Gilmore Girls Elimination Game

[ghoulina]

11, 28

[Gilmorefan]

10, 11

[Taryn74]

10 (I think Henry is adorable though)

 

11

[Kohola3]

10 (I, too, loved Henry and wish he'd been written in for a longer time) and 28.

[LeafontheWind]

10 and 28. I really wish Lane could have dated Henry for real for at least a little while.

[amensisterfriend]

11. The fencing match between Rory and Paris (I Solemnly Swear)
14.  The men discuss insurance and architecture at Rory's graduation (TASP)
16. Rory is joined by her fellow reading/headphoned classmate at end of LMLD
17. Rory's graduation speech (TASP)
18. Paris describing her "Felicity" dilemma to Lorelai (TASP?)
22.  Nanny comes to Paris' graduation, and brings the kids (TASP)
24.  Paris tells Headmaster Charleston "No hard feelings" at graduation, hee!  (TASP)
25.  Lorelai goes off on Headmaster after Rory is not allowed to take her test (The Deer Hunters)
27.  Paris tries to psych out her opponents during the speech contest.  Brad is "winningly naïve".  (TBO)
30.  Paris assigns Rory the piece on repaving the school parking lot and Rory turns it into a "bittersweet piece on how everybody and everything eventually becomes obsolete".  (N&N, S&N)
31.  Rory has to interview Max after he and Lorelai don't get married (N&N, S&N)
32. When Paris explains to Rory why she needs her to run as her VP in I Can't Get Started ("You’re quiet, you say excuse me, you look like little birds help you get dressed in the morning.")

 

10 and 28 are gone, and the next round is open! We're still voting against two...

[Taryn74]

Aw, 28.  *tear*  Loved their connection in that one.

 

Onward and forward.

 

11 (Do people actually like this one?  Please share why!)

 

16 - I like it, it's just not as memorable to me

 

It amuses me that almost all of the remaining scenes have Paris in them.  Heh.

[amensisterfriend]

I adore 28 as well, Taryn! 

[Kohola3]

I think 11 is a hoot.  Poor Rory is so flabbergasted!

 

24 doesn't do much for me and I am embarrassed by the helicopter parenting tantrum in 25.

[LeafontheWind]

I also find 11 hilarious. Rory is so confused and Paris is so intense (not that she isn't always intense, she just usually isn't holding a sword). I dig it!

I will go 24 and 25 as well.

[Taryn74]

I am embarrassed by the helicopter parenting tantrum in 25.

 

LORD yes.  The only reason I like 25 is because Headmaster never succumbed to Lorelai's "charms" and pretty much always gave her the what-for.  It amuses me.

[ghoulina]

11, 25

[lulu1960]

18 25

[amensisterfriend]

11. The fencing match between Rory and Paris (I Solemnly Swear)
14.  The men discuss insurance and architecture at Rory's graduation (TASP)
16. Rory is joined by her fellow reading/headphoned classmate at end of LMLD
17. Rory's graduation speech (TASP)
18. Paris describing her "Felicity" dilemma to Lorelai (TASP?)
22.  Nanny comes to Paris' graduation, and brings the kids (TASP)
27.  Paris tries to psych out her opponents during the speech contest.  Brad is "winningly naïve".  (TBO)
30.  Paris assigns Rory the piece on repaving the school parking lot and Rory turns it into a "bittersweet piece on how everybody and everything eventually becomes obsolete".  (N&N, S&N)
31.  Rory has to interview Max after he and Lorelai don't get married (N&N, S&N)
32. When Paris explains to Rory why she needs her to run as her VP in I Can't Get Started ("You’re quiet, you say excuse me, you look like little birds help you get dressed in the morning.")

 

24 and 25 are history, and the next round is open! We're still voting against two :)

[ghoulina]

11, 30

[LeafontheWind]

14 and 27. Both good moments, but nowhere near as important to me as the rest.

[Kohola3]

14, 27

[Taryn74]

Going with 11 and 16 again!

