Supernatural Survival Game

[Diane]

+ Phantom Traveler
-- Dead in the Water
- Asylum

64 - Faith
30 - Scarecrow   
29 - Pilot
23 - Something Wicked
19 - The Benders
18 - Devil's Trap
06 - Dead in the Water
02 - Phantom Traveler
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum

[catrox14]

+ Phantom Traveler
+ Dead in the Water
-- The Benders

64 - Faith
30 - Scarecrow   
29 - Pilot
23 - Something Wicked
19 - The Benders
16 - Devil's Trap
07- Dead in the Water
03 - Phantom Traveler
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum

[SueB]

-- Phantom Traveler
+ Devil's Trap
-- The Benders

64 - Faith
30 - Scarecrow   
29 - Pilot
23 - Something Wicked
17 - The Benders
17 - Devil's Trap
07- Dead in the Water
01 - Phantom Traveler
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum

[Wayward Son]

-- Phantom Traveler
+ Devil's Trap
-- The Benders

65 - Faith
30 - Scarecrow   
29 - Pilot
24 - Something Wicked
17 - The Benders
17 - Devil's Trap
07- Dead in the Water
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum

8. Phantom Traveler

[Diane]

This is just getting brutal, I love all of the episodes left.  Sue we need your great eulogies again, I can't do them justice.

Phantom Traveler, Dean being petrified to fly, but does it anyway, can't have Sam doing it alone.  Dean humming Metallica, both boys climbing over the fence. I liked it when they would help out old friends, or someone they had previously known, it was nice to see they had a past and that people reached out to them.  Isn't this also our first Demon sighting on the show?  Great episode.

+ Faith
+ The Benders
-- Something Wicked
66 - Faith
30 - Scarecrow   
29 - Pilot
22 - Something Wicked
18 - The Benders
17 - Devil's Trap
07- Dead in the Water
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum|
8. Phantom Traveler

[SueB]

Quote

Sue we need your great eulogies again, I can't do them justice.

I was waiting for Phantom Traveler... but like a poor marksman I "kept missing the target!" (Kirk to Khan, Star Trek II).

Farewell to the creepy Asylum.  We will revisit those blood stained halls many times as different locations in the upcoming years.  This episode had some GREAT lines "You're not going to shoot me again, are you? 'Cause that would be awkward." Nicely gruesome ghosts. Lampshading horror tropes.  Sam on ghost-anger-steroids. It provided us character insights (extra cookie/Dad's orders argument), unique plot-line, Dean's first Jack Nicholson impression, and (from the shallow end) a Jensen belly shot. 

Phantom Traveler BEGINS at the shallow end of the pool with the lovely Ackles Ass Equation shot.  It proceeds to show a fun chink in the armor of Dean (fear of flying) and we see the boys CLINGING to John's new voice mail message (FEELS).  I personally thought the VFx of the small plane crash was good but that grainy demon-smoke needed some serious work.  It was a fun episode with the first introduction of the "suits" -- Homeland Security versus FBI but it still counts.  

+ Devil's Trap
-- The Benders
-- Something Wicked

66 - Faith
30 - Scarecrow   
29 - Pilot
21 - Something Wicked
18 - Devil's Trap
16 - The Benders
07- Dead in the Water

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler

[AwesomO4000]

+ The Benders
-- Dead in the Water
+ Scarecrow

66 - Faith
31 - Scarecrow   
29 - Pilot
21 - Something Wicked
18 - Devil's Trap
17 - The Benders
05- Dead in the Water

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler

[Wayward Son]

+ Faith
+ Something Wicked
-- The Benders

67 - Faith
31 - Scarecrow   
29 - Pilot
22 - Something Wicked
18 - Devil's Trap
15 - The Benders
05- Dead in the Water

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler

[catrox14]

+ Dead in the Water
-- Devil's Trap
-- The Benders

67 - Faith
31 - Scarecrow   
29 - Pilot
22 - Something Wicked
16 - Devil's Trap
14 - The Benders
06- Dead in the Water

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler

[SueB]

These last 7 are putting up a fight before they go out the door.....

[Diane]

+ Faith
+ The Benders
- Dead in the Water

69 - Faith
31 - Scarecrow   
29 - Pilot
22 - Something Wicked
16 - Devil's Trap
15 - The Benders
04- Dead in the Water

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler

Edited April 26, 2017 by Diane
I can even copy right this morning

[SueB]

@Diane  Your votes are not reflected in the count....

[Diane]

1 minute ago, SueB said:

@Diane  Your votes are not reflected in the count....

Thank you, those were not even my votes, apparently I didn't get enough sleep last night!

