mauve

The mothman creature (Detour) Jenn (Je Souhaite) Ronnie Strickland (Bad Blood)

Tommy Conlon (Scary Monsters) Greg Pincus (Folie a Deux) Soul eater (The Gift)

Dr. Jack Preijers (Audrey Pauley) Soul eater (The Gift)l Oiver Martin (Sunshine Days) Erwin Lukesh (4-D) Reptile creature Herman Stites (Alone)

Maurice and Lyda (How the Ghosts Stole Christmas) and Felig in second place. Jenn (Je Souhaite) and the fear monster in second place. My number one for season 7 would actually have been Donnie Pfaster. Even though Orison is weaker that Irresistible, I still find him extremely creepy.

Underground fungus (Field Trip) Bernard Oates (Monday) Rob Roberts (Hungry) Max Harden (Rush) Full moon fear monster (X-Cops)

Wayne Weinsider (Terms of Endearment) Antenna emitting ELF waves (Drive) Underground fungus (Field Trip) Rob Roberts (Hungry) The Millennium Group (Millennium)

Sorry. Voted too fast as well. I'll wait for tomorrow.

I'm vacillating between John Lee Roche and Eddie Van Blundht, both extremely entertaining in their own way. I'm going to go with Roche for his intensity, psychopathy and believability. I find those kinds of villains all the more terrifying for their realism. My personal number three for season 4 would have been The Peacock family. They are just so disturbing and memorable. Ronnie Strickland is my favorite from season 5. My number two is the Mothman, though I find it more interesting in idea than in execution.

Overall, I love season 5 as well, queequeg. It's just that the monsters tend to be underwhelming. It just goes to prove that you can have an excellent episode in spite of a boring villain if the plot, structure and dialogues of the episode are good.

It's really interesting to see the inequality of the different seasons in terms of monsters. This game really brings it out. Season 4 had some really strong villains, but I couldn't care less about the vast majority of the villains from season 5. The same thing happened for me with season 2 and 3. Season 4 Bettie the Talking Tattoo through Ed Jerse (Never Again) Gerry Schnauz (Unruhe) Leonard Betts (Leonard Betts) Season 5 The AI (Kill Switch) Greg Pincus (Folie a Deux) Linda Bowman (Kitsunegari)

Season 4 Jason Nichols (Synchrony) Dr. Charles Goldstein (Demons) Nurse Innes (Elegy) Season 5 Aaron Starkey (All Souls) Charles Wesley Gotts (Mind’s Eye) Dr. Pollidori (Post-Modern Prometheus)

The Buente brothers/El Chupacabra (El Mundo Gira) Samuel Aboah (Teliko) Vernon Ephesian (The Field Where I Died)

Duane Barry Modell, followed by Terri and Margi (even though I don't think they are all that interesting). Makes you realized that season 3 had some really weak villains overall.

Season 2: Harry Cokely through BJ Morrow (Aubrey) Flukeworm (The Host) Leonard, the detachable conjoined twin (Humbug) Season 3: Virgil Incanto (2Shy) The bellhop, Puppet (Clyde Bruckman’s Final Repose) Special Agent Bill Patterson (Grotesque)

Sorry about the last round. I hadn't noticed Simon Gates was already gone. Season 2: Walter Chaco and the other townspeople of Dudley (Our Town) Harry Cokely through BJ Morrow (Aubrey) Dr. Banton (Soft Light) Season 3: Virgil Incanto (2Shy) Carl Wade (Oubliette) Darren Peter Oswald (D.P.O.)