SueB May 21, 2016 Share May 21, 2016 My memory is good but I'm going to have to say - not definitively. Link to comment
sarthaz May 21, 2016 Share May 21, 2016 Boo! I was going to guess that earlier, but 1) We've already done that in this thread and 2) @SueB was the one who guessed it! :) Link to comment
sarthaz May 23, 2016 Share May 23, 2016 Is it John's journal?!? :) j/k Does it have supernatural properties? Link to comment
catrox14 May 23, 2016 Share May 23, 2016 It's a thing. Does it have supernatural properties? No Link to comment
catrox14 May 23, 2016 Share May 23, 2016 Does it have supernatural properties? No Is it a weapon? No Link to comment
catrox14 May 23, 2016 Share May 23, 2016 51 minutes ago, catrox14 said: Does it have supernatural properties? No Is it a weapon? No Is it bigger than a Breadbox? No Link to comment
catrox14 May 23, 2016 Share May 23, 2016 Does it have supernatural properties? No Is it a weapon? No Is it bigger than a Breadbox? No Does it belong to Sam and/or Dean? Not really Link to comment
catrox14 May 24, 2016 Share May 24, 2016 Does it have supernatural properties? No Is it a weapon? No Is it bigger than a Breadbox? No Does it belong to Sam and/or Dean? Not really Does it have any mechanical parts? No Link to comment
catrox14 May 24, 2016 Share May 24, 2016 Does it have supernatural properties? No Is it a weapon? No Is it bigger than a Breadbox? No Does it belong to Sam and/or Dean? Not really Does it have any mechanical parts? No Does it appear in more than one episode? Yes Link to comment
BlueMeanie May 24, 2016 Author Share May 24, 2016 Does it appear in more than one season? Link to comment
catrox14 May 24, 2016 Share May 24, 2016 13 hours ago, catrox14 said: Does it have supernatural properties? No Is it a weapon? No Is it bigger than a Breadbox? No Does it belong to Sam and/or Dean? Not really Does it have any mechanical parts? No Does it appear in more than one episode? Yes Does it appear in more than one season? Yes Link to comment
catrox14 May 24, 2016 Share May 24, 2016 3 hours ago, catrox14 said: 16 hours ago, catrox14 said: Does it have supernatural properties? No Is it a weapon? No Is it bigger than a Breadbox? No Does it belong to Sam and/or Dean? Not really Does it have any mechanical parts? No Does it appear in more than one episode? Yes Does it appear in more than one season? Yes Is it made of metal? No Link to comment
AwesomO4000 May 25, 2016 Share May 25, 2016 Is it the dream catcher in the trunk of the Impala? Link to comment
catrox14 May 25, 2016 Share May 25, 2016 1 minute ago, AwesomO4000 said: oes it have supernatural properties? No Is it a weapon? No Is it bigger than a Breadbox? No Does it belong to Sam and/or Dean? Not really Does it have any mechanical parts? No Does it appear in more than one episode? Yes Does it appear in more than one season? Yes Is it made of metal? No Is it the dream catcher in the trunk of the Impala No Link to comment
BlueMeanie May 25, 2016 Author Share May 25, 2016 Can it be found in the trunk of the Impala? Link to comment
catrox14 May 25, 2016 Share May 25, 2016 Can it be found in the trunk of the Impala? AFAIK it's whereabouts are unknown. Link to comment
sarthaz May 25, 2016 Share May 25, 2016 Is it primarily made of wood or wood byproducts? Link to comment
catrox14 May 25, 2016 Share May 25, 2016 3 hours ago, sarthaz said: Is it primarily made of wood or wood byproducts? No. Link to comment
