mstaken March 27, 2014 Share March 27, 2014 Hi, everyone! I'm thinking this would be a lovely place to resume the ongoing Gilmore Girls elimination games we've been playing for years now! One idea that we'd batted around is doing 'great scenes in otherwise meh episodes' and/or 'great scenes for otherwise meh characters.' Should we get started on one of those as our inaugural game in our beautiful new home?! As always, other ideas are more than welcome! Link to comment
ina March 30, 2014 Share March 30, 2014 I'm game with either idea! Just start a list for either topic, and we'll add to it! Link to comment
mstaken March 30, 2014 Author Share March 30, 2014 (edited) Hmmm...since we may have some new players here, maybe we should just start with a good old-fashioned episode survival game, season by season? You guys know I never tire of those! Edited March 30, 2014 by mstaken Link to comment
mstaken March 30, 2014 Author Share March 30, 2014 Okay, so let's kick off our first survival game in this lovely new home! The rules: once per 24 hour period, you can vote for (++) or against (--) three of the items on our list. Once half the list has been eliminated, we change the ++ to + to ensure that the game doesn't last forever. Season 1: 15 - Pilot 15 - Lorelais' First Day at Chilton 15 - Kill Me Now 15 - The Deer Hunters 15 - Cinnamon's Wake 15 - Rory's Birthday Parties 15 - Kiss and Tell 15 - Love and War and Snow 15 - Forgiveness and Stuff 15 - Paris is Burning 15 - Double Date 15 - Concert Interruptus 15 - That Damn Donna Reed 15 - Christopher Returns 15 - Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers 15 - The Breakup Part 2 15 - The Third Lorelai 15 - Emily in Wonderland 15 - P.S. I Lo... 15 - Love, Daisies and Troubadours My votes and updated list: The Third Lorelai ++ (Stop laughing at me!) P.S. I Lo... -- (I'll spare you guys my usual rant!) Love and Daisis and Far Too Much Dean and Max -- Season 1: 17 - The Third Lorelai 15 - Pilot 15 - Lorelais' First Day at Chilton 15 - Kill Me Now 15 - The Deer Hunters 15 - Cinnamon's Wake 15 - Rory's Birthday Parties 15 - Kiss and Tell 15 - Love and War and Snow 15 - Forgiveness and Stuff 15 - Paris is Burning 15 - Double Date 15 - Concert Interruptus 15 - That Damn Donna Reed 15 - Christopher Returns 15 - Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers 15 - The Breakup Part 2 15 - Emily in Wonderland 13 - P.S. I Lo... 13 - Love, Daisies and Troubadours Link to comment
lulu1960 March 30, 2014 Share March 30, 2014 ++ Forgiveness and Stuff -- Love, Daisies and Troubadours -- Christopher Returns Link to comment
mstaken March 30, 2014 Author Share March 30, 2014 ++ Forgiveness and Stuff Wait, what? WHAT? Since when do you like Forgiveness and Stuff?! You must be an imposter! Oh, wait... :) Updated List: Season 1: 17 - The Third Lorelai 17 - Forgiveness and Stuff 15 - Pilot 15 - Lorelais' First Day at Chilton 15 - Kill Me Now 15 - The Deer Hunters 15 - Cinnamon's Wake 15 - Rory's Birthday Parties 15 - Kiss and Tell 15 - Love and War and Snow 15 - Paris is Burning 15 - Double Date 15 - Concert Interruptus 15 - That Damn Donna Reed 15 - Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers 15 - The Breakup Part 2 15 - Emily in Wonderland 13 - P.S. I Lo... 13 - Christopher Returns 11 - Love, Daisies and Troubadours Link to comment