[SueB]

- The Benders
+ Devil's Trap
- Something Wicked

69 - Faith
31 - Scarecrow   
29 - Pilot
20 - Something Wicked
17 - Devil's Trap
13 - The Benders
04- Dead in the Water

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler

[Diane]

+ The Benders
-- Something Wicked
-- Dead in the Water

69 - Faith
31 - Scarecrow   
29 - Pilot
18 - Something Wicked
17 - Devil's Trap
14 - The Benders
02- Dead in the Water

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler

[catrox14]

--The Benders
-- Something Wicked
+ Dead in the Water

69 - Faith
31 - Scarecrow   
29 - Pilot
16 - Something Wicked
17 - Devil's Trap
12 - The Benders
03- Dead in the Water

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler

Edited April 27, 2017 by catrox14

[SueB]

--The Benders
-- Something Wicked
+ Devil's Trp

69 - Faith
31 - Scarecrow   
29 - Pilot
18 - Devil's Trap
14 - Something Wicked
10 - The Benders
03- Dead in the Water

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler

[Diane]

--Dead in the Water
-- Something Wicked
+ Faith

70 - Faith
31 - Scarecrow   
29 - Pilot
18 - Devil's Trap
12 - Something Wicked
10 - The Benders
01- Dead in the Water

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler

[SueB]

--The Benders
-- Something Wicked
+ Devil's Trap

70 - Faith
31 - Scarecrow   
29 - Pilot
11 - Devil's Trap
10 - Something Wicked
08 - The Benders
01- Dead in the Water

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler

[AwesomO4000]

- Dead in the Water
+ Scarecrow
+ The Benders
 

70 - Faith
32 - Scarecrow   
29 - Pilot
11 - Devil's Trap
10 - Something Wicked
09 - The Benders
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water

[Wayward Son]

RIP Dead in the Water :( 

 

+ Faith 

+ Something Wicked

-- The Benders

 

71 - Faith
32 - Scarecrow   
29 - Pilot
11 - Devil's Trap
11 - Something Wicked
07 - The Benders
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water

[flyinghigh]

+1  Pilot

+1  Faith

-- The Benders

72 - Faith
32 - Scarecrow   
30 - Pilot
11 - Devil's Trap
11 - Something Wicked
05 - The Benders
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water

[SueB]

I couldn't take out Dean In The Water because I loved it so much.  Kim Manners brought so much to the series and this was the start of his era. I loved the story of little boy Dean and the heroic dive into the lake.  It was creepy and compelling.  But ifs time to go play...

--Something Wicked

+ Devil's Trap

-- The Benders

72 - Faith
32 - Scarecrow   
30 - Pilot
12 - Devil's Trap
09 - Something Wicked
03 - The Benders
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water

[Wayward Son]

+ Something Wicked

+ Faith

-- The Benders

73 - Faith
32 - Scarecrow   
30 - Pilot
12 - Devil's Trap
10 - Something Wicked
01 - The Benders
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water

[Diane]

Love The Benders can't be the one to let it go.

-- Something Wicked

+ Faith

+The Benders

74 - Faith
32 - Scarecrow   
30 - Pilot
12 - Devil's Trap
08 - Something Wicked
02 - The Benders
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water

[SueB]

Whilst I also love The Benders, it's time for those creepy Minnesota Hillbillies (WTF was with those accents? In Minnesota??) to run along.  But they should stop by the dentist first. 'Cause, damn.  But seriously, the Sheriff is one of my favorite characters. It's a compelling plot with some serious creep factor.  It also establishes the long tradition of "Monsters I get, people are crazy."  

-- Something Wicked
+ Scarecrow
--The Benders

74 - Faith
33 - Scarecrow   
30 - Pilot
12 - Devil's Trap
06 - Something Wicked

 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water
6. The Benders

[AwesomO4000]

+ Scarecrow
-- Something Wicked
+ Devil's Trap

74 - Faith
34 - Scarecrow   
30 - Pilot
13 - Devil's Trap
04 - Something Wicked

 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water
6. The Benders

[Diane]

-- Scarecrow
-- Something Wicked
+ Pilot

74 - Faith
32 - Scarecrow   
31 - Pilot
13 - Devil's Trap
02- Something Wicked

 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water
6. The Benders

[Wayward Son]

-- Scarecrow
+ Something Wicked
+ Faith

75 - Faith
30 - Scarecrow   
31 - Pilot
13 - Devil's Trap
03- Something Wicked

 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water
6. The Benders

[SueB]

+Scarecrow
-- Something Wicked
--  Pilot

75 - Faith
32 - Scarecrow   
29 - Pilot
13 - Devil's Trap
01- Something Wicked

 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water
6. The Benders

[AwesomO4000]

I guess it's somewhat expected that two of the top 5 episodes are Krikpe's, but I think it's kind of interesting that two of the others are by Sera Gamble and Raelle Tucker (writing as a team). (And a third episode of theirs is our #7.) I guess I liked their work together.

-- Pilot
-- Devil's Trap
+ Something Wicked

75 - Faith
32 - Scarecrow   
27 - Pilot
11 - Devil's Trap
02- Something Wicked

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water
6. The Benders

[Diane]

-- Something Wicked
+ Faith
+ Devil’s Trap

76 - Faith
32 - Scarecrow   
27 - Pilot
12 - Devil's Trap
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water
6. The Benders
5. Something Wicked

[Wayward Son]

Nooooooo Something Wicked is gone! I'm so sad -goes off to mourn- 

[Diane]

Just now, Wayward Son said:

Nooooooo Something Wicked is gone! I'm so sad -goes off to mourn- 

I am sorry, the last ones are like pulling teeth, I love them all.