[Gilmorefan]

11, 14

[lulu1960]

16 and 18

[amensisterfriend]

16. Rory is joined by her fellow reading/headphoned classmate at end of LMLD
17. Rory's graduation speech (TASP)
18. Paris describing her "Felicity" dilemma to Lorelai (TASP?)
22.  Nanny comes to Paris' graduation, and brings the kids (TASP)
27.  Paris tries to psych out her opponents during the speech contest.  Brad is "winningly naïve".  (TBO)
30.  Paris assigns Rory the piece on repaving the school parking lot and Rory turns it into a "bittersweet piece on how everybody and everything eventually becomes obsolete".  (N&N, S&N)
31.  Rory has to interview Max after he and Lorelai don't get married (N&N, S&N)
32. When Paris explains to Rory why she needs her to run as her VP in I Can't Get Started ("You’re quiet, you say excuse me, you look like little birds help you get dressed in the morning.")

 

11 and 14 are gone, and the next round is open! We're still voting against two :) 

[ghoulina]

30, 32

[lulu1960]

16 and 18

[LeafontheWind]

18 and 27

[Kohola3]

18, 30

[Kohola3]

Not to break the chain but have we ever done a "most hated" episode vote?

[Taryn74]

Oh that would be fun kohola!

 

16 and 32

[Gilmorefan]

18, 31

[amensisterfriend]

I'll go against 18 and 32 as well, and those are now history! We can now switch to voting against just one :) 

 

16. Rory is joined by her fellow reading/headphoned classmate at end of LMLD
17. Rory's graduation speech (TASP)
22.  Nanny comes to Paris' graduation, and brings the kids (TASP)
27.  Paris tries to psych out her opponents during the speech contest.  Brad is "winningly naïve".  (TBO)
30.  Paris assigns Rory the piece on repaving the school parking lot and Rory turns it into a "bittersweet piece on how everybody and everything eventually becomes obsolete".  (N&N, S&N)
31.  Rory has to interview Max after he and Lorelai don't get married (N&N, S&N)

[LeafontheWind]

27 (sorry, didn't see that we are voting for one! Shame on me for skimming!)

Edited November 27, 2015 by LeafontheWind

[Taryn74]

16

[Gilmorefan]

31

[ghoulina]

30

[lulu1960]

16

[Kohola3]

16

[amensisterfriend]

I love, love, LOVE 16! It's one of the more special scenes of the series for me. But, alas, the voters have spoken...16 is history, and we're down to our final five :) 

 

17. Rory's graduation speech (TASP)
22.  Nanny comes to Paris' graduation, and brings the kids (TASP)
27.  Paris tries to psych out her opponents during the speech contest.  Brad is "winningly naïve".  (TBO)
30.  Paris assigns Rory the piece on repaving the school parking lot and Rory turns it into a "bittersweet piece on how everybody and everything eventually becomes obsolete".  (N&N, S&N)
31.  Rory has to interview Max after he and Lorelai don't get married (N&N, S&N)

 

My vote: 30 (I love Paris more than pretty much anyone, but I'm kind of surprised this scene made it as far as it did!) 

[lulu1960]

31. I like 30 because Rory put Paris in her place.

[ghoulina]

30

 

 

(I hated to see 16 go as well!)

[Taryn74]

31.  Same as Lulu, it was nice seeing Rory have the upper hand there in 30, and it was one of those moments where they show us that Rory was talented at something rather than just tell us.

 

I liked 16, but it bugs me that we never saw her new "friend" again.  I don't even think we ever got her name.

[ghoulina]

I liked 16, but it bugs me that we never saw her new "friend" again.  I don't even think we ever got her name.

 

OT, but I do agree with this - I felt the same way about the Yale girls who initially mocked her, but then ended up bringing her coffee and asking her to come to freshmen assembly. 

[Gilmorefan]

31

I really liked sixteen too

[LeafontheWind]

Aw, I love 31! And I don't even like Max! But I love 30 more, so I will vote against 31 to save 30 for another round.

[Kohola3]

31

[amensisterfriend]

And then there were four... 

 

17. Rory's graduation speech (TASP)
22.  Nanny comes to Paris' graduation, and brings the kids (TASP)
27.  Paris tries to psych out her opponents during the speech contest.  Brad is "winningly naïve".  (TBO)
30.  Paris assigns Rory the piece on repaving the school parking lot and Rory turns it into a "bittersweet piece on how everybody and everything eventually becomes obsolete".  (N&N, S&N)

[Kohola3]

27

[Gilmorefan]

27

[lulu1960]

27

[LeafontheWind]

Yay, 27!

[Guest]

22

[Taryn74]

27