Gilmore Girls Elimination Game

[Kohola3]

20

[Taryn74]

13

[LeafontheWind]

13

[amensisterfriend]

Our final two: 

 

12. Richard helps Rory play a joke on Logan by pretending he has arranged for them to be married (Not as Cute as Pushkin)
20. Richard's doesn't want to go back to the pool house. Emily tells him to come home (Come Home)

 

My vote: 12 

[lulu1960]

20

[ghoulina]

20

[Taryn74]

20

[LeafontheWind]

20, because 12 is probably my favorite Richard moment ever!

[lottiedottie]

20, because 12 is probably my favorite Richard moment ever!

 

Agreed! 20

[amensisterfriend]

Our triumphant victor:

 

12. Richard helps Rory play a joke on Logan by pretending he has arranged for them to be married (Not as Cute as Pushkin)

 

Feel free to start listing your favorite S6 Richard moments as they leap to mind! 

[lulu1960]

Richard causes a scene in the courtroom. He isn't pleased that Rory's lawyer didn't do a better job. (NAIL)

Lorelai bursts into Richard and Emily's bedroom. Richard tries to explain that a con was not perpetrated on her and they want what is best for Rory. (NAIL)

Richard and Emily find Rory a job with the DAR (Fight Face)

Richard tells Emily that Rory can do anything she puts her mind to and she will do an excellent job hosting the DAR function. (We've Got Magic to Do)

Richard does not believe Lorelai when she tells him that the Huntzbergers  humiliated Rory. He says it was merely a misunderstanding (We've Got Magic to Do)

Richard has a confrontation with Mitchum. He finds out what was said to Rory. Realizes that Rory may be wasting her time at the DAR.  (We've Got Magic to Do)

Richard tells Emily that he saw Lorelai. Emily isn't pleased about it. He insists it was just a short conversation about a small fire at the Inn (Welcome to the Dollhouse)

Richard has a conversation with Logan. Logan thinks Richard is asking  about his intentions with Rory. (Welcome to the Dollhouse)

Richard and Emily sneak into the poolhouse. He tells Emily she should have worried about what was under the tootsie rolls. (Welcome to the Dollhouse)

 

I'll add more later

[lulu1960]

Richard returns the dollhouse. Now he agrees that Rory was wrong to quit Yale. Lorelai reminded him that they had had a plan. (21 is the Lonliest Number)

Richard interrupts Logan and Rory in the car. He and Emily must do something before she takes that 'step.' (21)

Richard tells Lorelai that he cleared the path for Rory to walk away from her goals. He bought her the 'sex mattress and sex boxstring' (21)

Richard tells Emily that the DAR is frivolous and meaningless. He doesn't want that live for Rory. (insulting Emily in the process) (21)

Richard has a run in with Colin and Finn as they pack Rory's belongings (The Prodigal Daughter Returns)

Richard calls Lorelai in a panic. Emily is gone. Her bed hasn't been slept in. (The Prodigal Daughter Returns)

Lorelai calls Richard and tells him that Christopher will now be paying for Yale (Friday Night's Alright for Fighting)

The big FND argument and hashing out all their problems. (Friday Night's Alright for Fighting)

[amensisterfriend]

Lulu's fabulous list:

 

1. Richard causes a scene in the courtroom. He isn't pleased that Rory's lawyer didn't do a better job. (NAIL)
2. Lorelai bursts into Richard and Emily's bedroom. Richard tries to explain that a con was not perpetrated on her and they want what is best for Rory. (NAIL)
3. Richard and Emily find Rory a job with the DAR (Fight Face)
4. Richard tells Emily that Rory can do anything she puts her mind to and she will do an excellent job hosting the DAR function. (We've Got Magic to Do)
5. Richard does not believe Lorelai when she tells him that the Huntzbergers  humiliated Rory. He says it was merely a misunderstanding (We've Got Magic to Do)
6. Richard has a confrontation with Mitchum. He finds out what was said to Rory. Realizes that Rory may be wasting her time at the DAR.  (We've Got Magic to Do)
7. Richard tells Emily that he saw Lorelai. Emily isn't pleased about it. He insists it was just a short conversation about a small fire at the Inn (Welcome to the Dollhouse)
8. Richard has a conversation with Logan. Logan thinks Richard is asking  about his intentions with Rory. (Welcome to the Dollhouse)
9. Richard and Emily sneak into the poolhouse. He tells Emily she should have worried about what was under the tootsie rolls. (Welcome to the Dollhouse)

