Jump to content

Type keyword(s) to search

Supernatural Survival Game


mstaken
  • Reply
  • Start Topic

Recommended Posts

I'm going to leave the list as is and start voting.  If we can get @SueB and @AwesomO4000 to join us, we could have some interesting discussion....  Now that I'm really looking at it, this is going to be tough.  Maybe one of the hardest rounds we've ever done.

++ Nightshifter
++ A Very Supernatural Christmas
-- On the Head of a Pin

17 - Nightshifter
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
15 - Pilot
15 - Scarecrow
15 - Something Wicked
15 - Faith
15 - The Benders
15 - In My Time of Dying
15 - What Is and What Should Never Be
15 - Hollywood Babylon
15 - Tall Tales
15 - Mystery Spot
15 - Bad Day at Black Rock
15 - Jus in Bello
15 - No Rest For the Wicked 
15 - Dream a Little Dream of Me 
15 - Lazarus Rising
15 - The Monster at the End of This Book
15 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
15 - In the Beginning
15 - Dark Side of the Moon
15 - The End
15 - Changing Channels
15 - Point of No Return
15 - Sam, Interrupted
13 - On the Head of a Pin

Link to comment

-- Faith
-- No Rest For the Wicked 
-- On the Head of a Pin

17 - Nightshifter
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
15 - Pilot
15 - Scarecrow
15 - Something Wicked
15 - The Benders
15 - In My Time of Dying
15 - What Is and What Should Never Be
15 - Hollywood Babylon
15 - Tall Tales
15 - Mystery Spot
15 - Bad Day at Black Rock
15 - Jus in Bello
15 - Dream a Little Dream of Me 
15 - Lazarus Rising
15 - The Monster at the End of This Book
15 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
15 - In the Beginning
15 - Dark Side of the Moon
15 - The End
15 - Changing Channels
15 - Point of No Return
15 - Sam, Interrupted
13 - No Rest For the Wicked 
13 - Faith
11 - On the Head of a Pin

Link to comment

++ The End
++Lazarus Rising
++On the Head of a Pin

17 - Nightshifter
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Lazarus Rising
17 - The End
15 - Pilot
15 - Scarecrow
15 - Something Wicked
15 - The Benders
15 - In My Time of Dying
15 - What Is and What Should Never Be
15 - Hollywood Babylon
15 - Tall Tales
15 - Mystery Spot
15 - Bad Day at Black Rock
15 - Jus in Bello
15 - Dream a Little Dream of Me
15 - The Monster at the End of This Book
15 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
15 - In the Beginning
15 - Dark Side of the Moon
15 - Changing Channels
15 - Point of No Return
15 - Sam, Interrupted
13 - On the Head of a Pi
13 - No Rest For the Wicked 
13 - Faith

Link to comment

Oh YAY!!! More players!!!

@Diane, it's really pretty simple. This round is the Best of Kripke and the episodes on the list are the top five from each season we voted on in previous rounds. So, you just choose 3 episodes on the list to either up- or down-vote by two points. You can only vote once in a 24-hour period. When the vote tally gets to zero, the episode is voted off the island. And, so the game doesn't last forever, when we've eliminated half the episodes on the list, we start only up-voting by one point, but still down-vote by two.

You can also advocate for episodes if you want. It's fun when people try to sway the voting.

  • Love 1
Link to comment
Just now, DittyDotDot said:

Oh YAY!!! More players!!!

@Diane, it's really pretty simple. This round is the Best of Kripke and the episodes on the list are the top five from each season we voted on in previous rounds. So, you just choose 3 episodes on the list to either up- or down-vote by two points. You can only vote once in a 24-hour period. When the vote tally gets to zero, the episode is voted off the island. And, so the game doesn't last forever, when we've eliminated half the episodes on the list, we start only up-voting by one point, but still down-vote by two.

You can also advocate for episodes if you want. It's fun when people try to sway the voting.

Ok so the numbers on the side are votes, do I change those when I do my list?

Link to comment

Ok here is go if I get anything wrong, please let me know.

