Jump to content

Type keyword(s) to search

DEM

Member
  • Posts

    291
  • Joined

Posts posted by DEM

  1. On 9/1/2017 at 7:38 AM, MarylandGirl said:

    I agree that Ambrose should have had more of an explanation planned for how he found the body--I guess he must have suggested that Cora led him there, based on what the female officer said? But that suggests that Cora shared the location, when really Ambrose pieced it together from what she said during hypnosis--especially the bus part.

    I agree. I'm unclear about exactly how Ambrose found the bus because I thought he had some sort of epiphany well after the fact as he was on his hike, but regardless it was pretty gross how he made Cora take the fall for that. That's at least the third time he's done something like that to Cora. He claims to want to help her, but then he does things like interview the husband about "Cora's drug use" in a way that was apparently very specific rather than general/hypothetical (e.g., "Does she have a history of depression? Anxiety? Drug use? Been prescribed any medications?"), so Mason explodes and refuses to bring their son to visit the jail.

    Ambrose is slippery and disingenuous when he doesn't need to be, and Pullman's "private, dirty joke" acting doesn't help.

     

    On 9/1/2017 at 7:26 PM, Shellbell59 said:

    Mason=bad

    I wrote off Mason in ep1 when he didn't come to the police station or even call Cora. Then he did a 180 and berated Cora for wanting to plead guilty and lost even more points. He's so far in the hole now that he loses points simply for showing his face.

     

    On 8/31/2017 at 8:11 AM, DoubleUTeeEff said:

    The sister is something else. Whether she is with Cora or against her, I wonder what the motive for getting Cora in trouble with her parents was. She doesn't seem like the type to panic over nothing to me.

    I haven't watched ep6 yet, but it wouldn't surprise me to learn that Phoebe did that because she was angry that Cora didn't answer the phone and give her all the creepy, voyeuristic details RIGHT NOW, rather than true concern for her safety.

     

    On 8/31/2017 at 11:20 PM, thuganomics85 said:

    So, we're past the halfway point, so I should have known we would be getting a state detective to show up.  This is the time when someone else gets involved and causes a bunch of jurisdictional crap and issues with the "lead" detective.  And, of course, they're making her come off so obviously gung-ho that Cora is guilty, that she's going to look like an idiot when it is revealed she's innocent (err, for this murder at least.)

    Yeah, now the show is aware of jurisdiction, when just a couple of eps ago, Ambrose and novice officer who needs to learn how to use the block function on her phone showed up to arrest husband and JD in a town that was an hour away.

    So many of these characters are annoying me that I hope the bones are Phoebe's, and Cora's DNA is on the blanket because it came from the family home. That's unlikely given the proximity to Sketchy Club, but I can dream. And shouldn't the police be concerned with identifying THE ACTUAL BODY?

    • Love 2
  2. On 7/13/2017 at 2:20 PM, ElectricBoogaloo said:

    Casting for a Limited Series, Movie or Special  - David Rubin

    Contemporary Costumes for a Series, Limited Series or Movie - Alix Friedberg, Risa Garcia & Patricia McLaughlin

    Music Supervision - Susan Jacobs ("You Get What You Need")

    Congratulations to these winners (from the Creative Arts ceremony), esp. to Susan Jacobs for winning the first ever award for the new Music Supervision category!

    • Love 2
  3. On 8/28/2017 at 1:39 PM, Wouter said:

    The entire Zairon arc led to a moment where the remaining Ishida ships could make a difference. Without them, Six would probably not have made the attempt.

    I watched this ep again the other day and was astounded by how smoothly goo!Two manoeuvred everyone: Ishida, Mikkei, Android, Six...

    • Love 2
  4. 4 hours ago, MissLucas said:

    Reynaud is not Five's sister (we still haven't seen her) but her step-mother.

    Technically, she's simply the adoptive mother of Five's sister.

    4 hours ago, MissLucas said:

    But wasn't this the Double Deception already?

    Nope, per Mallozzi it will be big and clear when it happens.

     

    Hey, how's this for ironic foreshadowing?