10. Richard returns the dollhouse. Now he agrees that Rory was wrong to quit Yale. Lorelai reminded him that they had had a plan. (21 is the Lonliest Number)
11. Richard interrupts Logan and Rory in the car. He and Emily must do something before she takes that 'step.' (21)
12. Richard tells Lorelai that he cleared the path for Rory to walk away from her goals. He bought her the 'sex mattress and sex boxstring' (21)
13. Richard tells Emily that the DAR is frivolous and meaningless. He doesn't want that live for Rory. (insulting Emily in the process) (21)
14. Richard has a run in with Colin and Finn as they pack Rory's belongings (The Prodigal Daughter Returns)
15. Richard calls Lorelai in a panic. Emily is gone. Her bed hasn't been slept in. (The Prodigal Daughter Returns)
16. Lorelai calls Richard and tells him that Christopher will now be paying for Yale (Friday Night's Alright for Fighting)
17. The big FND argument and hashing out all their problems. (Friday Night's Alright for Fighting)

 

I scanned the episode list but couldn't think of any additions..granted, I'm a lot less familiar with S6 than any other season :) Does anyone have any additions before we start voting?

[lulu1960]

I look at the transcripts. Give me a few more minutes. LOL.

[lulu1960]

At FND they try to have a civil convo on what they can and can not talk about but eventually all Richard can say is, I love shrimp! (You've Been Gilmored)

FND with Luke included. Richard gives them an earful of insurance stories. Death by starter pistol is one. (You've Been Gilmored)

Richard and Emily visit Stars Hollow. Lorelai tries to downplay the town. They mean Taylor, talk about potholes, and box stores.(The Real Paul Anka)

Richard tells Emily that she shouldn't serve spaghetti and meatballs to the girls because they always fight when they do. They are also donating money to Yale in Rory's name.  (Driving Miss Gilmore)

Richard unveils the model of the Rory Gilmore Astronomy Building (Partings)

[amensisterfriend]

Lulu, this is where I warble "Did you ever know that you're my heeerrrrooooo....?" :)

 

1. Richard causes a scene in the courtroom. He isn't pleased that Rory's lawyer didn't do a better job. (NAIL)
2. Lorelai bursts into Richard and Emily's bedroom. Richard tries to explain that a con was not perpetrated on her and they want what is best for Rory. (NAIL)
3. Richard and Emily find Rory a job with the DAR (Fight Face)
4. Richard tells Emily that Rory can do anything she puts her mind to and she will do an excellent job hosting the DAR function. (We've Got Magic to Do)
5. Richard does not believe Lorelai when she tells him that the Huntzbergers  humiliated Rory. He says it was merely a misunderstanding (We've Got Magic to Do)
6. Richard has a confrontation with Mitchum. He finds out what was said to Rory. Realizes that Rory may be wasting her time at the DAR.  (We've Got Magic to Do)
7. Richard tells Emily that he saw Lorelai. Emily isn't pleased about it. He insists it was just a short conversation about a small fire at the Inn (Welcome to the Dollhouse)
8. Richard has a conversation with Logan. Logan thinks Richard is asking  about his intentions with Rory. (Welcome to the Dollhouse)
9. Richard and Emily sneak into the poolhouse. He tells Emily she should have worried about what was under the tootsie rolls. (Welcome to the Dollhouse)
10. Richard returns the dollhouse. Now he agrees that Rory was wrong to quit Yale. Lorelai reminded him that they had had a plan. (21 is the Lonliest Number)
11. Richard interrupts Logan and Rory in the car. He and Emily must do something before she takes that 'step.' (21)
12. Richard tells Lorelai that he cleared the path for Rory to walk away from her goals. He bought her the 'sex mattress and sex boxstring' (21)
13. Richard tells Emily that the DAR is frivolous and meaningless. He doesn't want that live for Rory. (insulting Emily in the process) (21)
14. Richard has a run in with Colin and Finn as they pack Rory's belongings (The Prodigal Daughter Returns)
15. Richard calls Lorelai in a panic. Emily is gone. Her bed hasn't been slept in. (The Prodigal Daughter Returns)
16. Lorelai calls Richard and tells him that Christopher will now be paying for Yale (Friday Night's Alright for Fighting)
17. The big FND argument and hashing out all their problems. (Friday Night's Alright for Fighting)

