AwesomO4000 June 5, 2016 Share June 5, 2016 Oh good guess, catrox. I didn't think Sarah had ridden in the Impala, but then again, Lisa is alive so a big "Doh!" on my part. Link to comment
sarthaz June 5, 2016 Share June 5, 2016 1 hour ago, catrox14 said: Is it Sarah? Winner! It is indeed Sarah. I was inspired by your bottle of Johnnie, picking someone who got a callback many seasons later. I assumed she rode in the Impala when dating Sam and ghost-hunting with the boys, but I wasn't 100% certain there was actual footage of her in the backseat, so I rewatched to be sure. Yep. She's in there. Bring on the next game! 1 Link to comment
catrox14 June 5, 2016 Share June 5, 2016 1) Does this thing have magical properties? NO Link to comment
sarthaz June 5, 2016 Share June 5, 2016 Has it ever been owned by a Winchester or Campbell? Link to comment
catrox14 June 5, 2016 Share June 5, 2016 1) Does this thing have magical properties? NO 2) Has it ever been owned by a Winchester or Campbell? Yes-ish Link to comment
catrox14 June 5, 2016 Share June 5, 2016 1) Does this thing have magical properties? NO 2) Has it ever been owned by a Winchester or Campbell? Yes-ish 3)Is any part of it made of wood or stone? NO Link to comment
catrox14 June 5, 2016 Share June 5, 2016 1) Does this thing have magical properties? NO 2) Has it ever been owned by a Winchester or Campbell? Yes-ish 3)Is any part of it made of wood or stone? NO 4) Is it mechanical? NO Link to comment
AwesomO4000 June 6, 2016 Share June 6, 2016 Has this thing been seen in more than one episode? Link to comment
catrox14 June 6, 2016 Share June 6, 2016 1) Does this thing have magical properties? NO 2) Has it ever been owned by a Winchester or Campbell? Yes-ish 3)Is any part of it made of wood or stone? NO 4) Is it mechanical? NO 5) Has this thing been seen in more than one episode? YES Link to comment
catrox14 June 6, 2016 Share June 6, 2016 1) Does this thing have magical properties? NO 2) Has it ever been owned by a Winchester or Campbell? Yes-ish 3)Is any part of it made of wood or stone? NO 4) Is it mechanical? NO 5) Has this thing been seen in more than one episode? YES 6) Was it seen during the Kripke years? NO Link to comment
catrox14 June 6, 2016 Share June 6, 2016 1 hour ago, catrox14 said: ) Does this thing have magical properties? NO 2) Has it ever been owned by a Winchester or Campbell? Yes-ish 3)Is any part of it made of wood or stone? NO 4) Is it mechanical? NO 5) Has this thing been seen in more than one episode? YES 6) Was it seen during the Kripke years? NO 7) Was it seen during the Gamble years? NO Link to comment
sarthaz June 6, 2016 Share June 6, 2016 Is any of it made from human or animal parts? Bone, leather, teeth, skin, etc? Link to comment
catrox14 June 6, 2016 Share June 6, 2016 (edited) 1) Does this thing have magical properties? NO 2) Has it ever been owned by a Winchester or Campbell? Yes-ish 3)Is any part of it made of wood or stone? NO 4) Is it mechanical? NO 5) Has this thing been seen in more than one episode? YES 6) Was it seen during the Kripke years? NO 7) Was it seen during the Gamble years? NO 8) Is any of it made from human or animal parts? Bone, leather, teeth, skin, etc? Unclear but likely Edited June 6, 2016 by catrox14 Link to comment
catrox14 June 7, 2016 Share June 7, 2016 1) Does this thing have magical properties? NO 2) Has it ever been owned by a Winchester or Campbell? Yes-ish 3)Is any part of it made of wood or stone? NO 4) Is it mechanical? NO 5) Has this thing been seen in more than one episode? YES 6) Was it seen during the Kripke years? NO 7) Was it seen during the Gamble years? NO 8) Is any of it made from human or animal parts? Bone, leather, teeth, skin, etc? Unclear but likely 9) Is it in Season 8 or 9? YES Link to comment
catrox14 June 7, 2016 Share June 7, 2016 1) Does this thing have magical properties? NO 2) Has it ever been owned by a Winchester or Campbell? Yes-ish 3)Is any part of it made of wood or stone? NO 4) Is it mechanical? NO 5) Has this thing been seen in more than one episode? YES 6) Was it seen during the Kripke years? NO 7) Was it seen during the Gamble years? NO 8) Is any of it made from human or animal parts? Bone, leather, teeth, skin, etc? Unclear but likely 9) Is it in Season 8 or 9? YES 10) Is it a weapon? NO Link to comment
catrox14 June 7, 2016 Share June 7, 2016 1) Does this thing have magical properties? NO 2) Has it ever been owned by a Winchester or Campbell? Yes-ish 3)Is any part of it made of wood or stone? NO 4) Is it mechanical? NO 5) Has this thing been seen in more than one episode? YES 6) Was it seen during the Kripke years? NO 7) Was it seen during the Gamble years? NO 8) Is any of it made from human or animal parts? Bone, leather, teeth, skin, etc? Unclear but likely 9) Is it in Season 8 or 9? YES 10) Is it a weapon? NO 11) Is it bigger than a breadbox? YES Link to comment
