formerlyfreedom October 15, 2014 Share October 15, 2014 A place to discuss the stories and characters of The Detectorists. 1 Link to comment
Dan October 17, 2014 Share October 17, 2014 Funny episode! Loved that one of the guys Andy and Lance refer to as "Simon and Garfunkel" is named Paul. Also, really liked seeing Johnny Flynn of Scrotal Recall (http://forums.previously.tv/forum/1245-scrotal-recall/) show up. Had no idea he was a singer, too. 1 Link to comment
Snarkette October 19, 2014 Share October 19, 2014 Oh! There's a forum! I love this show. Another excellent episode, and an ending surprise that took me in a far different direction than I supposed it was going. 2 Link to comment
Latverian Diplomat October 21, 2014 Share October 21, 2014 I'm really enjoying this quiet little show, which is mostly character study but just enough plot thrown in to keep things interesting (like the surprise end of this episode). Also, strong hints in this one that Sophie is a spy for the Antiquisearchers? I was not expecting that. I don't have the most sophisticated ear, but the harmonized version of "New Age Girl" sounded pretty bad to me. Was it supposed to? Lance's modest solo version last week sounded much better to me. 1 Link to comment
Dan October 24, 2014 Share October 24, 2014 Terry announces that he is standing down as leader of the DMDC. Another funny episode. Can't wait until more people discover this show. 2 Link to comment
Latverian Diplomat October 24, 2014 Share October 24, 2014 (edited) It was a great episode. I have no idea who took the picture, though I'm still wondering if Sophie is part of some scheme. I find Andy and Becs quite charming as a couple. A lot of their exchanges are quite clever. The words of Becs' lines can be seen as quite sharp, but the actress does an amazing job of conveying affection in the delivery. She also conveys genuine anger about the things Becs' is genuinely upset about. Edited October 24, 2014 by Latverian Diplomat 4 Link to comment
ApathyMonger October 26, 2014 Share October 26, 2014 Also, really liked seeing Johnny Flynn of Scrotal Recall (http://forums.previously.tv/forum/1245-scrotal-recall/) show up. Had no idea he was a singer, too. I wish the shows weren't on at the same time. Both much sweeter sitcoms than I assumed they would be. Also odd seeing Aimee-Ffion Edwards on this immediately after Peaky Blinders, which she's also on. Link to comment
Snarkette October 26, 2014 Share October 26, 2014 The whole staged kiss thing feels ham-handed given how well the normal interactions are written. The manipulated conflict this episode just didn't work for me. Link to comment
ApathyMonger October 30, 2014 Share October 30, 2014 Andy, Lance, Becky and Sophie's secrets are on the verge of being revealed. Link to comment
ApathyMonger October 30, 2014 Share October 30, 2014 Also, really liked seeing Johnny Flynn of Scrotal Recall (http://forums.previously.tv/forum/1245-scrotal-recall/) show up. Had no idea he was a singer, too. Just found out that not only is he a singer, he performs the theme song. To a show that airs at the same as his own, which is weird. It would be like Zooey Deschanel performing the theme song for Marry Me. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p8PGl9A9V08 1 Link to comment
Snarkette November 1, 2014 Share November 1, 2014 Much better episode! Enjoyed it a lot. Link to comment
ApathyMonger November 6, 2014 Share November 6, 2014 A huge hole has been excavated and police are looking into it. I'll miss this show. I hope it comes back. Link to comment
ApathyMonger November 6, 2014 Share November 6, 2014 Not my favourite episode, but I'm very happy they confirmed it'll be back in a year. 1 Link to comment
Latverian Diplomat November 7, 2014 Share November 7, 2014 I could have done without Lance's philosophy on gender determinism and hobbies, but otherwise it was a fine finish. I'm glad Lance came to his senses about his ex-wife. The Power-Rangers detector was hilarious. 1 Link to comment
Netfoot November 7, 2014 Share November 7, 2014 (edited) What a tremendous little show! I'm so sorry that it's over, and thrilled to hear there will be another series next year. Best moment [ETA: of the series]: Andy returning from the bar to find Sophie drenched in beer. Edited November 7, 2014 by Netfoot 1 Link to comment
Dan November 7, 2014 Share November 7, 2014 I'll miss this show. I hope it comes back. It is coming back. The voice-over during the end credits said that show will be returning late next year. 1 Link to comment