Taryn74 March 31, 2014 Share March 31, 2014 (edited) Okay so this is not the same as the Elimination game, right? I need to go start supper but I'll come back and try to figure out how to play...lol... Back..... So are we supposed to vote for one (++) and two (--) or did it just work out that way with the previous votes? Edited March 31, 2014 by Taryn74 Link to comment
mstaken March 31, 2014 Author Share March 31, 2014 (edited) It just worked out that way, Taryn! I'm thrilled that you've migrated over, by the way :) You can give ++ to all three episodes, -- to all three episodes, two ++ and one -- or two -- and one ++. In other words, whatever combination you'd like! Make sense?! Edited March 31, 2014 by mstaken Link to comment
Taryn74 April 1, 2014 Share April 1, 2014 Ah ok, so it's three eps at a time, giving them whatever rating you want. Got it. -- LDaT (I have a very low tolerance level for Max and Dean both, so an ep that is saturated with the both of them? Gag me) ++ Double Date (probably one of my favorite eps of the entire series) ++ Cinnamon's Wake (the humor is snapping, and I love Morey more than is probably healthy) Link to comment
mstaken April 1, 2014 Author Share April 1, 2014 -- LDaT (I have a very low tolerance level for Max and Dean both, so an ep that is saturated with the both of them? Gag me) Amen! My votes: P.S. I Lo -- L, D and T -- Rory's Birthday Parties ++ Updating for my votes and Taryn's: Season 1: 17 - The Third Lorelai 17 - Forgiveness and Stuff 17 - Rory's Birthday Parties 17 - Double Date 17 - Cinnamon's Wake 15 - Pilot 15 - Lorelais' First Day at Chilton 15 - Kill Me Now 15 - The Deer Hunters 15 - Kiss and Tell 15 - Love and War and Snow 15 - Paris is Burning 15 - Concert Interruptus 15 - That Damn Donna Reed 15 - Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers 15 - The Breakup Part 2 15 - Emily in Wonderland 13 - Christopher Returns 11 - P.S. I Lo... 09 - Love, Daisies and Troubadours Link to comment
lulu1960 April 1, 2014 Share April 1, 2014 ++That Damm Donna Reed ++Forgiveness and Stuff --Christopher Returns Link to comment
mstaken April 2, 2014 Author Share April 2, 2014 Updating for lulu's votes and casting my own :) The Third Lorelai ++ Cinnamon's Wake -- P.S. I Lo... -- 19 - Forgiveness and Stuff 19 - The Third Lorelai 17 - Rory's Birthday Parties 17 - Double Date 17 - That Damn Donna Reed 15 - Pilot 15 - Cinnamon's Wake 15 - Lorelais' First Day at Chilton 15 - Kill Me Now 15 - The Deer Hunters 15 - Kiss and Tell 15 - Love and War and Snow 15 - Paris is Burning 15 - Concert Interruptus 15 - Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers 15 - The Breakup Part 2 15 - Emily in Wonderland 11 - Christopher Returns 09 - P.S. I Lo... 09 - Love, Daisies and Troubadours Link to comment
mstaken April 3, 2014 Author Share April 3, 2014 (edited) Updating for Taryn's votes and casting my own :) P.S. -- LDT -- F&S -- 19 - The Third Lorelai 19 - Double Date 17 - Rory's Birthday Parties 17 - That Damn Donna Reed 17 - Forgiveness and Stuff 15 - Pilot 15 - Cinnamon's Wake 15 - Lorelais' First Day at Chilton 15 - Kill Me Now 15 - The Deer Hunters 15 - Kiss and Tell 15 - Love and War and Snow 15 - Paris is Burning 15 - Concert Interruptus 15 - Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers 15 - The Breakup Part 2 15 - Emily in Wonderland 11 - Christopher Returns 05 - P.S. I Lo... 05 - Love, Daisies and Troubadours Edited April 3, 2014 by mstaken Link to comment
Taryn74 April 3, 2014 Share April 3, 2014 Paris is Burning -- (because I was reminded y'day about how much I hate that episode) Concert Interruptus ++ LDaT -- Link to comment
