joelene

Your choices hurt so much! All of them! What's your beef with Darin Morgan, Taryn? ;-) Season 2: Little Green Men Død Kalm Season 3 731 Nisei Talitha Cumi Just got to thinking that one ought to do a mytharc only elimination game later on... Or perhaps just collect data from all of the rounds. So much data!

This round was much clearer. Only six episodes got more than 1 vote! Light's out for Firewalker, Excelsis Dei and Soft Light from season 2 and The List, Oubliette and D.P.O. are abducted from season 3. Season 2: Little Green Men The Host Duane Barry Ascension One Breath Irresistible Die Hand Die Verletzt Colony End Game Død Kalm Humbug Our Town Anasazi Season 3: The Blessing Way Paper Clip Clyde Bruckman's Final Repose Nisei 731 Revelations War of the Coprophages Syzygy Piper Maru Apocrypha Pusher Jose Chung's 'From Outer Space' Quagmire Wetwired Talitha Cumi Vote for two season 2 episodes and three season 3 episodes in the order you want them eliminated!

Hah, aw, that's kinda cool actually. Let's nerd on, I say!

I'm clutching my pearls and all. Oh, but whyyyy, Taryn! ;P I'm silly sad about 2Shy. Love that one! I like F. Emasculata too, even tho I voted for it, it's already getting crazy hard with these seasons. LOL, "asparagus fungus". I have a soft spot for all the trapped-in-the-middle-of-nowhere episodes, plus Shawnee Smith, so I've always liked Firewalker. Season 2: Excelsis Dei Soft Light Little Green Men (I was gonne rewatch this one 'cuz I haven't seen it in forever and don't remember that much but I got caught up in a Scott & Bailey marathon...) Season 3: The List D.P.O. 731

No, no! You didn't miss anything! Nothing's been in order before now, certainly not from me, I just thought of it now that it might be easier to see which episode will be out when there is an even number of votes. It might also make the top 5 clearer. I edited my post above :)

mauve swooped in and made some things clearer and some not so much. That made the match between Firewalker and Red Museum instead. janetstclair voted for Firewalker but in her original post she wanted Red Museum out before Firewalker so I made the executive decision to make Red Museum the one to go. Make sense? No? It makes sense in my head to I hope you can deal with it. Aubrey, F. Emasculata and Red Museum are therefore owt, as well as Avatar, Grotesque and 2Shy (*sob*). Season 2: Little Green Men The Host Duane Barry Ascension One Breath Firewalker Excelsis Dei Irresistible Die Hand Die Verletzt Colony End Game Død Kalm Humbug Soft Light Our Town Anasazi Season 3: The Blessing Way Paper Clip D.P.O. Clyde Bruckman's Final Repose The List Oubliette Nisei 731 Revelations War of the Coprophages Syzygy Piper Maru Apocrypha Pusher Jose Chung's 'From Outer Space' Quagmire Wetwired Talitha Cumi Still three eps! Edit: Right, as you pointed out, no I haven't said anything about order before now, I just thought of it this last head-to-head that it might be easier to see which episode is the "weakest" if it comes to that. So, from now on, make your list in order and I might be able to figure out which one to go even if we have an even number of votes :)

Such divisive opinions! Four head to head today. Firewalker vs. F. Emasculata The List vs. 2Shy Choose! If you still haven't voted fully please emphasise the order you want them gone.

Season 2: Aubrey Excelsis Dei F. Emasculata Season 3: The List Avatar D.P.O.

Fresh Bones, The Calusari and Sleepless from season 2 are toast. From season 3 it's Hell Money, Teso Dos Bichos and The Walk that bite the dust. Next round! Season 2: Little Green Men The Host Duane Barry Ascension One Breath Firewalker Red Museum Excelsis Dei Aubrey Irresistible Die Hand Die Verletzt Colony End Game Død Kalm Humbug F. Emasculata Soft Light Our Town Anasazi Season 3: The Blessing Way Paper Clip D.P.O. Clyde Bruckman's Final Repose The List 2Shy Oubliette Nisei 731 Revelations War of the Coprophages Syzygy Grotesque Piper Maru Apocrypha Pusher Jose Chung's 'From Outer Space' Avatar Quagmire Wetwired Talitha Cumi Still the three episodes you'd like to see gone.

Damn, got a tie again for the third season 2 ep. Cast deciding vote between Sleepless, Red Museum and Aubrey! I vote Sleepless.

Lol, I don't remember the maggots at all! Or those wonderful Scully quotes. I do remember the quadruple amputee and the astral projection crap tho. Me and my brother taped all the episodes when they aired and, not knowing the proper titles, named them ourselves too! But the only episode I remember our own title of is Roland, which we dubbed "Propeller Professor." The Calusari was one of my favourites when I was a kid. I watched it over and over. It was the evil boy exorcism thing that got me hooked. It was the only episode that had an 18 y/o BBFC rating on the VHS box at the time as well! Oh, how the times change.