++ Faith
++ Lazarus Rising
++ Mystery Spot

 

19 - Lazarus Rising
17 – Mystery Spot
17 - Nightshifter
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - The End
15 - Faith
15 - Pilot
15 - Scarecrow
15 - Something Wicked
15 - The Benders
15 - In My Time of Dying
15 - What Is and What Should Never Be
15 - Hollywood Babylon
15 - Tall Tales
15 - Bad Day at Black Rock
15 - Jus in Bello
15 - Dream a Little Dream of Me
15 - The Monster at the End of This Book
15 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
15 - In the Beginning
15 - Dark Side of the Moon
15 - Changing Channels
15 - Point of No Return
15 - Sam, Interrupted
13 - On the Head of a Pi
13 - No Rest For the Wicked 

 

 

ignore the wanky spacing issues. Ugh.

Edited by Diane
fixing my wonky spaces, lol.
Link to comment
8 minutes ago, Diane said:

ignore the wanky spacing issues. Ugh.

No worries, it takes a little getting used to. I don't know how you're posting--mobile can be tricky--but in order to not get the extra spaces use "shift+return" instead of just "return". I don't know how to make that happen on mobile devices though.

Link to comment
Just now, DittyDotDot said:

No worries, it takes a little getting used to. I don't know how you're posting--mobile can be tricky--but in order to not get the extra spaces use "shift+return" instead of just "return". I don't know how to make that happen on mobile devices though.

Thank you, I am on a desktop computer (at work) lol.  I will try that.

  • Love 1
Link to comment

++ In My Time of Dying
++ The Monster at the End of This Book
-- On the Head of a Pin

19 - Lazarus Rising
17 – Mystery Spot
17 - Nightshifter
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
17 - The End
17 - In My Time of Dying
15 - Faith
15 - Pilot
15 - Scarecrow
15 - Something Wicked
15 - The Benders
15 - What Is and What Should Never Be
15 - Hollywood Babylon
15 - Tall Tales
15 - Bad Day at Black Rock
15 - Jus in Bello
15 - Dream a Little Dream of Me
15 - The Monster at the End of This Book
15 - In the Beginning
15 - Dark Side of the Moon
15 - Changing Channels
15 - Point of No Return
15 - Sam, Interrupted
13 - No Rest For the Wicked 
11 - On the Head of a Pin

  • Love 1
Link to comment

-- Point of No Return
-- No Rest For the Wicked 
-- On the Head of a Pin

19 - Lazarus Rising
17 – Mystery Spot
17 - Nightshifter
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
17 - The End
17 - In My Time of Dying
15 - Faith
15 - Pilot
15 - Scarecrow
15 - Something Wicked
15 - The Benders
15 - What Is and What Should Never Be
15 - Hollywood Babylon
15 - Tall Tales
15 - Bad Day at Black Rock
15 - Jus in Bello
15 - Dream a Little Dream of Me
15 - The Monster at the End of This Book
15 - In the Beginning
15 - Dark Side of the Moon
15 - Changing Channels
15 - Sam, Interrupted
13 - Point of No Return
11 - No Rest For the Wicked 
09 - On the Head of a Pin

  • Love 1
Link to comment

++ Faith
++ What Is and What Should Never Be
-- On the Head of a Pin  (because I just absolutely hate this episode)
 

19 - Lazarus Rising
17 – Mystery Spot
17 - Nightshifter
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
17 - The End
17 - In My Time of Dying
17 – Faith
17 - What Is and What Should Never Be
15 - Pilot
15 - Scarecrow
15 - Something Wicked
15 - The Benders
15 - Hollywood Babylon
15 - Tall Tales
15 - Bad Day at Black Rock
15 - Jus in Bello
15 - Dream a Little Dream of Me
15 - The Monster at the End of This Book
15 - In the Beginning
15 - Dark Side of the Moon
15 - Changing Channels
15 - Sam, Interrupted
13 - Point of No Return
11 - No Rest For the Wicked 
07- On the Head of a Pin

  • Love 1
Link to comment
1 minute ago, DittyDotDot said:

Aww, there's another one of us weirdos who hate this episode @Demented Daisy. ;)

It never ceases to just piss me off.  It's cruel and it takes Dean where he never should have had to go in the first place. Ugh!!! Hey weirdos unite!

Edited by Diane
  • Love 2
Link to comment
3 minutes ago, Diane said:

It never ceases to just piss me off.  It's cruel and it takes Dean where he never should have had to go in the first place. Ugh!!! Hey weirdos unite!

My main issue with the episode is I feel like they never really committed to the episode so it never achieves what it wants to be. Actually, I'd say I feel like the show doesn't actually understand the episode by it's execution.