nolieblue April 4, 2014 Share April 4, 2014 Concert Interruptus ++ Paris is Burning -- P.S. I Lo++ (OU I liked it!) Link to comment
mstaken April 4, 2014 Author Share April 4, 2014 Updating for the two above posts and voting: LDaT -- P.S. I Lo... -- KaT -- 19 - The Third Lorelai 19 - Double Date 19 - Concert Interruptus 17 - Rory's Birthday Parties 17 - That Damn Donna Reed 17 - Forgiveness and Stuff 15 - Pilot 15 - Cinnamon's Wake 15 - Lorelais' First Day at Chilton 15 - Kill Me Now 15 - The Deer Hunters 15 - Love and War and Snow 15 - Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers 15 - The Breakup Part 2 15 - Emily in Wonderland 13 - Kiss and Tell 11 - Paris is Burning 11 - Christopher Returns 05 - P.S. I Lo... 01 - Love, Daisies and Troubadours Link to comment
lulu1960 April 5, 2014 Share April 5, 2014 --christopher Returns ++ Forgiveness and Stuff ++ Cinnamon's Wake Link to comment
eledgy April 5, 2014 Share April 5, 2014 Hi all! Nice to see you here in new digs! Maybe I'm just slow but can you explain how this works again? It's not making sense to me.... (and why this system rather than the one we were using over at TWoP? Maybe it's an older method from before I started hanging out...) Link to comment
lulu1960 April 5, 2014 Share April 5, 2014 Eledgy it's just a different game. I don't get it really either but basically you have three votes so you can decide to try to get rid of something or give points to something. There really isn't any rhyme or reason. Or you can do a combo. Right now each point counts as two points (either plus or minus). Eledgy it's just a different game. I don't get it really either but basically you have three votes so you can decide to try to get rid of something or give points to something. There really isn't any rhyme or reason. Or you can do a combo. Right now each point counts as two points (either plus or minus). Link to comment
ina April 5, 2014 Share April 5, 2014 LDT -- Paris is Burning -- P.S. -- In an anti s1 mood this morning... Link to comment
mstaken April 5, 2014 Author Share April 5, 2014 Adding in Ina and Lulu's votes and casting my own! F&S -- P.S. I Lo... -- CR -- 19 - The Third Lorelai 19 - Double Date 19 - Concert Interruptus 17 - Forgiveness and Stuff 17 - Rory's Birthday Parties 17 - That Damn Donna Reed 17 - Cinnamon's Wake 15 - Pilot 15 - Lorelais' First Day at Chilton 15 - Kill Me Now 15 - The Deer Hunters 15 - Love and War and Snow 15 - Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers 15 - The Breakup Part 2 15 - Emily in Wonderland 13 - Kiss and Tell 09 - Paris is Burning 07 - Christopher Returns 01 - P.S. I Lo... Eliminated! Love, Daisies and Troubadours Link to comment
Taryn74 April 5, 2014 Share April 5, 2014 Christopher Returns ++ (because the townies' interactions with him make me laugh) PS I Lo... -- Paris is Burning -- Link to comment
mstaken April 6, 2014 Author Share April 6, 2014 Factoring in Taryn's votes and casting my own: TDDR -- RBP ++ KaT -- 19 - The Third Lorelai 19 - Double Date 19 - Concert Interruptus 19 - Rory's Birthday Parties 17 - Forgiveness and Stuff 17 - Cinnamon's Wake 15 - Pilot 15 - That Damn Donna Reed 15 - Lorelais' First Day at Chilton 15 - Kill Me Now 15 - The Deer Hunters 15 - Love and War and Snow 15 - Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers 15 - The Breakup Part 2 15 - Emily in Wonderland 11 - Kiss and Tell 09 - Christopher Returns 07 - Paris is Burning Eliminated! Love, Daisies and Troubadours P.S. I Lo... Link to comment