    Quote

    3x03, Welcome to the Revolution

    SIX: This is an opportunity to to help, to do the right thing.
    TWO: And then what? Watch it blow up in our faces again? We make terrible heroes.

    • Love 3
  5. 3 hours ago, Clanstarling said:

    How many of the events in Future Five's list have we seen or at least been introduced to this season?

    Five of eight.

    3x11: The Dwarf Star Conspiracy
    Not Yet: The Double Deception
    3x13: Kryden
    Not Yet: Carina
    Not Yet: The Accelerated
    3x12: The Fall of the House of Ishida
    3x10: A meeting with [Android's] creator
    3x13: The Black Ships

    • Love 10
  6. I enjoyed this ep a lot!

    Kudos to VFX on the space battle and the opening of the portal.

    I liked that Ryo's Ishida story continues on. After last week, I was worried it would tied up in a neat bow (Big Overture, Little Show) and not have much lingering effect on his individual story or his relationship with the crew (as I felt Five's memory wipe sadly did after S1). But this ep showed that Ryo/Ishida will continue to be an issue. Also cool was the way it illuminated Teku's character and highlighted a somewhat hidden facet: Teku may be an honest, loyal fellow of great integrity, but the schoolteacher also possesses a spine of steel and a mind for strategy.

    I KNEW there was something wrong with Two when Six found her.  I practically cheered when Six questioned her, but even after she passed the test I was still unsettled. By the time I had accepted that, okay, maybe all was as it seemed, BOOM! ALIEN TWO! (I kinda wish the first reveal had been omitted.)

    This was a great ep for Two & for Melissa O'Neil. Everyone involved -- O'Neil, Mullie, and director Murphy -- hit the sweet spot with Two, particularly in her role as commander. O'Neil did a great job differentiating Two from both Portia and Alien Two while still showing that all 3 originated from the same "base" character.  And Two in the training room! And Two fulfilled her original design-purpose when we least expected it!! To be quite frank, Two vs. Alien Possession is 10,000 times more interesting to me than Two Has a Baby (??!).

    Actually, I'd extend that comment about sweet spots to all of the main characters. I knew and understood each of the characters, but also learned more about them.

    Delighted by the many surprises and, importantly, that they didn't feel hokey or forced or conveeenient. Closely related were the callbacks -- big and small, specific and thematic -- to earlier episodes. So much "Hey! Oooh!"

    Re: Six. Part of me believes that he will be okay, but another part recognises it could go either way. I don't want to lose Six.

    In closing (for now): Truffault. :-)

    • Love 8
  7. 25 minutes ago, Clanstarling said:

    I think Five's sister and Two's daughter could be the same kid - Five and/or her sibling could have been adopted by the original parents.

    I'm confused. What original parents? You're saying that Five's sister might not actually have been her biological sibling? Five and her sister were actually adoptees who were then orphaned and then Sis was adopted again?

    Per 3x02, Five's sister is older than she ("She was adopted when you were still a baby").  I don't have a freaking clue how old Two is supposed to be, but I doubt it's old enough that she could have produced a child at least 17 years prior to present day.

    • Love 1
  8. On 8/17/2017 at 0:18 PM, Wouter said:

    but not make a few tours of the entire lab to make sure she didn't miss anybody.

    from 2x09

    ERIC WAVER: When you broke free, you were brutally efficient. .... You killed them all. The research team, technicians, the security personnel, everyone on that station, except me.

    • Love 1
  9. On 8/14/2017 at 2:12 PM, Wouter said:

    I'm not sure if the Rebecca, as depicted in this episode (during her time with Shaw), had really gone over the edge in the way that Portia later did.

    I'm not sure I agree. I don't think it was absolutely necessary for Rebecca to kill every last thing that moved in order to escape Dwarf Star, and mass slaughter is generally, well, shocking.  She hadn't gone over the edge only in the sense that she went back to being not-homicidal for a while.

    For myself, for now, I think Portia is the story of how Rebecca got stuck in dark mode, rather than how she turned. In other words, Two is Rebecca's default personality (generally normal but capable of great violence) while Portia is Dark Mode.

