Charmed: Elimination Games

[4evaQuez]

How to make a quilt, animal pragmatism, that old black magic

[amensisterfriend]

Yay---someone else showed up to vote! I'll break the tie by going for (against!) Devil's Music, Quilt and Old Black Magic, so those are eliminated.. Here's our updated list:

 

Witch Trial
Morality Bites
The Painted World
She's a Man, Baby, a Man!
They're Everywhere
P3 H20
Ms. Hellfire
Heartbreak City
Reckless Abandon
Awakened
Animal Pragmatism
Pardon My Past
Give Me a Sign
Murphy's Luck
Chick Flick
Ex Libris
Astral Monkey
Apocalypse, Not
Be Careful What You Witch For

 

The next round is open! My votes: Ex Libris, Heartbreak City, Animal Pragmatism 

[Kohola3]

Witch Trial, Painted World, Animal Prag

[4evaQuez]

Witch Trial, Animal Prag, Heartbreak City

[amensisterfriend]

Morality Bites
The Painted World
She's a Man, Baby, a Man!
They're Everywhere
P3 H20
Ms. Hellfire
Reckless Abandon
Awakened
Pardon My Past
Give Me a Sign
Murphy's Luck
Chick Flick
Ex Libris
Astral Monkey
Apocalypse, Not
Be Careful What You Witch For

 

Animal Pragmatism, Heartbreak City and Witch Trial and history, and the next round is open! We're still voting against three :) 

 

My votes: They're Everywhere (I can never remember a single thing about this one, which is generally not a good sign!), Reckless Abandon, Ex Libris

[4evaQuez]

Ms. Hellfire, Heartbreak City and Reckless Abandon

[amensisterfriend]

4eva, Heartbreak City is already gone :) 

[4evaQuez]

Ooops! She's a Man, Baby, a Man!

[amensisterfriend]

Hoping and waiting for at least one more voter :) 

[Kohola3]

Hellfire, She's a Man, Everywhere

[amensisterfriend]

I'll switch my vote from Reckless Abandon to Hellfire so that we can avoid a tiebreaker, and Hellfire, Everywhere and She's a Man are history! 

 

Morality Bites
The Painted World
P3 H20
Reckless Abandon
Awakened
Pardon My Past
Give Me a Sign
Murphy's Luck
Chick Flick
Ex Libris
Astral Monkey
Apocalypse, Not
Be Careful What You Witch For

 

We're down to voting against just TWO :) 

[4evaQuez]

Reckless Abandon, Apocalypse Not

[Kohola3]

Ditto.  Reckless Apocalypse

[amensisterfriend]

Morality Bites
The Painted World
P3 H20
Awakened
Pardon My Past
Give Me a Sign
Murphy's Luck
Chick Flick
Ex Libris
Astral Monkey
Be Careful What You Witch For

 

Abandoned and Apocalypse are history, and the next round is open! 

 

My votes: Ex Libris and Astral Monkey

 

S2 is so weird for me in that I'd be totally fine never seeing at least 60% of it again, but the episodes I do like are among my favorites of the series and ones that I could watch over and over. 

[Kohola3]

Oh, geez, I hated that monkey thing.  I'll agree with Ex Libris as well.

[4evaQuez]

Ex Libris and Astral Monkey

[amensisterfriend]

Morality Bites
The Painted World
P3 H20
Awakened
Pardon My Past
Give Me a Sign
Murphy's Luck
Chick Flick
Be Careful What You Witch For

 

So since it's just us voting and we're all unanimous this round, should we just end this now and move forward?! Ex-Libris is gone and has taken that Astral Monkey with him, and the next round is open! We're still voting against two and, argh, we're at the stage where this is really hard for me now! 

[Kohola3]

Painted Flick

[amensisterfriend]

I'll go with Give Me a Sign and Chick Flick. (I had remembered loving this one, but it's not quite as great for me as I had recalled...and I'm just so sick of Dan by now!) 

[4evaQuez]

Give Me a Sign and Chick Flick

[amensisterfriend]

Morality Bites
The Painted World
P3 H20
Awakened
Pardon My Past
Murphy's Luck
Be Careful What You Witch For

 

Sign and Chick Flick are our latest casualties, and the next round is open! This is the time we're voting against two. 

 

My votes: P3H20 and Awakened, because while Awakened is great, I just find myself less eager to rewatch the heavier non-finale episodes. By contrast, I can rewatch the 'lighter' good episodes with ridiculous frequency :)

Edited March 31, 2016 by amensisterfriend

[Kohola3]

The Painted World
P3 H20

[4evaQuez]

P3 H20 - (I'm happy you all voted for this, too. I honestly thought you would ban me from the board because I was planning to vote for this next).

 

Painted World

[amensisterfriend]

Morality Bites
Awakened
Pardon My Past
Murphy's Luck
Be Careful What You Witch For

 

(I'm happy you all voted for this, too. I honestly thought you would ban me from the board because I was planning to vote for this next)

 

BANNED. Just kidding, of course :) Even if you voted against my favorites every round, I'd be thrilled to have you here, especially since only three of us are playing! I don't know why I love Painted World so much, by the way. I tend to love episodes where we see Prue at work for some reason, and Phoebe is just so lovable and relatable in this one. 