We should get special rings or something, though. ;)

  • Love 2
Link to comment
Just now, DittyDotDot said:

My main issue with the episode is I feel like they never really committed to the episode so it never achieves what it wants to be. Actually, I'd say I feel like the show doesn't actually understand the episode by it's execution.

We should get special rings or something, though. ;)

I have to agree with you. And yes specials rings.

  • Love 2
Link to comment

I'm fighting tooth and nail for On the Head of a Pin.  It's one of the best episodes of the entire series IMO

Jensen's work is brilliant and heartbreaking and that alone is enough to put in the top 10 of all time for me. Give him all damn awards.

Obviously, if Dean had never made the deal to save Sam's life, none of this happens.  But the show did have Dean sell his soul for Sam and did send Dean to Hell.  As upsetting and disturbing as this episode is I'm grateful for it's existence because FINALLY we get glimpse into what 40 years in Hell did to Dean.  We got a glimpse of how 30 years of abuse and torture at Alastair's hands turned Dean into a man that did the same to others for 10 years. Yes, it's upsetting. It should be!

Aside from Dean's torture of Alastair, this episode really was packed maybe too much and they should have spent more time with Dean and Alastair.  We find out that Dean inadvertently started the Apocalpyse because of being tormented for 30 fucking years. His soul was crushed. My soul was crushed. It showed us just what assholes the angels were and that Cas was struggling with his faith. His first real acknowledgment of doubt. Cas made his choice in this episode IMO to be with Dean/humanity.  We learned that Sam could KILL with his mind.  My only disappointment with the episode is that they did not let Dean kill Alastair. 

++ No Rest for the Wicked
++ On the Head of a Pin
-- Point of No Return 

19 - Lazarus Rising
17 – Mystery Spot
17 - Nightshifter
17 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
17 - The End
17 - In My Time of Dying
17 – Faith
17 - What Is and What Should Never Be
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
15 - Pilot
15 - Scarecrow
15 - Something Wicked
15 - The Benders
15 - Hollywood Babylon
15 - Tall Tales
15 - No Rest For the Wicked
15 - Bad Day at Black Rock
15 - Jus in Bello
15 - Dream a Little Dream of Me
15 - The Monster at the End of This Book
15 - In the Beginning
15 - Dark Side of the Moon
15 - Changing Channels
15 - Sam, Interrupted
11 - Point of No Return
09 - On the Head of a Pin

Link to comment
12 hours ago, catrox14 said:

I'm fighting tooth and nail for On the Head of a Pin.  It's one of the best episodes of the entire series IMO

I also loathe the episode, but maybe for different reasons than I think others do. I agree that too much was packed into it, and yes, we learned that Sam can kill with his mind... and also that Sam is drinking demon blood, but this is stuffed into an episode mostly about Dean, so that this supposedly huge thing that they've been hinting at and hiding from us about Sam is pretty much just an afterthought in this episode centered around yet another revelation about  Dean and his hell issues. Which while I agree that they didn't spend enough time on Dean's time in hell and the effects on him, they somehow spent even less time on revelations about Sam's demon blood drinking issues. There wasn't even a flashback as to why Sam even started drinking demon blood - a pretty huge event horizon to just skip over in my opinion. So not only didn't we learn that, but in addition, could they leave Sam's concern in this episode as to what the torturing would do to Dean and his wanting to go save Dean from that? Nope, Sam has to say that Dean isn't "strong enough" to do it, so Sam needs to make sure that he is. Thanks a lot show. So not only no flashbacks to why Sam started drinking demon blood in the first place that maybe, just maybe, might've given us some perspective on or sympathy for Sam, but we have to take a potentially good motive from Sam and turn him into a jerk... so all of that great work Jensen did just made me more angry, because of course Dean went through the worst torture ever and turned into something he hated and just has all the guilt heaped upon him besides so we feel extra awful for him, but not only that, guess what? Look! His brother is also a huge jerk who just thinks he's weak... %$#^ you, show. Haaaate!

But despite all of that, for you @catrox14, I was not going to downvote the episode... but then you downvoted one my favorite episodes and since it will be next on the chopping block if I leave your episode alone, I just can't do it. I'm sorry, but I love "Point of No Return" - an episode where the writers finally, finally after all the crappiness in season 4, let Sam have positive things to say about his confidence in Dean again and express those feelings to Dean. And don't think it doesn't gall me that it's a Carver episode, so that I wonder what the hell happened that he forgot about moments like that and gave us the Sam assassination that was season 8. But nevertheless I love the episode anyway.