    • Love 2
  10. 7 hours ago, Wouter said:

    This is assuming that this version of events is actually 100% true.

    As I was falling asleep last night I suddenly had the idea that whatever tipped Portia over the edge -- again -- had to do with Dr Shaw (a betrayal?).  Like you, I'm confused about Two's psychology. Every time I think I have a tentative handle on it and/or am prepared to "just go with it", new information wrecks my mental model.  I had accepted the idea that Rebecca's by turns sterile and abusive "upbringing" in a lab led straight to Portia. That made sense. However, it didn't explain how, even with a memory wipe, she'd turn into someone with a strong moral compass (and sometimes be compassionate to the point of tears). So, I'd chalked that part up to "a wizard did it": Rebecca's base design included fully mature personality and empathy and moral reasoning. Although that wouldn't leave as much to work with from a character development perspective, she could still be predisposed to psychopathy and violence when wronged, and it fit the data.

    But now Dr Shaw comes along and, although her existence shores up the empathy & adult relations bits, it re-opens the question of why Rebecca reverted to full-time psychopathy. We could surmise that the mere loss of Shaw turned Rebecca back because Rebecca's personality was always shaky, but I guess there's more to the story.

     

    7 hours ago, Wouter said:

    The one with Portia and Das stood out to me: there was already a lot of Two in her behaviour and mannerisms, which may indicate that Emily/Das/Five was a greater influence, than the mindwipe, in Portia becoming Two.

    If we accept that Rebecca always had the capability of being a nice person, then Das at best reminded her that not all humans are terrible, so Portia was nice in that moment. That leaves Two's agency as a character intact, and it doesn't further contort an already stretched timeline. I know Ryo said stuff in 2x12, but no, just no. (Plus, Ryo's next moves were back-to-back mass murders, so his words need a lot of salt.)

  11. 4 hours ago, Clanstarling said:

    Either way, it is nuclear energy which is released, which is I was talking about.

    OK, just go with Terrafamilia's analogy, which is exactly what I was trying to say, but TF was clearer.

    (Plus, all the hosts were fried so the aliens were SOL anyway.)

    • Love 2
  12. The ink aliens first appeared in 2x09 (Going Out Fighting) when the crew infiltrated the Dwarf Star labs on Earth in order to acquire new nanites for Two. Three and Six were captured, etc.

    Six is the worst undercover operative ever! By the 17th 'significant glance' at Two, I was questioning his every credential.

     

    1 hour ago, Clanstarling said:

    Is it just me, or wouldn't the nuke just feed the gateway, not destroy it? The gateway was feeding on the reactor, which isn't that different

    Hmm, I'm no nuclear physicist, but I'm pretty sure it is very different.  Think: nuclear power plant vs nuclear bomb (or even everyday nuclear power plant vs nuclear meltdown).

    • Love 7
  13. On 8/5/2017 at 7:57 AM, 2727 said:

    Closed captioning would have it be Suki but the syfy recaps say Sookie.

    And Zoie Palmer writes Sukie, so I guess that's the correct one? But I'm with you: I hope we don't have to learn it.

     

    1 hour ago, Paloma said:

    It was not clear to me when that scene took place

    We know the Portia-Das scene was pre-wipe because Android (and Two) had forgotten it! It's the activity that the alt-universe Android alluded to in 2x08 and which Two and Five discussed in 2x10. Five said, "It was you. You made her this way. You took an obsolete model with no empathy emulators or emotional subroutines, and you tried to make her more human."

    I found it very gratifying when Das called Android "just a machine" and Portia contradicted her.

    I don't know why the upgrades weren't done before Portia left Sanctuary, but if what Ryo said in 2x12 about finding Android on Lyra-9 was accurate, then perhaps there was a hitch and Portia and Android were separated for a time?

    • Love 5
  14. 3 hours ago, 2727 said:

    How is Victor able to unlock Android's memories, again?

