mstaken May 29, 2014 Author Share May 29, 2014 Something Wicked -- Faith -- Dead in the Water -- 52 - Pilot48 - Scarecrow11 - Something Wicked08- The Benders 07 - Faith03 - Dead in the Water GANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkin Link to comment
DittyDotDot May 29, 2014 Share May 29, 2014 + Scarecrow -- Faith -- Dead In The Water 52 - Pilot49 - Scarecrow13 - Something Wicked 08- The Benders 07 - Faith 03 - Dead in the Water GANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkin Link to comment
SueB May 30, 2014 Share May 30, 2014 -- The Benders + Faith -- Something Wicked 52 - Pilot 49 - Scarecrow 11 - Something Wicked 08 - Faith 06- The Benders 03 - Dead in the Water GANKED: Route 666 Bugs Provenance Dead Man's Blood Hook Man Nightmare Asylum Wendigo Hell House Bloody Mary Home Salvation Shadow Phantom Traveler Devil's Trap Skin Link to comment
7kstar May 30, 2014 Share May 30, 2014 -- The Benders-- Faith+ Something Wicked52 - Pilot49 - Scarecrow12 - Something Wicked06 - Faith03- The Benders 03 - Dead in the Water GANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkin Link to comment
tinyurl May 30, 2014 Share May 30, 2014 -- Something Wicked+ Dead in the Water+ Faith 52 - Pilot49 - Scarecrow10 - Something Wicked07 - Faith 04 - Dead in the Water03- The Benders GANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkin Link to comment
mstaken May 30, 2014 Author Share May 30, 2014 (edited) Dead in the Water, Faith, Something Wicked -- 52 - Pilot49 - Scarecrow08 - Something Wicked05 - Faith03- The Benders 02 - Dead in the Water GANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkin Edited May 30, 2014 by mstaken Link to comment
7kstar May 31, 2014 Share May 31, 2014 +Faith +Something Wicked + Pilot 53 - Pilot49 - Scarecrow09 - Something Wicked06 - Faith03- The Benders 02 - Dead in the Water GANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkin Link to comment
SueB May 31, 2014 Share May 31, 2014 +Faith -- Something Wicked -- Benders 53 - Pilot49 - Scarecrow07 - Something Wicked07 - Faith 02 - Dead in the Water01- The Benders GANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkin Link to comment
DittyDotDot May 31, 2014 Share May 31, 2014 + Scarecrow -- Faith -- Dead In The Water 53 - Pilot50 - Scarecrow07 - Something Wicked05 - Faith 01- The Benders GANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkin Dead in the Water Link to comment
mstaken May 31, 2014 Author Share May 31, 2014 Pilot + Something Wicked -- Faith -- 54 - Pilot50 - Scarecrow05 - Something Wicked03 - Faith01- The BendersGANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkinDead in the Water Link to comment
tinyurl May 31, 2014 Share May 31, 2014 Something Wicked -- Faith + Scarecrow + 54 - Pilot51 - Scarecrow 04 - Faith03 - Something Wicked01- The Benders GANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkinDead in the Water Link to comment
SueB June 1, 2014 Share June 1, 2014 (edited) A moment of silence for The Benders ..well, SOMETHING had to go. But I've come to praise the episode, not just to bury it. The Benders was truly an excellent episode. The kickass sheriff, the jar of teeth, Dean retracting his "eat me", and of course the best line: "Demons I get, people are crazy." Something Wicked -- Faith + The Benders -- 54 - Pilot51 - Scarecrow 05 - Faith01 - Something Wicked GANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkinDead in the Water The Benders Edited June 1, 2014 by SueB 1 Link to comment
7kstar June 1, 2014 Share June 1, 2014 Something Wicked + (have to fight for it one more time) Faith -- (Like it and one I rewatch a lot but guess I have to pick my top one.) Scarecrow -- (Just like the Pilot more!) 54 - Pilot49 - Scarecrow 03 - Faith02 - Something Wicked GANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkinDead in the Water The Benders Link to comment
mstaken June 1, 2014 Author Share June 1, 2014 Awww...I love that tribute to Benders, SueB! Something Wicked -- Faith -- Pilot + 55 - Pilot49 - Scarecrow01 - FaithGANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkinDead in the WaterThe Benders Something Wicked Link to comment
