Jump to content

Type keyword(s) to search

starri

Member
  • Posts

    7.8k
  • Joined

Posts posted by starri

  1. I think if we're cataloging changes, it's worth pointing out the ravens as well.

    -Jessamy is not present in the story, and if memory serves, only has one appearance in the entire comic, in "Thermidor."  I also question if Alex would have been able to kill her as she's the ghost of a woman who became a dream.

    -Matthew's character is tweaked a little from the comics.  He's less sarcastic and comes across as more friendly and helpful.  We also see Morpheus reject him at first.  And the backstory is different, since I'm sure they had to lose the connection to Swamp Thing, same as they did with JLI and Infinity, Inc.

    1 hour ago, Chicago Redshirt said:

    14. Shifted Morpheus's escape from the 1980s to 2022ish, which makes things a little messier. We have to handwave that certain characters would be long dead or way older, and certain things probably would be done differently. An in-person meeting of serial killers in the Zoom era seems quaint, for instance. 

    The one place where I think it improved the story was in relation to Hob.  In the comic, Morpheus escapes in time to make their meeting.  By keeping him imprisoned for an extra 30+ years, it would look to Hob like he'd actually been rejected, which deepens their reconnection in the present day.

    • Love 8
  2. 6 hours ago, paramitch said:

    But watching Bette, for instance (a truly kind person, if subtly nervous -- I wouldn't quite go to homophobic -- of her gay friend) descend all the way down into hell because she attempted to be kind to people was really hard to watch.

    Spoiler

    She is COMPLETELY homophobic in the comic.  She has an internal monolog that Judy being a lesbian is a sin against God, and in the stories that she writes that whitewash small town life, makes sure to marry off Judy and her girlfriend to men.

    She's also not really being kind to people.  She's using them as grist for her banal tales.

    • Useful 1
    • Love 4
  3. 12 minutes ago, Chicago Redshirt said:

    I loved the update where Jed was being groomed to be the Sandman rather than Hector Hall.

    If I had known about that going in, I would have been sure i would hate it.  But instead of Brute and Glob torturing the kid so they could be kings of their own little realm, we had Gault giving Jed a space to feel safe and in control because she didn't want to be scary.  That's a good change, and I also appreciated that it made Morpheus look like the unreasonable one.

    21 minutes ago, Chicago Redshirt said:

    Also, I think it is something where show Lyta should have been way more freaked the f--- out that she got pregnant by her dead husband in dreams (as opposed to the comic book version, where it seemed like Brute and Glob messed with her mind). 

    If I remember right, she was pregnant before Hector died.  She was just an airhead not being able to realize she'd been pregnant for two years while living with him in Jed's dream.

    The only change that I wasn't crazy about was the way they had to handwave Unity.  They seemed to actively try to make the viewer not think too hard about the fact that she'd be 118 in 2022.

    • Love 1
  4. As much as I probably shouldn't admit this, the post-coital scene between the Corinthian and Carl was REALLY sexy.  I'm glad Carl made it out.

    The casting on this show is out of this world.  Stephen Fry is perfect for Gilbert in a way I can't describe.  So too all the other Florida housemates, and the appropriately creepy Nimrod, Funland, and gender-bent Good Doctor.  But I'm damned impressed they cast a Lyta who looks so much like Gal Gadot.

    • Love 10
  5. I'm impressed that they melded two issues of the comic that are very tonally different into an episode that was so cohesive.  I was a bit close to tears at certain points during the first half, particularly the bit with the baby.  

    • Like 1
    • Sad 2
    • Love 12
  6. On a more meta level, I'm really glad that Sam Kieth and Mark Dringenberg also get creator credits.  Given the comic book industry's historic problems with doing that, it's nice that they're forthright that Gaiman wasn't the only midwife that helped birth this baby.

    • Like 1
    • Love 1
  7. 11 minutes ago, SilverStormm said:

    This is the second time I didn't enjoy this particular part of the story. David Thewlis was awesome in his portrayal but the character of John gives me the heebie-geebies, miss me with him.

    I legitimately gasped and shut my eyes at points during this, particularly when Bette stabbed her eyes.  This disturbed the hell out of me, and I think it was in a good way, and still wasn't as horrifying as its comics counterpart.  But jeez, some of the gore was brutal.

    • Love 7
  8. I had a lot of negative reaction to Jenna Coleman's casting because I HAAAAAAAAAATED Clara, even though I acknowledge her performance was good.  And John Constantine is such an iconic character (and, if I'm being completely honest, one I find attractive), the gender bending was a little iffy for me.  But both actor and character were awesome.  

    • Like 3
    • Applause 2
  9. 3 hours ago, paramitch said:

    I really don't agree that the Eddie/Richie subtext is there in the book. I honestly think King is horrible on this front -- he's incredibly awkward when writing about homosexuality (or was at the time of IT), and while I don't think he's homophobic as a person (he's definitely an ally on social media, and his takedown of JKRowling in support of trans women was glorious).

    He's not homophobic at all.  Back in the 70s and 80s, he wasn't any worse than a lot of people, as depressing as that can be to remember.  His daughter (who identifies as non-binary) is married to a woman, and after they came out, you can notice how he wrote about the topic start to shift.

    I can't speculate as to what his intentions were in the novel, but the film didn't invent it out of whole cloth.

    • Like 2
  10. 16 minutes ago, snickers said:

    I think what made that scene so powerful is because it shows some of it from Jupe’s eye level- it was like physically being there - I also thought I know he lives through the attack it didn’t mean he still couldn’t have been hurt - and I really didn’t want to have to see or hear that after what we just saw/didn’t see

    I think one of the other reasons that it's so effective is that it literalizes the theme of both Jupe and and the Heywoods' obsession with Jean Jacket:  chasing fame will chew you up and spit you out.  

    Speaking of, Jordan Peele released fake opening credits for Gordy's Home.  The images parallel much of what we see of Gordy's rampage.  And we get the genesis of the winking cowboy.

  11. 4 hours ago, Luckylyn said:

    So I saw this video where someone speculates that OJ is dead and what Em sees is his spirit because he can be seen below the “Out Yonder” sign.  My theory is he’s alive.

    I actually wondered the same thing.  I thought it was ambiguous.  I also wasn't quite sure if Angel survived either.

    Very surprised that the Burbank Fry's is still standing.

  12. 3 hours ago, Luckylyn said:

    Gordy and Jean Jacket are simply being what they are and following their instinctive nature.  Humans trying to manage them  for profit endangers everyone around them.

    Also true of the horses.  But we're contrasting the Heywoods' respect for the horses' nature with Jup's lack of same.  Up to, and including using Lucky as bait.

    3 hours ago, Luckylyn said:

    Interestingly at the end Em’s focus isn’t checking to see if they got their Oprah shot but on seeing if her brother is okay.  

    Man, the whole climax was soooooo good.  I'm glad it was Em who got to save the day.

    • Like 4
    • Love 3
  13. 14 hours ago, AimingforYoko said:

    Only quibble, they should've used Marley's original "No Woman, No Cry".

    IMHO, since the the trailer focused almost exclusively on the women, it's more appropriate to have a female voice.

    And this was a lot more somber than the original, which I think fits the tone they were going for better.

    • Like 2
    • Love 8
  14. This was definitely more of a thriller (I've seen more than a few comparing it to Spielberg's summer popcorn movies, and they're apt), but I had a phenomenal time.

    It did take the story a little too long to get going, but Keke Palmer made up for it. 

    • Like 2
    • Love 2
×
×
  • Create New...