18. At FND they try to have a civil convo on what they can and can not talk about but eventually all Richard can say is, I love shrimp! (You've Been Gilmored)
19. FND with Luke included. Richard gives them an earful of insurance stories. Death by starter pistol is one. (You've Been Gilmored)
20. Richard and Emily visit Stars Hollow. Lorelai tries to downplay the town. They mean Taylor, talk about potholes, and box stores.(The Real Paul Anka)
21. Richard tells Emily that she shouldn't serve spaghetti and meatballs to the girls because they always fight when they do. They are also donating money to Yale in Rory's name.  (Driving Miss Gilmore)
22. Richard unveils the model of the Rory Gilmore Astronomy Building (Partings)

 

Feel free to start voting against three :) 

[LeafontheWind]

1, 5, and 19

[lulu1960]

1 3 16

[amensisterfriend]

1, 3 and 5...sadly, I like VERY few of these! 

Edited April 4, 2015 by amensisterfriend

[Taryn74]

1, 5, 21

[lottiedottie]

3, 14, 19

[ghoulina]

2, 3, 5

[amensisterfriend]

2. Lorelai bursts into Richard and Emily's bedroom. Richard tries to explain that a con was not perpetrated on her and they want what is best for Rory. (NAIL)
4. Richard tells Emily that Rory can do anything she puts her mind to and she will do an excellent job hosting the DAR function. (We've Got Magic to Do)
6. Richard has a confrontation with Mitchum. He finds out what was said to Rory. Realizes that Rory may be wasting her time at the DAR.  (We've Got Magic to Do)
7. Richard tells Emily that he saw Lorelai. Emily isn't pleased about it. He insists it was just a short conversation about a small fire at the Inn (Welcome to the Dollhouse)
8. Richard has a conversation with Logan. Logan thinks Richard is asking  about his intentions with Rory. (Welcome to the Dollhouse)
9. Richard and Emily sneak into the poolhouse. He tells Emily she should have worried about what was under the tootsie rolls. (Welcome to the Dollhouse)
10. Richard returns the dollhouse. Now he agrees that Rory was wrong to quit Yale. Lorelai reminded him that they had had a plan. (21 is the Lonliest Number)
11. Richard interrupts Logan and Rory in the car. He and Emily must do something before she takes that 'step.' (21)
12. Richard tells Lorelai that he cleared the path for Rory to walk away from her goals. He bought her the 'sex mattress and sex boxstring' (21)
13. Richard tells Emily that the DAR is frivolous and meaningless. He doesn't want that live for Rory. (insulting Emily in the process) (21)
14. Richard has a run in with Colin and Finn as they pack Rory's belongings (The Prodigal Daughter Returns)
15. Richard calls Lorelai in a panic. Emily is gone. Her bed hasn't been slept in. (The Prodigal Daughter Returns)
16. Lorelai calls Richard and tells him that Christopher will now be paying for Yale (Friday Night's Alright for Fighting)
17. The big FND argument and hashing out all their problems. (Friday Night's Alright for Fighting)
18. At FND they try to have a civil convo on what they can and can not talk about but eventually all Richard can say is, I love shrimp! (You've Been Gilmored)
19. FND with Luke included. Richard gives them an earful of insurance stories. Death by starter pistol is one. (You've Been Gilmored)
20. Richard and Emily visit Stars Hollow. Lorelai tries to downplay the town. They mean Taylor, talk about potholes, and box stores.(The Real Paul Anka)
21. Richard tells Emily that she shouldn't serve spaghetti and meatballs to the girls because they always fight when they do. They are also donating money to Yale in Rory's name.  (Driving Miss Gilmore)
22. Richard unveils the model of the Rory Gilmore Astronomy Building (Partings)

