Jump to content

Type keyword(s) to search

Inquisitionist

Member
  • Posts

    3.4k
  • Joined

Posts posted by Inquisitionist

  1. On 12/9/2021 at 6:04 AM, BeatrixK said:

    Susan Sharon - if it weren't for the voice, there's no way I would have thought it was the same actress.

    I thought she looked better than the 3 lead actresses.  Heck, when I attended my 40-year high school reunion, where everyone was 58, I thought most of us looked better than this lot. 

    On 12/9/2021 at 5:33 PM, Lebanna said:

    I liked most of the funeral but the eulogy, read by Miranda, was terrible. For a second I thought it was supposed to be a ‘someone stop her, she’s drunk’ moment, but then I realized that it was intended to be beautiful and emotional. I can only assume that we’re supposed to think that Carrie was never was much of a writer.

    It sounded a lot like what Carrie wrote for that wedding couple back in season 2 or 3.

    On 12/9/2021 at 6:24 PM, violet and green said:

    I was unable to focus on the funeral as I was mentally trying to take that ridiculous little hat off Carrie's too-tight slicked hair. 

    Am I alone in thinking that Carrie (and SJP) would look so much better with a shorter, softer hair style parted on the side?  

    On 12/10/2021 at 9:13 AM, Yeah No said:

    I was never particularly team Big but I was definitely never team Aidan.  Aidan played mind games with Carrie in his own way.  He almost broke up with her because she smoked and then lied about it because she knew he made it a deal breaker. 

    As I remember it, Aidan told Carrie that smoking was a deal-breaker for him when she lit up at the end of their first date -- perfectly acceptable behavior in my book, as I could never date a smoker either.  Carrie then lied by saying she was only an occasional smoker and trying to hide her addiction from him rather than just accept the facts and move on.

    • Love 9
  2. Quote

    a plane that had infected people landed in Toronto (as that is where the book starts) 

    It's been a few years since I read the book, so I had forgotten the Toronto setting (Emily St. John Mandel is Canadian, so that makes sense).  Interesting that it was changed to Chicago with actual filming here.

    • Love 1
  3. Just watched it last night.  Thought it was oddly paced with some scenes of NOTHING that went on too long.  During the trek from the grocery store, it was like the pandemic had already hit -- there was no one else in the grocery store or on the streets, except for the guy whose car had hit a tree.  I loved the book so I'm sticking with it, but if I hadn't read it, this first episode would leave me only borderline interested.

    • Love 3
  4. On 4/4/2019 at 9:58 PM, SimoneS said:

    Kyle Secor is such a good actor. I can't believe that he is reduced to do guest stints on The Flash and worse yet, has to work with talentless Danielle Panabaker. I guess it is better than working part-time at Trader Joe's like Geoffrey Owens, but still... Acting is such a tough business.

    Indeed it is.  And Kyle has written a book about that!  My copy is due to arrive on Monday.  

  5. On 12/9/2021 at 8:02 AM, Yeah No said:

    I thought Miranda's misstep with her prof. was a very good depiction of the wokeness minefield out there these days.  She just kept taking out one foot and re-inserting the other.  I wouldn't have let that trip me up, but that's me.

    OMG, I've just watched this scene, and I can't go on.  As an attorney, Miranda should know that you NEVER say more than you absolutely have to.  When did she go brain-dead?

    • Love 15
  6. Re Epstein's death -- there are so many "what ifs" about the Beatles.   Personally, I've often wondered if they would even have existed if Paul's mother had not died when he was 14.  Mary was quite set on him pursuing his education and Hamburg would not have set well with her -- let alone John Lennon.

    I finally got around to reading Tune In a few months ago.  This is the first volume of a planned 3-part definitive biography of the Beatles by Mark Lewisohn.  800 pages covering them through the end of 1962.  They could have fallen apart many times before then -- coincidences played a large role in their ability to continue.  Quite amazing to ponder!

    • Useful 1
    • Love 3
  7. 2 hours ago, FancyRhubarb said:

    George doesn't get nearly enough attention for his songwriting skills. It must've been hard to get your stuff when your bandmates are geniuses and to only get one or two songs per album. I'll go to my grave arguing that Long, Long, Long was one of the best songs on The White Album. 

    At one point (in part 3, I think), George laments that he his backlog of songs is enough to last for decades if he continues to get just 2 songs per Beatles album.  Between Paul and George, the group could have put out two albums per year with a few songs thrown in by John (his later Beatles material interests me the least). 

    • Love 4
  8. 13 hours ago, Scout Finch said:

    When there was talk of whether the roof could hold the weight and then you see the boards that don't look sturdy, I was thinking about how that might have been the actual end of The Beatles. "They had a tragic ending when the boards gave way and they all plunged to their deaths."

    When Paul had himself hoisted up on that pulley thing... and when he tossed Heather increasingly higher into the air...  I was holding my breath!  😅

    • Love 2
  9. OMG, Oh! Darling is so clearly about Paul's bandmates:

    Quote

     

    Oh! Darling, if you leave me
    I'll never make it alone
    Believe me when I beg you
    Don't ever leave me alone

    When you told me you didn't need me anymore
    Well you know I nearly broke down and cried
    When you told me you didn't need me anymore
    Well you know I nearly broke down and died

     

    And this is like a day or two after we saw Paul fighting back tears...  He really thought at that time that he couldn't be anything but a Beatle.  "I'll never make it alone" is a plea to the others.  

    • Useful 2
    • Love 7
  10. 11 hours ago, Scout Finch said:

    While Heather has a relationship with her bio dad she's said she considers Paul to be her father. I had no idea how comfortable and close they already were by the time he married Linda, a little under two months after this was filmed. It was reminiscent of my stepdad who my mom married when I was about the same age as Heather.

