mcnelisp

But Eugene was making bullets for a whole season or more. In fact they had an all out shoot -out with the Negan crew. After that apparently all was relatively quiet for years so they should still have had their remaining bullets...and plenty of time for Eugene to make more. I think the reason is if they had guns they would simply kill the whisperers quickly and the story line would be over.

If only they all still carried guns like they did for every season until now When did the world get so nice that nobody needs to carry a firearm any longer? Even teenagers and women can fire a gun...like we saw in the the previous seasons. Oh well...I guess I am asking for too much logic 🙂

good point. maybe they arrived well after Negan was finished (remember years have passed)...or they knew Negan and crew could take them out so they stayed hidden until the Negan/Rick thing finished. Either way I still don't understand why the characters don't carry guns any longer. I have no clue how all 10 were captured simultaneously but if they were all armed (LIKE THEY USED TO BE) things would have different.

Yeah same thing here. I know we have to suspend some belief in this show but they were able to round up these 10 people simultaneously? Huh? Also, where the hell is everyone's guns? Every season until now had armed combat all the time? The world has not changed...people still need their guns...but now they don't carry them any longer? If the 10 had their guns the outcome would be different. At least I think so since I still have no idea how they were captured.