DittyDotDot June 1, 2014 Share June 1, 2014 Down to the final two, eh? Truly hardest decision. -- Pilot+ Scarecrow -- Faith 53 - Pilot50 - Scarecrow GANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkinDead in the WaterThe Benders Something Wicked Faith Link to comment
7kstar June 2, 2014 Share June 2, 2014 (Sniff, by Faith the one time that Sam did find a way to Save Dean's life and that scene with the reaper and Layla at the end such a killer. Sniff, Something Wicked, yes I liked the flashback but mainly I liked how Sam saw how much Dean had given up for him and Sue I echo your thoughts about Benders. Sniff) Pilot + Scarecrow -- 54 - Pilot48 - Scarecrow GANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkinDead in the WaterThe Benders Something Wicked Faith Link to comment
mstaken June 2, 2014 Author Share June 2, 2014 Pilot + Scarecrow -- 55 - Pilot46 - ScarecrowGANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkinDead in the WaterThe BendersSomething WickedFaith Link to comment
DittyDotDot June 2, 2014 Share June 2, 2014 I echo your love of Something Wicked, mostly because that's when I finally understood why Dean always followed his father's instructions. Seriously, I have to choose between these two? They're both so fantastic. What to do, what to do... -- Pilot+ Scarecrow 53 - Pilot47 - Scarecrow GANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkinDead in the WaterThe BendersSomething WickedFaith Link to comment
mstaken June 2, 2014 Author Share June 2, 2014 S2 promises to be even more painfully difficult...isn't this fun?! ;) Link to comment
DittyDotDot June 2, 2014 Share June 2, 2014 I'll only say what I say to a co-worker almost every week, I don't think we have the same idea of fun. Hee! ;) Hey, speaking of fun, I was thinking of starting a Hangman thread here too, but since it went silent over at TWoP I wondered if there was any interest? Link to comment
7kstar June 3, 2014 Share June 3, 2014 + Pilot-- Scarecrow 54 - Pilot45 - Scarecrow GANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkinDead in the WaterThe BendersSomething WickedFaith Have to go with the one that hooked me into the brother's story Link to comment
SueB June 3, 2014 Share June 3, 2014 Salute to two greats: Something Wicked - Dean's damage, John's parenting style, Sam's insight Faith - to me this was THE episode that kicked off the depth of the metaphysical this show would reach. Plus it had that kickass "Don't Fear The Reaper" montage. Truly a memorable episode. In my top 10 for the series for sure. -- Pilot+ Scarecrow Note: I reserve the right to change my opinion randomly as these two are too close to call. Tonight's vote is in favor of the "classic" nature of Scarecrow vs the exposition in Pilot. 52 - Pilot46 - Scarecrow GANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkinDead in the WaterThe BendersSomething WickedFaith Link to comment
DittyDotDot June 3, 2014 Share June 3, 2014 I can respect that reasoning SueB, and probably makes more sense than mine currently is...even 'em up. I don't really feel like I'm voting against the Pilot if it's still ahead. I don't know what I'm going to do if that changes. ;) -- Pilot+ Scarecrow 50 - Pilot47 - Scarecrow GANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkinDead in the WaterThe BendersSomething WickedFaith Link to comment
mstaken June 3, 2014 Author Share June 3, 2014 Pilot + Scarecrow -- 51 - Pilot45 - ScarecrowGANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkinDead in the WaterThe BendersSomething WickedFaith Link to comment
tinyurl June 3, 2014 Share June 3, 2014 Pilot + Scarecrow -- 52 - Pilot43 - Scarecrow GANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkinDead in the WaterThe BendersSomething WickedFaith Link to comment
SueB June 4, 2014 Share June 4, 2014 Pilot -- Scarecrow + 50 - Pilot 44 - Scarecrow GANKED: Route 666 Bugs Provenance Dead Man's Blood Hook Man Nightmare Asylum Wendigo Hell House Bloody Mary Home Salvation Shadow Phantom Traveler Devil's Trap Skin Dead in the Water The Benders Something Wicked Faith Link to comment
