Droogie October 11, 2015 Share October 11, 2015 I can't. I'm out. I feel like whichever one I choose will hurt the other seasons' feelings. 3 Link to comment
amensisterfriend October 12, 2015 Share October 12, 2015 Ha---okay, if it's reached the point of torture, we can totally stop playing :) I definitely understand! 1 Link to comment
Droogie October 12, 2015 Share October 12, 2015 (edited) My feeling is that S1 would be the last one standing. Maybe that's true with every long-running series. And I love, love, love subsequent seasons -- but S1 hooked me. Everything else is gravy. Edited October 12, 2015 by Droogie 1 Link to comment
normasm October 12, 2015 Share October 12, 2015 No, Droogie, leave it as it lays or play it to the end. No point in playing a game if we're just going to cheese out. I would go with 4 myself, because, desert island, that's what I would watch of the remaining choices. I didn't watch the series from the beginning, so, that varies from some of you. But we can't just stop playing because it's hard. It's a game. 1 Link to comment
ForeverAlone October 12, 2015 Share October 12, 2015 If I could only watch one season, I would choose season 4. But if I could only watch one episode, I would choose Extreme Aggressor. 2 Link to comment
Danielg342 October 12, 2015 Share October 12, 2015 S2. Hard choice...but I'm with normasm. It's not much of a game if we chicken out as soon as it gets tough...a good game involves a challenge. This is where it begins. 1 Link to comment
Old Dog October 12, 2015 Share October 12, 2015 Well if I absolutely must I guess it has to be S2 even though that hurts because of Revelations. 3 Link to comment
rapgodminho October 12, 2015 Share October 12, 2015 If it keeps going like this it won't be hard for me at all, since I still choose season 1! ~ Link to comment
Droogie October 12, 2015 Share October 12, 2015 (edited) No, Droogie, leave it as it lays or play it to the end. No point in playing a game if we're just going to cheese out. I would go with 4 myself, because, desert island, that's what I would watch of the remaining choices. I didn't watch the series from the beginning, so, that varies from some of you. But we can't just stop playing because it's hard. It's a game.I can't choose. I'm a blinker.I'll never choose S1. And I can't choose S2 bc Fisher King, Big Game and Revelations. And I can't choose S4 because, well, S4. I simply don't know. Seriously, I would need a lot of discussion and perhaps to watch those seasons again to make a decision. Edited October 12, 2015 by Droogie 2 Link to comment
amensisterfriend October 12, 2015 Share October 12, 2015 So I'm not sure whether we're still playing, but someone else should feel free to run it if we are---my mom needs surgery, so I'll be in and out of the hospital a lot over the next few weeks and may have very limited computer access! Link to comment
thewhiteowl October 12, 2015 Share October 12, 2015 Best wishes for you and your Mom. 1 Link to comment
Old Dog October 12, 2015 Share October 12, 2015 I hope that your mom's surgery goes well - sending good wishes. 1 Link to comment
normasm October 12, 2015 Share October 12, 2015 Amen, hope you and your mom will fare well. We can bring this game back up for the final Death Rounds! when you are back and rested. Good luck! 2 Link to comment
Danielg342 October 13, 2015 Share October 13, 2015 Best wishes amensisterfriend. We'll wait- your mother's health is more important than an Internet forum. 3 Link to comment
amensisterfriend November 7, 2015 Share November 7, 2015 Thank you all so much for the compassion and support! It's a long road, but the latest report from the surgeon and oncologist is that my mother is "recovering like gangbusters," so we're very grateful :) I'm back in my on apartment (after discovering that I would be the worst nurse EVER, by the way), and I'd love to resume the game if you guys are up for it! 3 Link to comment
normasm November 7, 2015 Share November 7, 2015 Such good news, amen! Yay! And, no, you would not be the worst nurse, because you were there. Remind us all of where we were.... 1 Link to comment
Danielg342 November 7, 2015 Share November 7, 2015 The game is down to this (as far as I can tell): S1 (1 vote) S2 (2 votes) S4 Link to comment
amensisterfriend November 7, 2015 Share November 7, 2015 Okay, so let's resume with these three awesome seasons...as painful as this may be, just vote for the one you most want eliminated :) (And we're starting this round again, so if you already voted...please feel free to vote again!) Season 1Season 2Season 4 Link to comment
