Hi! First time poster here ...
I was at the audition with JOSH! and ignoring my bias against him because he got the call and I didn't, I want to kinda defend him.
In the audition, he was the exact same as he was on the show. He was incredibly loud, he was the only male contestant wearing a golf shirt, and he was pretty obnoxious. He was also probably the least impressive player in the room, though he played quite well on the actual show so kudos to JOSH! for that.
Anyways, Maggie Speak, the main contestant coordinator, just ate it up. She loved him. She commented how he was the only one she has met that's even louder than she is. Since his loud, obnoxious, under-dressed shtick is what got him on the show, you really can't blame him for sticking with it. This one is on Maggie.