    Had a relationship -- Mel See died over 20 years ago.  Paul had spent a month or so living with Linda and Heather in their tiny apartment in NYC in October 1968.  I think the two of them went over to London with him almost immediately after that.  So Heather had been around Paul a lot in a short period. 

    10 hours ago, rmontro said:

    I don't know what it is, but The Long and Winding Road has never really appealed to me.  I recognize that it has a good melody and lyrics, and that it was a #1 single.  But it just has never clicked with me, I think it's too slow.  I acknowledge it's a good song but it bores me.  

    Glad to see I'm not the only one.  I find it dirge-like and rather monotonous.  

    8 hours ago, nilyank said:

    I know that there was a deadline to come up wiht the songs and make the record, but why was there a deadline? They arrive on day one with a couple of idea of songs but nothing really for the whole record yet. 

    Ringo was committed to start filming The Magic Christian in late January and would not be available for several months after that.  I think this is explained at the start of Ep. 1.

    • Love 3
  11. 2 hours ago, ProudMary said:

    Baby brother George at 24(!) is continually having his ideas pushed aside by his big brothers, which we can surmise has been the dynamic since young George joined the band.
    ...


    The sequence showing the conception of "Get Back" was truly amazing, seeing McCartney's mind at work. So intimate. 

    ...


    Was John so messed up at this point that he needed an emotional support animal directly by his side at all times?

    Not TL at all!  George was actually 25 and close to 26 when this was filmed in Jan. 1969.  He was born in Feburary, 1943.  Paul is 20 months younger than John, and George is only 8 months younger than Paul.  But if you look at photos of 14-year-old George (the age at which he joined the group), he really looks like a little kid.  John and Paul tended to keep him in that "box" despite his growing maturity and creativity.  It really is a little sad.   

    It's not often we see the creative process at work so clearly.  I know Paul would often have a tune worked out before coming to the studio, but with Get Back, he really does seem to be composing on the spot.  Extraordinary.

    The John/Yoko dynamic eludes me to this day.  John was certainly in the thrall of heavy drugs (though perhaps less so in Jan. 1969 than he had been during the White Album sessions, when Ono first became glued to his side).  I've read and watched a ton of interviews with John and I believe he had some serious psychological issues, including narcissism and paranoia -- a rather deadly combination.  I wish he'd gotten some real treatment somewhere along the way rather than the various snake-oil fads that Yoko appears to have conned him into trying. 

    And while McCartney sometimes draws criticism for alleged "revisionism" of the Beatles story... John was a master at this.  I've seen an interview where he slams Let It Be as "granny music" and says he doesn't know what Paul is thinking when he writes something like that.  He didn't seem to mind recording the song, and surely he must have known that "mother Mary" was a reference to Paul's deceased mother.  Even if Paul didn't come out and say that directly to John, it doesn't take a genius to figure it out.  

    • Love 11
  12. 17 hours ago, WendyCR72 said:

    What got me is how respectful/quiet Yoko Ono was. For all the talk of how she "broke up The Beatles", she seemed to stay out of the way and seemed to get along with Linda (Eastman) McCartney.

     Could be respectful editing.  She screeches in Part II.  And asks George Martin where one can purchase classical music scores.  Seriously? 

    10 hours ago, Jeebus Cripes said:

    The thing bothered me about Yoko is not that she's there but that she's literally sitting up front as though she is a member of the band. Not just on one occasion but on what seems like a daily basis. This would irritate me beyond the telling even though she isn't saying a word. It's incredibly intrusive. I noticed when Linda was there that she respectively sat a distance away, which is appropriate because she's not a member of the band. I just find it rude on the part of John and Yoko. 

    Poor George. I said aloud, "George is so over it" about one minute before he stood up and declared he quit. 

    Amen to both of these observations.  George got such short shrift. 

    I had not known about his Hare Krishna friends attending at Twickenham, but they also sat quietly at a distance. 

    One of my favorite moments is Paul's passive aggressiveness in Part I.  Someone asks his opinion about a graphic design, and he says something like "Ask John and Yoko -- they're artists." (Meanwhile, I'll just sit at the piano spinning out one memorable tune after another.)

    • Love 9
  13. On 4/2/2020 at 8:45 AM, IslandGirl said:

    I thought the actor who played Elena's ex did a terrible job in the final scene where he calls her a narcissist & says it's not his job to make her life more bearable. I felt like I was watching an actor act & it ruined the great dialogue for me.

    I didn't think the dialog was great either.

    On 4/2/2020 at 3:12 PM, OtterMommy said:

    I thought that was strange too.  One on hand, the actor playing Jamie was too old to be playing a college senior...

    And too young to be playing a contemporary of Reese Witherspoon:  in 2020, she was 44 and he was 31.  I snickered when the character referenced his 40th birthday. 

  14. On 4/1/2020 at 7:41 PM, Adgirl said:

    Maybe because your perspective and hers are similar. Have you tried seeing this invasive woman from Mia's pov?

    Mia has invited that invasiveness. So no, I don't get her perspective.

    On 4/2/2020 at 3:48 AM, dmc said:

    Getting a job at Elena's to keep an eye on Pearl doesn't make any sense.  ...  However Mia has kept the connection with Elena going, not Elena. At any time, Mia could have distanced herself and chose not to until the last episode.   

    Amen. Both characters have acted oddly, but Mia has escalated the situation.

    On 4/3/2020 at 11:06 AM, Kiki620 said:

    I thought so too.  And to make it a further unbelieveable storyline, a naked picture of a random pregnant woman (I know it's Mia) commands $30k?  What in the world would make that picture special in any way to someone other than Mia?

    I think we'll see that its value is due to the artist (photographer) not the subject. Why a hotel would want that hanging in its lobby is beyond me though...

    • Love 1
×
×
  • Create New...