Season 2 Sleepless Fresh Bones Aubrey Season 3 These two... The List The Walk ... I can never remember them or tell them apart in my head. I even watched them both not that long ago for this reason but then I promptly forgot again. They're both about revenge killings, I think? I don't even know Hell Money (TDB is almost so bad it's good, and I'll take that over boring)

Right, then! 3 sucks, literally and figuratively, and was booted along with the one with the invisible elephant and Blood. Season 2: Little Green Men The Host Sleepless Duane Barry Ascension One Breath Firewalker Red Museum Excelsis Dei Aubrey Irresistible Die Hand Die Verletzt Fresh Bones Colony End Game Død Kalm Humbug The Calusari F. Emasculata Soft Light Our Town Anasazi Season 3: The Blessing Way Paper Clip D.P.O. Clyde Bruckman's Final Repose The List 2Shy The Walk Oubliette Nisei 731 Revelations War of the Coprophages Syzygy Grotesque Piper Maru Apocrypha Pusher Teso Dos Bichos Hell Money Jose Chung's 'From Outer Space' Avatar Quagmire Wetwired Talitha Cumi Vote for your bottom three episodes from each season!

There's a tie for third out between Blood and Sleepless. Quick, cast the deciding votes! Mine's for Blood. Sorry, Blood, you don't have speedo Mulder.

Sweet! I'll add season 3 tomorrow in case the people who already voted doesn't stop by again before. It's one episode less and I'll even it out as we go along. Fresh Bones is memorable for this freaky scene: And since Sleepless is on the table...

No feelings about doing two seasons at a time then? I concur with Bastet on this one. 3 Blood Sleepless Edit: Realise now that you who emphasised season 2 votes means you were up for it. Sorry, missed that!

Well well well, we have a winner. Ice rules season 1! Squeeze is runner up and Beyond the Sea (which I thought was a lock) is second runner up. Good game, folks! Based on the votes for each round we have a full season ranking: 24. Space 22 (tied). Shapes 22 (tied). Jersey Devil 21. Young at Heart 20. Roland 19. Born Again 18. Miracle Man 17. Ghost in the Machine 16. Gender Bender 15. Shadows 14. Conduit 13. Lazarus 12. Fallen Angel 11. E.B.E. 10. Fire 9. Erlenmeyer Flash 8. Deep Throat 7. Tooms 6. Pilot 4 (tied). Eve 4 (tied). Darkness Falls 3. Beyond the Sea 2. Squeeze 1. Ice I was wondering how you guys would feel about playing two seasons simultaneously? Separately, but at the same time, so season 2 and 3 now. Less time for people to drop off the game (which seemed to happen a lot on TWoP during these sorts of games), plus, voting is fun. Then at the end gather the top from each season and make an all-stars round. Anyway, if you're into the idea, or you prefer to vote on one season at a time, lemme know. Either way we shall get started on season 2 right away! Little Green Men The Host Blood Sleepless Duane Barry Ascension 3 One Breath Firewalker Red Museum Excelsis Dei Aubrey Irresistible Die Hand Die Verletzt Fresh Bones Colony End Game Fearful Symmetry Død Kalm Humbug The Calusari F. Emasculata Soft Light Our Town Anazazi Vote for three episodes you want gone.

I want crazy Meredith to come back. Unpopular?

Yeah, I think if we were trying to vote best episode objectively it would've been my vote.Wow, all three episodes tied! What a race!

Seconded.

Well, crap. My favourite of favourites Darkness Falls got snuffed out along with all those glorious Eve wackadoos. Final round!!! Squeeze Ice Beyond the Sea Cast your one vote for that most special season 1 x-file. Imma go wiiiith... ... ........ Squeeze. I'll have a full season ranking put together when season 2 voting starts tomorrow too!

I've always wondered, is Fox News affiliated with the Fox Network or not? I sounds like it should be but when I look at the programming on Fox (Glee, etc) that doesn't make any sense. So if not Fox, what network is it connected to? Or is it it's own horrible network?

In my younger gay days, early to mid-90's, I had the biggest crush on Eddie (Billy Warlock) from Baywatch. That might be the earliest crush I remember. Then Dean Cain from Louis & Clark, Chad Allen from Dr. Quinn, Sam from The Flying Doctors (Peter O'Brien, I had to look that up), Cameron Daddo from Model's Inc., Jonathan Brandis (RIP) from SeaQuest. As I became a proper teenager I switched Chad Allen for Joe Lando, David Borenanananaz off Buffy, Grant Show off Melrose Place, half the male cast from Sunset Beach (Eddie Cibrian and whoever played Ricardo, Father Antonio and Tim). I was obsessed with The X Files, and even tho I thought him very attractive, I always had a bigger crush on Gillian Anderson than David Duchovny.

Pilot and Tooms got squeezed out. Penultimate round! Squeeze Ice Eve Beyond the Sea Darkness Falls My votes: Ice Eve

Pilot Ngugh, this is HARD. The following six are just such damn fine pieces of television. Not that the previous weren't, but, yeah. Okay. Tooms.