Gilmore Girls Elimination Game

[lulu1960]

I can look. I think I got up to The Party's Over.

[lulu1960]

Richard comes to investigate the dog on the patio. Women of Questionable Morals

Richard shows Emily how to find the dog's breed as well as luggage on the computer (WoQM)

Richard needs a bowl for 'Dog' and he must stop feeding him stew. (WoQM)

Richard insists that Emily stays when the girls come to FND. They tell them about Chris' dad dying. (WoQM)

Richard is jealous and ends up rear-ending Emily's car at the function (Come Home)

Richard's doesn't want to go back to the pool house. Emily tells him to come home (Come Home

[lulu1960]

Rory ignores her grandmother and Richard tries to smooth out the situation. (So Good Talk)

Richard calls Lorelai and tries to get her to forgive Emily. Lorelai will still talk to him. (So.. Good Talk)

Richard goes to the inn about a insurance matter. Says that Lorelai has done a fine job with the inn. And she should sell it. (So ... Good Talk)

Emily is upset with Richard that he saw Lorelai.  "This is not a popularity contest."  "No, not a contest. You’ve already won."  "Emily, you are acting incredibly immature!" (So ... Good Talk)
Richard explains that maybe Luke didn't understand when Emily told him to get back together with Lorelai. (Pulp Fiction)

Richard and Emily must invite Logan over for dinner immediately. "The ball has been dropped!" (Kropogs)

Richard calls Lorelai and informs her that Mike Armstrong is interested in the Inn (Kropogs)

Richard and Emily have visions of their own compound on the Cape with blondhaired  blue-eyed grandchildren (Kropogs)

Edited March 10, 2015 by lulu1960

[lulu1960]

Double post

Edited March 10, 2015 by lulu1960

[amensisterfriend]

1. Emily tell Richard that she is going to Europe and having two glasses of wine at lunch."Only prostitutes have two glasses of wine at lunch" She is clearly not the woman that he married.(Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller)
2. Richard explains to Lorelai and Rory who Robert is. Is he a butler, a valet, a geisha? (Written in the Stars)
3. Richard tries to go to his study. Emily says he should have made an appointment because she may have been stark naked. He counters that she has never been stark naked. Not even when skinny dipping. (Written in the Stars)
4. Richard and Emily are discussing bills, and Richard's smelly car that leaves oil on the driveway. "Really? You can see the driveway with your nose way up in the air like that?" (Written in the Stars)
5. Richard and Rory have lunch at Yale. Rory tries to convince him to talk to Emily himself but he doesn't want to be a bother. (Pippi)
6. Lorelai visits Richard in the pool house and learns he is in a barbershop quartet. (Pippi)
7. Richard tells Emily about the quartet. He notices the panic room and simply says "Very good." (Pippi)
8. Lorelai begs her father to not make Luke go golfing. But according to Richard it is his right to meet him. (You Jump. I Jump Jack)
9. Richard and Luke go golfing. They talk coins, shaves, franchising, hobbies, and books by Dick (You Jump. I Jump Jack)
10. Richard serves the girls meat on a stick. "Drinks last one hour at most. Then you get the dinner portion, which can last several hours. Especially the way you structure things. You get more time. I should at least be able to serve appetizers with my drinks." (The Party's Over)
11. Emily and Richard are in cahoots with the all male Yale Party (The Party's Over)
12. Richard helps Rory play a joke on Logan by pretending he has arranged for them to be married (Not as Cute as Pushkin)
13. Richard's speech to Emily at their vow renewal ceremony "Just for tonight, you can call me Bill." (Wedding Bell Blues)
14. Richard and Emily reconciled yesterday.  And last night.  And this morning.  (Come Home)

15. Richard comes to investigate the dog on the patio. Women of Questionable Morals
16. Richard shows Emily how to find the dog's breed as well as luggage on the computer (WoQM)
17. Richard needs a bowl for 'Dog' and he must stop feeding him stew. (WoQM)
18. Richard insists that Emily stays when the girls come to FND. They tell them about Chris' dad dying. (WoQM)

19. Richard is jealous and ends up rear-ending Emily's car at the function (Come Home)
20. Richard's doesn't want to go back to the pool house. Emily tells him to come home (Come Home)

