S02.E12: Road to the Finals

[txhorns79 21,298]

Quote

The three finalists compete for the golden trophy.

Air Date: December 18, 2019

[adhoc 3,773]

Ha, the Rottweiler says he lost to a Cat, but he's not going to lose to Flamingo or Fox. 

Chris Daughtry lost AI, Katherine McPhee won that season. Case closed.  Right?

Edited December 19, 2019 by adhoc

[meggonzo 899]

Taylor Hicks actually won that season of AI. 

[Dani 31,943]

18 minutes ago, adhoc said:

Ha, the Rottweiler says he lost to a Cat, but he's not going to lose to Flamingo or Fox. 

Chris Daughtry lost AI, Katherine McPhee won that season. Case closed.  Right?

 

3 minutes ago, meggonzo said:

Taylor Hicks actually won that season of AI. 

Yep but when Chris was eliminated he was in the bottom two with Katherine. I rewatched to refresh my memory and when Seacrest announced the bottom two he called them Kat and Chris. 

Edited December 19, 2019 by Dani

[adhoc 3,773]

Oh, that's right, I forgot about Katherine losing to Taylor Hicks. Still, I figured that the clue referred to her and Chris in their season of AI.

[Was-MArsenault 2,699]

I wonder why the live discussion thread for the show was never opened.