So thankful this is here! I watched the series when it aired, but recently started a rewatch and just finished Jacksonville.
I'll admit I wasn't a huge fan of Peter/Olivia. I like both characters and definitely found Peter charming. I guess I was invested to a point (the same point I reached with Sydney/Vaughn) just to see Olive get a happy ending.
I was not prepared for all my Jacksonville feelings. I squeed when Peter stroked her cheek and they almost kiss. And then when they both dress up for their "date." And Olivia fixing her hair in the mirror and smiling! AND THEN SHE SEES HIM GLIMMER AND I WAS NOT PREPARED. Actual full throttle, body bending NOOOOOOO. AND THE WAY SHE LOOKS AT WALTER AFTER.
AND THE "PLEASE DON'T TELL HIM." GAAAAAAH
So glad I restarted the show, I forgot how much I loved it.