[Wayward Son]

Just now, Diane said:

I am sorry, the last ones are like pulling teeth, I love them all.

It's fine I've been expecting it for a while! I'm just sad because it and Faith are my top two of the season. At least I do like all of the remaining episodes which certainly helps :)

[Wayward Son]

-- Scarecrow
+ Faith
+ Pilot

77 - Faith
30 - Scarecrow   
28 - Pilot
12 - Devil's Trap
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water
6. The Benders
5. Something Wicked

[SueB]

Something Wicked is the episode that made our hearts ache for the Weechesters.  And it's debatable who many of us disliked more in this episode, the MOTW or John.  We learned about Dean while Sam also learned about Dean's commitment to following orders.  Powerful episode. 

 

+ Scarecrow
-- Faith
-- Pilot

75 - Faith
31 - Scarecrow   
26 - Pilot
12 - Devil's Trap
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water
6. The Benders
5. Something Wicked

[Diane]

+ Faith
-- Scarecrow
-- Devil’s Trap

76 - Faith
29 - Scarecrow   
26 - Pilot
10 - Devil's Trap
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water
6. The Benders
5. Something Wicked

[Wayward Son]

+ Faith

+ Pilot
-- Scarecrow


77 - Faith
27 - Scarecrow   
27 - Pilot
10 - Devil's Trap
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water
6. The Benders
5. Something Wicked

[SueB]

-- Devil's Trap

-- Pilot
+ Scarecrow


77 - Faith
28 - Scarecrow   
25 - Pilot
08 - Devil's Trap
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water
6. The Benders
5. Something Wicked

Edited May 4, 2017 by SueB
Distracted posting

[AwesomO4000]

@SueB Your votes and numbers aren't the same, so I am hoping that you actually meant to upvote "Scarecrow" 1 and downvote "Pilot" 2. If not and you actually meant to upvote "Pilot" 1 and "Scarecrow" down 2, whoever is voting next will need to adjust "Scarecrow" down 3 and "Pilot" up 3.

+ Scarecrow
-- Pilot
-- Devil's Trap

77 - Faith
29 - Scarecrow   
23 - Pilot
06 - Devil's Trap
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water
6. The Benders
5. Something Wicked

Edited May 4, 2017 by AwesomO4000

[SueB]

AwesomeO, you are correct.  I'll fix my vote numbers to match my voting.  *distracted brain*

[Diane]

-- Scarecrow
-- Pilot
+ Devil's Trap

77 - Faith
27 - Scarecrow   
21 - Pilot
07 - Devil's Trap
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water
6. The Benders
5. Something Wicked

[Wayward Son]

+ Faith

+ Pilot

-- Scarecrow

 

78 - Faith
25 - Scarecrow   
22 - Pilot
07 - Devil's Trap
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water
6. The Benders
5. Something Wicked

[Wayward Son]

Double posts, but it's been over a day since I cast my last vote? 

 

+ Faith

+ Pilot

-- Scarecrow

 

79 - Faith
23 - Scarecrow   
23 - Pilot
07 - Devil's Trap
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water
6. The Benders
5. Something Wicked

Edited May 6, 2017 by Wayward Son

[SueB]

Missed last night so I'm voting early today...

 

 

-- Devil's Trap

-- Pilot

+ Scarecrow

 

79 - Faith
24 - Scarecrow   
21 - Pilot
07 - Devil's Trap
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water
6. The Benders
5. Something Wicked

[Diane]

-- Devil's Trap
-- Pilot
+ Faith

 

80 - Faith
24 - Scarecrow   
19 - Pilot
05 - Devil's Trap
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water
6. The Benders
5. Something Wicked

[Wayward Son]

+ Pilot
-- Scarecrow 
+ Faith

 

81 - Faith
22 - Scarecrow   
20 - Pilot
05 - Devil's Trap
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water
6. The Benders
5. Something Wicked

[AwesomO4000]

-- Devil's Trap
-- Pilot
+ Scarecrow

81 - Faith
23 - Scarecrow   
18 - Pilot
03 - Devil's Trap
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water
6. The Benders
5. Something Wicked

[Diane]

-- Scarecrow
-- Pilot
-- Devil's Trap

81 - Faith
21 - Scarecrow   
16 - Pilot
01 - Devil's Trap
 

They went on a hunting trip.  And they haven't been home in a few days.

22. Bugs
21. Route 666
20. Dead Man's Blood
19. Nightmare
18. Hook Man
17. Wendigo
16. Hell House
15. Shadow
14. Home
13. Salvation
12. Skin
11. Provenance
10. Bloody Mary
9. Asylum
8. Phantom Traveler
7. Dead in the Water
6. The Benders
5. Something Wicked