it should be disqualified, but I wouldn't be one to nominate it or vote for it. I think we need to specify the episode and the scene, so whoever nominated it would need to choose which Carry On they wanted to be included. I might be inclined to nominate to the Carry On from Fan Fiction.

 

Precisely what I was thinking.  Otherwise, it's S1 finale, S2 finale, S3 finale, etc etc etc.

 

I second all of your nominations, but would add:

 

"Don't Fear the Reaper" from Faith

"Bad Moon Rising" from the S1 finale

"Silent Lucidity" from Heart

"White Rabbit" from Simon Said

"Heat of the Moment" from Mystery Spot

"Thunderkiss '65" from Sex and Violence (Can't help it.  Love Rob Zombie.)

"Goodbye Stranger" from Goodbye Stranger

Edited August 12, 2015 by Demented Daisy

[DittyDotDot]

All very fine choices too! 

 

So, now we're up to:

• "Back in Black" with Baby's triumphant return in Bloodlust
• "Renegade" from the end of Nightshifter
• "Rooster" from the end of Folsolm Prison Blues
• "A Well-Respected Man" from the beginning of It's A Terrible Life
• "Spirit in the Sky" from Good God, Y'all
• "Knockin' on Heaven's Door" with the fireworks in Dark Side of the Moon
• "The Gambler" from Weekend at Bobby's
• "Play with Fire" from The Man Who Knew Too Much
• "Don't Fear the Reaper" from Faith
• "Bad Moon Rising" from Devil's Trap
• "Silent Lucidity" from Heart
• "White Rabbit" from Hunted
• "Heat of the Moment" from Mystery Spot
• "Thunderkiss '65" from Sex and Violence 
• "Goodbye Stranger" from Goodbye Stranger
• "Stonehenge" from Simon Said

 

 

What say the rest of you?

 

ETA: Fixed "White Rabbit" as it was from Hunted, not Simon Said...which reminded me to add "Stonehenge" from Simon Said.

Edited August 12, 2015 by DittyDotDot

[7kstar]

I'm fine with the music

but think we should add: Hibbing 911 "The Weight" When the guys come in and meet Jodie and Donna.  It's also a song that Jensen sang at a convention and was added in the ep for the fans.

 

 

[AwesomO4000]

There might be too many musical moments to do them all? Maybe we have to break them up... maybe at least seasons 1-5 and 6-10?

 

Some more for me:

 

• "Wanted Dead or Alive" from "No Rest for the Wicked" (because that's got to be iconic, right?)
• "Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas" from "A Very Supernatural Christmas" (because adorable, hopeful Sam and *sniff*)
• Laugh, I Nearly Died" from the end of "Bloody Mary" (where Sam gives the "you're my brother and I'd die for you," speech and then sees the the hallucination of Jessica)
• "Simple Kind of Man" from "Free to Be You and Me" (the juxtaposed montages of Sam and Dean's current lives as busboy and hunter)
• "Do You Love Me?" from "The End" (the army shoots the zombies and unknowingly saves Dean in the 2014 End-verse)
• "Space Oddity" from "Clap Your Hands If You believe" (Dean versus Tinkerbell)
• That bending spoons in my mind song from the Dr.Sexy parody from "Changing Channels" (because that shit was perfect for that scene...) Or the Supernatural sitcom theme song from "Changing Channels" (because that was also funny)
• "Behind Blue Eyes" from "Book of the Damned" (because ouch)
• "Can't Find My Way Home" from "Do You Believe in Miracles"

 

Some other potentials I remember and like, but maybe not on the same level? (Game-runner's choice)

 

• "In-A-Gadda-Da-Vida" from "Skin" (that shit was creepy)
• "Run Through the Jungle" from "Sin City"
• The "Ghostfacers" theme song or "Hocus Pocus" from "Ghostfacers" (the second one was the set up montage)
• "Beautiful Loser" from "Exile on Main Street"
• "You Sexy Thing" or "Miracles" from "Mommy Dearest" (the first as Eve attacks and the second - though shorter - as Cas looks over the devastation and we find out for sure that he's working with Crowley
• "These Boots Are Made for Walking" from "Meet the New Boss" (Godstiel visits Crowley in his trailer)
• "All Out of Love" from "Slash Fiction" (because: Hee!)
• "Cherry Pie" from "The Song Remains the Same"
• "You Shook Me All Night Long" from "The Slice Girls"
• "Vincent" from "Survival of the Fittest" (Castiel listens to this in the car and talks with Dean)
• "The Famous Final Scene" from "Road Trip" (Dean's montage)
• "I'm Too Sexy" from "Black" (because hee)
• "Sundown" from "Fan Fiction" (Dean tunes up Baby) or "Carry On Wayward Son" (because *sniff*)
• "Head Full of Doubt / Road Full of Promise" from "Halt and Catch Fire" (the teaser as the truck drives off the bridge into the title card)

Edited August 12, 2015 by AwesomO4000

[Demented Daisy]

We had 45+ entries last time.  If we use all suggestions so far, we're at almost the same number....

