I think the reason Cary looks a little off in the la facce is because her neck is almost nonexistent. At first I thought she was tensing her shoulders a lot or had terrible posture, but no - she has no neck. She looks like when I would pull the heads off my Barbies and then jam them back on (I'm not a serial killer now, promise).
She's obviously still traditionally gorgeous, but I agree the creep factor outweighs everything else with her and pseudo-Dubrow.