21. Rory ignores her grandmother and Richard tries to smooth out the situation. (So Good Talk)
22. Richard calls Lorelai and tries to get her to forgive Emily. Lorelai will still talk to him. (So.. Good Talk)
23. Richard goes to the inn about a insurance matter. Says that Lorelai has done a fine job with the inn. And she should sell it. (So ... Good Talk)
24. Emily is upset with Richard that he saw Lorelai.  "This is not a popularity contest."  "No, not a contest. You’ve already won."  "Emily, you are acting incredibly immature!" (So ... Good Talk)
25. Richard explains that maybe Luke didn't understand when Emily told him to get back together with Lorelai. (Pulp Fiction)
26. Richard and Emily must invite Logan over for dinner immediately. "The ball has been dropped!" (Kropogs)
27. Richard calls Lorelai and informs her that Mike Armstrong is interested in the Inn (Kropogs)
28. Richard and Emily have visions of their own compound on the Cape with blondhaired  blue-eyed grandchildren (Kropogs)

 

Thanks, lulu! If we're all set, everyone should feel free to vote against the three you most want eliminated... 

[Taryn74]

4 - I found it particularly nasty

5 - I don't even remember it, LOL

19 - ugh

[lulu1960]

4 11 26

Taryn, 5 was when he told Rory he finished The fall of the Roman Empire. Took him 30 years or some such thing.

Edited March 11, 2015 by lulu1960

[ghoulina]

4, 8, 11

[Kohola3]

4. 11, 19

[amensisterfriend]

8, 9 and 11

[LeafontheWind]

8, 9, and 11

[amensisterfriend]

1. Emily tell Richard that she is going to Europe and having two glasses of wine at lunch."Only prostitutes have two glasses of wine at lunch" She is clearly not the woman that he married.(Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller)
2. Richard explains to Lorelai and Rory who Robert is. Is he a butler, a valet, a geisha? (Written in the Stars)
3. Richard tries to go to his study. Emily says he should have made an appointment because she may have been stark naked. He counters that she has never been stark naked. Not even when skinny dipping. (Written in the Stars)
5. Richard and Rory have lunch at Yale. Rory tries to convince him to talk to Emily himself but he doesn't want to be a bother. (Pippi)
6. Lorelai visits Richard in the pool house and learns he is in a barbershop quartet. (Pippi)
7. Richard tells Emily about the quartet. He notices the panic room and simply says "Very good." (Pippi)
9. Richard and Luke go golfing. They talk coins, shaves, franchising, hobbies, and books by Dick (You Jump. I Jump Jack)
10. Richard serves the girls meat on a stick. "Drinks last one hour at most. Then you get the dinner portion, which can last several hours. Especially the way you structure things. You get more time. I should at least be able to serve appetizers with my drinks." (The Party's Over)
12. Richard helps Rory play a joke on Logan by pretending he has arranged for them to be married (Not as Cute as Pushkin)
13. Richard's speech to Emily at their vow renewal ceremony "Just for tonight, you can call me Bill." (Wedding Bell Blues)
14. Richard and Emily reconciled yesterday.  And last night.  And this morning.  (Come Home)
15. Richard comes to investigate the dog on the patio. Women of Questionable Morals
16. Richard shows Emily how to find the dog's breed as well as luggage on the computer (WoQM)
17. Richard needs a bowl for 'Dog' and he must stop feeding him stew. (WoQM)
18. Richard insists that Emily stays when the girls come to FND. They tell them about Chris' dad dying. (WoQM)
19. Richard is jealous and ends up rear-ending Emily's car at the function (Come Home)
20. Richard's doesn't want to go back to the pool house. Emily tells him to come home (Come Home)
21. Rory ignores her grandmother and Richard tries to smooth out the situation. (So Good Talk)
22. Richard calls Lorelai and tries to get her to forgive Emily. Lorelai will still talk to him. (So.. Good Talk)
23. Richard goes to the inn about a insurance matter. Says that Lorelai has done a fine job with the inn. And she should sell it. (So ... Good Talk)
24. Emily is upset with Richard that he saw Lorelai.  "This is not a popularity contest."  "No, not a contest. You’ve already won."  "Emily, you are acting incredibly immature!" (So ... Good Talk)
25. Richard explains that maybe Luke didn't understand when Emily told him to get back together with Lorelai. (Pulp Fiction)
26. Richard and Emily must invite Logan over for dinner immediately. "The ball has been dropped!" (Kropogs)
27. Richard calls Lorelai and informs her that Mike Armstrong is interested in the Inn (Kropogs)
28. Richard and Emily have visions of their own compound on the Cape with blondhaired  blue-eyed grandchildren (Kropogs)

 

4, 8 and 11 are gone, and the next round is open! 

