sarthaz June 1, 2016 Share June 1, 2016 20) Is there any chance in Hell that we can guess this? 20) Are we going to feel really stupid when you tell us? I've been racking my brain trying to think of something that connects Season 6 or 7 with Season 10 or 11 that isn't a weapon or supernatural or metal or wood or textile, and I got nuthin. So I'll trim the field and ask: Does it appear in Season 7? Link to comment
catrox14 June 1, 2016 Share June 1, 2016 (edited) Okay so we are approaching the 20th question. Here is a summary. It's a thing 1)Does it have supernatural properties? No 2) Is it a weapon? No 3) Is it bigger than a Breadbox? No 4)Does it belong to Sam and/or Dean? Not really. 5) Does it have any mechanical parts? No 6) Does it appear in more than one episode? Yes 7) Does it appear in more than one season? Yes 8) Is it made of metal? No 9) Is it the dream catcher in the trunk of the Impala No 10) Can it be found in the trunk of the Impala? AFAIK, it's whereabouts are unknown 11 )Is it made of wood or wood by-products? No. 12 ) Does it appear during the Kripke years? No 13) Does it have anything to do with the Men of Letters? No 14) Is it primarily composed of textiles? No15) Is it of man-made materials (i.e. not found in that form in nature)? Consists of both natural and man-made materials. 16 ) Does it appear in Seasons 6, 7, or 8? Yes it appears in one of those seasons 17 )Does it appear in Season 8? No 18) Does it also appear in season 9? No 19) Was it ever mentioned on-screen (as opposed to simply being in the background)? Yes. 20) Does it appear in season 7? Yes Edited June 1, 2016 by catrox14 Link to comment
catrox14 June 1, 2016 Share June 1, 2016 (edited) 1 hour ago, sarthaz said: 20) Is there any chance in Hell that we can guess this? 20) Are we going to feel really stupid when you tell us? I've been racking my brain trying to think of something that connects Season 6 or 7 with Season 10 or 11 that isn't a weapon or supernatural or metal or wood or textile, and I got nuthin. So I'll trim the field and ask: Does it appear in Season 7? 20)a. Yes you can definitely figure this out. Definitely. 20)b. I don't think you'll feel stupid but I think you might slap your collective forehead. And go "AHHHH OF COURSE" and then laugh. You guys aren't idjits. Edited June 1, 2016 by catrox14 Link to comment
catrox14 June 1, 2016 Share June 1, 2016 (edited) 1 hour ago, sarthaz said: Sorry, THIS specifically ^^^^ is not the correct answer. Edited June 1, 2016 by catrox14 Link to comment
catrox14 June 1, 2016 Share June 1, 2016 41 minutes ago, sarthaz said: Balls! Hope someone else gets it. See my edit Link to comment
SueB June 2, 2016 Share June 2, 2016 oh wait... you mean it's the SPECIFIC bottle Rufus gave Bobby. I almost guessed that about 3 times. I would argue there's nothing "natural" about whiskey. It is man-made. BUT I'll go ahead and formally guess: - the SPECIFIC bottle Rufus gave Bobby 1 Link to comment
catrox14 June 2, 2016 Share June 2, 2016 SueB is correct. Whiskey is made from natural ingredients that's why I said it's both natural and man-made. You have to start with the grains. But if y'all have a problem with my clues, we can just throw out this game and someone else can make a new one. I think I was fair with all of my clues. Link to comment
SueB June 2, 2016 Share June 2, 2016 Nah, it's okay... I was right there with it belong to either Bobby, Rufus, Charlie, or Jodi....and glass (not metal or wood) worked... but I kept getting stuck on the whiskey. However, I see your point... technically it's manmade but I can see your POV. Having said all this... I'm happy to defer to someone else if they want to be the game master. I'll give it 3 hrs for someone else to pipe up.... Link to comment
BlueMeanie June 2, 2016 Author Share June 2, 2016 That was a good one Catrox. I haven't had much time to play lately, but I don't think I would have guessed it anyway. By the way, glad to see that people seem to be enjoying this game, I wasn't sure how it would go. :-) Link to comment
AwesomO4000 June 2, 2016 Share June 2, 2016 31 minutes ago, SueB said: Having said all this... I'm happy to defer to someone else if they want to be the game master. I'll give it 3 hrs for someone else to pipe up.... I would do it, but I don't think it would feel earned. Besides, I feel like sarthaz came so close, so if sarthaz wants to do it, then he/she should get the chance. Link to comment
sarthaz June 2, 2016 Share June 2, 2016 Balls! I just picked the first google image that came up. I clearly meant the Rufus bottle from Time After Time and Safe House. I'm happy to defer to SueB, though. Or run a game if she doesn't want to. I'm ok either way. As to the clues, I think you did fine with what you had. I didn't want to guess it sooner because the cap and label are made of metal, and the twisting cap could be a mechanical operation, but that's nitpicky and I think your clues were fair. I found that to be an excellent game and very difficult, but not impossible. Link to comment
