Jump to content

Type keyword(s) to search

Hall Of Fame: Past Winners & 'Winners'


Recommended Posts

2017

Traditional "Good" Awards

  • Best Drama: Game of Thrones
  • Best Episode Of A Drama: This Is Us, “Memphis”
  • Best Performance In A Drama:  Tatiana Maslany, Orphan Black
  • Best Comedy: The Good Place
  • Best Episode Of A Comedy: The Good Place, "Michael’s Gambit"
  • Best Performance In A Comedy:  Andre Braugher, Brooklyn Nine-Nine
  • Best Reality Show: The Great British Bake Off
  • Best Episode Of A Reality Show: The Great British Bake Off/ Baking Show, "Episode 10 - The Final"
  • Best Dramedy: Feud: Bette & Joan
  • Best Talk Show: Last Week Tonight

 Traditional "Bad" Previously Awards

  • Worst Drama: Girls
  • Worst Episode Of A Drama: Once Upon a Time, "Wish You Were Here"
  • Worst Performance In A Drama: Katie Cassidy, Arrow
  • Worst Comedy: 2 Broke Girls
  • Worst Episode Of A Comedy: Imaginary Mary, "Pilot"
  • Worst Performance In A Comedy: Jenna Elfman, Imaginary Mary
  • Worst Reality Show: Keeping Up With The Kardashians
  • Worst Episode Of A Reality Show: Survivor, "What Happens On Exile, Stays On Exile"
  • Worst Dramedy: Gilmore Girls: A Year In The Life
  • Worst Talk Show: Dr. Phil

Non-Traditional "Good" Previously Awards

  • Best Animal Performance: Bear, Person of Interest
  • Best Back From the Dead Character: Jon Snow, Game of Thrones
  • Best Cliffhanger: The rebooted Good Place, The Good Place
  • Best Death Scene: Hodor, Game of Thrones
  • Best Hell Yeah! Moment: Sansa's final confrontation with Ramsay, Game of Thrones
  • Best Moment In A Comedy: The Good Place, The truth behind The Good Place is revealed
  • The Big Chill: Best Show To Binge Watch: Stranger Things
  • Best Musical Moment: iZombie, Rob Thomas performs and is eaten by zombies
  • Best Opening Credits/Theme Song: Game Of Thrones
  • That Guy Used to Suck: Best Character Redemption Arc: Sansa Stark, Game of Thrones
  • Best Villain: Cersei Lannister, Game of Thrones
  • Most Meta, Meta Moment: Supergirl, Cat Grant (Calista Flockhart, Harrison Ford's wife) says she never saw "Star Wars”
  • Funniest Moment In A Drama: Orphan Black, Krystal meets her clone-sister Sarah for the 1st time, sees no resemblance whatsoever
  • Most Dramatic Moment In A Comedy: Brooklyn Nine-Nine, Terry gets racially profiled
  • Best Season/Series Finale: Game Of Thrones
  • Character You Would Most Want As Your BFF: Terry Jeffords, Brooklyn Nine-Nine
  • Best Moment In A Drama: This is Us "Just breathe...."
  • Best Moment In A Reality Show: Leah Remini: Scientology and the Aftermath, Aaron Smith-Levin explains how his Scientologist neighbor cut off his entire family, but wouldn't disconnect from his dog
  • Best Season-Long Mindfuck: The Good Place
  • Best, or Most Shippable, Couple: This Is Us, Beth and Randall Pearson
  • Best Badass: Leah Remini, Leah Remini: Scientology and the Aftermath
  • Best Animated Show: Bob's Burgers
  • Biggest Holy Shit! Moment: The Oscars, La La Land Wins Best Picture... Oops! Our bad! Moonlight Wins Best Picture
  • "This Show Used To Suck!": Best TV Series Comeback: Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.
  • Best Performance By An Inanimate Object: The Christmas Light Wall, Stranger Things
  • Most Gratuitous Fanservice: This Is Us, Milo Ventimiglia's ass

Non-Traditional "Bad" Awards

  • Least Entertaining Villain: Negan, The Walking Dead
  • "Idiot Stick" Award for Dumbest Character Moment: Once Upon A Time, Belle repeatedly defends, goes back to, and/or stays with Rumplestiltskin
  • Couple With The Least Chemistry: Grey's Anatomy, Arizona Robbins and Eliza Minnick
  • Most Anticipated New Show That Failed Miserably: Gilmore Girls: A Year In The Life
  • The "Why Isn't He/She In Jail For This?" Suspension Of Disbelief Award: Scandal, All of it
  • The Cerulean Sphere Award For Storyline With Most Wasted Potential: Game of Thrones, Watching Margaery Tyrell out-play the High Sparrow all season for nothing
  • Worst Couple: Once Upon a Time, Rumplestiltskin and Belle
  • Worst Moment In A Drama: The Walking Dead, Negan beating Glenn and Abe to death with a baseball bat
  • Worst So-Called Badass: Negan, The Walking Dead
  • Most Unwelcome (or Unwanted) Comeback/Reboot; The "Mostly Come Back At Night, Mostly" Award: Dirty Dancing
  • Worst Moment In A Reality Show: Survivor, Jeff outs Zeke as transgender
  • Pierce Of The Year: Robin McGraw, The Dr. Phil Show
  • Most Unintentionally Funny Line: RuPaul's Drag Race, "I feel like I have to prove that I have a talent that I might not know that I might have. But I hope I do." Valentina
  • Show You Most Enjoy Hate Watching: America's Next Top Model
  • Most Painful Cancellation/Series Ending: The Nightly Show with Larry Wilmore
  • Show That Still Airs Long Past Its Expiration Date: Keeping Up With The Kardashians
  • Worst Use Of A Wig: Lizzie, The Blacklist
  • Worst Death Scene: Glenn and Abraham, The Walking Dead
  • Worst Moment In A Comedy: The Big Bang Theory, Penny's family was boring
  • Most Obnoxious Product Placement: Black-ish, Walt Disney World
  • Most Inept Villain: Maurice LeFay, Fargo