    Good question. I went back and watched 2x04 (his intro ep), and there he ran a diagnostic and concluded that Android was different by design. It seems to me that there's much going on with Victor that he's hiding. It wouldn't surprise me to learn that he could unlock and/or already knew a lot more, but he's concealing it. The fact that he tried to convince Android that the Raza crew might have been lying about Android's memory wipe even though he KNOWS that the crew were themselves at a catastrophic cognitive loss tells me this dude is up to no good. He's probably a double agent!

    • Love 4
  15. Phew. In the thread for 3x07 I complained (yet again!) about the lack of tie-in between Two and The Android. Never would I have dreamt that we'd get a story like this one!  Dr Victor Frankenstein Irena Shaw created Rebecca, then Dwarf Star snatched Rebecca away and tortured her crazy, but Rebecca escaped and returned to Irena, only to find out Irena was dying so Irena made herself an android body (our Android!) but then decided not to use it, and eventually the lovers (which is kinda creepy if you think about it but okay) parted ways and Portia (née Rebecca) carted Android along with her in her murderous rampage across the galaxy.  Phew!

    Amazing.

    As is usual with Two and Android, however, they never got around to talking about themselves with one another.  Android had nice talks with Six and Three, but it remains to be seen whether Android and Two will ever talk about what they each learned independently about their pasts and what that means for them in the present. As lovely as it was for Six to assert that Android's provenance doesn't make her "lesser" in his eyes; the Irena-Suki comparison doesn't have the same relevance or emotional resonance to him as it would to Two.

    This disconnect is interesting. I mean, there have been hints since at least 1x02 (I think) that Android was connected to Two more so than to the ship, and although we've seen their bond over the series, they tend to keep each other at a certain distance. It's almost as if, despite all the memory wipes, they both know there are things they don't want to deal with.

    Turning to the Three/Sarah story: Nice payoff! I liked the way all these threads came together.  And despite my earlier desire for Sarah to be evil (heh), now I hope she never will be, and that she'll foil whatever nefarious plan Victor is plotting! That goes triple if he attempts to harm Dr Shaw (who also better not be evil). Gosh, I really don't like him.

    This ep clarified (again?) what I don't like about Five and why I don't find somewhat similar behaviours from Three off-putting.  Five is very black-and-white, about face without any self-reflection. Three can be selfish and bigoted, but he: 1) owns those attitudes and 2) when he changes his mind it's because he's thought about stuff and he doesn't try to justify the change with high-minded (but ultimately self-serving) rhetoric. Moreover, his crew mates don't gloss over his selfishness or try to make it noble.

    Finally: RYO!!  That flashback was a nice surprise!

    • Love 8
  16. 21 hours ago, LittleIggy said:

    Mia took the keys Adrian stupidly left sitting beside him on the bench.

    Gah, you can just SEE the writing, you know? So bad.

    Mia is now on my Misted List. I feel like I rate most of the characters according to who I want to least see die.

    • Love 1
  17. 21 hours ago, thuganomics85 said:

    Hmm, not the Two-centric episode I was hoping for

    You deceived me, thuganomics!  How could you?  That fight scene was great though, but the editing between parts 1 and 2 was strange. Two was down and Ryo pulled over a hook/chain and then we left them, but when we came back, Two popped up again -- offscreen. I would have to have seen her regain the upper hand.

    I want my favourite duo back together again. That Fall needs to happen soon so Ryo can come back to his senses.

     

    23 hours ago, Gillian Rosh said:

    Of course Five saved the day.

    Of course.  I did like that Two figured out all on her own that Android was the culprit.

    I'm conflicted about Sarah not being evil.  Heh.

    • Love 1
  18. 12 minutes ago, Wouter said:

    As for Two, IMO she does has a season-arc: her fight with Ryo will end on a personal note. The season started with Two declaring they will go after Ryo, it will likely end with a personal confrontation (and maybe a fight to the death - allthough other endings are possible too).

    Good point. Considering how much a like Two-Four as a duo, you'd think I'd be more attuned to this.  I guess it hasn't felt prominent enough lately?

    Ryo would be a dummy to push a fight to the death.  Two can survive the vacuum of space; he's not winning that game!

×
×
  • Create New...