DittyDotDot June 4, 2014 Share June 4, 2014 -- Pilot+ Scarecrow 48 - Pilot45 - Scarecrow GANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkinDead in the WaterThe BendersSomething WickedFaith Link to comment
mstaken June 4, 2014 Author Share June 4, 2014 Pilot + Scarecrow -- 49 - Pilot43 - ScarecrowGANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkinDead in the WaterThe BendersSomething WickedFaith Link to comment
tinyurl June 4, 2014 Share June 4, 2014 Pilot + Scarecrow -- 50 - Pilot41 - Scarecrow GANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkinDead in the WaterThe BendersSomething WickedFaith Link to comment
7kstar June 5, 2014 Share June 5, 2014 Pilot + Scarecrow -- 51 - Pilot39 - Scarecrow GANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkinDead in the WaterThe BendersSomething WickedFaith Link to comment
mstaken June 5, 2014 Author Share June 5, 2014 Pilot + Scarecrow -- 52 - Pilot37 - ScarecrowGANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkinDead in the WaterThe BendersSomething WickedFaith Link to comment
SueB June 6, 2014 Share June 6, 2014 Pilot -- Scarecrow + 50 - Pilot38 - Scarecrow GANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkinDead in the WaterThe BendersSomething WickedFaith Link to comment
DittyDotDot June 6, 2014 Share June 6, 2014 -- Pilot + Scarecrow 48 - Pilot39 - Scarecrow GANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkinDead in the WaterThe BendersSomething WickedFaith Link to comment
mstaken June 6, 2014 Author Share June 6, 2014 Pilot + Scarecrow -- 49 - Pilot37 - ScarecrowGANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkinDead in the WaterThe BendersSomething WickedFaith Link to comment
SueB June 7, 2014 Share June 7, 2014 Proposal: With only a few of us playing, it seems to me the answer is a foregone conclusion: The Pilot is going to win and Scarecrow is second. How about we just declare Pilot the winner, Scarecrow as runner up and move on to S2? Pilot --Scarecrow + 47 - Pilot38 - Scarecrow GANKED:Route 666BugsProvenanceDead Man's BloodHook ManNightmareAsylumWendigoHell HouseBloody MaryHomeSalvationShadowPhantom TravelerDevil's TrapSkinDead in the WaterThe BendersSomething WickedFaith 1 Link to comment
DittyDotDot June 7, 2014 Share June 7, 2014 I can get behind that...I hated voting against either of them anyway. 1 Link to comment
7kstar June 7, 2014 Share June 7, 2014 Pilot is my vote and I'm fine with moving on to season 2. Had a major upset, and RL is taking a toll on my free time. So whatever ya want to do is fine with me. Link to comment
PeteMartell June 7, 2014 Share June 7, 2014 I keep forgetting to vote (apologies) or have other things going on, but since I've been MIA for a lot of this I'll go along with what the rest of you want. Pilot winning is OK with me. Link to comment
mstaken June 7, 2014 Author Share June 7, 2014 I'm happy to post the S2 list and get us started! Is that what we've decided...? Link to comment
DittyDotDot June 7, 2014 Share June 7, 2014 In the immortal words of the arc angel Gabriel--"Let's light this candle!"--Hee! Link to comment
mstaken June 7, 2014 Author Share June 7, 2014 Our S2 List: In My Time of Dying Everybody Loves a Clown Bloodlust Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things Simon Said No Exit The Usual Suspects Crossroad Blues Croatoan Hunted Playthings Nightshifter Houses of the Holy Born Under a Bad Sign Tall Tales Roadkill Heart Hollywood Babylon Folsom Prison Blues What Is and Never Should Be All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1 All Hell Breaks Loos Pt 2 My votes: Tall Tales ++ No Exit -- Heart -- 17 - Tall Tales 15 - In My Time of Dying15 - Everybody Loves a Clown15 - Bloodlust15 - Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things15 - Simon Said15 - The Usual Suspects15 - Crossroad Blues15 - Croatoan15 - Hunted15 - Playthings15 - Nightshifter15 - Houses of the Holy15 - Born Under a Bad Sign15 -Roadkill15 -Hollywood Babylon15 - Folsom Prison Blues15 - What Is and Never Should Be15 - All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 115 - All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2 13 - No Exit 13 - Heart Link to comment