catrox14 May 25, 2016 Share May 25, 2016 15 hours ago, catrox14 said: 15 hours ago, AwesomO4000 said: Does it have supernatural properties? No Is it a weapon? No Is it bigger than a Breadbox? No Does it belong to Sam and/or Dean? Not really Does it have any mechanical parts? No Does it appear in more than one episode? Yes Does it appear in more than one season? Yes Is it made of metal? No Is it the dream catcher in the trunk of the Impala No Can it be found in the trunk of the Impala? AFAIK, it's whereabouts are unknown Is it made of wood or wood by-products? No. Link to comment
catrox14 May 25, 2016 Share May 25, 2016 (edited) It's a thing: 1)Does it have supernatural properties? No 2) Is it a weapon? No 3) Is it bigger than a Breadbox? No 4)Does it belong to Sam and/or Dean? Not really 5) Does it have any mechanical parts? No 6) Does it appear in more than one episode? Yes 7) Does it appear in more than one season? Yes 8) Is it made of metal? No 9) Is it the dream catcher in the trunk of the Impala No 10) Can it be found in the trunk of the Impala? AFAIK, it's whereabouts are unknown 11 )Is it made of wood or wood by-products? No. 12 ) Does it appear during the Kripke years? No Edited May 25, 2016 by catrox14 Link to comment
sarthaz May 27, 2016 Share May 27, 2016 Does it have anything to do with Men of Letters? Link to comment
catrox14 May 27, 2016 Share May 27, 2016 Quote 1)Does it have supernatural properties? No 2) Is it a weapon? No 3) Is it bigger than a Breadbox? No 4)Does it belong to Sam and/or Dean? Not really 5) Does it have any mechanical parts? No 6) Does it appear in more than one episode? Yes 7) Does it appear in more than one season? Yes 8) Is it made of metal? No 9) Is it the dream catcher in the trunk of the Impala No 10) Can it be found in the trunk of the Impala? AFAIK, it's whereabouts are unknown 11 )Is it made of wood or wood by-products? No. 12 ) Does it appear during the Kripke years? No 13) Does it have anything to do with the Men of Letters? No Link to comment
catrox14 May 27, 2016 Share May 27, 2016 18 hours ago, catrox14 said: Quote 1)Does it have supernatural properties? No 2) Is it a weapon? No 3) Is it bigger than a Breadbox? No 4)Does it belong to Sam and/or Dean? Not really 5) Does it have any mechanical parts? No 6) Does it appear in more than one episode? Yes 7) Does it appear in more than one season? Yes 8) Is it made of metal? No 9) Is it the dream catcher in the trunk of the Impala No 10) Can it be found in the trunk of the Impala? AFAIK, it's whereabouts are unknown 11 )Is it made of wood or wood by-products? No. 12 ) Does it appear during the Kripke years? No 13) Does it have anything to do with the Men of Letters? No 14) Is it primarily composed of textiles? No Link to comment
catrox14 May 28, 2016 Share May 28, 2016 (edited) 6 hours ago, sarthaz said: Does it appear in Seasons 6, 7, or 8? Yes it appears in one of those seasons Edited May 28, 2016 by catrox14 Link to comment
SueB May 28, 2016 Share May 28, 2016 Is it of man-made materials (i.e. not found in that form in nature)? Link to comment
catrox14 May 28, 2016 Share May 28, 2016 31 minutes ago, SueB said: Is it of man-made materials (i.e. not found in that form in nature)? Hmmm.. Yes and no. It has both natural and man-made materials. Link to comment
sarthaz May 30, 2016 Share May 30, 2016 I have no clue, so I'll burn some questions on process of elimination: Does it appear in Season 8? Link to comment
catrox14 May 30, 2016 Share May 30, 2016 It's a thing 1)Does it have supernatural properties? No 2) Is it a weapon? No 3) Is it bigger than a Breadbox? No 4)Does it belong to Sam and/or Dean? Not really 5) Does it have any mechanical parts? No 6) Does it appear in more than one episode? Yes 7) Does it appear in more than one season? Yes 8) Is it made of metal? No 9) Is it the dream catcher in the trunk of the Impala No 10) Can it be found in the trunk of the Impala? AFAIK, it's whereabouts are unknown 11 )Is it made of wood or wood by-products? No. 12 ) Does it appear during the Kripke years? No 13) Does it have anything to do with the Men of Letters? No 14) Is it primarily composed of textiles? NO 15) Is it of man-made materials (i.e. not found in that form in nature)? Hmmm.. It has both natural and man-made materials. 16 ) Does it appear in Seasons 6, 7, or 8? Yes it appears in one of those seasons 17 )Does it appear in Season 8? No Link to comment