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

2018

Traditional Awards

The Best

  • Best Animated Show - Bob's Burgers
  • Best Drama - Game of Thrones
  • Best Comedy - The Good Place
  • Best Competitive Reality Show - The Great British Baking Show
  • Best Non-Competitive Reality Show - Anthony Bourdain: Parts Unknown
  • Best SciFi/Supernatural Show - Stranger Things
  • Best Episode Of A Drama - Game of Thrones: "The Dragon and the Wolf"
  • Best Episode Of A Comedy - The Good Place: "The Trolley Problem"
  • Best Episode Of A Competitive Reality Show - The Great Canadian Baking Show: "Canadian"
  • Best Episode of a Non-Competitive Reality Show - Leah Remini: Scientology and the Aftermath: "The Rise of David Miscaviage"
  • Best Episode of a SciFi/Supernatural Show - Black Mirror: "USS Callister"
  • Best Talk Show - Last Week Tonight with John Oliver
  • Best Writing - The Good Place
  • Best Cinematography - The Crown
  • Best Set Design - The Good Place
  • Best Costuming - The Crown
  • Best CGI - Game of Thrones
  • Best Stunt - Game of Thrones: Dany's dragonfall, and later the dragon melting the wall.

The Worst

  • Worst Animated Show - Family Guy
  • Worst Comedy - Roseanne
  • Worst Competitive Reality Show - The Bachelor
  • Worst Drama - Wisdom of the Crowd
  • Worst Non-Competitive Reality Show - Mama June: From Not to Hot
  • Worst SciFi/Supernatural Show - Marvel's Inhumans
  • Worst Talk Show - Megyn Kelly Today
  • Worst Writing - Once Upon a Time
  • Worst CGI - Marvel's Inhumans
  • Most Obvious Stunt Work - Marvel's Inhumans
  • Worst Episode of a SciFi/Supernatural Show - Stranger Things: "Chapter Seven: The Lost Sister"
  • Worst Episode Of A Comedy - 9JKL: "Pilot"
  • Worst Episode Of A Drama - Scandal: "Standing in the Sun"
  • Worst Episode of a Competitive Reality Show - Big Brother: the episode where Paul gets 3 weeks of safety
  • Worst Episode Of A Non-Competitive Reality Show - Sister Wives: "PolygaMexacamist Wedding"

Non-Traditional Awards

The Good 

  • Favorite TV Moment Of The Year - Game of Thrones: "Tell Cersei it was me."
  • Favorite New Show Of The Season - Killing Eve
  • Now I Can Die Happy: Most Satisfying Death Scene - Game of Thrones: Winter came for House Frey
  • LMFAO: Funniest Scene From A Comedy - Brooklyn Nine-Nine: The "I Want It That Way" musical police lineup
  • Did That Just Happen?!: Biggest 'What The Actual Fuck' Moment From A Drama - Game of Thrones: The Night King taking down Viserion with an ice spear
  • You Couldn’t Make This Shit Up!!: Most Batshit Insane Moment From A Reality Show - The Bachelor: Arie breaks up with Becca after picking her.
  • Life On The Edge: Biggest Cliffhanger - Game of Thrones: The Wall falls
  • That Guy Used to Suck: Favorite Character Redemption Arc - The Good Place: Michael
  • Name That Tune: Favorite Opening Credits/ Theme Song - Game of Thrones
  • The Big Chill: Favorite Binge-Watch - Stranger Things
  • Badassiest Badass: Ain’t Got Time To Bleed - Scientology and the Aftermath: Leah Remini
  • We Heart Bad Boys: Favorite Villain - Game of Thrones: Cersei
  • We Go Together: Favorite Couple Or Ship - Brooklyn Nine-Nine: Jake and Amy
  • Will You Be My BFF?: Favorite Secondary Character - The Good Place: Janet
  • More Than Just A Prop: Favorite Performance By An Inanimate Object - The Good Place: The Trolley
  • Who’s A Good Boy: Favorite Performance By A Real Animal - Brooklyn Nine-Nine: Cheddar
  • No Fleas On Them!: Favorite CGI Animal - Game of Thrones: Drogon
  • “This Show Used To Suck”: Favorite TV Series Comeback - Legends of Tomorrow
  • Be Careful What You Wish For: Most Gratuitous Fanservice - Game of Thrones: Jon Snow and Daenereys Targaryen have sex
  • Was It Good For You Too?: Favorite Season/Series Finale - Game of Thrones: "The Dragon and the Wolf"
  • Now I Have An Ice Cream Headache: Biggest Season-Long Mindfuck - The Walking Dead: Keeping Negan alive
  • BFFs Forever!: Favorite Friendship - The Good Place: Eleanor and Michael