Once I get it back up and somewhat safe, I'll lay off OtHoaP for a bit, despite my haaaate!

On 9/6/2016 at 7:27 AM, Demented Daisy said:

If we can get @SueB and @AwesomO4000 to join us, we could have some interesting discussion....

Hee you may regret that I came to join, DD, because I think I have some very different opinions on some of the episodes than many and will likely be a thorn in peoples' side on some of that. One of the main ones being my absolute "meh" when it comes to "Lazurus Rising." (Especially in retrospect, I thought it was a bit too murky with the storytelling, and didn't really hold together for me when the rest of the narrative was revealed. So much so, that I had to create a few headcanons just to make it make sense).

To make it easier, I'm going to put my vote next in another post, so that anyone using it for the next vote won't have to work around all of my above discussion.

Edited by AwesomO4000
edited for further clarification... geez can't I just say something for goodness sakes without having to explain it.
  • Love 2
Link to comment

Changed my mind - for you, catrox, I'll leave OtHoaP alone... this time. If "Point of No Return" starts getting in trouble, though, all bets are off. I'm already sad that one of my two tied for favorite season 4 episodes didn't even make the list while "On the Head.." did. *grumble, grumble*

++ Point of No Return
-- Dream a Little Dream of Me
-- Something Wicked

19 - Lazarus Rising
17 – Mystery Spot
17 - Nightshifter
17 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
17 - The End
17 - In My Time of Dying
17 – Faith
17 - What Is and What Should Never Be
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
15 - Pilot
15 - Scarecrow
15 - The Benders
15 - Hollywood Babylon
15 - Tall Tales
15 - No Rest For the Wicked
15 - Bad Day at Black Rock
15 - Jus in Bello
15 - The Monster at the End of This Book
15 - In the Beginning
15 - Dark Side of the Moon
15 - Changing Channels
15 - Sam, Interrupted
13- Dream a Little Dream of Me
13 - Something Wicked
13 - Point of No Return
09 - On the Head of a Pin

Link to comment

I just realized I screwed up my vote yesterday.  I'll fix that now.  Silly me.

7 hours ago, AwesomO4000 said:

Hee you may regret that I came to join, DD, because I think I have some very different opinions on some of the episodes than many and will likely be a thorn in peoples' side on some of that.

But that's what makes it interesting!  If we all agreed, how very dull would that be?  ;-)

++ Changing Channels
++ Tall Tales
-- On the Head of a Pin (No mercy from me!  ;-) )

19 - Lazarus Rising
17 – Mystery Spot
17 - Nightshifter
17 - The Monster at the End of This Book
17 - The End
17 - In My Time of Dying
17 – Faith
17 - What Is and What Should Never Be
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Changing Channels
17 - Tall Tales
15 - Pilot
15 - Scarecrow
15 - The Benders
15 - Hollywood Babylon
15 - No Rest For the Wicked
15 - Bad Day at Black Rock
15 - Jus in Bello
15 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
15 - In the Beginning
15 - Dark Side of the Moon
15 - Sam, Interrupted
13- Dream a Little Dream of Me
13 - Something Wicked
13 - Point of No Return
07 - On the Head of a Pin

Link to comment

I swear, @AwesomO4000 I'm not doing this just to get you to vote against On the Head of a Pin... .

-- Something Wicked
-- Point of No Return
-- On the Head of a Pin

While I don't hate Point of No Return, it's not a particular favorite. Just using these early votes to clear out some of the chaff is all.

19 - Lazarus Rising
17 – Mystery Spot
17 - Nightshifter
17 - The Monster at the End of This Book
17 - The End
17 - In My Time of Dying
17 – Faith
17 - What Is and What Should Never Be
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Changing Channels
17 - Tall Tales
15 - Pilot
15 - Scarecrow
15 - The Benders
15 - Hollywood Babylon
15 - No Rest For the Wicked
15 - Bad Day at Black Rock
15 - Jus in Bello
15 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
15 - In the Beginning
15 - Dark Side of the Moon
15 - Sam, Interrupted
13- Dream a Little Dream of Me
11 - Something Wicked
11 - Point of No Return
05 - On the Head of a Pin

 

10 hours ago, AwesomO4000 said:

Hee you may regret that I came to join, DD, because I think I have some very different opinions on some of the episodes than many and will likely be a thorn in peoples' side on some of that.