 

My votes: 9, 19 and 28

[ghoulina]

5, 24, 26

[Taryn74]

5, 19, 24

[LeafontheWind]

2, 9, and 25

[lulu1960]

24 25 26

[Kohola3]

5, 24, 25

[amensisterfriend]

1. Emily tell Richard that she is going to Europe and having two glasses of wine at lunch."Only prostitutes have two glasses of wine at lunch" She is clearly not the woman that he married.(Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller)
2. Richard explains to Lorelai and Rory who Robert is. Is he a butler, a valet, a geisha? (Written in the Stars)
3. Richard tries to go to his study. Emily says he should have made an appointment because she may have been stark naked. He counters that she has never been stark naked. Not even when skinny dipping. (Written in the Stars)
6. Lorelai visits Richard in the pool house and learns he is in a barbershop quartet. (Pippi)
7. Richard tells Emily about the quartet. He notices the panic room and simply says "Very good." (Pippi)
9. Richard and Luke go golfing. They talk coins, shaves, franchising, hobbies, and books by Dick (You Jump. I Jump Jack)
10. Richard serves the girls meat on a stick. "Drinks last one hour at most. Then you get the dinner portion, which can last several hours. Especially the way you structure things. You get more time. I should at least be able to serve appetizers with my drinks." (The Party's Over)
12. Richard helps Rory play a joke on Logan by pretending he has arranged for them to be married (Not as Cute as Pushkin)
13. Richard's speech to Emily at their vow renewal ceremony "Just for tonight, you can call me Bill." (Wedding Bell Blues)
14. Richard and Emily reconciled yesterday.  And last night.  And this morning.  (Come Home)
15. Richard comes to investigate the dog on the patio. Women of Questionable Morals
16. Richard shows Emily how to find the dog's breed as well as luggage on the computer (WoQM)
17. Richard needs a bowl for 'Dog' and he must stop feeding him stew. (WoQM)
18. Richard insists that Emily stays when the girls come to FND. They tell them about Chris' dad dying. (WoQM)
19. Richard is jealous and ends up rear-ending Emily's car at the function (Come Home)
20. Richard's doesn't want to go back to the pool house. Emily tells him to come home (Come Home)
21. Rory ignores her grandmother and Richard tries to smooth out the situation. (So Good Talk)
22. Richard calls Lorelai and tries to get her to forgive Emily. Lorelai will still talk to him. (So.. Good Talk)
23. Richard goes to the inn about a insurance matter. Says that Lorelai has done a fine job with the inn. And she should sell it. (So ... Good Talk)
26. Richard and Emily must invite Logan over for dinner immediately. "The ball has been dropped!" (Kropogs)
27. Richard calls Lorelai and informs her that Mike Armstrong is interested in the Inn (Kropogs)
28. Richard and Emily have visions of their own compound on the Cape with blondhaired  blue-eyed grandchildren (Kropogs)

 

I actually liked 5 and 24---liked by the lower standards of S5, that is----but those scenes, along with 25, are now history. The next round is open! 

 

My votes: 9, 19 and 28

[Taryn74]

19, 21, 28

 

I like 9 solely for Richard saying he's going to pull up 'Dick' on the internet and see what comes up.  Good luck with that.

[Kohola3]

2, 19, 28

[lulu1960]

10 21 26

Not 10. I meant 28

[LeafontheWind]

2, 9, and 28

[ghoulina]

9, 22, 26

[amensisterfriend]