The Bad

  • Least Favorite TV Moment Of The Year - Real Time with Bill Maher: Bill Maher refers to himself as a "house n****r"
  • This Nearly Killed Me: Saddest Death Scene - TIE - Game of Thrones: Viserion AND Stranger Things: Bob
  • Weird Science: Most Unbelievable Or Impossible “Scientific” Explanation - The Walking Dead: Zombie guts can suddenly be weaponized to create zombies
  • The Cerulean Sphere Award: Biggest Plot Point Letdown - The Walking Dead: You can become a walker simply by getting walker blood in an open cut or wound even though this has happened to the main characters literally dozens of times before and never caused them to turn
  • Not You Again: Least Entertaining Villain - The Walking Dead: Negan
  • Breaking Up Is Hard To Do: Couple You Wish Would Call It Quits - Grey's Anatomy: Jackson and Maggie
  • The Pierce Of The Year: Most Disposable Character - Roseanne: Roseanne
  • Long in the Tooth: Show That Still Airs Long Past Its Expiration Date - Grey's Anatomy
  • I Just Can’t Quit You: Favorite Show To Hate Watch - Big Brother
  • That Hurts: Most Painful Cancellation - Brooklyn Nine-Nine
  • They Mostly Come Back At Night, Mostly Award: Most Unwelcome Comeback Or Reboot - Roseanne
  • Idiot Stick: Dumbest Character Moment - The Walking Dead: Rick doesn't kill Negan in the season finale and instead "jails" him
  • What A Let Down: Anticipated New Show That Failed Miserably - Marvel's Inhumans
  • My Eyes! My Eyes!: Scene or Image From A TV Show That You Wish You Could Unsee - Game of Thrones: Sam peeling Jorah Mormont's greyscale/skin off
  • Seen But Not Heard: Child Character You Never Want To Hear From Again - Modern Family: Manny
  • Thanks For Letting Me Know You're Supposed To Be Hedy Lamarr: Casting Failure Of Someone As A Historical Figure  - The Crown: Michael C. Hall as John F. Kennedy

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

2019

Awards

The Best

  • Best Writing
    • WINNER: The Good Place
    • Runner-Up: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver
  • Best Set Design
    • WINNER: Game of Thrones
    • Runner-Up: The Good Place
  • Favourite Comedy Show
    • WINNER: The Good Place
    • Runner-Up: The Big Bang Theory
  • Favourite Genre Show
    • WINNER: Lucifer
    • Runner-Up: Doctor Who 
  • Favourite Reality/Non-Fiction Show
    • WINNER: The Great British Bake-Off
    • Runner-Up: Leah Remini: Scientology & The Aftermath
  • Favourite Animated Show
    • WINNER: Bob's Burgers
    • Runner-Up: DuckTales
  • Favourite Drama Show
    • WINNER: Chernobyl
    • Runner-Up: Killing Eve

The Worst

  • The Poo-Litzer Prize: Worst Writing
    • WINNER: Game of Thrones
    • Runner-Up: Riverdale
  • Stab Myself in the Eye With a Fork: Worst Reality Person on TV
    • WINNER: Whitney Way Thore (My Big Fat Fabulous Life)
    • Runner-Up: Kayne West (Keeping Up With the Kardashians) and Jenny McCarthy (The Masked Singer) (TIE)
  • Let the Hate Flow Through You: Worst Show on the Air
    • WINNER: Keeping Up With The Kardashians
    • Runner-Up: Mama June: From Not to Hot
  • What Dafuq Just Happened?!: Worst Payoff To An Ongoing Storyline
    • WINNER: Bran the Broken is crowned "most interesting," and therefore King (Game of Thrones)
    • Runner-Up: Jon's Targaryen background amounted to nothing (Game of Thrones)

The Good

  • The Leading Leading Players: Favourite Actor/Actress
    • WINNER: Kristen Bell (The Good Place)
    • Runner-Up: Peter Dinklage (Game of Thrones)
  • Who’s a Good Boy: Favourite Performance By a Real Animal
    • WINNER: Cheddar (Brooklyn Nine Nine)
    • Runner-Up: Clyde (Elementary)
  • No Fleas on Them!: Favourite CGI Animal
    • WINNER: Ghost (Game of Thrones)
    • Runner-Up: Drogon (Game of Thrones)
  • We Heart Bad Boys: Favourite Villain 
    • WINNER: Villanelle (Killing Eve)
    • Runner-Up: Mrs Wardwell (Chilling Adventures of Sabrina)
  • That Guy Used to Suck: Favourite Character Redemption Arc
    • WINNER: Theon Greyjoy (Game of Thrones)
    • Runner-Up: Sandor "The Hound" Clegane (Game of Thrones)
  • You Like me, You Real-ly Like Me: Favourite Reality Personality
    • WINNER: Leah Remini (Leah Remini: Scientology & The Aftermath)
    • Runner-Up: Christian Siriano (Project Runway)
  • Big D (or V) Energy: Badassiest Badass
    • WINNER: Arya Stark (Game of Thrones)
    • Runner-Up: Villanelle (Killing Eve)
  • The Other Guys: Favourite Secondary Character
    • WINNER: Janet (The Good Place)
    • Runner-Up: Raymond Holt (Brooklyn Nine Nine)
  • The Strong Silent Type: Favourite Performance By An Inanimate Object
    • WINNER: The Starbucks Cup (Game of Thrones)
    • Runner-Up: The Elevator (Big Bang Theory)
  • I’m So Happy They’re Going To Have All the Sex: Favourite Couple or Ship
    • WINNER: Jake and Amy (Brooklyn Nine Nine)
    • Runner-Up: Eleanor and Chidi (The Good Place)
  • BFFs Forever: Favourite Friendship
    • WINNER: Michael and Janet (The Good Place)
    • Runner-Up: Penny and Sheldon (The Big Bang Theory)
  • This Show Used To Suck: Favourite TV Series Comeback
    • WINNER: Lucifer
    • Runner-Up: Star Trek: Discovery
  • The Big Chill: Favorite Binge-Watch 
    • WINNER: Lucifer
    • Runner-Up: Killing Eve
  • The Reason I Haven't Returned Your Calls: Favourite New Show of the Year
    • WINNER: The Kids Are Alright
    • Runner-Up: Chernobyl
  • Life On The Edge: Biggest Cliffhanger
    • WINNER: Drogon flies off with Dany's body... to where? (Game of Thrones)
    • Runner-Up: Lucifer returns to Hell (Lucifer)
  • Hell Yes!: Favourite TV Show Moment of The Year
    • WINNER: Brienne is made a Knight of the Seven Kingdoms (Game of Thrones)
    • Runner-Up: Leslie Jones' "Weekend Update" commentary (Saturday Night Live)
  • You Couldn’t Make This Shit Up!!: Most Batshit Insane Moment from a Reality Show
    • WINNER: Tiffany, who weighs 671 pounds, explains that she primarily eats grapes, yogurt and crackers (My 600 Lb Life)
    • Runner-Up: Edge of Extinction Contestant who only played 13 days out of a total 39 wins the $1 million prize (Survivor)
  • LMFAO: Funniest Scene from a Comedy
    • WINNER: The Kavanaugh Hearing (Saturday Night Live)
    • Runner-Up: Chidi has an existential crisis that culminates in him making chili with Peeps and M&Ms in front of his class (The Good Place)
  • Now I Can Die Happy: Most Satisfying Death Scene
    • WINNER: The Night King (Game of Thrones)
    • Runner-Up: Theon Greyjoy (Game of Thrones)
  • Happy Endings (Not that kind, pervert): Favourite Season/Series Finale
    • WINNER: The Big Bang Theory
    • Runner-Up: Russian Doll 
  • Name That Tune: Favourite Opening Credits/Theme Song
    • WINNER: Game of Thrones
    • Runner-Up: Last Week Tonight With John Oliver
  • Get Your GOAT: Favourite Show of All Time
    • WINNER: Buffy the Vampire Slayer
    • Runner-Up: The Golden Girls
  • Oldie but a Goodie (or Bestie Even): Favourite Show that no longer airs
    • WINNER: Buffy the Vampire Slayer
    • Runners-Up: Breaking Bad, Leverage, The West Wing (TIE)