What the demented on said!

ETA: Aren't you gonna play with us @SueB?

Edited by DittyDotDot
  • Love 3
Link to comment

++ The Benders (because this episode was so creepy, people are way scarier than monsters and I really liked the sheriffs deputy)
++ Bad Day at Black Rock
-- On the Head of a Pin (no mercy from me either, sorry)

19 - Lazarus Rising
17 – Mystery Spot
17 - Nightshifter
17 - The Monster at the End of This Book
17 - The End
17 - In My Time of Dying
17 – Faith
17 - What Is and What Should Never Be
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Changing Channels
17 - Tall Tales
17 - The Benders
15 - Pilot
15 - Scarecrow
15 - Hollywood Babylon
15 - No Rest For the Wicked
15 - Bad Day at Black Rock
15 - Jus in Bello
15 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
15 - In the Beginning
15 - Dark Side of the Moon
15 - Sam, Interrupted
13- Dream a Little Dream of Me
13 - Something Wicked
11 - Point of No Return
03 - On the Head of a Pin

Link to comment

-- Monster at the End of This Book
-- Dream a Little Dream of Me (only part of the episode I like is Dean seeing Dreamon!Dean).
++ On the Head of a Pin  (you'll have to drag this episode from my cold dead hand. I will never forget Dean's face when he learned what had happened. Jensen's work was so beautifully subtle and you could see Dean's existence crumble. Just more perfect Ackting. )

@AwesomO4000 I'll leave PoNR alone for the moment. :)

19 - Lazarus Rising
17 – Mystery Spot
17 - Nightshifter
17 - The End
17 - In My Time of Dying
17 – Faith
17 - What Is and What Should Never Be
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Changing Channels
17 - Tall Tales
17 - The Benders
15 - Pilot
15 - The Monster at the End of This Book
15 - Scarecrow
15 - Hollywood Babylon
15 - No Rest For the Wicked
15 - Bad Day at Black Rock
15 - Jus in Bello
15 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
15 - In the Beginning
15 - Dark Side of the Moon
15 - Sam, Interrupted
13 - Something Wicked
11 - Point of No Return
11- Dream a Little Dream of Me
05 - On the Head of a Pin

Link to comment

-- The Benders (die die die)
++ Lazarus Rising
++ Mystery Spot

21 - Lazarus Rising
19 – Mystery Spot
17 - Nightshifter
17 - The End
17 - In My Time of Dying
17 – Faith
17 - What Is and What Should Never Be
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Changing Channels
17 - Tall Tales
15 - The Benders
15 - Pilot
15 - The Monster at the End of This Book
15 - Scarecrow
15 - Hollywood Babylon
15 - No Rest For the Wicked
15 - Bad Day at Black Rock
15 - Jus in Bello
15 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
15 - In the Beginning
15 - Dark Side of the Moon
15 - Sam, Interrupted
13 - Something Wicked
11 - Point of No Return
11- Dream a Little Dream of Me
05 - On the Head of a Pin

Link to comment

Did I mention I was out of the country*? The things I do for catrox....

++ Point of No Return (love this)
++ On the Head of a Pin (I f*cking love this episode too)
-- Something Wicked

21 - Lazarus Rising
19 – Mystery Spot
17 - Nightshifter
17 - The End
17 - In My Time of Dying
17 – Faith
17 - What Is and What Should Never Be
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Changing Channels
17 - Tall Tales
15 - The Benders
15 - Pilot
15 - The Monster at the End of This Book
15 - Scarecrow
15 - Hollywood Babylon
15 - No Rest For the Wicked
15 - Bad Day at Black Rock
15 - Jus in Bello
15 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
15 - In the Beginning
15 - Dark Side of the Moon
15 - Sam, Interrupted
13 - Point of No Return
11- Dream a Little Dream of Me

11- Something Wicked
07 -On the Head of a Pin

 

 

*30th wedding anniversary in Riviera Maya, friends staying with Joe (my son) whose hand rehab is doing reasonably well ... For those who were wondering.

  • Love 2
Link to comment

Yes, congrats @SueB! And...

Quote

++ Point of No Return (love this)

Yay!

-- Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
++ Point of No Return
-- Dream a Little Dream of Me

21 - Lazarus Rising
19 – Mystery Spot
17 - Nightshifter
17 - The End
17 - In My Time of Dying
17 – Faith
17 - What Is and What Should Never Be
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Changing Channels
17 - Tall Tales
15 - The Benders
15 - Pilot
15 - The Monster at the End of This Book
15 - Scarecrow
15 - Hollywood Babylon
15 - No Rest For the Wicked
15 - Bad Day at Black Rock
15 - Jus in Bello
15 - In the Beginning
15 - Dark Side of the Moon
15 - Sam, Interrupted
15 - Point of No Return
13 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
11 - Something Wicked
09 - Dream a Little Dream of Me
07 -On the Head of a Pin

Link to comment

-- On the Head of a Pin
-- Something Wicked
-- AYT, G?  IM, DW

21 - Lazarus Rising
19 – Mystery Spot
17 - Nightshifter
17 - The End
17 - In My Time of Dying
17 – Faith
17 - What Is and What Should Never Be
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Changing Channels
17 - Tall Tales
15 - The Benders
15 - Pilot
15 - The Monster at the End of This Book
15 - Scarecrow
15 - Hollywood Babylon
15 - No Rest For the Wicked
15 - Bad Day at Black Rock
15 - Jus in Bello
15 - In the Beginning
15 - Dark Side of the Moon
15 - Sam, Interrupted
15 - Point of No Return
11 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
09 - Something Wicked
09 - Dream a Little Dream of Me
05 - On the Head of a Pin

Edited by Demented Daisy
  • Love 1
Link to comment

-- Point of No Return
++ Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
-- On the Head of a Pin

 

21 - Lazarus Rising
19 – Mystery Spot
17 - Nightshifter
17 - The End
17 - In My Time of Dying
17 – Faith
17 - What Is and What Should Never Be
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Changing Channels
17 - Tall Tales
15 - The Benders
15 - Pilot
15 - The Monster at the End of This Book
15 - Scarecrow
15 - Hollywood Babylon
15 - No Rest For the Wicked
15 - Bad Day at Black Rock
15 - Jus in Bello
15 - In the Beginning
15 - Dark Side of the Moon
15 - Sam, Interrupted
13 - Point of No Return
13 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
09 - Something Wicked
09 - Dream a Little Dream of Me
03 - On the Head of a Pin

Link to comment

-- On the Head of a Pin
-- Something Wicked
++ Dark Side of the Moon

21 - Lazarus Rising
19 – Mystery Spot
17 - Nightshifter
17 - The End
17 - In My Time of Dying
17 – Faith
17 - What Is and What Should Never Be
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Changing Channels
17 - Tall Tales
17 - Dark Side of the Moon
15 - The Benders
15 - Pilot
15 - The Monster at the End of This Book
15 - Scarecrow
15 - Hollywood Babylon
15 - No Rest For the Wicked
15 - Bad Day at Black Rock
15 - Jus in Bello
15 - In the Beginning
15 - Sam, Interrupted
13 - Point of No Return
13 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
07 - Something Wicked
09 - Dream a Little Dream of Me
01 - On the Head of a Pin

Link to comment

You know what? I'm going to mercy kill my beloved On the Head of Pin. I don't want it killed by those who hate it. I would rather it die by my loving hand as someone who values and appreciates all that it was.  Good bye On The Head of a Pin.  You deserved a far better fate.  RIP. :(:(:(

-- On the Head of a Pin
++ Lazarus Rising
++ The End


23 - Lazarus Rising
19 – Mystery Spot
19 - The End
17 - Nightshifter
17 - In My Time of Dying
17 – Faith
17 - What Is and What Should Never Be
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Changing Channels
17 - Tall Tales
17 - Dark Side of the Moon
15 - The Benders
15 - Pilot
15 - The Monster at the End of This Book
15 - Scarecrow
15 - Hollywood Babylon
15 - No Rest For the Wicked
15 - Bad Day at Black Rock
15 - Jus in Bello
15 - In the Beginning
15 - Sam, Interrupted
13 - Point of No Return
13 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
07 - Something Wicked
09 - Dream a Little Dream of Me

 

Sent to It's Own Private Heaven (or another one if you guys can think of one)
On the Head of a Pin

Edited by catrox14
  • Love 1
Link to comment
17 minutes ago, SueB said:

Waaaaaahhhhhhhh!!!!!! ????????