lulu1960 April 6, 2014 Share April 6, 2014 -- Christopher Returns --The Deer Hunters ++Cinnamon's Wake Link to comment
Taryn74 April 6, 2014 Share April 6, 2014 Kiss and Tell -- Paris is Burning -- Kill Me Now ++ Link to comment
mstaken April 6, 2014 Author Share April 6, 2014 Updated List: 19 - The Third Lorelai 19 - Double Date 19 - Concert Interruptus 19 - Rory's Birthday Parties 19 - Cinnamon's Wake 17 - Forgiveness and Stuff 17 - Kill Me Now 15 - Pilot 15 - That Damn Donna Reed 15 - Lorelais' First Day at Chilton 15 - Love and War and Snow 15 - Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers 15 - The Breakup Part 2 15 - Emily in Wonderland 13 - The Deer Hunters 09 - Kiss and Tell 07 - Christopher Returns 05 - Paris is Burning Eliminated! Love, Daisies and Troubadours P.S. I Lo... Link to comment
lulu1960 April 8, 2014 Share April 8, 2014 --Christopher Returns --The Deer Hunters ++That Damn Donna Reed Link to comment
nolieblue April 9, 2014 Share April 9, 2014 --Christopher Returns ++Star-Crossed Lovers and other Strangers ++ Forgiveness and Stuff Link to comment
mstaken April 9, 2014 Author Share April 9, 2014 Updating for the above posts and casting my own votes: TDDR -- Cinnamon's Wake -- F and S -- Updated List: 19 - The Third Lorelai 19 - Double Date 19 - Concert Interruptus 19 - Rory's Birthday Parties 17 - Forgiveness and Stuff 17 - Kill Me Now 17 - Cinnamon's Wake 17 - Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers 15 - Pilot 15 - That Damn Donna Reed 15 - Lorelais' First Day at Chilton 15 - Love and War and Snow 15 - The Breakup Part 2 15 - Emily in Wonderland 11 - The Deer Hunters 09 - Kiss and Tell 05 - Paris is Burning 03 - Christopher Returns Eliminated! Love, Daisies and Troubadours P.S. I Lo... Link to comment
mstaken April 10, 2014 Author Share April 10, 2014 Voting again and hoping others join me! :) Cinnamom's Wake -- Star-Crossed Lovers -- Kiss and Tell -- 19 - The Third Lorelai 19 - Double Date 19 - Concert Interruptus 19 - Rory's Birthday Parties 17 - Forgiveness and Stuff 17 - Kill Me Now 15 - Cinnamon's Wake 15 - Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers 15 - Pilot 15 - That Damn Donna Reed 15 - Lorelais' First Day at Chilton 15 - Love and War and Snow 15 - The Breakup Part 2 15 - Emily in Wonderland 11 - The Deer Hunters 07 - Kiss and Tell 05 - Paris is Burning 03 - Christopher Returns Eliminated! Love, Daisies and Troubadours P.S. I Lo... Link to comment
Taryn74 April 10, 2014 Share April 10, 2014 Shoot, sorry, I forget about this game. I guess because it's not the same as the Elimination game where you tally after everyone votes. PiB -- Kiss and Tell -- Christopher Returns ++ 1 Link to comment
lulu1960 April 10, 2014 Share April 10, 2014 --Deer Hunters --Christopher Returns --Paris is Burning Link to comment
mstaken April 11, 2014 Author Share April 11, 2014 Updating the list and casting my own votes: CW -- F&S -- KaT -- 19 - The Third Lorelai 19 - Double Date 19 - Concert Interruptus 19 - Rory's Birthday Parties 15 - Forgiveness and Stuff 15 - Kill Me Now 15 - Cinnamon's Wake 15 - Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers 15 - Pilot 15 - That Damn Donna Reed 15 - Lorelais' First Day at Chilton 15 - Love and War and Snow 15 - The Breakup Part 2 15 - Emily in Wonderland 09 - The Deer Hunters 03 - Kiss and Tell 03 - Christopher Returns Eliminated! Love, Daisies and Troubadours P.S. I Lo... Paris is Burning Link to comment
