My last words on the Julia-Joel topic. First, I appreciate all dissenting opinions for their thoughtfulness, insight, and civility. I also appreciate those who agree as I believed mine to be a unique view and I'm glad there are some others out there to verify that I am not entirely off my rocker (at least on this opinion).
Also, Cattitude, well said above. I was touched by your words and the sacrifices you have made when your husband is away. I'll refrain from quoting due to length.
My perspective is somewhat biased as the father of an autistic child. It is a daily battle of trying to serve your child and at the same time prepare your child for the world. I think Parenthood got it right in the early seasons, just demonstrating how constant the battle is ... but then went astray more and more as Max was provided with zero discipline. Parents who care about their autistic child will tell you, you have to establish consequences (revoking privileges, taking toys away, etc.), and it is a constant battle to find the right balance of grace and punishment, knowing that you will make many mistakes.
Given this perspective, I see strong similarities between the way Max is treated by his parents and Julia is treated by her family. Not surprisingly, I see strong similarities with how they function in life as well, doing what they want based on impulse rather than considering the needs of those around them. To me, it was never about the sex. That was just symptomatic and demonstrative of her desire for self-gratification. It was Julia's insensitivity to Joel having to not just re-enter the work force after years away, but do so as the sole provider. He did so willingly without complaining, and had to put in many long hours, as anyone would in that situation, only to hear the constant complaining of his wife. She is a strong women for goodness sake ... I think she had it within her to contemplate the reality, Joel would have to put in many hours restarting his career, and needs support instead of criticism. Then, when he tried to communicate that, she starts spending time with divorced dad.
Both Max and Julia live most of their lives seeing how those around them can meet their needs. They both need loving parents who will sit them down and be truthful with them, tell them how they messed up, and to seek forgiveness. That last episode, I think Max was the only one of the two to do so ... to ask forgiveness.
Thanks again all for the interesting discussion. I enjoyed being a part of it.