Taryn74 May 4, 2015 Share May 4, 2015 14. It was sweet, but kinda strange and out-of-place at the same time. Link to comment
LeafontheWind May 4, 2015 Share May 4, 2015 14 (as long as 15 or 17 comes out on top I am happy!) Link to comment
amensisterfriend May 5, 2015 Share May 5, 2015 Our final three! 15. Richard tells Emily to sit still at the graduation. He tells Lorelai he will take the pictures. "Lorelai, I will note the time. I will take the photo. You just sit there and enjoy your daughter’s graduation from Yale. This is as much your moment as Rory’s. Enjoy it." (Unto the Breach)16. Last FND for a while. Rory got the job. They will definitely stay for after-dinner drinks. "Hear. Hear." (Bon Voyage)17. Richard tells Lorelai that the Bon Voyage party is as much for her as it is for Rory. (Bon Voyage) Link to comment
amensisterfriend May 6, 2015 Share May 6, 2015 Awww...more unanimity and harmony! 16 is history, and we're down to our final two: 15. Richard tells Emily to sit still at the graduation. He tells Lorelai he will take the pictures. "Lorelai, I will note the time. I will take the photo. You just sit there and enjoy your daughter’s graduation from Yale. This is as much your moment as Rory’s. Enjoy it." (Unto the Breach)17. Richard tells Lorelai that the Bon Voyage party is as much for her as it is for Rory. (Bon Voyage) --After this, we can have a battle among the top three moments from each season, provided you guys are up for it! Link to comment
lottiedottie May 6, 2015 Share May 6, 2015 I can't eliminate either one! They are both great moments. Ugh. If I have to choose, 15. Link to comment
lulu1960 May 6, 2015 Share May 6, 2015 Great final two. Notice they are very similar in tone. I think I enjoy 15 a bit more. In 17, Emily is a tad bit annoying. 17 1 Link to comment
amensisterfriend May 6, 2015 Share May 6, 2015 Yeah, it's funny, because I was utterly meh on most of these---but LOVE the final two to the point where it pains me to pick one over the other! I'll obediently follow the group and vote to eliminate 17. And, yes, if you guys jumped off a bridge, I'd probably do it too ;) 2 Link to comment
amensisterfriend May 7, 2015 Share May 7, 2015 Our winner! 15. Richard tells Emily to sit still at the graduation. He tells Lorelai he will take the pictures. "Lorelai, I will note the time. I will take the photo. You just sit there and enjoy your daughter’s graduation from Yale. This is as much your moment as Rory’s. Enjoy it." (Unto the Breach) Is everyone up for now voting on our top four winners from each round? 1 Link to comment
amensisterfriend May 7, 2015 Share May 7, 2015 1. "I'm an autumn!" (Richard's realization at Rory's birthday party!)2. Seeing how upset Emily is, a hospitalized Richard gently says "Yes Emily. You may go first." (Forgiveness and Stuff)3. Richard defends Lorelai when Straub insults her (Christopher Returns)4. Richard is quietly complicit in helping Lorelai sneak away from the painfully boring date Emily sprung on her (Star Crossed Lovers) 5. Richard gets playful and frisky with Emily during the carriage ride (Bracebridge)6. Richard and Emily display a moment of pure pride as Lorelai crosses the stage to get her diploma (Lorelai's Graduation Day)7. Richard admitting his new secretary is no "Margie", even though he really means she is no Lorelai (Help Wanted)8. Richard is worried about the fight he had with Rory. It was their first one and he did not care for it. -Hammers and Veils9. Richard tells Rory and Lorelai how he was engaged to Pennilyn Lott but once he saw Emily in the blue dress he had no choice. (Let the Games Begin)10. Richard tells the story of how he proposed to Emily. (Let the Games Begin)11. Richard and Emily look on proudly as Rory calls them her twin pillars at her graduation (Those Are Strings, Pinnochio)12. Richard serves Johnny Machete to the girls at FND. Plus they are super excited that Rory chose Yale. (Happy Birthday, Baby)13. Richard telling his Naked Guy story to both one-up Marty and put him at ease at the same time.14. Richard breaks down after his mother's death (The Reigning Lorelai)15. Richard tells Emily they shouldn't keep Trix's ashes above the mantle (TRL)16. Richard happily runs off to sing with the Whiffenpoofs at Yale (TKBNO)17. Emily tell Richard that she is going to Europe and having two glasses of wine at lunch."Only prostitutes have two glasses of wine at lunch" She is clearly not the woman that he married.(Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller)18. Richard helps Rory play a joke on Logan by pretending he has arranged for them to be married (Not as Cute as Pushkin)19. Richard's speech to Emily at their vow renewal ceremony "Just for tonight, you can call me Bill." (Wedding Bell Blues)20. Richard's doesn't want to go back to the pool house. Emily tells him to come home (Come Home)21. Richard returns the dollhouse. Now he agrees that Rory was wrong to quit Yale. Lorelai reminded him that they had had a plan. (21 is the Lonliest Number)22. Richard tells Lorelai that he cleared the path for Rory to walk away from her goals. He bought her the 'sex mattress and sex boxstring' (21)23. The big FND argument and hashing out all their problems. (Friday Night's Alright for Fighting)24. At FND they try to have a civil convo on what they can and can not talk about but eventually all Richard can say is, I love shrimp! (You've Been Gilmored) 25. Richard and Emily sing at Rory's party. "You're the top you have graduated. You're the top, your grandparents are elated."(Unto the Breach)26. Richard tells Emily to sit still at the graduation. He tells Lorelai he will take the pictures. "Lorelai, I will note the time. I will take the photo. You just sit there and enjoy your daughter’s graduation from Yale. This is as much your moment as Rory’s. Enjoy it." (Unto the Breach)27. Last FND for a while. Rory got the job. They will definitely stay for after-dinner drinks. "Hear. Hear." (Bon Voyage)28. Richard tells Lorelai that the Bon Voyage party is as much for her as it is for Rory. (Bon Voyage) Welcome to the battle of the top four Richard moments from each season. Just vote for the three you most want to eliminate! Link to comment
amensisterfriend May 8, 2015 Share May 8, 2015 13, 22 and 24 are gone, and the next round is open! We're still voting against three: 1. "I'm an autumn!" (Richard's realization at Rory's birthday party!)2. Seeing how upset Emily is, a hospitalized Richard gently says "Yes Emily. You may go first." (Forgiveness and Stuff)3. Richard defends Lorelai when Straub insults her (Christopher Returns)4. Richard is quietly complicit in helping Lorelai sneak away from the painfully boring date Emily sprung on her (Star Crossed Lovers)5. Richard gets playful and frisky with Emily during the carriage ride (Bracebridge)6. Richard and Emily display a moment of pure pride as Lorelai crosses the stage to get her diploma (Lorelai's Graduation Day)7. Richard admitting his new secretary is no "Margie", even though he really means she is no Lorelai (Help Wanted)8. Richard is worried about the fight he had with Rory. It was their first one and he did not care for it. -Hammers and Veils9. Richard tells Rory and Lorelai how he was engaged to Pennilyn Lott but once he saw Emily in the blue dress he had no choice. (Let the Games Begin)10. Richard tells the story of how he proposed to Emily. (Let the Games Begin)11. Richard and Emily look on proudly as Rory calls them her twin pillars at her graduation (Those Are Strings, Pinnochio)12. Richard serves Johnny Machete to the girls at FND. Plus they are super excited that Rory chose Yale. (Happy Birthday, Baby)14. Richard breaks down after his mother's death (The Reigning Lorelai)15. Richard tells Emily they shouldn't keep Trix's ashes above the mantle (TRL)16. Richard happily runs off to sing with the Whiffenpoofs at Yale (TKBNO)17. Emily tell Richard that she is going to Europe and having two glasses of wine at lunch."Only prostitutes have two glasses of wine at lunch" She is clearly not the woman that he married.(Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller)18. Richard helps Rory play a joke on Logan by pretending he has arranged for them to be married (Not as Cute as Pushkin)19. Richard's speech to Emily at their vow renewal ceremony "Just for tonight, you can call me Bill." (Wedding Bell Blues)20. Richard's doesn't want to go back to the pool house. Emily tells him to come home (Come Home)21. Richard returns the dollhouse. Now he agrees that Rory was wrong to quit Yale. Lorelai reminded him that they had had a plan. (21 is the Lonliest Number)23. The big FND argument and hashing out all their problems. (Friday Night's Alright for Fighting)25. Richard and Emily sing at Rory's party. "You're the top you have graduated. You're the top, your grandparents are elated."