amensisterfriend December 3, 2015 Share December 3, 2015 Our final three: 17. Rory's graduation speech (TASP)22. Nanny comes to Paris' graduation, and brings the kids (TASP)30. Paris assigns Rory the piece on repaving the school parking lot and Rory turns it into a "bittersweet piece on how everybody and everything eventually becomes obsolete". (N&N, S&N) Link to comment
Taryn74 December 4, 2015 Share December 4, 2015 22 or 30, 22 or 30.......... Hmmmm...... I guess I'll go with 22. Really love Nanny though. Link to comment
Kohola3 December 4, 2015 Share December 4, 2015 (edited) Oops, double post. Edited December 4, 2015 by Kohola3 Link to comment
LeafontheWind December 4, 2015 Share December 4, 2015 22- I like Paris and Nanny's relationship, but not enough for this to beat out the other two moments. Link to comment
amensisterfriend December 4, 2015 Share December 4, 2015 Our final two: 17. Rory's graduation speech (TASP)30. Paris assigns Rory the piece on repaving the school parking lot and Rory turns it into a "bittersweet piece on how everybody and everything eventually becomes obsolete". (N&N, S&N) My vote: 30, which wouldn't have even made my top 10. Link to comment
Kohola3 December 4, 2015 Share December 4, 2015 Both are on my "blech" list. The graduation speech was totally expected, nothing new or interesting. Of the two I guess I will go with 30. Link to comment
Guest December 4, 2015 Share December 4, 2015 22, which shouldn't have even made the list! :) Link to comment
LeafontheWind December 4, 2015 Share December 4, 2015 I like both of these, but not as much as some of the others that were eliminated :( I will go with 17 because I like that Rory gets a deserved win against Paris. You know, back when she worked hard for what she earned. Link to comment
amensisterfriend December 7, 2015 Share December 7, 2015 Our triumphant winner: 17. Rory's graduation speech (TASP) I'm yet to watch it or even think about it without getting choked up :) 2 Link to comment
amensisterfriend January 26, 2016 Share January 26, 2016 I'm really missing this game!!! If anyone has any suggestions as to what we should play next, I will happily run it :) Link to comment
amensisterfriend January 26, 2016 Share January 26, 2016 ---In the interim, maybe we can do a quick and fun one: premieres and finales! Just vote for the TWO of these episodes you want to eliminate: Pilot Love, Daisies and Troubadours Sadie, Sadie I Can't Get Started Lazy Hazy Crazy Days Those Are Strings, Pinocchio Ballrooms & Biscotti Raincoats and Recipes Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller A House Is Not A Home New and Improved Lorelai Partings The Long Morrow Bon Voyage Link to comment
LeafontheWind January 26, 2016 Share January 26, 2016 The New and Improved Daisy Miller 1 Link to comment
Kohola3 January 26, 2016 Share January 26, 2016 Lazy Hazy Days. Could we do most loved scenes? Or would that take years to complete each season? There are some episodes I hate but that have one gem of a scene that makes it worth watching. Link to comment
amensisterfriend January 26, 2016 Share January 26, 2016 Kohola, we're voting against TWO, not one :) Maybe we could narrow it down by most loved ---- scenes? Like most loved friendship scenes, most loved family scenes, most loved romantic scenes? Otherwise, it'll probably be too unwieldy! I totally agree that even most of my least favorite episodes have a few great isolated scenes, so Best Scenes in Otherwise Sub-par Episodes would be awesome if not for the fact that there's obviously no consensus on which episodes are considered bad! (For example, LHC, which yu just voted against in this first round, is a favorite of mine!) Link to comment
Taryn74 January 27, 2016 Share January 27, 2016 NAIL, Partings - both just made me too sad Link to comment
amensisterfriend January 27, 2016 Share January 27, 2016 We've Parted with Partings and prefer Original Recipe Lorelai to the 'New and Improved' version. The next round is open! We're still voting against two :) PilotLove, Daisies and TroubadoursSadie, SadieI Can't Get StartedLazy Hazy Crazy DaysThose Are Strings, PinocchioBallrooms & BiscottiRaincoats and RecipesSay Goodbye to Daisy MillerA House Is Not A HomeThe Long MorrowBon Voyage Link to comment
amensisterfriend January 27, 2016 Share January 27, 2016 I'll vote to Say Goodbye to a House Is Not a Home...there's a lot to like about both episodes, but the Rory stuff here is painful for me! Link to comment
lulu1960 January 27, 2016 Share January 27, 2016 Love Daisies and Troubies in the Long Morrow Link to comment
LeafontheWind January 28, 2016 Share January 28, 2016 I hope the final list is Not a Home for Daisy Miller Link to comment
amensisterfriend January 28, 2016 Share January 28, 2016 (edited) PilotLove, Daisies and TroubadoursSadie, SadieI Can't Get StartedLazy Hazy Crazy DaysThose Are Strings, PinocchioBallrooms & BiscottiRaincoats and RecipesThe Long MorrowBon Voyage Our representatives from S5 and S6 are now history, and the next round is open! This is the last time we'll vote against TWO :) My votes: Sadie, Sadie doesn't Love Daisies and Troubadours (but she does love saying her own name twice for some inexplicable reason!) Edited January 28, 2016 by amensisterfriend Link to comment
amensisterfriend January 29, 2016 Share January 29, 2016 PilotLove, Daisies and TroubadoursI Can't Get StartedThose Are Strings, PinocchioBallrooms & BiscottiRaincoats and RecipesThe Long MorrowBon Voyage Lazy Hazy (which I love beyond reason!) and Sadie Sadie (which...eh, it's probably my least favorite episode of all of S2) are history, and the next round is open! We're down to voting against just ONE :) My vote: Love, Daisies. and Troubadours (Am I the only one who had no idea what a troubadour was prior to watching GG?!) Link to comment
Kohola3 January 29, 2016 Share January 29, 2016 Agreed. Ditch the daisies. And, yes, I did know what a troubadour was but then I'm old and went to a lot of Renaissance dinners in my day. 1 Link to comment
lulu1960 January 29, 2016 Share January 29, 2016 The Long Morrow. (May I squee at the official confirmation news of the GG revival?) 1 Link to comment
Taryn74 January 29, 2016 Share January 29, 2016 Long Morrow (I'm casting a side-eye at Daisies, though. It's next on my list.) 1 Link to comment
ghoulina January 30, 2016 Share January 30, 2016 Still sticking with Raincoats. While the Kirk thing actually makes me laugh and I love what happens with Luke and Lorelei, Rory and Dean just ruin the entire thing for me. Plus, Jason bugs and Richard and Emily make me really sad. Link to comment
amensisterfriend January 31, 2016 Share January 31, 2016 PilotLove, Daisies and TroubadoursI Can't Get StartedThose Are Strings, PinocchioBallrooms & BiscottiRaincoats and RecipesBon Voyage Long Morrow is history, and the next round is open! My vote: (I Don't) Love Daisies and Troubadours Link to comment
LeafontheWind January 31, 2016 Share January 31, 2016 Ballrooms for me. The Ice Cream Queen stuff bugs me, and nothing else is good enough to offset my annoyance. Link to comment
lulu1960 January 31, 2016 Share January 31, 2016 Ballrooms for me too. Emily being controlling. Rory not just explaining the situation. I did like the Luke and Lorelai parts though. Link to comment
amensisterfriend February 1, 2016 Share February 1, 2016 PilotI Can't Get StartedThose Are Strings, PinocchioBallrooms & BiscottiRaincoats and RecipesBon Voyage Daisies is gone, and we're down to our final five :) Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.