The Best Supernatural Episode Tournament

[Wayward Son]

This is a game I was involved in on a different boards year ago. 

As the thread name suggests it's basically a tournament to see which episodes come out on top. 

We're going to be voting for our LEAST favorites, and instead of pitting every single episode of SN against each other at once we are going to do it by season. Then we shall let the winners of each season face each other, but that's not for awhile. One episode will be eliminated from each round and most rounds should last a week. 

PLEASE START BY NOMINATING YOUR FIVE LEAST FAVOURITE EPISODES OF SEASON ONE. 

SEASON ONE

Pilot 
Wendigo
Dead in the Water
Phantom Traveler 
Bloody Mary 
Skin
Hook Man 
Bugs 
Home 
Asylum 
Scarecrow 
Faith 
Route 666 
Nightmare 
The Benders 
Shadow 
Hell House

Something Wicked
Provenance 
Dead Man's Blood 
Salvation 
Devil's Trap 

Edited March 15, 2017 by Wayward Son

[Wayward Son]

My nominations are 

- The Wendigo

- Skin 

- Bugs

- Route 666

- The Benders

[Diane]

- Something Wicked
- Bloody Mary
- Hook Man
- Shadow
- Home

[Demented Daisy]

Isn't this just the survival game?  

4 hours ago, Wayward Son said:

One episode will be eliminated from each round and most rounds should last a week. 

So it could take months to determine the "best" of season 1?

[Wayward Son]

4 minutes ago, Demented Daisy said:

So it could take months to determine the "best" of season 1?

At the moment yes. Although I can shorten the deadline to 3 days or something similar if people want the pace to be quickened. It was just to make sure everyone who wants to be involved has an opportunity to post their votes. 

Edited March 15, 2017 by Wayward Son

[Meredith Quill]

Hi guys,

This seems like it's pretty much a dupe of the Survival Game? If someone can explain to us how it isn't we'd be happy to allow it, otherwise we'd prefer not to have 2 topics that appear so similar.