1. Emily tell Richard that she is going to Europe and having two glasses of wine at lunch."Only prostitutes have two glasses of wine at lunch" She is clearly not the woman that he married.(Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller)
2. Richard explains to Lorelai and Rory who Robert is. Is he a butler, a valet, a geisha? (Written in the Stars)
3. Richard tries to go to his study. Emily says he should have made an appointment because she may have been stark naked. He counters that she has never been stark naked. Not even when skinny dipping. (Written in the Stars)
6. Lorelai visits Richard in the pool house and learns he is in a barbershop quartet. (Pippi)
7. Richard tells Emily about the quartet. He notices the panic room and simply says "Very good." (Pippi)
10. Richard serves the girls meat on a stick. "Drinks last one hour at most. Then you get the dinner portion, which can last several hours. Especially the way you structure things. You get more time. I should at least be able to serve appetizers with my drinks." (The Party's Over)
12. Richard helps Rory play a joke on Logan by pretending he has arranged for them to be married (Not as Cute as Pushkin)
13. Richard's speech to Emily at their vow renewal ceremony "Just for tonight, you can call me Bill." (Wedding Bell Blues)
14. Richard and Emily reconciled yesterday.  And last night.  And this morning.  (Come Home)
15. Richard comes to investigate the dog on the patio. Women of Questionable Morals
16. Richard shows Emily how to find the dog's breed as well as luggage on the computer (WoQM)
17. Richard needs a bowl for 'Dog' and he must stop feeding him stew. (WoQM)
18. Richard insists that Emily stays when the girls come to FND. They tell them about Chris' dad dying. (WoQM)
20. Richard's doesn't want to go back to the pool house. Emily tells him to come home (Come Home)
21. Rory ignores her grandmother and Richard tries to smooth out the situation. (So Good Talk)
22. Richard calls Lorelai and tries to get her to forgive Emily. Lorelai will still talk to him. (So.. Good Talk)
23. Richard goes to the inn about a insurance matter. Says that Lorelai has done a fine job with the inn. And she should sell it. (So ... Good Talk)
26. Richard and Emily must invite Logan over for dinner immediately. "The ball has been dropped!" (Kropogs)
27. Richard calls Lorelai and informs her that Mike Armstrong is interested in the Inn (Kropogs)

 

9, 19 and 28 are gone, and the next round is open! We can shift to voting against just TWO. 
 

[LeafontheWind]

2 and 10

Edited March 17, 2015 by LeafontheWind

[Taryn74]

2, 21

[lulu1960]

26 27

[amensisterfriend]

26 and 27

[ghoulina]

22, 26

 

 

 

ooops, edited because I was distracted and didn't realize we were just voting against two!

Edited March 17, 2015 by ghoulina

[Kohola3]

2, 26

[amensisterfriend]

1. Emily tell Richard that she is going to Europe and having two glasses of wine at lunch."Only prostitutes have two glasses of wine at lunch" She is clearly not the woman that he married.(Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller)
3. Richard tries to go to his study. Emily says he should have made an appointment because she may have been stark naked. He counters that she has never been stark naked. Not even when skinny dipping. (Written in the Stars)
6. Lorelai visits Richard in the pool house and learns he is in a barbershop quartet. (Pippi)
7. Richard tells Emily about the quartet. He notices the panic room and simply says "Very good." (Pippi)
10. Richard serves the girls meat on a stick. "Drinks last one hour at most. Then you get the dinner portion, which can last several hours. Especially the way you structure things. You get more time. I should at least be able to serve appetizers with my drinks." (The Party's Over)
12. Richard helps Rory play a joke on Logan by pretending he has arranged for them to be married (Not as Cute as Pushkin)
13. Richard's speech to Emily at their vow renewal ceremony "Just for tonight, you can call me Bill." (Wedding Bell Blues)
14. Richard and Emily reconciled yesterday.  And last night.  And this morning.  (Come Home)
15. Richard comes to investigate the dog on the patio. Women of Questionable Morals
16. Richard shows Emily how to find the dog's breed as well as luggage on the computer (WoQM)
17. Richard needs a bowl for 'Dog' and he must stop feeding him stew. (WoQM)
18. Richard insists that Emily stays when the girls come to FND. They tell them about Chris' dad dying. (WoQM)
20. Richard's doesn't want to go back to the pool house. Emily tells him to come home (Come Home)
21. Rory ignores her grandmother and Richard tries to smooth out the situation. (So Good Talk)
22. Richard calls Lorelai and tries to get her to forgive Emily. Lorelai will still talk to him. (So.. Good Talk)
23. Richard goes to the inn about a insurance matter. Says that Lorelai has done a fine job with the inn. And she should sell it. (So ... Good Talk)
27. Richard calls Lorelai and informs her that Mike Armstrong is interested in the Inn (Kropogs)

 

2 and 26 are gone, and the next round is open! We're still voting against two :) 

 

My votes: 22 and 27

[ghoulina]

22, 27

[lulu1960]

21 27

[Taryn74]

21, 27

[LeafontheWind]

10 and 27

[Kohola3]

1, 27

[amensisterfriend]

I have a weird fondness for 21...I just like seeing people pleasing Rory, normally so hyper-concerned with being on good terms with everyone no matter how much they're fighting with each other, showing Emily just how irked she is. 

[lulu1960]

I feel the same way about 22. I liked how Lorelai wasn't okay with Emily's behavior and told Richard so. 