amensisterfriend November 7, 2015 Share November 7, 2015 Argh, this is so hard! I'm thinking I'll probably have to join Danielg342 in voting against S2 here, but it has some of my all-time favorites. And it pains me to vote against the one season that gives us both Elle and Emily! (Especially since S2 Emily is my favorite incarnation of the character.) Link to comment
amensisterfriend November 9, 2015 Share November 9, 2015 Hoping for another couple of votes before I end this round :) Link to comment
amensisterfriend November 9, 2015 Share November 9, 2015 Okay, shall we move on to the torture known as voting against one of our final two surviving seasons?! Season 1 Season 4 Just vote for the one that you most want eliminated. Meanwhile, once this is over we can do the episodes from each season :) 1 Link to comment
normasm November 9, 2015 Share November 9, 2015 It's brutal, but if i had to live without 4, I just couldn't stand it. Eliminate 1. Link to comment
ReidFan November 9, 2015 Share November 9, 2015 :-( I guess I came into this too late. I would've voted for 1 to be gone before 2. *sniffle* but since it's down to 1 and 4 now I'll have to save 4 and say 1 .....if my vote even matters :D 1 Link to comment
Old Dog November 9, 2015 Share November 9, 2015 It's not right and it's not fair but if one has to go it has to be Season 1. 1 Link to comment
Danielg342 November 9, 2015 Share November 9, 2015 Tough choice...but I'll have to go with S4. Link to comment
amensisterfriend November 10, 2015 Share November 10, 2015 Our triumphant victor: Season 4! And now for the episode game... Extreme Aggressor Compulsion Won't Get Fooled Again Plain Sight Broken Mirror LDSK The Fox Natural Born Killer Derailed The Popular Kids Blood Hungry What Fresh Hell? Poison Riding the Lightning Unfinished Business The Tribe A Real Rain Somebody's Watching Machismo Charm and Harm Secrets and Lies Fisher King Pt 1 Just vote for the three episodes that you most want eliminated! Link to comment
Old Dog November 10, 2015 Share November 10, 2015 Riding the Lightning Charm and Harm Machismo Link to comment
normasm November 10, 2015 Share November 10, 2015 Natural Born Killer Ride the Lightning Secrets and Lies Oh, and YAY! season 4. Relatively speaking.... Link to comment
ForeverAlone November 10, 2015 Share November 10, 2015 Natural Born Killer Machismo Secrets and Lies Link to comment
amensisterfriend November 10, 2015 Share November 10, 2015 I have a bizarre, inexplicable soft spot for Machismo :) What Fresh Hell? Natural Born Killer Somebody's Watching (I should love a Reid-centric episode, right?! But somehow this one just doesn't work me!) Link to comment
ReidFan November 10, 2015 Share November 10, 2015 it would be far easier for me to just vote for the three I want to see stay.......<<will need to think about this more>> Link to comment
Danielg342 November 10, 2015 Share November 10, 2015 Riding The Lightning Poison Blood Hungry Link to comment
ReidFan November 10, 2015 Share November 10, 2015 okay, thought about it, refreshed my memory, these three can go: Secrets and Lies What Fresh Hell Blood Hungry Unfinished Business crap. that's four. Okay, the first three I suppose. Off with their heads! 1 Link to comment
amensisterfriend November 11, 2015 Share November 11, 2015 Extreme AggressorCompulsionWon't Get Fooled AgainPlain SightBroken MirrorLDSKThe FoxDerailedThe Popular KidsBlood HungryWhat Fresh Hell?PoisonUnfinished BusinessThe TribeA Real RainSomebody's WatchingMachismoCharm and HarmFisher King Pt 1 Natural Born Killer, Secrets and Lies (which I find oddly engaging despite knowing it's kind of terrible!) and Riding the Lightning (which I really like...have I mentioned I have terrible taste?!) are our first casualties, and the next round is...drum roll...officially open. We're still voting against three! My votes: What Fresh Hell? Poison Somebody's Watching Link to comment
Old Dog November 11, 2015 Share November 11, 2015 Blood Hungry Charm and Harm Machismo Link to comment
Danielg342 November 11, 2015 Share November 11, 2015 Blood Hungry Poison Charm and Harm Link to comment
normasm November 11, 2015 Share November 11, 2015 Yay! I win the first round!!!! I'm so cool... It gets tougher, though, doesn't it? Machismo Won't Get Fooled Again Blood Hungry (reluctantly) 2 Link to comment
ReidFan November 11, 2015 Share November 11, 2015 What Fresh HellBlood HungryUnfinished Business Link to comment
ForeverAlone November 12, 2015 Share November 12, 2015 Machismo Blood Hungry Won't Get Fooled Again Link to comment
amensisterfriend November 12, 2015 Share November 12, 2015 Machismo and Blood Hungry are history (for some reason I adore both!), but we have a four-way for that final spot among Won't Get Fooled Again, What Fresh Hell?, Poison and Charm and Harm. Just vote for the ONE of those four you most want eliminated. Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.