The Bad

  • Back! Show! Killer!: Least Favourite Actor
    • WINNER: Michael Weatherly (Bull)
    • Runner-Up: Jussie Smollett (Empire)
  • Breaking Up Is Hard To Do!: Couple You Wish Would Call It Quits 
    • WINNER: Jaime and Cersei Lannister (Game of Thrones)
    • Runner-Up: Kate and Toby (This is Us)
  • Useless Twit: Most Disposable Character 
    • WINNER: Euron Greyjoy (Game of Thrones)
    • Runner-Up: Gina (Brooklyn Nine-Nine)
  • Please Die in the Season Finale: Least Entertaining Villain
    • WINNER: Euron Greyjoy (Game of Thrones)
    • Runner-Up: Negan (The Walking Dead)
  • Be Careful What You Wish For: Most Gratuitous Fanservice 
    • WINNER: Jon Snow rides a dragon (Game of Thrones)
    • Runner-Up: When Sheldon realizes he has no friends, the end scene shows what his future friends from Big Bang Theory are doing as children (Young Sheldon)
  • What Kind of Mushrooms Were Those Anyway?: Biggest Season-long Mindfuck
    • WINNER: Bran, who, despite having psychic abilities, not only letting them go to waste, he becomes King, despite doing nothing to earn it (Game of Thrones)
    • Runner-Up: Dany, who once imprisoned her dragons for accidentally killing a child, deliberately kills thousands of innocent people, including children (Game of Thrones)
  • Fuck This!: Least Favourite TV Show Moment of The Year
    • WINNER: Daenerys burns King's Landing (Game of Thrones)
    • Runner-Up: Quentin dies a cruel and pointless death negating his whole character arc (The Magicians)
  • This Nearly Killed Me: Saddest Death Scene
    • WINNER: Lyanna Mormont (Game of Thrones)
    • Runner-Up: Rhaegal (Game of Thrones)
  • Did That Just Happen?!: Biggest What the Actual Fuck Moment from a Drama
    • WINNER: Nicky Pearson is still alive and living in Pennsylvania (This is Us)
    • Runner-Up: Villanelle throws Amber's social worker under the bus/truck (Killing Eve)
  • How Stuff (Doesn’t) Work: Most Unbelievable or Impossible “Scientific” Explanation
    • WINNER: Sheldon & Amy win Nobel Prize for (something???) less than a year after "scientific" discovery (The Big Bang Theory)
    • Runner-Up: Euron Greyjoy firing massive bolts from a ballista on moving platform and hitting a moving target miles up in the sky three times in quick succession (Game of Thrones)
  • You’ve Got to be Fucking Kidding Me: Biggest Plot Point Letdown
    • WINNER: Jon's meaningless Targaryen background (Game of Thrones)
    • Runner-Up: Bran's Three Eyed Raven powers doing nothing of significance (Game of Thrones)
  • Idiot Stick: Dumbest Character Moment 
    • WINNER: Jamie goes back to Cersei despite knowing that she wants him & Tyrion dead, and despite Brienne begging him to stay, only to end up dying with Cersei anyway (Game of Thrones)
    • Runner-Up: Maggie has a plan to kill Negan, goes to kill Negan, is willing to fight Michonne to kill Negan, then lets Negan live because he's sad? (The Walking Dead)
  • That Hurts: Most Painful Cancellation 
    • WINNER: The Kids Are Alright
    • Runner-Up: One Day At A Time
  • Long in the Tooth: Show That Still Airs Long Past Its Expiration Date
    • WINNER: Law & Order: SVU
    • Runner-Up: Grey's Anatomy
  • Talk About An Anti-Climax: Anticipated New Show That Failed Miserably
    • WINNER: Murphy Brown
    • Runner-Up: Manifest
  • They Mostly Come Back At Night, Mostly Award: Most Unwelcome Show Revival or Reboot
    • WINNER: Last Man Standing
    • Runner-Up: American Idol
  • I Just Can’t Quit You: Favorite Show to Hate Watch
    • WINNERS: My 600 lb Life and The Walking Dead (TIE)
    • Runner-Up: This is Us

