IgotThis

R E A C H....but I've seen stranger things. There's a chance the Ross father impregnated Erin, hell, maybe he shot her too. Gross, I know. However, he never said anything about why Billy might have killed Erin. Why not ask the question? Neither did John. The father was at the reunion too. This would be the ultimate surprise right? Where's their mom? Maybe the Apple doesn't fall too far from the tree. Acts all accusatory and sanctimonious with John when all along he messed up with Erin? Maybe she saw him as a father or grandfather figure. The boys may want to cover up for their dad.

"Kenny wasn't shown entering the house early in the morning." Yes he was, you're mistaken. Kenny was shown stumbling in to the house in the morning Erin's body was shown in the creek. It was at the end of epiosde 1 (The day the body was found). The other scene you referenced with Erin was her cooking dinner for her dad the night before when he came home from work. According to her phone it was 8:30ish in the early evening. She then asked her dad if she could borrow the truck. I'm not sure what you mean by ETA. Anyways, yes, it doesn't mean he left anywhere but they sure gave the impression he did. He had a change of clothes too. Did he get up, smoke, and fail to realize Erin wasn't home? I guess we may never know. The body was found by a jogger and she was officially pronounced dead at 7:14 am by a medic.

Thanks for this. So we know Frank was out cold. What we also know is that this may have been an attempt for John to have an alibi as well. We got drunk that night! Frank was up bright & early the next day. Where was Erin's dad? He was shown entering the house in the early morning that Erin's body was found. Are they going to address that? He said he had been home the whole night.

We're so close to the end that I think this is the last attempt at misdirection by the writers. Billy helped clean up John's mess and John was most likely the killer. There are a few surprises they can still throw at us but they would be too over the top. The biggest question and the elephant in the room for Episode 6 is that no one has asked "Why would Billy kill her"? I mean, its pretty straight forward, right? The Dad didn't ask John, John didn't ask his Dad. John's wife told Mare that Billy was the killer because he incestuously impregnated his cousin's daughter. Yeah, and? He decided to wait a few years to kill her? Why? So, the obvious answer (outside of what the writer's are trying to have us believe) is that John impregnated Erin; John & Billy killed Erin & has now manipulated Billy in to taking the wrap for him. We have all the clues we need to come to this conclusion: John is promiscuous, John (According to Billy) doesn't take responsibility for the messes he makes, etc..

I believe it was Dylan's friend Sean.

As of the end of Episode 4: 1. I think Erin's father should probably be the prime suspect in her murder. A lot of characters are being caught up in half-truths and non-disclosure but no one has seemingly lied like he did. Erin's dad told Mare "All fucking night", when asked if he was home the night of Erin's murder. Yet, at the end of episode one, they show him returning to his house in the morning. Where had he been? We already know he owns a gun & may be a bad shot from not being able to kill Dylan. Was he upset with Erin for having the baby? Was he upset for having to take care of them both? He immediately tried to place blame on Dylan as the only one who would want to hurt to her. Of course, there's always a chance the writers could explain his being outside as something else but they sure made it look like he had been out. The show has provided many winding roads and suspects to keep viewers guessing - including casting Guy Pearce as just some schmuck love interest. I'm beginning believe they cast a typically leading-actor in a supporting role as an intentional attempt at deflection to keep the audience guessing. Jess (Erin's supposed best friend) is some piece of work & could also be a part of another side story implicating her in a catfishing scheme. She never told Mare (as far as what we've been shown) that Erin was lured to Sharp's Creek by Brianna & company. Why didn't she disclose that? One of the other interrogated teens told Mare to look in to the catfishing stuff. Did she? I'm not sure what to make of Deacon Mark yet. He said he had a 2 minute cell phone conversation with Erin the night of the murder but never disclosed that information to detectives until confronted. Why not? Mare said it was odd he didn't contact them with that information & never pressed him for an answer. He apparently also found her bike & discarded it in a river. Where did he get the bike? Why did he dispose of it? Why did he avoid the detectives when they came over to question him a second time? Is he protecting another youth who approached him for help? Perhaps the real father of Erin's baby? 2. I think the kidnappings will end up being unrelated to Erin's murder. Mare & Zabel will solve those kidnappings much the way he solved the other cold case. He said he solved the missing 10 year old's case by rechecking statements & trying to find holes in timelines. The vehicle used in the kidnapping was a worker truck with ladders on top. The kidnapper used the attic of an old tavern to hide his 2 victims. White male with black hair. Was that his property or is he some blue-collar worker?