 

1, 3 and 5 are gone, and the next round is open! We're still voting against three :)

[lulu1960]

2 7 16

[Taryn74]

21 - it was just dumb

11

13

[ghoulina]

2, 7, 16

[LeafontheWind]

16, 19, and 21

[lottiedottie]

14, 19, 20

[Kohola3]

2, 7, 21

[amensisterfriend]

I'll happily go along with the votes against 7, 16 and 21, which means those are now eliminated! Just vote against the TWO that you want to eliminate next :) 
 

2. Lorelai bursts into Richard and Emily's bedroom. Richard tries to explain that a con was not perpetrated on her and they want what is best for Rory. (NAIL)
4. Richard tells Emily that Rory can do anything she puts her mind to and she will do an excellent job hosting the DAR function. (We've Got Magic to Do)
6. Richard has a confrontation with Mitchum. He finds out what was said to Rory. Realizes that Rory may be wasting her time at the DAR.  (We've Got Magic to Do)
8. Richard has a conversation with Logan. Logan thinks Richard is asking  about his intentions with Rory. (Welcome to the Dollhouse)
9. Richard and Emily sneak into the poolhouse. He tells Emily she should have worried about what was under the tootsie rolls. (Welcome to the Dollhouse)
10. Richard returns the dollhouse. Now he agrees that Rory was wrong to quit Yale. Lorelai reminded him that they had had a plan. (21 is the Lonliest Number)
11. Richard interrupts Logan and Rory in the car. He and Emily must do something before she takes that 'step.' (21)
12. Richard tells Lorelai that he cleared the path for Rory to walk away from her goals. He bought her the 'sex mattress and sex boxstring' (21)
13. Richard tells Emily that the DAR is frivolous and meaningless. He doesn't want that live for Rory. (insulting Emily in the process) (21)
14. Richard has a run in with Colin and Finn as they pack Rory's belongings (The Prodigal Daughter Returns)
15. Richard calls Lorelai in a panic. Emily is gone. Her bed hasn't been slept in. (The Prodigal Daughter Returns)
17. The big FND argument and hashing out all their problems. (Friday Night's Alright for Fighting)
18. At FND they try to have a civil convo on what they can and can not talk about but eventually all Richard can say is, I love shrimp! (You've Been Gilmored)
19. FND with Luke included. Richard gives them an earful of insurance stories. Death by starter pistol is one. (You've Been Gilmored)
20. Richard and Emily visit Stars Hollow. Lorelai tries to downplay the town. They mean Taylor, talk about potholes, and box stores.(The Real Paul Anka)
22. Richard unveils the model of the Rory Gilmore Astronomy Building (Partings)

[lulu1960]

2 and 22. I have to concur, none of these give me the warm and fuzzies about Richard.