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

2020

The Best

  • Best Drama
    • WINNER: The Mandalorian
    • Runnerup: The Crown
  • Best Comedy
    • WINNER: The Good Place
    • Runnerup: Brooklyn Nine Nine
  • Best Reality Show
    • WINNER: The Great British Bake Off
    • Runnerup: Top Chef
  • Best Episode of a Drama
    • WINNER: The Crown - “Aberfan”
    • Runnnerup: Zoey’s Extraordinary Playlist - “Zoey’s Extraordinary Dad”
  • Best Episode of a Comedy
    • WINNER: The Good Place - “Whenever You’re Ready”
    • Runnerup: Schitt’s Creek - “Happy Ending”
  • Best Animated Show
    • WINNER: Bob’s Burgers
    • Runnerup: Star Wars: The Clone Wars
  • Best Talk Show
    • WINNER: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver 
    • Runnerup: Late Show with Stephen Colbert
  • Best Writing
    • WINNER: The Good Place
    • Runnerup: The Crown
  • Best Stunt
    • WINNER: Brooklyn Nine Nine - Captain Holt fights Cheddar’s dognapper
    • Runnerup: Legends of Tomorrow - The fight scene with improvised “weapons” (like the Flowbee and Shake Weights) set to Sisqo’s “Thong Song”

The Worst

  • Worst Drama
    • WINNER: Grey’s Anatomy
    • Runnerup: Law & Order: SVU
  • Worst Comedy
    • WINNER: Last Man Standing
    • Runnerup: Will & Grace
  • Worst Reality Show
    • WINNER: Keeping Up with the Kardashians
    • Runnerup: Mama June: From Hot to Not
  • Worst Episode of a Drama
    • WINNER: Grey’s Anatomy - “Leave a Light On”
    • Runnerup: The Good Doctor - “I Love You”
  • Worst Episode of a Comedy
    • WINNER: Will & Grace - “What a Dump”
    • Runnerup (three way tie): The Good Place - “Whenever You’re Ready,” Indebted - “Everybody’s Talking about a Web of Lies,” Sunnyside - “Dr. Potato”
  • Worst Episode of a Reality Show
    • WINNER: The Masked Singer - “Masking for a Friend: Week 33” (Chaka Khan is voted out)
    • Runnerup: My Big Fat Fabulous Life - “The Engagement Party”
  • Worst Animated Show
    • WINNER: Family Guy
    • Runnerup: South Park
  • Worst Talk Show
    • WINNER: The View
    • Runnerup: The Wendy Williams Show
  • Worst Writing
    • WINNER: Riverdale
    • Runnerup: Grey’s Anatomy

Non-Traditional: The Good

  • Yasssss!: Favorite TV Moment Of The Year
    • WINNER: The Mandalorian - Baby Yoda is revealed
    • Runnerup: The Good Place - Chidi's wave speech
  • Aww Yissss: Favorite New Show Of The Season
    • WINNER: The Mandalorian
    • Runnerup: Zoey’s Extraordinary Playlist
  • LMAO: Funniest Scene from a Comedy
    • WINNER: Brooklyn Nine Nine - Holt and Terry dancing to 'Push It' while Amy is in labor
    • Runnerup: Schitt's Creek - Moira's movie premiere of "The Crows Have Eyes 3" ends in a crow attack
  • Did That Just Happen?!: Biggest What the Actual Fuck Moment from a Scripted Show
    • WINNER: Grey's Anatomy - Alex Karev returns to Izzy offscreen and breaks up with Jo in a letter
    • Runnerup: This is Us - Randall used the fact that his mother Rebecca kept knowledge of his biological father a secret to guilt trip her into a Alzheimer’s drug trial she said she wasn’t going to do, and THEN let the other siblings believe it was all her idea
  • You Couldn’t Make This Shit Up!!: Most Batshit Insane Moment from a Reality Show 
    • WINNER: The Masked Singer - Rob Gronkowski beats Chaka Khan to make it to the Final Nine
    • Runnerup: Tiger King - Travis Maldonado's accidental suicide/Josh Dial's reaction
  • Life On The Edge: Biggest Cliffhanger
    • WINNER: This Is Us: The aftermath of Kevin’s and Randall’s brutal verbal confrontation
    • Runnerup: Watchmen: As Angela's foot hovers over the pool we are left to wonder if she did indeed inherit Dr. Manhattan's powers and thus can walk on water
  • That Guy Used to Suck: Favorite Character Redemption Arc
    • WINNER: What We Do in the Shadows - Colin Robinson
    • Runnerup: Supergirl - Lena Luthor
  • Name That Tune: Favorite Opening Credits/ Theme Song 
    • WINNER: The Great British Bake Off
    • Runnerup: What We Do in the Shadows
  • Music to My Ears: Favorite Musical Moment
    • WINNER: Saturday Night Live - David Byrne performs "Once In A Lifetime"
    • Runnerup: Zoey's Extraordinary Playlist - "American Pie"
  • The Big Chill:  Favorite Binge-Watch
    • WINNER: The Great British Bake Off
    • Runnerup: Schitt’s Creek
  • Asskicker: Favorite Badass 
    • WINNER: The Good Place - Janet
    • Runnerup: Watchmen - Angela Abar
  • We Heart Bad Boys: Favorite Villain
    • WINNER: The Good Place - Shawn
    • Runnerup: Killing Eve – Villanelle
  • We Go Together: Favorite Couple or Ship
    • WINNER: The Good Place - Eleanor and Chidi
    • Runnerup: Brooklyn Nine Nine - Captain Holt and Kevin
  • Will You Be My BFF?: Favorite Secondary Character
    • WINNER: The Good Place - Janet
    • Runnerup: This Is Us - Beth
  • More than Just a Prop: Favorite Performance By An Inanimate Object
    • WINNER: Schitt's Creek - Moira Rose's wigs
    • Runnerup: Stumptown - Dex's cassette tape
  • Who’s a Good Boy!: Favorite Performance By a Live Animal
    • WINNER: Brooklyn Nine Nine - Cheddar (he's won three years in a row)
    • Runnerup: Elementary - Clyde 
  • Be Careful What You Wish For: Most Gratuitous Fanservice
    • WINNER: Veronica Mars - Jason Dohring gets shirtless almost immediately
    • Runnerup (tie): Arrow - The Flash (Grant Gustin) meets The Flash (Ezra Miller), Star Trek: Picard - Riker shows up with a fleet of starships
  • Fuck, That Was Amazing!: Favorite Season/Series Finale
    • WINNER: The Good Place
    • Runnerup: Schitt’s Creek
  • Head Rekt: Best Season-long Mindfuckery
    • WINNER: Prodigal Son - Ainsley turns out to be Martin's prodigal child, not Malcolm
    • Runnerup (tie): Watchmen - The White Night and Dr. Manhattan's plan, You - Love Quinn is not like Joe's other victims
  • Favorite Archived/Current Show COVID Has Led You To Bingeing On (Member Category Winner)
    • WINNER: The Great British Bake Off
    • Runnerup (tie): Golden Girls, Tiger King
  • GOAT: Greatest Show of All Time
    • WINNER: Golden Girls
    • Runnerup: M*A*S*H