catrox14 June 8, 2016 Share June 8, 2016 Bumping....don't give up y'all. This is easier than you think! Link to comment
catrox14 June 8, 2016 Share June 8, 2016 1) Does this thing have magical properties? NO 2) Has it ever been owned by a Winchester or Campbell? Yes-ish 3)Is any part of it made of wood or stone? NO 4) Is it mechanical? NO 5) Has this thing been seen in more than one episode? YES 6) Was it seen during the Kripke years? NO 7) Was it seen during the Gamble years? NO 8) Is any of it made from human or animal parts? Bone, leather, teeth, skin, etc? Unclear but likely 9) Is it in Season 8 or 9? YES 10) Is it a weapon? NO 11) Is it bigger than a breadbox? YES 12 ) Has it been inside the bunker? YES Link to comment
catrox14 June 8, 2016 Share June 8, 2016 13 minutes ago, AwesomO4000 said: Is it Dean's "Dead man's" robe? @AwesomO4000 swoops in FTW. WINNER WINNER CHICKEN DINNER 1 Link to comment
AwesomO4000 June 9, 2016 Share June 9, 2016 Yayyyyy! (Imagine Kermit the frog waving his arms). Well, I was going to do a person, but looking back at the beginning of the thread, I noticed that we haven't done an episode yet, so I thought I'd try something different. It's an episode. Link to comment
catrox14 June 9, 2016 Share June 9, 2016 15 minutes ago, AwesomO4000 said: Yayyyyy! (Imagine Kermit the frog waving his arms). 2 Link to comment
AwesomO4000 June 9, 2016 Share June 9, 2016 1) Is it a Monster of the Week-focused episode? I would say more yes than no. Link to comment
AwesomO4000 June 9, 2016 Share June 9, 2016 1) Is it a Monster of the Week-focused episode? I would say more yes than no. 2) Did it air before Bobby died? Yes Link to comment
sarthaz June 9, 2016 Share June 9, 2016 Is the "monster" killed by a physical weapon (stabbed, shot, decapitated vs burning bones, burning house, incantation, etc)? Link to comment
AwesomO4000 June 9, 2016 Share June 9, 2016 (edited) 1) Is it a Monster of the Week-focused episode? I would say more YES than no. 2) Did it air before Bobby died? YES 3) Is the "monster" killed by a physical weapon (stabbed, shot, decapitated vs burning bones, burning house, incantation, etc)? NO* * (I was going to try to specify, but it actually made it more confusing than informative) Edited June 9, 2016 by AwesomO4000 Clarification Link to comment
sarthaz June 9, 2016 Share June 9, 2016 Trying hard not to ask chronological questions, because that makes it too easy to narrow down. :) Is there another hunter (or future hunter) in this episode besides Sam, Dean, or Bobby? Link to comment
AwesomO4000 June 9, 2016 Share June 9, 2016 14 minutes ago, sarthaz said: Trying hard not to ask chronological questions, because that makes it too easy to narrow down. :) I think it's okay. Even if it narrows it down to one season, there are still at least 16 - 23 episodes to choose from to start, and then narrow down the clues so... 1) Is it a Monster of the Week-focused episode? I would say more YES than no. 2) Did it air before Bobby died? YES 3) Is the "monster" killed by a physical weapon (stabbed, shot, decapitated vs burning bones, burning house, incantation, etc)? NO* 4) Is there another hunter (or future hunter) in this episode besides Sam, Dean, or Bobby? NO (Or at least not really) Link to comment
AwesomO4000 June 9, 2016 Share June 9, 2016 1) Is it a Monster of the Week-focused episode? I would say more YES than no. 2) Did it air before Bobby died? YES 3) Is the "monster" killed by a physical weapon (stabbed, shot, decapitated vs burning bones, burning house, incantation, etc)? NO* 4) Is there another hunter (or future hunter) in this episode besides Sam, Dean, or Bobby? NO (Or at least not really) 5) Is the "monster" an angel or a demon? YES Link to comment
sarthaz June 10, 2016 Share June 10, 2016 4 hours ago, AwesomO4000 said: I think it's okay. Even if it narrows it down to one season, there are still at least 16 - 23 episodes to choose from to start, and then narrow down the clues so... A simple binary search could solve in just 8 questions, and that's no fun ... :) Do any humans die after the Winchesters are on the case? Link to comment