I know. I know. :(. It was gonna die tomorrow if not today. It was down to one and if I upvoted and you upvoted it would have only been at 5. It was just prolonging the inevitable. It broke my heart to do it, but like I said, rather it be me who loves it with all my heart than someone else. 

  • Love 2
Link to comment

-- Hollywood Babylon (do not like, I will admit it did make me look up the actress to see if she really was in fear.com...)
-- The Benders (did I say die for this enough times yet?  Too much like that X-Files episode "Home" that I only watched once, when it first aired)
++ Bad Day at Black Rock (because I'm in the middle of watching it right now!)


23 - Lazarus Rising
19 – Mystery Spot
19 - The End
17 - Nightshifter
17 - In My Time of Dying
17 – Faith
17 - What Is and What Should Never Be
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Changing Channels
17 - Tall Tales
17 - Dark Side of the Moon
17 - Bad Day at Black Rock
15 - Pilot
15 - The Monster at the End of This Book
15 - Scarecrow
15 - No Rest For the Wicked
15 - Jus in Bello
15 - In the Beginning
15 - Sam, Interrupted
13 - Hollywood Babylon
13 - The Benders
13 - Point of No Return
13 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
07 - Something Wicked
09 - Dream a Little Dream of Me

 

Sent to Its Own Private Heaven
On the Head of a Pin

  • Love 1
Link to comment

++ Point of No Return

-- Something Wicked

++ The Monster at the End of This Book


23 - Lazarus Rising
19 – Mystery Spot
19 - The End
17 - Nightshifter
17 - In My Time of Dying
17 – Faith
17 - What Is and What Should Never Be
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Changing Channels
17 - Tall Tales
17 - Dark Side of the Moon
17 - Bad Day at Black Rock
17 - The Monster at The End on This Book
15 - Point of No Return
15 - Scarecrow
15 - No Rest For the Wicked
15 - Jus in Bello
15 - In the Beginning
15 - Sam, Interrupted
13 - Hollywood Babylon
13 - The Benders
13 - Hollywood Babylon
13 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
09 - Dream a Little Dream of Me
05 - Something Wicked

Sent to Its Own Private Heaven
On the Head of a Pin

Link to comment

-- Lazurus Rising
++ Mystery Spot
-- Jus In Bello (Hendricksen dying and smug Ruby kinda brings this one down a bit for me)

21 - Lazarus Rising
21 – Mystery Spot
19 - The End
17 - Nightshifter
17 - In My Time of Dying
17 – Faith
17 - What Is and What Should Never Be
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Changing Channels
17 - Tall Tales
17 - Dark Side of the Moon
17 - Bad Day at Black Rock
17 - The Monster at The End on This Book
15 - Point of No Return
15 - Scarecrow
15 - No Rest For the Wicked
15 - In the Beginning
15 - Sam, Interrupted
13 - Jus in Bello
13 - Hollywood Babylon
13 - The Benders
13 - Hollywood Babylon
13 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
09 - Dream a Little Dream of Me
05 - Something Wicked

Sent to Its Own Private Heaven
On the Head of a Pin

Link to comment

Aw, I love Hollywood Babylon.  It's one of my season 2 faves.  But I don't think it's the best, so I'm not going to worry about trying to save it.

++ Nightshifter
-- Sam, Interrupted
-- Something Wicked 

21 - Lazarus Rising
21 – Mystery Spot
19 - The End
19 - Nightshifter
17 - In My Time of Dying
17 – Faith
17 - What Is and What Should Never Be
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Changing Channels
17 - Tall Tales
17 - Dark Side of the Moon
17 - Bad Day at Black Rock
17 - The Monster at The End of This Book
15 - Point of No Return
15 - Scarecrow
15 - No Rest For the Wicked
15 - In the Beginning
13 - Sam, Interrupted
13 - Jus in Bello
13 - Hollywood Babylon
13 - The Benders
13 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
09 - Dream a Little Dream of Me
03 - Something Wicked