catrox14 June 2, 2016 Share June 2, 2016 1 minute ago, sarthaz said: Balls! I just picked the first google image that came up. I clearly meant the Rufus bottle from Time After Time and Safe House. I'm happy to defer to SueB, though. Or run a game if she doesn't want to. I'm ok either way. As to the clues, I think you did fine with what you had. I didn't want to guess it sooner because the cap and label are made of metal, and the twisting cap could be a mechanical operation, but that's nitpicky and I think your clues were fair. I found that to be an excellent game and very difficult, but not impossible. I went back and forth on the cap and label and I literally googled to make sure what it was made of but there is a cork or rubber stopper on the one that I saw and the whole thing wasn't made of metal I lumped that under man-made in my head. LOL I didn't think about twisting the cap as being "mechanical". I suspected sarthaz that you were intending to go with the bottle from Safe House and Time after Time but since you didn't go with that one, I had to give it to SueB. Sorry! Link to comment
catrox14 June 2, 2016 Share June 2, 2016 Is this character human and alive at present? Link to comment
sarthaz June 2, 2016 Share June 2, 2016 It's a character. 1) Is this character human and alive at present? NO (unless you want me to answer this as two separate questions?) Link to comment
catrox14 June 3, 2016 Share June 3, 2016 11 hours ago, sarthaz said: It's a character. 1) Is this character human and alive at present? NO (unless you want me to answer this as two separate questions?) Just to clarify. I'm asking one question. I'm asking if the character is BOTH human and alive at present? Link to comment
BlueMeanie June 3, 2016 Author Share June 3, 2016 (edited) I think the answer "no" to that specific question implies that they are either not human and presently alive, human but presently dead, or not human and not presently alive. It's impossible to know which. Just as a reminder, as per the rules, the respondent should always answer with a "yes" or "no" whenever possible. There's no need to elaborate unless there is no other way to respond. Edited June 3, 2016 by BlueMeanie Link to comment
sarthaz June 3, 2016 Share June 3, 2016 It's a character. 1) Is this character human and alive at present? NO Link to comment
SueB June 3, 2016 Share June 3, 2016 Sorry catrox, I'm not sophisticated enough to understand how that narrows down the list.... I'll ask a question in a different direction but eventually I'll need it spelled out I think... 2. Has this character ridden in the Impala? Link to comment
sarthaz June 3, 2016 Share June 3, 2016 (edited) It's a boolean question. I was afraid to answer it literally for fear of confusion. Basically it means that the character is not BOTH human AND currently alive. That means the character could be in one of three remaining groups: 1) Human and Dead; 2) Inhuman and Dead; 3) Inhuman and Alive. It's a very specific question, and if I'd said YES, you'd have really narrowed the pool. But alas, the answer is NO. 1) Is this character human and alive at present? NO 2) Has this character ridden in the Impala? YES Edited June 3, 2016 by sarthaz 1 Link to comment
sarthaz June 3, 2016 Share June 3, 2016 1) Is this character human and alive at present? NO 2) Has this character ridden in the Impala? YES 3) Is the character a demon? NO Link to comment
sarthaz June 3, 2016 Share June 3, 2016 1) Is this character human and alive at present? NO 2) Has this character ridden in the Impala? YES 3) Is the character a demon? NO 4) Is the character female? YES Link to comment
sarthaz June 3, 2016 Share June 3, 2016 1) Is this character human and alive at present? NO 2) Has this character ridden in the Impala? YES 3) Is the character a demon? NO 4) Is the character female? YES 5) Is the character a protagonist? YES Link to comment
sarthaz June 3, 2016 Share June 3, 2016 1) Is this character human and alive at present? NO 2) Has this character ridden in the Impala? YES 3) Is the character a demon? NO 4) Is the character female? YES 5) Is the character a protagonist? YES 6) Is the character only seen in female form? YES Link to comment
sarthaz June 4, 2016 Share June 4, 2016 1) Is this character human and alive at present? NO 2) Has this character ridden in the Impala? YES 3) Is the character a demon? NO 4) Is the character female? YES 5) Is the character a protagonist? YES 6) Is the character only seen in female form? YES 7) Is the character in more than one episode? YES Link to comment
AwesomO4000 June 4, 2016 Share June 4, 2016 Does the character have supernatural powers or abilities? Link to comment
sarthaz June 4, 2016 Share June 4, 2016 1) Is this character human and alive at present? NO 2) Has this character ridden in the Impala? YES 3) Is the character a demon? NO 4) Is the character female? YES 5) Is the character a protagonist? YES 6) Is the character only seen in female form? YES 7) Is the character in more than one episode? YES 8) Does the character have supernatural powers or abilities? NO Link to comment
SueB June 4, 2016 Share June 4, 2016 Welp... that really narrows it down for me... I may be off on the wrong tangent but I THINK we are looking at Dead human females who had more than one story and rode in the impala. That's a limited subset. 9) Is it Ellen? Link to comment