(Unto the Breach)26. Richard tells Emily to sit still at the graduation. He tells Lorelai he will take the pictures. "Lorelai, I will note the time. I will take the photo. You just sit there and enjoy your daughter’s graduation from Yale. This is as much your moment as Rory’s. Enjoy it." (Unto the Breach)27. Last FND for a while. Rory got the job. They will definitely stay for after-dinner drinks. "Hear. Hear." (Bon Voyage)28. Richard tells Lorelai that the Bon Voyage party is as much for her as it is for Rory. (Bon Voyage) Link to comment
amensisterfriend May 10, 2015 Share May 10, 2015 (edited) I'll go with 3, 25 and 27 as well, so those three are eliminated. The next round is open! We're still voting against three... :) 1. "I'm an autumn!" (Richard's realization at Rory's birthday party!)2. Seeing how upset Emily is, a hospitalized Richard gently says "Yes Emily. You may go first." (Forgiveness and Stuff)4. Richard is quietly complicit in helping Lorelai sneak away from the painfully boring date Emily sprung on her (Star Crossed Lovers)5. Richard gets playful and frisky with Emily during the carriage ride (Bracebridge)6. Richard and Emily display a moment of pure pride as Lorelai crosses the stage to get her diploma (Lorelai's Graduation Day)7. Richard admitting his new secretary is no "Margie", even though he really means she is no Lorelai (Help Wanted)8. Richard is worried about the fight he had with Rory. It was their first one and he did not care for it. -Hammers and Veils9. Richard tells Rory and Lorelai how he was engaged to Pennilyn Lott but once he saw Emily in the blue dress he had no choice. (Let the Games Begin)10. Richard tells the story of how he proposed to Emily. (Let the Games Begin)11. Richard and Emily look on proudly as Rory calls them her twin pillars at her graduation (Those Are Strings, Pinnochio)12. Richard serves Johnny Machete to the girls at FND. Plus they are super excited that Rory chose Yale. (Happy Birthday, Baby)14. Richard breaks down after his mother's death (The Reigning Lorelai)15. Richard tells Emily they shouldn't keep Trix's ashes above the mantle (TRL)16. Richard happily runs off to sing with the Whiffenpoofs at Yale (TKBNO)17. Emily tell Richard that she is going to Europe and having two glasses of wine at lunch."Only prostitutes have two glasses of wine at lunch" She is clearly not the woman that he married.(Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller)18. Richard helps Rory play a joke on Logan by pretending he has arranged for them to be married (Not as Cute as Pushkin)19. Richard's speech to Emily at their vow renewal ceremony "Just for tonight, you can call me Bill." (Wedding Bell Blues)20. Richard's doesn't want to go back to the pool house. Emily tells him to come home (Come Home)21. Richard returns the dollhouse. Now he agrees that Rory was wrong to quit Yale. Lorelai reminded him that they had had a plan. (21 is the Loneliest Number)23. The big FND argument and hashing out all their problems. (Friday Night's Alright for Fighting)26. Richard tells Emily to sit still at the graduation. He tells Lorelai he will take the pictures. "Lorelai, I will note the time. I will take the photo. You just sit there and enjoy your daughter’s graduation from Yale. This is as much your moment as Rory’s. Enjoy it." (Unto the Breach)28. Richard tells Lorelai that the Bon Voyage party is as much for her as it is for Rory. (Bon Voyage) My votes: 8, 21 and 23 Edited May 10, 2015 by amensisterfriend Link to comment