Sent to Its Own Private Heaven
On the Head of a Pin

Edited by Demented Daisy
Link to comment

-- Point of No Return
-- No Rest For the Wicked
-- Something Wicked

21 - Lazarus Rising
21 – Mystery Spot
19 - The End
19 - Nightshifter
17 - In My Time of Dying
17 – Faith
17 - What Is and What Should Never Be
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Changing Channels
17 - Tall Tales
17 - Dark Side of the Moon
17 - Bad Day at Black Rock
17 - The Monster at The End of This Book
15 - Scarecrow
15 - In the Beginning
13 - Sam, Interrupted
13 - Jus in Bello
13 - Hollywood Babylon
13 - The Benders
13 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
13 - Point of No Return
13 - No Rest For the Wicked
09 - Dream a Little Dream of Me
01 - Something Wicked

Sent to Its Own Private Heaven
On the Head of a Pin

 

2 hours ago, Demented Daisy said:

Aw, I love Hollywood Babylon.  It's one of my season 2 faves.  But I don't think it's the best, so I'm not going to worry about trying to save it.

That's exactly how I feel about Dream a Little Dream of Me. I love so much of what the art department did with the set dec and such, but I wouldn't say it's a "best" episode, just one I love. I won't vote against it, though.

  • Love 1
Link to comment

++ Mystery Spot (it's all about the hug!)
-- The Benders
-- Something Wicked (John's a dick to Dean and possibly used his own children as bait)

23 – Mystery Spot
21 - Lazarus Rising
19 - The End
19 - Nightshifter
17 - In My Time of Dying
17 – Faith
17 - What Is and What Should Never Be
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Changing Channels
17 - Tall Tales
17 - Dark Side of the Moon
17 - Bad Day at Black Rock
17 - The Monster at The End of This Book
15 - Scarecrow
15 - In the Beginning
13 - Sam, Interrupted
13 - Jus in Bello
13 - Hollywood Babylon
13 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
13 - Point of No Return
13 - No Rest For the Wicked
11 - The Benders
09 - Dream a Little Dream of Me

Sent to Its Own Private Heaven
On the Head of a Pin
Something Wicked

Link to comment

-- Mystery Spot (I like it but it's not a run-a-way #1 for me)
++ Point of No Return
++ Faith

23 – Mystery Spot
21 - Lazarus Rising
19 - The End
19 - Nightshifter
19 – Faith
17 - In My Time of Dying
17 - What Is and What Should Never Be
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Changing Channels
17 - Tall Tales
17 - Dark Side of the Moon
17 - Bad Day at Black Rock
17 - The Monster at The End of This Book
15 - Point of No Return
15 - Scarecrow
15 - In the Beginning
13 - Sam, Interrupted
13 - Jus in Bello
13 - Hollywood Babylon
13 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
13 - No Rest For the Wicked
11 - The Benders
09 - Dream a Little Dream of Me

Sent to Its Own Private Heaven
On the Head of a Pin
Something Wicked

Link to comment

++ Mystery spot
++ Faith

++ the Benders

 

25 - Mystery Spot
21 - Lazarus Rising

21 - Faith
19 - The End
19 - Nightshifter
17 - In My Time of Dying
19 - What Is and What Should Never Be
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Changing Channels
17 - Tall Tales
17 - Dark Side of the Moon
17 - Bad Day at Black Rock
17 - The Monster at The End of This Book
15 - Scarecrow
15 - In the Beginning

15 - the Benders
13 - Sam, Interrupted
13 - Jus in Bello
13 - Hollywood Babylon
13 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
15 - Point of No Return
13 - No Rest For the Wicked
09 - Dream a Little Dream of Me

Sent to Its Own Private Heaven
On the Head of a Pin
Something Wicked

Link to comment

++ The End
-- Dream a Little Dream of Me
++ No Rest for the Wicked

25 - Mystery Spot
21- Lazarus Rising
21 - The End
21- Faith
19 - Nightshifter
17 - In My Time of Dying
19 - What Is and What Should Never Be
17 - A Very Supernatural Christmas
17 - Changing Channels
17 - Tall Tales
17 - Dark Side of the Moon
17 - Bad Day at Black Rock
17 - The Monster at The End of This Book
15 - Scarecrow
15 - In the Beginning
15 - No Rest For the Wicked
15 - the Benders
13 - Sam, Interrupted
13 - Jus in Bello
13 - Hollywood Babylon
13 - Are You There, God?  It's Me, Dean Winchester
15 - Point of No Return
07 - Dream a Little Dream of Me

Sent to Its Own Private Heaven
On the Head of a Pin
Something Wicked

Link to comment

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...