Taryn74 April 11, 2014 Share April 11, 2014 Emily in Wonderland ++ Kiss and Tell -- Cinnamon's Wake ++ Link to comment
mstaken April 13, 2014 Author Share April 13, 2014 Adding in Taryn's votes and casting my own! TDDR -- Cinnamon's Wake -- The Third Lorelai ++ 21 - The Third Lorelai 19 - Double Date 19 - Concert Interruptus 19 - Rory's Birthday Parties 17 - Emily in Wonderland 15 - Forgiveness and Stuff 15 - Kill Me Now 15 - Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers 15 - Pilot 15 - Lorelais' First Day at Chilton 15 - Love and War and Snow 15 - The Breakup Part 2 13 - That Damn Donna Reed 13 - Cinnamon's Wake 09 - The Deer Hunters 03 - Christopher Returns 01 - Kiss and Tell Eliminated! Love, Daisies and Troubadours P.S. I Lo... Paris is Burning Link to comment
mstaken April 14, 2014 Author Share April 14, 2014 Woo hoo---so glad someone else is voting! Factoring in noieblue's votes and casting my own: CW -- TDDR -- KaT -- (GONE!) 21 - The Third Lorelai 19 - Double Date 19 - Concert Interruptus 19 - Rory's Birthday Parties 17 - Emily in Wonderland 17 - Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers 15 - Forgiveness and Stuff 15 - Pilot 15 - Lorelais' First Day at Chilton 15 - Love and War and Snow 15 - The Breakup Part 2 13 - Kill Me Now 13 - That Damn Donna Reed 11 - Cinnamon's Wake 09 - The Deer Hunters 03 - Christopher Returns Eliminated! Love, Daisies and Troubadours P.S. I Lo... Paris is Burning Kiss and Tell Link to comment
lulu1960 April 14, 2014 Share April 14, 2014 (edited) -- Christopher Returns -- The Deer Hunters ++ Cinnamon's Wake I seem to always forget to vote. Edited April 14, 2014 by lulu1960 Link to comment
mstaken April 15, 2014 Author Share April 15, 2014 I seem to always forget to vote. I'll gently remind you ;) My votes: Star-Crossed -- TDDR -- CW -- 21 - The Third Lorelai 19 - Double Date 19 - Concert Interruptus 19 - Rory's Birthday Parties 17 - Emily in Wonderland 15 - Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers 15 - Forgiveness and Stuff 15 - Pilot 15 - Lorelais' First Day at Chilton 15 - Love and War and Snow 15 - The Breakup Part 2 13 - Kill Me Now 11 - That Damn Donna Reed 11 - Cinnamon's Wake 07 - The Deer Hunters 01 - Christopher Returns Eliminated! Love, Daisies and Troubadours P.S. I Lo... Paris is Burning Kiss and Tell Link to comment
lulu1960 April 15, 2014 Share April 15, 2014 -- CR -- The Deer Hunters ++ That Damn Donna Reed Link to comment
Taryn74 April 16, 2014 Share April 16, 2014 I'm so sorry guys, I just don't enjoy the survival game, that's why I've never really played it anywhere. Please don't hate me! Maybe we can get some of our other games going here too, I'll participate in those for sure. Link to comment
mstaken April 16, 2014 Author Share April 16, 2014 Factoring in lulu's votes and casting my own: Star-crossed -- Forgiveness -- Cinnamon's Wake -- 21 - The Third Lorelai 19 - Double Date 19 - Concert Interruptus 19 - Rory's Birthday Parties 17 - Emily in Wonderland 15 - Pilot 15 - Lorelais' First Day at Chilton 15 - Love and War and Snow 15 - The Breakup Part 2 13 - Kill Me Now 13 - Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers 13 - Forgiveness and Stuff 13 - That Damn Donna Reed 09 - Cinnamon's Wake 05 - The Deer Hunters Eliminated! Love, Daisies and Troubadours P.S. I Lo... Paris is Burning Kiss and Tell Christopher Returns Link to comment
lulu1960 April 17, 2014 Share April 17, 2014 --The Deer Hunters ++ Forgiveness ++ Cinnamon's Wake Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.