Snarkette November 8, 2014 Share November 8, 2014 What a beautiful episode. Can't decide whether I'm happy or sad they didn't find the treasure there. 2 Link to comment
Snarkette October 30, 2015 Share October 30, 2015 Great return. What a gem of a show! Link to comment
Netfoot October 30, 2015 Share October 30, 2015 Don't we get a separate topic for each episode in S2? Link to comment
Snarkette October 30, 2015 Share October 30, 2015 While we can, theoretically, having 2 replies per thread gets pretty dispiriting Link to comment
Netfoot October 30, 2015 Share October 30, 2015 OK. There was a moment when Becky was telling Andy that she wanted to go out with Gay Martin. As she opened the door of the cupboard (fridge?) I'm not sure what it was that passed across her face. Amusement? Sorrow? Link to comment
Snarkette October 30, 2015 Share October 30, 2015 It's definitely amusement. She can barely stop laughing at Andy, and takes a quick moment to indulge while he cannot see her face Link to comment
Netfoot October 30, 2015 Share October 30, 2015 Good! I thought so. I didn't want some sort of left-handed reaction, like she is angry at Andy because he isn't angry at her. This show is so good. Why aren't more people watching? Link to comment
Snarkette November 6, 2015 Share November 6, 2015 Another brilliant ep. I particularly loved the Simon and Garfunkel face-off. Link to comment
Netfoot November 6, 2015 Share November 6, 2015 (edited) The entire "Thick as two short plonks" exchange had me hooting so loud I woke the puppy! And I chuckled loudly and uncontrollably for the next 10 minutes. This show is so good it's a damned shame it isn't more widely appreciated. Edited November 6, 2015 by Netfoot Link to comment
Snarkette November 6, 2015 Share November 6, 2015 Are you sure you didn't wake the two invisible puppies? (My favorite part from last series) Link to comment
Cherpumple November 9, 2015 Share November 9, 2015 So glad I looked for this forum! I stumbled on this show accidentally last year and was so happy to see it return. Is there something sketchy about that German dude? He seemed surprised that Andy had found information about his grandfather's plane crash, and seemed to hesitate when identifying his grandfather's name from the crew list, but I can't tell if he's another detectorist infiltrating the group, or just a gap year wanker. Link to comment
Netfoot November 9, 2015 Share November 9, 2015 Is there something sketchy about that German dude? Hard to tell. So far he seems fairly harmless, but occasionally he doesn't quite ring true. Link to comment
Snarkette November 9, 2015 Share November 9, 2015 He seems like such an ass. But he doesn't ping my detectorist radar, if you know what I mean. I'm pretty sure he's not up and up, but probably more about zoning, museums, or his grandpa was German Mafia and did a DB Cooper Link to comment
Netfoot November 9, 2015 Share November 9, 2015 I agree. He may be up to no good, but if he is, it isn't about the "Dirt Sharks" or any other Detectorist group. Two short plonks. I'm still laughing at that. Link to comment
Snarkette November 13, 2015 Share November 13, 2015 Oh man, I love this show. German dude is *totally* corrupt and I do not trust him. I guessed about mystery girl as soon as she showed up at the park. Link to comment
Netfoot November 13, 2015 Share November 13, 2015 Oh man, I love this show. German dude is *totally* corrupt and I do not trust him. Yeh, something dodgy there. Can't quite figure out what. I'll speculate he's after something of value that was on the plane that nobody knows is there. He quickly shushed up S&G when they were talking about having an observer present. Stolen artwork or bullion or something being smuggled out of Germany at the end of WW-II. Link to comment
Cherpumple November 15, 2015 Share November 15, 2015 I totally agree with your prediction Netfoot, and can't wait to see what's on the plane. I also liked that we found out about Lance's mystery woman, but it would be nice for him to actually start dating. The storyline with the mayor's chain was amusing, and I wish they'd show more of that kind of thing. It feels like there hasn't been a lot of actual detecting this season, so it was nice to see them find something. I really like the music on this show; it's very soothing. Link to comment