Non-Traditional - The Bad

  • I Reject This: Least Favorite TV Moment of the Year
    • WINNER: Veronica Mars - Logan dies pointlessly in a car bomb in the last minutes of the last episode minutes after marrying Veronica
    • Runnerup: Survivor - Missy & Elizabeth bond with Kellee over Dan’s sexual misconduct to her face, but later confess that they didn’t feel it was a big deal and lied to gain Kellee’s trust for the upcoming vote
  • That Nearly Killed Me: Saddest Death Scene 
    • WINNER: The Good Place - Eleanor, Chidi and Jason walking through "The Door" and turning into sprinkles of light
    • Runnerup: Riverdale - Fred Andrews
  • Weird Science: Most *‘Umm, What Now?’ Side-Eye Explanation of Tech/Science 
    • WINNER: Grey's Anatomy - Richard's dementia is due to cobalt poisoning from a hip prothesis which has turned to complete mush while not impairing at all his ability to walk
    • Runnerup: Watchmen - Angela is hooked up to an elephant that serves as a "neumo-dialysis" treatment because she took a drug called Nostalgia that caused a "recollective infestation" of someone else's memories into her mind. This treatment flushes out the foreign memories and allows her own memories to flood back as these invaders clear out
  • You’ve Got to be Fucking Kidding Me: Biggest Plot Point Letdown
    • WINNER: Grey's Anatomy - Alex Karev returns to Izzy and breaks up with Jo in a letter
    • Runnerup: The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel - Rose & Abe Weissman go broke and move in with the Maisels after Abe gets fired from Bell Labs, then quits his tenured professorship at Columbia (thereby also losing their apartment) and Rose willingly relinquishes her family's trust money
  • Not You Again: Least Entertaining Villain 
    • WINNER: Walking Dead - Negan
    • Runnerup: Survivor - Boston Rob Mariano
  • Breaking Up Is Hard To Do!: Couple You Wish Would Call It Quits
    • WINNER: The Good Doctor - Shaun and Lea
    • Runnerup: This Is Us - Kate and Toby
  • The Pierce Of The Year: Dispensable Character Who Could Vanish And No-one Would Notice
    • WINNER: Star Trek: Picard - Narek and his incest sister
    • Runnerup: Grey's Anatomy - Glasses (Levi)
  • Long in the Tooth: Show That Still Airs Long Past Its Expiration Date
    • WINNER: Grey’s Anatomy
    • Runnerup: Law & Order: SVU
  • I Just Can’t Quit You: Favorite Show to Hate Watch
    • WINNER: 90 Day Fiancé
    • Runnerup: Big Brother
  • Ow, That Hurt: Most Painful Cancellation
    • WINNER: God Friended Me
    • Runnerup (tie): Emergence, Single Parents
  • They Mostly Come Back At Night, Mostly Award: Most Unwelcome Comeback or Reboot 
    • WINNER: Mad About You
    • Runnerup: BH 90210
  • Idiot Stick: Dumbest Character Moment
    • WINNER: Veronica Mars - Veronica, a skilled investigator, fails to notice that the bomber has left a suspicious-looking knapsack in her car, even though he does it right in front of her
    • Runnerup: The Flash - Barry doesn't realize for months that his wife was replaced by a duplicate from the mirror dimension
  • That Anticlimax Tho: Anticipated New Show That Failed Miserably
    • WINNER: Carol’s Second Act
    • Runnerup: Nancy Drew

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  • Love 1
Link to comment

2021

The Best

  • Best Drama
    • Winner: The Queen's Gambit
    • Runner up: Mare of Easttown
  • Best Comedy
    • Winner: Ted Lasso
    • Runner up: Superstore
  • Best Genre Show
    • Winner: WandaVision
    • Runner up: The Mandalorian
  • Best Reality Show (EXACT SAME RESULTS AS LAST YEAR)
    • Winner: The Great British Bake Off
    • Runner up: Top Chef
  • Best Animated Show
    • Winner: Bob's Burgers
    • Runner up: Ducktales
  • Best Talk Show (EXACT SAME RESULTS AS LAST YEAR)
    • Winner: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver
    • Runner up: The Late Show with Stephen Colbert
  • Best Writing
    • Winner: The Queen's Gambit
    • Runner up: WandaVision
  • Best Stunt
    • Winner: The Mandalorian - Luke Skywalker vs. the Death Troopers
    • Runner up: 9-1-1 - Launching the bus off the overpass and into the 12th floor of an office building