 

We're down to voting against just ONE! 

 

My vote: Awakened

[4evaQuez]

Awakened

[Kohola3]

Ditto.

[amensisterfriend]

Our fabulous final four!

 

Morality Bites
Pardon My Past
Murphy's Luck
Be Careful What You Witch For

 

My vote: Be Careful What You Witch For---it's a terrific episode, but just one that I'm a little less likely to rewatch...?

[Kohola3]

Pardon my Past

[4evaQuez]

Be Careful What You Witch For

[amensisterfriend]

Our terrific trio:

 

Morality Bites
Pardon My Past
Murphy's Luck

 

My vote: Murphy's Luck, though I love them all. Apparently I just really adore when our Halliwells leave the present timeline :) 

[Kohola3]

Murphy

[4evaQuez]

Murphy's Luck. I'm honestly shocked the episode made it this far, but I do love it tremendously. 

[amensisterfriend]

Our terrific time traveling two:

 

Morality Bites
Pardon My Past

[amensisterfriend]

My vote: Pardon My Past. As much as I like PMP, I like MB a whole lot more! 

[Kohola3]

Morality......no, Pardon........no, Morality.  It's hard.  I think........Pardon.  Morality has that really shocking burning scene that really leaves an impression.

[amensisterfriend]

Plus, PMP has yet more of the tiresome Leo/Piper/Dan love triangle angst, which...*yawn* :) 

[amensisterfriend]

Whichever way 4eva votes, it looks like Morality Bites is our triumphant winner! Our season 3 list...and, argh, this is going to be SO hard because I love way too many of these:

 

The Honeymoon's Over

Magic Hour 

Once Upon a Time

All Halliwell's Eve

Sight Unseen

Primrose Empath

Power Outage

Sleuthing With the Enemy

Coyote Piper

We All Scream for Ice Cream

Blinded By the Whitelighter

Wrestling with Demons

Bride and Gloom

The Good, the Bad and the Cursed

Just Harried

Death Takes a Halliwell

Pre-Witched

Sin Fransisco

The Demon Who Came in from the Cold

Exit Strategy

Look Who's Barking

All Hell Breaks Loose

 

Just vote for the THREE that you most want eliminated :)

[Kohola3]

Once Upon a Time, Ice Cream, Sin

[4evaQuez]

Magic Hour, Once Upon a Time, Ice Cream

[amensisterfriend]

I'll just copy these:

 

Magic Hour, Once Upon a Time, Ice Cream

 

Our updated list:

 

The Honeymoon's Over

All Halliwell's Eve
Sight Unseen
Primrose Empath
Power Outage
Sleuthing With the Enemy
Coyote Piper
Blinded By the Whitelighter
Wrestling with Demons
Bride and Gloom
The Good, the Bad and the Cursed
Just Harried
Death Takes a Halliwell
Pre-Witched
Sin Fransisco
The Demon Who Came in from the Cold
Exit Strategy
Look Who's Barking
All Hell Breaks Loose

 

....we're still voting against three, and I'm already struggling to eliminate any of the ones that remain :)

[Kohola3]

Coyote, Blinded, Sin

[amensisterfriend]

My votes: Coyote Piper, Wrestling with Demons, The Demon Who Came in from the Cold

[4evaQuez]

Coyote Piper, Wrestling with Demons, The Demon Who Came in from the Cold

[amensisterfriend]

The Honeymoon's Over
All Halliwell's Eve
Sight Unseen
Primrose Empath
Power Outage
Sleuthing With the Enemy
Blinded By the Whitelighter
Bride and Gloom
The Good, the Bad and the Cursed
Just Harried
Death Takes a Halliwell
Pre-Witched
Sin Francisco
Exit Strategy
Look Who's Barking
All Hell Breaks Loose

 

Wrestling, The Demon Who Came in from the Cold and Wrestling are history, and the next round is open! We're still voting against three :)

[Kohola3]

Sight Unseen, Sin Francisco, Power Outage

[amensisterfriend]

I'll go with Sight Unseen, Power Outage and Exit Strategy...but this would be a lot easier if i didn't love this season :) I already looked at the episode list for S4 and think I'm going to struggle just as mightily with that one! 

[4evaQuez]

Sight Unseen, Sin Francisco, Power Outage

[amensisterfriend]

The Honeymoon's Over
All Halliwell's Eve
Primrose Empath
Sleuthing With the Enemy
Blinded By the Whitelighter
Bride and Gloom
The Good, the Bad and the Cursed
Just Harried
Death Takes a Halliwell
Pre-Witched
Exit Strategy
Look Who's Barking
All Hell Breaks Loose

 

Sight Unseen, Power Outage and my beloved Sin Fransisco (I swear that episode is in my top five of the entire series...I have weird taste!) have been eliminated, and the next round is open! We can switch to voting against just TWO :) 

[4evaQuez]

The Good, the Bad and the Cursed and Just Harried.

[amensisterfriend]

I'll go with Sleuthing with the Enemy and Just Harried, but have I mentioned that I really love this season?! Yes, I know...I mention it every painful round :)