DittyDotDot June 7, 2014 Share June 7, 2014 This is going to be very hard! ++ In My Time Of Dying ++ Hollywood Babylon -- No Exit 17 - Tall Tales 17 - In My Time of Dying 17 -Hollywood Babylon15 - Everybody Loves a Clown15 - Bloodlust15 - Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things15 - Simon Said15 - The Usual Suspects15 - Crossroad Blues15 - Croatoan15 - Hunted15 - Playthings15 - Nightshifter15 - Houses of the Holy15 - Born Under a Bad Sign15 -Roadkill15 - Folsom Prison Blues15 - What Is and Never Should Be15 - All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 115 - All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2 13 - Heart 11 - No Exit Link to comment
SueB June 7, 2014 Share June 7, 2014 (edited) Ah...you beat me by an hour. Sorry you had to do the labor. THANKS. But first... a moment of praise for the S1 final two: Pilot -- 10 freaking years. Yeah, you deserve it. This was an awesome premise that set up two fascinating characters, classic horror tales, overarching mytharc, all withiin the context of Middle America, Classic Rock and the awesome Impala. I was captured by both and the brotherly dynamic right from the start. You WIN. Scarecrow - the obvious runner up for it's combination of outstanding horror, expansion of the mythos, some of the best dialog of the series, brother angst/bonding, and PIE. ***Looks at S2 List*** We've got work to do ++ In My Time Of Dying ++ All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2 ++ Crossroad Blues 19 - In My Time of Dying 17 - Tall Tales 17 -Hollywood Babylon 17 - Crossroad Blues 17 - All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2 15 - Everybody Loves a Clown15 - Bloodlust15 - Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things15 - Simon Said15 - The Usual Suspects15 - Croatoan15 - Hunted15 - Playthings15 - Nightshifter15 - Houses of the Holy15 - Born Under a Bad Sign15 -Roadkill15 - Folsom Prison Blues15 - What Is and Never Should Be15 - All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1 13 - Heart 11 - No Exit Edited June 7, 2014 by SueB 1 Link to comment
mstaken June 7, 2014 Author Share June 7, 2014 I love the tributes, SueB! I think you missed the votes just above your post, though :) Link to comment
mstaken June 7, 2014 Author Share June 7, 2014 ***Looks at S2 List*** We've got work to do Hee---it's embarrassing how much I love that scene :) Link to comment
7kstar June 7, 2014 Share June 7, 2014 (edited) Quote ***Looks at S2 List*** We've got work to do Quote Hee---it's embarrassing how much I love that scene :) See we can find things we agree on. :) Ditto, me too! ++ Hollywood Babylon ++ All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2 ++ What Is and Never Should Be 19 - In My Time of Dying 19 -Hollywood Babylon 19 - All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 2 17 - Tall Tales 17 -Hollywood Babylon 17 - Crossroad Blues 17 - What Is and Never Should Be 15 - Everybody Loves a Clown 15 - Bloodlust 15 - Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things 15 - Simon Said 15 - The Usual Suspects 15 - Croatoan 15 - Hunted 15 - Playthings 15 - Nightshifter 15 - Houses of the Holy 15 - Born Under a Bad Sign 15 -Roadkill 15 - Folsom Prison Blues 15 - All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 1 13 - Heart 11 - No Exit Edited June 7, 2014 by 7kstar Link to comment
mstaken June 8, 2014 Author Share June 8, 2014 (edited) Heart -- No Exit -- Born Under a Bad Sign ++ 19 - In My Time of Dying19 -Hollywood Babylon19 - All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 217 - Tall Tales17 -Hollywood Babylon 17 - Born Under a Bad Sign17 - Crossroad Blues17 - What Is and Never Should Be15 - Everybody Loves a Clown15 - Bloodlust15 - Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things15 - Simon Said15 - The Usual Suspects15 - Croatoan15 - Hunted15 - Playthings15 - Nightshifter15 - Houses of the Holy15 -Roadkill15 - Folsom Prison Blues15 - All Hell Breaks Loose Pt 111 - Heart09 - No Exit Edited June 8, 2014 by mstaken Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.