The Worst

  • Worst Drama
    • Winner: Bull
    • Runner up: Grey's Anatomy
  • Worst Comedy
    • Winner: Last Man Standing
    • Runner up: Emily in Paris
  • Worst Genre Show
    • Winner: Batwoman
    • Runner up: The Walking Dead
  • Worst Reality Show (EXACT SAME RESULTS AS LAST YEAR)
    • Winner: Keeping up with the Kardashians
    • Runner up: Mama June: Road to Redemption
  • Worst Animated Show 
    • Winner: Family Guy
    • Runner up: American Dad
  • Worst Talk Show
    • Winner: Dr. Phil
    • Runner up: The Dr. Oz Show
  • Worst Writing
    • Winner: Bull
    • Runner up: New Amsterdam

The Good

  • Aw Yessss!: Favorite TV Moment Of The Year
    • Winner: The Mandalorian - Luke Skywalker's comeback
    • Runner up: WandaVision - Wanda becomes The Scarlet Witch
  • My New Happy Place: Favorite New Show Of The Season
    • Winner: WandaVision
    • Runner up: Bridgerton
  • LMFAO: Funniest Scene From A Scripted Show
    • Winner: The Falcon and the Winter Soldier - Sam and Bucky are forced to attend couples therapy
    • Runner up: Mare of Easttown - Mister Carroll reveals that he had an affair with Mare's mother, Helen, after the funeral of his wife
  • Did That Just Happen?!: Biggest What The Actual Fuck Moment From A Scripted Show
    • Winner: The Crown - Charles lashing out at Diana for hugging a child with AIDS and accusing her of making his mistress feel bad
    • Runner up: Big Sky - Cody Hoyt, the presumed leading man played by Ryan Phillippe, getting shot in the head in the show's debut episode
  • You Couldn’t Make This Shit Up!!: Most Batshit Insane Moment From A Reality Show
    • Winner: The Bachelorette - Clare Crowley decides after night 1 that Dale is her man and she will not entertain anyone else so she quits mid-season
    • Runner up: The Masked Singer - The Snail is revealed to be Kermit the Frog
  • Life On The Edge: Biggest Cliffhanger
    • Winner: The Umbrella Academy - The Hargreeves return home only to find their father alive, Ben and its now the Sparrow Academy
    • Runner up: This Is Us - The show flash forwards five years into the future, where Kate is getting remarried to her boss
  • That Guy Used To Suck: Favorite Character Redemption Arc
    • Winner: Lucifer - Dan Espinoza
    • Runner up: The Falcon and the Winter Soldier - Bucky Barnes
  • Name That Tune: Favorite Opening Credits/Theme Song
    • Winner: Supernatural ("Carry On My Wayward Son")
    • Runner up: Last Week Tonight With John Oliver
  • Music To My Ears: Favorite Musical Moment
    • Winner: WandaVision - "Agatha All Along"
    • Runner up: Zoey's Extraordinary Playlist - "I Melt With You"
  • The Big Chill: Favorite Binge-Watch
    • Winner: WandaVision
    • Runner up: TIE, Bridgerton & The Queen's Gambit
  • Asskicker: Favorite Badass
    • Winner: The Mandalorian - Luke Skywalker
    • Runner up: Lucifer - Maze
  • We Heart Bad Boys: Favorite Villain
    • Winner: WandaVision - Agatha Harkness
    • Runner up: The Mandalorian - Moff Gideon
  • We Go Together: Favorite Couple Or Ship
    • Winner: WandaVision - Wanda and Vision
    • Runner up: Bridgerton - Daphne and Simon
  • It Just Wouldn't Be The Same Without You: Favorite Lead Character
    • Winner: Lucifer - Lucifer
    • Runner up: The Mandalorian - The Mandalorian
  • Will You Be My BFF?: Favorite Secondary Character
    • Winner: Bridgerton - Lady Danbury
    • Runner up: Young Sheldon - Missy Cooper
  • Not Just A Prop: Favorite Performance By An Inanimate Object
    • Winner: The Queen's Gambit - Beth's Imaginary ceiling chess set
    • Runner up: The Mandalorian - Metal ball
  • Who’s a Good Boy!: Favorite Performance By a Live Animal
    • Winner: The Crown - The corgis
    • Runner up: Mom - Gus
  • Be Careful What You Wish For: Most Gratuitous Fanservice
    • Winner: Grey's Anatomy - Meredith's Purgatory Beach bringing back various dead characters
    • Runner up: Law and Order SVU - Stabler returns only to have the show kill off his wife
  • Wow, That Was Amazing!: Favorite Season/Series Finale
    • Winner: The Mandalorian
    • Runner up: WandaVision
  • Head Rekt: Best Season-long Mindfuckery
    • Winner: WandaVision - Almost everyone in town turned out to be hostages/ victims of Wanda's desperate plot to hold on to Vision
    • Runner up: WandaVision - Agatha plays into the "nosy neighbour" trope through several sitcom genres to figure out the source of Wanda's power
  • The GOAT: Greatest Show Of All Time
    • Winner: Frasier
    • Runner up: The Great British Bake Off/Baking Show
  • Straight Off The Runway: Character With Best Wardrobe
    • Winner: The Queen's Gambit - Beth Harmon
    • Runner up: The Crown - Princess Margaret
  • Take Me Home Tonight: Best TV Show Home
    • Winner: Bridgerton - Duke of Hastings' Estate
    • Runner up: WandaVision - Wanda and Vision's house
  • Best Show Adjustment To The Pandemic (Member Category Poll Winner)
    • Winner: The Late Show with Stephen Colbert - went from episode in the tub, to host in his house without an audience and virtual guests
    • Runner up: The Great British Bake Off/Baking Show