AwesomO4000 June 10, 2016 Share June 10, 2016 9 minutes ago, sarthaz said: A simple binary search could solve in just 8 questions, and that's no fun ... :) Hee - well yes if you just focused on when in the season it was (It took me a moment to figure out what you meant. I guess that would be a good rule modification to not have any questions beyond which season if it's an episode.) Based on the above questions though, you have the seasons narrowed down at least a little bit. 1) Is it a Monster of the Week-focused episode? I would say more YES than no. 2) Did it air before Bobby died? YES 3) Is the "monster" killed by a physical weapon (stabbed, shot, decapitated vs burning bones, burning house, incantation, etc)? NO* 4) Is there another hunter (or future hunter) in this episode besides Sam, Dean, or Bobby? NO (Or at least not really) 5) Is the "monster" an angel or a demon? YES 6) Do any humans die after the Winchesters are on the case? YES Link to comment
SueB June 10, 2016 Share June 10, 2016 AwesomeO...not a question, just looking to clarify ... "NO*" vs "NO" is not a typo. Link to comment
AwesomO4000 June 10, 2016 Share June 10, 2016 (edited) 10 hours ago, SueB said: AwesomeO...not a question, just looking to clarify ... "NO*" vs "NO" is not a typo. Sorry for the delay. It's been one of those days... The original "NO*" above had a caveat, but I removed it and put a notation instead, because it ended up being more confusing than anything, and the difficulty for me was because the question could be interpreted two ways. 1) The "monster" in this particular episode was killed by being stabbed, shot, decapitated, etc. vs burning bones, incantation, burning house or 2) the "monster" (type) in general is killed by being stabbed, shot, decapitated, etc. The "NO" only qualified for the first interpretation of the answer, but I wasn't sure how to answer that without making it more confusing or giving away too much information. But since question # 5 helps with that - because both demons and angels for example can be killed by stabbing - this answered that iffy part of the question. So now you know that the monster is an angel or a demon BUT it was not killed (in the meaning that it has completely ceased to be, never to return) by being stabbed, shot, decapitated, etc in this episode. So in other words, this episode would not for example be "All Hell Breaks Loose, pt 2," because Azazel was shot and was definitely killed, never to return, nor would it be "Point of No Return," because ditto for Zachariah except he was stabbed. I left the * in there to emphasize the fact that the "monster" was not killed by being shot, stabbed, etc., in this episode. I can remove it now if it is confusing and now that we have the added information that it is a demon or an angel. Or I can leave it to emphasize that in this episode, the monster was not killed by any of those methods. There is actually also further confusion / gray area here with that question, but I'm hoping that further questions will sort that little kerfluffle out. If not and there is difficulty with the guessing, I will qualify... somehow. I hope that helped more than was more confusing. Edited June 10, 2016 by AwesomO4000 edited for further clarification... geez can't I just say something for goodness sakes without having to explain it. 2 Link to comment
sarthaz June 10, 2016 Share June 10, 2016 Thanks for the clarification! That original question was mine. Sorry if it was vague. I had intended it to mean in this particular episode, but I see now how it could be confusing. :) Is a Devil's Trap used in this episode? Link to comment
AwesomO4000 June 10, 2016 Share June 10, 2016 2 minutes ago, sarthaz said: Thanks for the clarification! That original question was mine. Sorry if it was vague. I had intended it to mean in this particular episode, but I see now how it could be confusing. :) Is a Devil's Trap used in this episode? No problem - not your fault at all. It's the episode not wanting to fit specifically into your question. ; ) 1) Is it a Monster of the Week-focused episode? I would say more YES than no. 2) Did it air before Bobby died? YES 3) Is the "monster" killed by a physical weapon (stabbed, shot, decapitated vs burning bones, burning house, incantation, etc)? NO 4) Is there another hunter (or future hunter) in this episode besides Sam, Dean, or Bobby? NO (Or at least not really) 5) Is the "monster" an angel or a demon? YES 6) Do any humans die after the Winchesters are on the case? YES 7) Is a Devil's Trap used in this episode? NO Link to comment
SueB June 10, 2016 Share June 10, 2016 AwesomeO, thanks for the answer. That really clears things up -- I couldn't figure out what was confusing but now I understand. So thanks. 1 Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.