Scott might slip in there. He has had his mistakes but recently those have come from trying to help other people. He has had some positive reviews and I think he would be in a better place if he took a second or two to breathe before speaking or bringing a dish up to the pass. Last night he was really only called out for things he was helping with. I could see his argument that his service was just as good as Kashia's. She had a few mistakes but nothing too serious or that wasn't corrected.
I disagree. Scott is a total screw-up in the kitchen. True, not to the extent that others have been, but there's a reason most of the confessionals about him have been negative. Even with the things he's done right, there's clearly a whole lot more he's done wrong. Helping others has very obviously done more harm than good, and the teams he's been on have picked up on it. If that were a positive thing, they'd have portrayed it as such. But since it hasn't been, Scott's clearly messed up more than we've seen.
Does Scott (or Melanie, for that matter) ever work an actual station of his own? He always seems to be "helping people out" instead of doing his own job.
Scott has worked his own station before, but it's usually an easy station too hard to mess up, like appetizers. And even then, he's had mistakes there. It's another reason why I don't see him lasting much longer. He hasn't really been challenged yet or taken a big step to do something risky in the kitchen like, say, Rochelle has by doing many dishes she hasn't done yet.
S12.E14: 8 Chefs Compete
in Hell's Kitchen
I disagree. Scott is a total screw-up in the kitchen. True, not to the extent that others have been, but there's a reason most of the confessionals about him have been negative. Even with the things he's done right, there's clearly a whole lot more he's done wrong. Helping others has very obviously done more harm than good, and the teams he's been on have picked up on it. If that were a positive thing, they'd have portrayed it as such. But since it hasn't been, Scott's clearly messed up more than we've seen.
Scott has worked his own station before, but it's usually an easy station too hard to mess up, like appetizers. And even then, he's had mistakes there. It's another reason why I don't see him lasting much longer. He hasn't really been challenged yet or taken a big step to do something risky in the kitchen like, say, Rochelle has by doing many dishes she hasn't done yet.