"However, as with most cases of this nature, we can't really ignore how the show has treated female contestants of color: Monique Coleman, Mya, Mel B, Brandy, were to all at varying extents treated very dismissively by the show despite talent. I leave out Wendy and Nene because they were't that great of dancers to begin with. I'm sure there may be other contestants I can't remember off hand however I have counter question. I think the biggest frustration for Tamar in terms of viewers that are airing grievances is that she is simply being added to the list of black female contestants that are getting a very targetted narrative on this show (unapproachable, lacks warmth or connection, too much attitude). The only time she's come off as slightly vulnerable is when she spoke about her husband almost dying. That's a bit extreme and I'm sure for her routines to come out as good as they have been she has to listen to Val at some point, why not show these times?"
You bring up good points....issues that always must be looked at and addressed. This old white lady is always on the lookout for people who may be receiving different treatment for a plethora of reasons. I don't know that I completely agree with everything you put forth but it is a very important discussion. Someone has already talked about Mel B. (loved her and she seemed to be a strong and well liked contestant), Laila Ali....well, you try to put Laila in a corner and she will set things straight. I do admire her grace and the way she carries herself. I think she may be a lot like her dad. I am enjoying reading this thread. Many good and important points being made.
Sus.