This was my second favorite old-school challenge (all-time favorite challenge is still the original Battle of the Seasons). I lost so much respect for Emily on this challenge though - I always thought of her as a bad-ass who stood her ground, and to watch her leave because her boyfriend got kicked off was so depressing to me. Especially because you know she would've been smart enough to knock over the puzzle after they'd finished it.
I liked this challenge too because it was back when it wasn't all about strength in order to win. I hate that because most of the cast members got dumber, we had to suffer through the elimination of puzzle solving (and anything that isn't brute strength) being eliminated. Even look at those final three men - other than Mark, with the way the challenge is structured now, I seriously doubt Colin and Jamie would make it to the end. Especially Colin, since he had a sprained ankle for most of the challenge.
I did like Colin's blog he kept around the time of the challenge - I wish I still had the link, because I remember there being a lot of inside info he put in there.
Now see, while I don't love it, I don't consider that cheating. It wasn't against the rules for them to look at the puzzle, and one of the women should've been smart enough to knock it over (and as I said above, I bet Emily would've knocked it over in a heartbeat). The fact that they didn't think of that is their own fault. I wouldn't have been mad if the men's team finished the puzzle first and the women looked at theirs.