marys1000 November 17, 2015 Share November 17, 2015 Good! I thought so. I didn't want some sort of left-handed reaction, like she is angry at Andy because he isn't angry at her. This show is so good. Why aren't more people watching? I recently watched S1, didn't know there was a S2. But I've already forgotten where I watched S1 - was it Acorn? Link to comment
Snarkette November 21, 2015 Share November 21, 2015 He totally got the job. It was a real hero moment -- showing his actual interest through that pipe, probably unlike the other credentialed but dispassionate other applicants. Link to comment
Snarkette November 27, 2015 Share November 27, 2015 Oh a very good ep indeed but so sad. I hope next week has some hope for everyone. Link to comment
Netfoot November 27, 2015 Share November 27, 2015 (edited) I knew it, I knew it, I knew it!!! I knew that guy was up to no good! And I strongly suspected gold was involved. Now they have him and Simon & Garfunkel too! It's pretty obvious that the fourth person was Sophie. She may be the one that went straight past the sleeping watchmen. Or that could have been Peter (?) the German. Bit of an unhappy confrontation between Andy and Becky at the end. Andy did have a point -- Becky decided to go to Africa and Andy's reservations didn't seem to matter to her much. On the other hand, Becky was also on target (if somewhat cruel) when she said Andy was spineless. He really does seem to be extremely indecisive, and lacking in self-confidence. I wonder if this heralds a break-up that gives Andy an opportunity to develop his relationship with Sophie? He's obviously sweet on her! But while I'm sure a fling with Sophie would be fun, Becky is a far more suitable partner for him, and after all, Stanley is his child! And Basil Brush pays a visit to the sleepers in Estend Lane! Edited November 29, 2015 by Netfoot Link to comment
Cherpumple November 29, 2015 Share November 29, 2015 I really hope someone finds that stash of gold next episode. I'd love for the gang to get a big win like that, after missing out on the Saxon horde last season- what ever happened to that storyline, anyway? Have they just stopped looking for it? And I'm dying to see these 'gold dances' that we keep hearing about. Even though the endeavour is getting off to a bad start with both of them keeping secrets from each other, I think Becky and Andy should definitely go to Africa. It's a great opportunity that they apparently were both very interested in at some point, and if it turns out to be a disaster, they can always leave. I just wish they would actually have a real conversation about it and acknowledge that Andy's fears and reservations are perfectly natural and expected. In fact, I would be surprised if anyone in that position wasn't scared- it's a huge leap into the unknown, and having a very young child makes it more difficult. I think he needs his feelings to be validated, but I also think that his fears shouldn't stop him from going. Link to comment
Netfoot November 29, 2015 Share November 29, 2015 I totally agree with your last paragraph! Sure, when they were younger, Andy and Becky talked about going to Africa. But surely Becky can see that circumstances have changed? They are more mature now, no longer kids, and they have a young baby. Presumably, they aren't going to be in some part of Africa that is well equipped with modern amenities, because they are going out to offer aid in their various fields. Presumably in rural areas that don't have immediate access to top-notch health care. With a young child like Stanley, what happens if he becomes ill and needs advanced medical attention in a hurry? The two need to sit down and discuss this, because I don't feel Andy is wrong to have doubts. Where Andy is wrong is not openly voicing those misgivings and insisting that he and Becky work out a new plan to suit their new circumstances, and not simply assume that the plans they formulated 10-15 years ago will still be satisfactory! I don't know what happened to the Saxon hoard from last season. In the finale, they were detecting across the ground and stopped just shy of making the discovery. I guess they have simply not returned to that area since. What I am interested in, is the book and golden artifact that we see getting laid down at the beginning of S02E01. And we've seen it several times since then, in passing. (I don't know if they could recover the book, but the golden artifact, for sure.) I believe that the next episode is the season finale, and they still have to unearth the Nazi gold or prove that there is none, identify the fourth Nighthawk who was just observing (who I'm sure is Sophie), and still somehow find themselves detecting somewhere else so they can find the book/artifact. And draw the series to conclusion. These series are too damned short! Link to comment