amensisterfriend May 11, 2015 Share May 11, 2015 1. "I'm an autumn!" (Richard's realization at Rory's birthday party!)2. Seeing how upset Emily is, a hospitalized Richard gently says "Yes Emily. You may go first." (Forgiveness and Stuff)4. Richard is quietly complicit in helping Lorelai sneak away from the painfully boring date Emily sprung on her (Star Crossed Lovers)5. Richard gets playful and frisky with Emily during the carriage ride (Bracebridge)6. Richard and Emily display a moment of pure pride as Lorelai crosses the stage to get her diploma (Lorelai's Graduation Day)7. Richard admitting his new secretary is no "Margie", even though he really means she is no Lorelai (Help Wanted)9. Richard tells Rory and Lorelai how he was engaged to Pennilyn Lott but once he saw Emily in the blue dress he had no choice. (Let the Games Begin)10. Richard tells the story of how he proposed to Emily. (Let the Games Begin)11. Richard and Emily look on proudly as Rory calls them her twin pillars at her graduation (Those Are Strings, Pinnochio)12. Richard serves Johnny Machete to the girls at FND. Plus they are super excited that Rory chose Yale. (Happy Birthday, Baby)14. Richard breaks down after his mother's death (The Reigning Lorelai)15. Richard tells Emily they shouldn't keep Trix's ashes above the mantle (TRL)17. Emily tell Richard that she is going to Europe and having two glasses of wine at lunch."Only prostitutes have two glasses of wine at lunch" She is clearly not the woman that he married.(Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller)18. Richard helps Rory play a joke on Logan by pretending he has arranged for them to be married (Not as Cute as Pushkin)19. Richard's speech to Emily at their vow renewal ceremony "Just for tonight, you can call me Bill." (Wedding Bell Blues)20. Richard's doesn't want to go back to the pool house. Emily tells him to come home (Come Home)23. The big FND argument and hashing out all their problems. (Friday Night's Alright for Fighting)26. Richard tells Emily to sit still at the graduation. He tells Lorelai he will take the pictures. "Lorelai, I will note the time. I will take the photo. You just sit there and enjoy your daughter’s graduation from Yale. This is as much your moment as Rory’s. Enjoy it." (Unto the Breach)28. Richard tells Lorelai that the Bon Voyage party is as much for her as it is for Rory. (Bon Voyage) 8, 16 and 21 are gone, and the next round is open! This is the last time we'll vote against three... Link to comment
amensisterfriend May 12, 2015 Share May 12, 2015 17 and 23 are gone, but we have a tie between 4 and 14 for that final spot. Just vote for the one of those two you most want eliminated! My tiebreaker vote: 14 Link to comment
amensisterfriend May 12, 2015 Share May 12, 2015 1. "I'm an autumn!" (Richard's realization at Rory's birthday party!)2. Seeing how upset Emily is, a hospitalized Richard gently says "Yes Emily. You may go first." (Forgiveness and Stuff)4. Richard is quietly complicit in helping Lorelai sneak away from the painfully boring date Emily sprung on her (Star Crossed Lovers)5. Richard gets playful and frisky with Emily during the carriage ride (Bracebridge)6. Richard and Emily display a moment of pure pride as Lorelai crosses the stage to get her diploma (Lorelai's Graduation Day)7. Richard admitting his new secretary is no "Margie", even though he really means she is no Lorelai (Help Wanted)9. Richard tells Rory and Lorelai how he was engaged to Pennilyn Lott but once he saw Emily in the blue dress he had no choice. (Let the Games Begin)10. Richard tells the story of how he proposed to Emily. (Let the Games Begin)11. Richard and Emily look on proudly as Rory calls them her twin pillars at her graduation (Those Are Strings, Pinnochio)12. Richard serves Johnny Machete to the girls at FND. Plus they are super excited that Rory chose Yale. (Happy Birthday, Baby)15. Richard tells Emily they shouldn't keep Trix's ashes above the mantle (TRL)18. Richard helps Rory play a joke on Logan by pretending he has arranged for them to be married (Not as Cute as Pushkin)19. Richard's speech to Emily at their vow renewal ceremony "Just for tonight, you can call me Bill." (Wedding Bell Blues)20. Richard's doesn't want to go back to the pool house. Emily tells him to come home (Come Home)26. Richard tells Emily to sit still at the graduation. He tells Lorelai he will take the pictures. "Lorelai, I will note the time. I will take the photo. You just sit there and enjoy your daughter’s graduation from Yale. This is as much your moment as Rory’s. Enjoy it." (Unto the Breach)28. Richard tells Lorelai that the Bon Voyage party is as much for her as it is for Rory. (Bon Voyage) Thanks for jumping in so quickly, Kohola! The next round is now open, and we're down to voting against just two. Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.