[Kohola3]

2, 22

[amensisterfriend]

14 and 22

[ghoulina]

2, 22

[LeafontheWind]

19 and 22

[Taryn74]

2, 22

[lottiedottie]

20, 22

[amensisterfriend]

4. Richard tells Emily that Rory can do anything she puts her mind to and she will do an excellent job hosting the DAR function. (We've Got Magic to Do)
6. Richard has a confrontation with Mitchum. He finds out what was said to Rory. Realizes that Rory may be wasting her time at the DAR.  (We've Got Magic to Do)
8. Richard has a conversation with Logan. Logan thinks Richard is asking  about his intentions with Rory. (Welcome to the Dollhouse)
9. Richard and Emily sneak into the poolhouse. He tells Emily she should have worried about what was under the tootsie rolls. (Welcome to the Dollhouse)
10. Richard returns the dollhouse. Now he agrees that Rory was wrong to quit Yale. Lorelai reminded him that they had had a plan. (21 is the Lonliest Number)
11. Richard interrupts Logan and Rory in the car. He and Emily must do something before she takes that 'step.' (21)
12. Richard tells Lorelai that he cleared the path for Rory to walk away from her goals. He bought her the 'sex mattress and sex boxstring' (21)
13. Richard tells Emily that the DAR is frivolous and meaningless. He doesn't want that live for Rory. (insulting Emily in the process) (21)
14. Richard has a run in with Colin and Finn as they pack Rory's belongings (The Prodigal Daughter Returns)
15. Richard calls Lorelai in a panic. Emily is gone. Her bed hasn't been slept in. (The Prodigal Daughter Returns)
17. The big FND argument and hashing out all their problems. (Friday Night's Alright for Fighting)
18. At FND they try to have a civil convo on what they can and can not talk about but eventually all Richard can say is, I love shrimp! (You've Been Gilmored)
19. FND with Luke included. Richard gives them an earful of insurance stories. Death by starter pistol is one. (You've Been Gilmored)
20. Richard and Emily visit Stars Hollow. Lorelai tries to downplay the town. They mean Taylor, talk about potholes, and box stores.(The Real Paul Anka)
 

2 and 22 are history, and the next round is open! 

 

My votes:11 and 14 (honestly, any scene with Colin is kind of automatically on my "ugh" list!) and 

[lulu1960]

8 11

[ghoulina]

11, 15

[LeafontheWind]

11 and 19

[Taryn74]

11, 19

[lottiedottie]

4, 14

[Kohola3]

11, 14

[amensisterfriend]

4. Richard tells Emily that Rory can do anything she puts her mind to and she will do an excellent job hosting the DAR function. (We've Got Magic to Do)
6. Richard has a confrontation with Mitchum. He finds out what was said to Rory. Realizes that Rory may be wasting her time at the DAR.  (We've Got Magic to Do)
8. Richard has a conversation with Logan. Logan thinks Richard is asking  about his intentions with Rory. (Welcome to the Dollhouse)
9. Richard and Emily sneak into the poolhouse. He tells Emily she should have worried about what was under the tootsie rolls. (Welcome to the Dollhouse)
10. Richard returns the dollhouse. Now he agrees that Rory was wrong to quit Yale. Lorelai reminded him that they had had a plan. (21 is the Lonliest Number)
12. Richard tells Lorelai that he cleared the path for Rory to walk away from her goals. He bought her the 'sex mattress and sex boxstring' (21)
13. Richard tells Emily that the DAR is frivolous and meaningless. He doesn't want that live for Rory. (insulting Emily in the process) (21)
15. Richard calls Lorelai in a panic. Emily is gone. Her bed hasn't been slept in. (The Prodigal Daughter Returns)
17. The big FND argument and hashing out all their problems. (Friday Night's Alright for Fighting)
18. At FND they try to have a civil convo on what they can and can not talk about but eventually all Richard can say is, I love shrimp! (You've Been Gilmored)
19. FND with Luke included. Richard gives them an earful of insurance stories. Death by starter pistol is one. (You've Been Gilmored)
20. Richard and Emily visit Stars Hollow. Lorelai tries to downplay the town. They mean Taylor, talk about potholes, and box stores.(The Real Paul Anka)

 

11 and 14 are gone, and the next round is open. We're still voting against two! 

[lottiedottie]

4, 8

[Kohola3]

4, 8

[ghoulina]

4, 15

[lulu1960]

4 and 8

[amensisterfriend]

8 and 15