ApathyMonger December 3, 2015 Share December 3, 2015 I don't know if this is really the right topic for this, but Season 1 is now on Netflix US: http://www.netflix.com/title/80065658 1 Link to comment
ApathyMonger December 3, 2015 Share December 3, 2015 Great finale. Toby Jones was excellent in that final scene. I didn't realise we were getting a Christmas special. I wonder if they'll jump ahead to Andy and Becky being back, or if it'll be just after the finale? 2 Link to comment
Netfoot December 4, 2015 Share December 4, 2015 Very enjoyable. Glad that Peter got his comeuppance, but I'm still convinced that the 4th Nighthawk was Sophie, yet they didn't go near that. I expect that will surface in a later series. There will be more series to follow, right? Only, with Andy and Becky off to Botswana, it does leave a gaping hole in the cast. So glad Lance got to do his Gold Dance. And to reconnect with his daughter. Actually, I thought for a moment that she would turn on her new detector and find the German gold! I am somewhat confused when Peter said that they had done the work, and he had reaped the reward. What reward does he claim to have reaped? My ghodd, how I lusted after Becky's mother! In a bygone age... Link to comment
Latverian Diplomat December 4, 2015 Share December 4, 2015 (edited) I don't know what happened to the Saxon hoard from last season. In the finale, they were detecting across the ground and stopped just shy of making the discovery. I guess they have simply not returned to that area since. They mentioned in the first episode that they gave up on that site. It sounded like they went a few more times, but they just missed it. So, I was glad this season's artifact was found. Edited December 4, 2015 by Latverian Diplomat 1 Link to comment
Cherpumple December 4, 2015 Share December 4, 2015 (edited) I'm so happy for Lance! The look on his face when he discovered the treasure got me choked up a bit. And I kind of loved how it happened from a feeling and a hunch, like it was calling out to him. I'm glad that Andy and Becky are going to Africa, and if they do a time jump, it would be nice to see a more confident, experienced Andy return. However, there's a chance that they may cancel their plans if they actually have stumbled upon a full horde, since I'm sure Andy would want to be there to help sort through it all. I assume that what Lance found was the horde that we saw get buried in the first episode this season, so there is more to find besides that jewel. Other than that, I have to say that I'm very impressed with Mackenzie Crook, as both the writer and main character in this show. He has such a distinctive look that I never thought I'd ever see him as anyone other than Gareth Keenan, but he really has done a great job with this project, and I look forward to watching more of his shows in the future, either this one (hopefully!) or others. ETA: I loved that they used a picture of the real Simon and Garfunkel on their 'wanted' poster, because they didn't have a picture of the actual Dirt Sharks. Ha! Edited December 4, 2015 by Cherpumple 4 Link to comment
Netfoot December 24, 2015 Share December 24, 2015 Just watched the Christmas Special, which was actually slightly longer than the usual episodes. Quite interesting, especially Lance's (re)actions. This is a tremendous little series, and I truly do hope there is another series or two to come. Link to comment
Snarkette December 24, 2015 Share December 24, 2015 Didn't love the special as much as the last ep. It was a bit too panto with the "curse". Still enjoyed it though. Hope there's more in the future. 1 Link to comment
SusanSunflower April 6, 2016 Share April 6, 2016 (edited) I watched this episode last night for a second time -- didn't the picture of "the kiss" get torn up in the driveway (and not thrown away in Bec's mother's bin) ... that it then reappeared intact the better for Andy to confront Sophie (and Simon and Garfunkel) ... Edited April 6, 2016 by SusanSunflower Link to comment
marys1000 April 20, 2016 Share April 20, 2016 Are all current posters Brits? I thought this would be back on...where did I see season 1? Acorn? by now but haven't found s2 yet. 1 Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.