[Taryn74]

I'd probably like 21 if I could remember it, heh. 

 

I do remember 22.  Wasn't that when Emily kept calling and Lorelai would hang up on her?  Hee.

[lulu1960]

22 is when Lorelai is walking outside and Richard calls her. Lorelai basically says that Rory is mad because Luke got hurt because of Emily's meddling.

[amensisterfriend]

27 is gone, but we have a tie between 21 and 22. Just vote for the one of those two that you most want eliminated! 

[LeafontheWind]

I will go with 21, but only because I love it so much when Lorelai hangs up as soon as she hears Emily's voice.

[Taryn74]

21

[amensisterfriend]

1. Emily tell Richard that she is going to Europe and having two glasses of wine at lunch."Only prostitutes have two glasses of wine at lunch" She is clearly not the woman that he married.(Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller)
3. Richard tries to go to his study. Emily says he should have made an appointment because she may have been stark naked. He counters that she has never been stark naked. Not even when skinny dipping. (Written in the Stars)
6. Lorelai visits Richard in the pool house and learns he is in a barbershop quartet. (Pippi)
7. Richard tells Emily about the quartet. He notices the panic room and simply says "Very good." (Pippi)
10. Richard serves the girls meat on a stick. "Drinks last one hour at most. Then you get the dinner portion, which can last several hours. Especially the way you structure things. You get more time. I should at least be able to serve appetizers with my drinks." (The Party's Over)
12. Richard helps Rory play a joke on Logan by pretending he has arranged for them to be married (Not as Cute as Pushkin)
13. Richard's speech to Emily at their vow renewal ceremony "Just for tonight, you can call me Bill." (Wedding Bell Blues)
14. Richard and Emily reconciled yesterday.  And last night.  And this morning.  (Come Home)
15. Richard comes to investigate the dog on the patio. Women of Questionable Morals
16. Richard shows Emily how to find the dog's breed as well as luggage on the computer (WoQM)
17. Richard needs a bowl for 'Dog' and he must stop feeding him stew. (WoQM)
18. Richard insists that Emily stays when the girls come to FND. They tell them about Chris' dad dying. (WoQM)
20. Richard's doesn't want to go back to the pool house. Emily tells him to come home (Come Home)
22. Richard calls Lorelai and tries to get her to forgive Emily. Lorelai will still talk to him. (So.. Good Talk)
23. Richard goes to the inn about a insurance matter. Says that Lorelai has done a fine job with the inn. And she should sell it. (So ... Good Talk)

 

The next round is open! 

 

My votes: 22 and 23
 

[LeafontheWind]

10 and 23

[Kohola3]

10, 22

[Taryn74]

22, 23

[lulu1960]

7 23

[ghoulina]

22, 23

[amensisterfriend]

1. Emily tell Richard that she is going to Europe and having two glasses of wine at lunch."Only prostitutes have two glasses of wine at lunch" She is clearly not the woman that he married.(Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller)
3. Richard tries to go to his study. Emily says he should have made an appointment because she may have been stark naked. He counters that she has never been stark naked. Not even when skinny dipping. (Written in the Stars)
6. Lorelai visits Richard in the pool house and learns he is in a barbershop quartet. (Pippi)
7. Richard tells Emily about the quartet. He notices the panic room and simply says "Very good." (Pippi)
10. Richard serves the girls meat on a stick. "Drinks last one hour at most. Then you get the dinner portion, which can last several hours. Especially the way you structure things. You get more time. I should at least be able to serve appetizers with my drinks." (The Party's Over)
12. Richard helps Rory play a joke on Logan by pretending he has arranged for them to be married (Not as Cute as Pushkin)
13. Richard's speech to Emily at their vow renewal ceremony "Just for tonight, you can call me Bill." (Wedding Bell Blues)
14. Richard and Emily reconciled yesterday.  And last night.  And this morning.  (Come Home)
15. Richard comes to investigate the dog on the patio. Women of Questionable Morals
16. Richard shows Emily how to find the dog's breed as well as luggage on the computer (WoQM)
17. Richard needs a bowl for 'Dog' and he must stop feeding him stew. (WoQM)
18. Richard insists that Emily stays when the girls come to FND. They tell them about Chris' dad dying. (WoQM)
20. Richard's doesn't want to go back to the pool house. Emily tells him to come home (Come Home)
 

22 and 23 are gone, and the next round is open! We're still voting against two :)