sarthaz June 4, 2016 Share June 4, 2016 1) Is this character human and alive at present? NO 2) Has this character ridden in the Impala? YES 3) Is the character a demon? NO 4) Is the character female? YES 5) Is the character a protagonist? YES 6) Is the character only seen in female form? YES 7) Is the character in more than one episode? YES 8) Does the character have supernatural powers or abilities? NO 9) Is it Ellen? NO Link to comment
catrox14 June 4, 2016 Share June 4, 2016 Has the character been seen only in seasons 9 through 11? Link to comment
sarthaz June 4, 2016 Share June 4, 2016 1) Is this character human and alive at present? NO 2) Has this character ridden in the Impala? YES 3) Is the character a demon? NO 4) Is the character female? YES 5) Is the character a protagonist? YES 6) Is the character only seen in female form? YES 7) Is the character in more than one episode? YES 8) Does the character have supernatural powers or abilities? NO 9) Is it Ellen? NO 10) Has the character been seen only in seasons 9 through 11? NO Link to comment
sarthaz June 4, 2016 Share June 4, 2016 1) Is this character human and alive at present? NO 2) Has this character ridden in the Impala? YES 3) Is the character a demon? NO 4) Is the character female? YES 5) Is the character a protagonist? YES 6) Is the character only seen in female form? YES 7) Is the character in more than one episode? YES 8) Does the character have supernatural powers or abilities? NO 9) Is it Ellen? NO 10) Has the character been seen only in seasons 9 through 11? NO 11) Is it Jo? NO Link to comment
SueB June 4, 2016 Share June 4, 2016 Was the character seen in the Kripke years (S1-S5) Link to comment
sarthaz June 5, 2016 Share June 5, 2016 1) Is this character human and alive at present? NO 2) Has this character ridden in the Impala? YES 3) Is the character a demon? NO 4) Is the character female? YES 5) Is the character a protagonist? YES 6) Is the character only seen in female form? YES 7) Is the character in more than one episode? YES 8) Does the character have supernatural powers or abilities? NO 9) Is it Ellen? NO 10) Has the character been seen only in seasons 9 through 11? NO 11) Is it Jo? NO 12) Was the character seen in the Kripke years (S1-S5) YES Link to comment
sarthaz June 5, 2016 Share June 5, 2016 1) Is this character human and alive at present? NO 2) Has this character ridden in the Impala? YES 3) Is the character a demon? NO 4) Is the character female? YES 5) Is the character a protagonist? YES 6) Is the character only seen in female form? YES 7) Is the character in more than one episode? YES 8) Does the character have supernatural powers or abilities? NO 9) Is it Ellen? NO 10) Has the character been seen only in seasons 9 through 11? NO 11) Is it Jo? NO 12) Was the character seen in the Kripke years (S1-S5) YES 13) Is it Young Mary? NO Link to comment
sarthaz June 5, 2016 Share June 5, 2016 1) Is this character human and alive at present? NO 2) Has this character ridden in the Impala? YES 3) Is the character a demon? NO 4) Is the character female? YES 5) Is the character a protagonist? YES 6) Is the character only seen in female form? YES 7) Is the character in more than one episode? YES 8) Does the character have supernatural powers or abilities? NO 9) Is it Ellen? NO 10) Has the character been seen only in seasons 9 through 11? NO 11) Is it Jo? NO 12) Was the character seen in the Kripke years (S1-S5) YES 13) Is it Young Mary? NO 14) Is it Jodi Mills? NO Link to comment
AwesomO4000 June 5, 2016 Share June 5, 2016 (edited) 14 hours ago, SueB said: Welp... that really narrows it down for me... I may be off on the wrong tangent but I THINK we are looking at Dead human females who had more than one story and rode in the impala. That's a limited subset. It would be an even smaller subset than that, since it also rules out psychics (like Pamela) witches (like Rowena) and humans who got turned into monsters (like Madison). Although I also realize Rowena is still alive, so she was just an example of a human witch. Also later introduced female characters are out. So I'm also trying to think of a non-human character that doesn't have supernatural powers or abilities. (I couldn't think of one so far). I have two guesses, but I can't remember for sure if either rode in the Impala. Oh wait - one I was thinking of was an antagonist, so, ah crap... I'll just go for it, since I think there was an Impala ride to the hospital when she got stabbed by a demon... Is it Lisa? Edited June 5, 2016 by AwesomO4000 Link to comment
sarthaz June 5, 2016 Share June 5, 2016 1) Is this character human and alive at present? NO 2) Has this character ridden in the Impala? YES 3) Is the character a demon? NO 4) Is the character female? YES 5) Is the character a protagonist? YES 6) Is the character only seen in female form? YES 7) Is the character in more than one episode? YES 8) Does the character have supernatural powers or abilities? NO 9) Is it Ellen? NO 10) Has the character been seen only in seasons 9 through 11? NO 11) Is it Jo? NO 12) Was the character seen in the Kripke years (S1-S5) YES 13) Is it Young Mary? NO 14) Is it Jodi Mills? NO 15) Is it Lisa? NO Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.