sde127

I haven’t finished watching this show or reading through the other comments but I wanted to come on here and see if anyone was taking about Carrie and what she did for a living. Does anyone else get the impression that she was maybe a prostitute and/or had substance abuse problems? When the mother and sister was on I felt like they were trying not to say some things and maybe that was a condition of doing the shown. When the sister read the letter that was written it seemed to be written by someone who maybe didn’t have much intelligence which makes me feel like she would be more vulnerable to shady people.

I may be completely wrong but I have a feeling that the whole pregnancy thing is Brittany and Schena messing with Jax.

Just found this forum and am loving reading everyone's posts. I am true ID addict and love all things true crime. Love you guys! I wanted to comment on Reasonable Doubt. I am really loving this show even though I didn't think I would after watching the first episode because I figured every case would be them finding the prisoner wrongfully convicted. I am pleasantly surprised that is not the case. I immediately recognized the detective from The First 48 : Birmingham. I really like when murders from The First 48 show up on ID channel so I like seeing the detective in this new role. The episode I really wanted to talk about was the one where the cop was convicted for killing his mistress right before going to court for child support. I thought the wife was so weird in that episode and didn't know as much as she pretended to know. She was trying so hard to save face. Also thought the guy in the next episode that was convicted of beating his wife then pretending it was a car accident was a total jerk as was his supporters. I think he totally beat her and is covering it up.

Had to log in to say I agree 100% with everything you said about the other cast members feelings about Katherine. Couldn't have said it better myself ?

Thank you so much for this! I've been dying to come here and say the same thing! I do not like Brittany at all and I've always thought there was more to her than she is showing. Maybe it's just because I live in her neck of the woods and hate that she is from here and people may think we are all like her because we are not. There is no way she didn't know what kind of person Jax was before moving there and I think she will take everything he has to give with a smile so people don't see the real her because she is not going anywhere!

She actually said it the last episode I think so I'm in the wrong thread on this one but she said that Caleb was the favorite son-in-law and if Tony wanted to compete for it then he had to spend more time with them or something along those lines. Not an exact quote by any means. It wasn't even exactly what she said but how she said it and the look on her face when she did that struck me as so snotty

Long time lurker first time poster. I haven't read all the comments yet so I apologize if these things have been covered already but just had to create an account to post my own thoughts and observations. The first thing that struck me about this episode was the TH where Mykeltie was bragging about her manipulating skills and Tony made that gesture with his hands. At first I had no idea what he was doing but she sure knew that he was telling her she was getting the big head. This must not have been the first time he has inisuated that for her to know so fast what he was saying and maybe I'm being to sensitive but it strikes me as his way of controlling her by bringing her down. I see a red flag for future verbal abuse and I say this from experience. Another thought I had was her requesting the honeymoon. Makes me think that Maddie and Caleb are getting some sort of compensation for airing their wedding like maybe a honeymoon or money they used for a honeymoon and this is the real reason Mykeltie was so dead set on August because this was still during the filming schedule and she would also get an aired wedding with compensation. By waiting till December she doesn't get those things and the parents know it but she can't say that while being filmed. I think that's why she said they wouldn't have the money in December but caught herself before saying she would in August JMO of course Last thing and I know this was another episode but I just had to comment on Robyn's comment about Caleb being the favorite son-in-law. Even if true I thought it was a very snotty thing to say on national television. I've never liked her and she's the reason I quit watching the last couple of seasons. Not sure what got me sucked into this season lol