SueB May 31, 2016 Share May 31, 2016 Quote 7) Does it appear in more than one season? Yes Can you clarify... the answer to Question 7 (above) and 16 (below) Quote 16 ) Does it appear in Seasons 6, 7, or 8? Yes it appears in one of those seasons see bolded text. Can you confirm BOTH are still correct. That it was in ONE of the seasons (6 or 7) AND that it has appeared in more than one season. I see a possible way for that to be true, I just need confirmation there's no boo-boo here. Link to comment
catrox14 May 31, 2016 Share May 31, 2016 (edited) Yes both are still correct. There is no mistake. Edited May 31, 2016 by catrox14 Link to comment
AwesomO4000 May 31, 2016 Share May 31, 2016 (edited) Does it also appear in season 9? Edited May 31, 2016 by AwesomO4000 Link to comment
catrox14 May 31, 2016 Share May 31, 2016 It's a thing 1)Does it have supernatural properties? No 2) Is it a weapon? No 3) Is it bigger than a Breadbox? No 4)Does it belong to Sam and/or Dean? Not really 5) Does it have any mechanical parts? No 6) Does it appear in more than one episode? Yes 7) Does it appear in more than one season? Yes 8) Is it made of metal? No 9) Is it the dream catcher in the trunk of the Impala No 10) Can it be found in the trunk of the Impala? AFAIK, it's whereabouts are unknown 11 )Is it made of wood or wood by-products? No. 12 ) Does it appear during the Kripke years? No 13) Does it have anything to do with the Men of Letters? No 14) Is it primarily composed of textiles? NO15) Is it of man-made materials (i.e. not found in that form in nature)? Hmmm.. It has both natural and man-made materials. 16 ) Does it appear in Seasons 6, 7, or 8? Yes it appears in one of those seasons 17 )Does it appear in Season 8? No 18) Does it also appear in season 9? No Link to comment
SueB May 31, 2016 Share May 31, 2016 Was this item ever mentioned on-screen (as opposed to simply being in the background)? Link to comment
catrox14 May 31, 2016 Share May 31, 2016 19) Was it ever mentioned on-screen (as opposed to simply being in the background)? Yes. Link to comment
catrox14 June 1, 2016 Share June 1, 2016 Okay so we are approaching the 20th question. Here is a summary. It's a thing 1)Does it have supernatural properties? No 2) Is it a weapon? No 3) Is it bigger than a Breadbox? No 4)Does it belong to Sam and/or Dean? Not really. 5) Does it have any mechanical parts? No 6) Does it appear in more than one episode? Yes 7) Does it appear in more than one season? Yes 8) Is it made of metal? No 9) Is it the dream catcher in the trunk of the Impala No 10) Can it be found in the trunk of the Impala? AFAIK, it's whereabouts are unknown 11 )Is it made of wood or wood by-products? No. 12 ) Does it appear during the Kripke years? No 13) Does it have anything to do with the Men of Letters? No 14) Is it primarily composed of textiles? No15) Is it of man-made materials (i.e. not found in that form in nature)? Consists of both natural and man-made materials. 16 ) Does it appear in Seasons 6, 7, or 8? Yes it appears in one of those seasons 17 )Does it appear in Season 8? No 18) Does it also appear in season 9? No 19) Was it ever mentioned on-screen (as opposed to simply being in the background)? Yes. Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.