[SueB]

1) I'm up for the music thing

2) I'm fine with up to 45 but if it expands beyond that, I think we should split.

3) I agree with no "Carry On".  I think we just declare that the Supernatural Song Emeritus and vote on the others

4) You guys have listed all I remember (and then some...)

 

ETA:  I'm just glad Mystery Spot made it to the Top 3.  To me, that was the quintessential dark comedy Supernatural.  "Do these tacos taste funny?"

Edited August 12, 2015 by SueB

[catrox14]

What about Road So Fars non: Carry On Wayward Son category?

 

ELO- The Long Black Road for The Hunter Games?

Thunderstruck - I think twice

[Demented Daisy]

catrox, do you mean as part of this round?  Because I think we'd have enough of those for the next round.

[AwesomO4000]

Yes, for me, the montages are sort of a different animal. There are definitely some I loved (And I love your choice - love me some ELO.), but I only went with the plot / action related music for my choices this time.

[7kstar]

I'm fine with Carry On being left out...I can't imagine SP without it now, so I just assume it would win and lets go with the others to see what would come after.  lol

 

If we did the best montage then we could put one in.  If we need to split the seasons like 1-5 & 6-10 that is fine with that.  :)

[DittyDotDot]

Okay, so here's the list with all the suggestions so far...has everyone weighed in? If so, I think we can start voting. I prefer to vote in the morning, so I'll wait till then.

 

15 - "Back in Black" with Baby's triumphant return in Bloodlust
15 - "Renegade" from the end of Nightshifter
15 - "Rooster" from the end of Folsolm Prison Blues
15 - "A Well-Respected Man" from the beginning of It's A Terrible Life
15 - "Spirit in the Sky"  from Good God, Y'all
15 - "Knockin' on Heaven's Door" with the fireworks from Dark Side of the Moon
15 - "The Gambler" from Weekend at Bobby's
15 - "Play with Fire" from The Man Who Knew Too Much
15 - "Don't Fear the Reaper" from Faith
15 - "Bad Moon Rising" from Devil's Trap
15 - "Silent Lucidity" from Heart
15 - "White Rabbit" from Hunted
15 - "Heat of the Moment" from Mystery Spot
15 - "Thunderkiss '65" from Sex and Violence
15 - "Goodbye Stranger" from Goodbye Stranger
15 - "Stonehenge" from Simon Said

15 -"Wanted Dead or Alive" from No Rest for the Wicked
15 - "Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas" from A Very Supernatural Christmas
15 - "Laugh, I Nearly Died" from the end of Bloody Mary
15 - "Simple Kind of Man" from Free to Be You and Me
15 - "Do You Love Me?" from "The End"
15 - "Space Oddity" from Clap Your Hands If You believe
15 - "Bending spoons in my mind" from from Changing Channels

15 - "Supernatural sitcom theme song" from Changing Channels
15 - "Behind Blue Eyes" from Book of the Damned
15 - "Can't Find My Way Home" from Do You Believe in Miracles

[SueB]

Voting!  Damn. This is HARD.

++ Renegade

++ Don't Fear the Reaper

-- Stonehenge (I don't really dislike it... but I was trying not to just upvote EVERYTHING and Dean, that van should be driven by a guy with a pornstache...it's NOPE in my book)

 

17 - "Renegade" from the end of Nightshifter

17 - "Don't Fear the Reaper" from Faith

15 - "Back in Black" with Baby's triumphant return in Bloodlust
15 - "Rooster" from the end of Folsolm Prison Blues
15 - "A Well-Respected Man" from the beginning of It's A Terrible Life
15 - "Spirit in the Sky"  from Good God, Y'all
15 - "Knockin' on Heaven's Door" with the fireworks from Dark Side of the Moon
15 - "The Gambler" from Weekend at Bobby's
15 - "Play with Fire" from The Man Who Knew Too Much
15 - "Bad Moon Rising" from Devil's Trap
15 - "Silent Lucidity" from Heart
15 - "White Rabbit" from Hunted
15 - "Heat of the Moment" from Mystery Spot
15 - "Thunderkiss '65" from Sex and Violence
15 - "Goodbye Stranger" from Goodbye Stranger

15 -"Wanted Dead or Alive" from No Rest for the Wicked
15 - "Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas" from A Very Supernatural Christmas
15 - "Laugh, I Nearly Died" from the end of Bloody Mary
15 - "Simple Kind of Man" from Free to Be You and Me
15 - "Do You Love Me?" from "The End"
15 - "Space Oddity" from Clap Your Hands If You believe
15 - "Bending spoons in my mind" from from Changing Channels

15 - "Supernatural sitcom theme song" from Changing Channels
15 - "Behind Blue Eyes" from Book of the Damned
15 - "Can't Find My Way Home" from Do You Believe in Miracles

13 - "Stonehenge" from Simon Said

Edited August 13, 2015 by SueB