The Bad

  • Pass the Brain Bleach: Least Favorite TV Moment of the Year
    • Winner: Jeopardy! - Dr. Oz acts as the guest host
    • Runner up: This Is Us - Randall takes a swim with his dead mother and lets out his emotions by screaming
  • That Nearly Killed Me: Saddest Death Scene
    • Winner: Mare of Easttown - Colin Zabel
    • Runner up: WandaVision - Wanda's children
  • Weird Science: Most "Ummm, What Now?" Side-Eye Explanation Of Tech/Science
    • Winner: Debris - A piece of debris causes people to be instantly replicated as clones, only some are very messed up and one has two heads. The clones are... never mentioned again
    • Runner up: Young Sheldon - Sheldon's Tandy computer was not (in reality at that time) technologically capable of the tasks he was accomplishing
  • Whaaaat! Are You Effing Kidding Me?: Biggest Plot Point Letdown
    • Winner: Supernatural - Dean dies after 15 seasons of fighting (and dying) to save the world (or his brother), and there is no funeral, no wake, not one single person lamenting his death, and his Heaven is only marginally better than the Memorex version in S5
    • Runner up: This is Us- Randall finally gets closure with his bio mom by skinny dipping with an imaginary ghost version of her in presumably alligator infested Louisiana waters
  • Ugh, Not You Again: Least Entertaining Villain
    • Winner: The Walking Dead - Negan
    • Runner up: The Blacklist - Elizabeth Keene
  • Breaking Up Is Hard To Do!: Couple You Wish Would Call It Quits
    • Winner: Grey's Anatomy - Owen and Teddy
    • Runner up: The Conners - Ben and Darlene
  • The Pierce Of The Year: Dispensable Character Who Could Vanish And No-one Would Notice
    • Winner: The Conners - DJ Conner
    • Runner up: A Million Little Things - Delilah Dixon
  • Long In The Tooth: Show That Still Airs Long Past Its Expiration Date
    • Winner: Grey's Anatomy
    • Runner up: Keeping Up with the Kardashians
  • I Just Can’t Quit You: Favorite Show To Hate Watch
    • Winner: My 600-lb Life
    • Runner up: This Is Us
  • Ow, That Hurt: Most Painful Cancellation
    • Winner: Brooklyn Nine Nine
    • Runner up: Stumptown
  • Idiot Stick: Dumbest Character Moment
    • Winner: The Blacklist - Liz insisting on letting multiple people die just so she can learn Reddington's secrets
    • Runner up: WandaVision - Hayward threatening Wanda's children
  • That Anticlimax Tho: Anticipated New Show That Failed Miserably
    • Winner: Call Me Kat
    • Runner up: Emily in Paris
  • Here Without You: Favorite Current Show That Didn’t Air This Season
    • Winner: Brooklyn Nine Nine
    • Runner up: What We Do in the Shadows
  • Like 1
  • Useful 1
Link to comment

2022 (Spring)

Traditional

Best Drama

  • Winner: Better Call Saul
  • Runnerup: Squid Game

Worst Drama

  • Winner: Bull
  • Runnerup: Grey's Anatomy

Best Comedy

  • Winner: Abbott Elementary
  • Runnerup: Ghosts (US)

Worst Comedy

  • Winner: And Just Like That (landslide)
  • Runnerup: Call Me Kat

Best Genre Show

  • Winner: Stranger Things
  • Runnerup: Lucifer

Worst Genre Show

  • Winner: La Brea
  • Runnerup: Riverdale

Best Writing

  • Winner: Abbott Elementary
  • Runnerup: Ted Lasso

Worst Writing

  • Winner: And Just Like That
  • Runnerup: Grey's Anatomy

Best Talk Show (exact same results three years running)

  • Winner: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver
  • Runnerup: The Late Show with Stephen Colbert

Worst Talk Show

  • Winner: Real Time with Bill Maher
  • Runnerup: The View

Best Reality Show

  • Winner: The Great British Baking Show (winner for six years running now)
  • Runnerup: The Amazing Race

Worst Reality Show

  • Winner: The Kardashians (huuuuuge landslide)
  • Runnerup: Sister Wives

Best Animated Show

  • Winner: Bob's Burgers (winner for five years running now)
  • Runnerup: What If...?

Best Stunt

  • Winner: Only Murders in the Building - Charles's slow, drugged roll for help
  • Runnerup: Stranger Things - Max floating in the graveyard

Non-Traditional

Ow, That Hurt: Most Painful Cancellation

  • Winner: Zoey's Extraordinary Playlist
  • Runnerup: Legends of Tomorrow

LMFAO: Funniest Scene From a Scripted Show

  • Winner: Only Murders in the Building - Charles gives his big Hero Speech only to reveal it's all in his head and everyone else sees him mumbling incoherently
  • Runnerup: Loki - The Loki variants all double-crossing each other

My New Happy Place: Favorite New Show Of The Season

  • Winner: Abbott Elementary
  • Runnerup: Ghosts

That Anticlimax Tho: Anticipated New Show That Failed Miserably

  • Winner: And Just Like That (landslide)
  • Runnerup: Ordinary Joe

Long In The Tooth: Show That Still Airs Long Past Its Expiration Date 

  • Winner: Grey's Anatomy (winner three years running now)
  • Runnerup: Real Time with Bill Maher

The Book Was Better, Maybe?: Favorite Adaptation Of Existing Source Material

  • Winner: Bridgerton
  • Runnerup: (tie) All Creatures Great and Small, Ghosts (US)

I Just Can’t Quit You: Favorite Show To Hate Watch

  • Winner: This Is Us
  • Runnerup: Grey's Anatomy

Music To My Ears: Favorite Musical Moment

  • Winner: Stranger Things - Running Up That Hill
  • Runnerup: What We Do in the Shadows - 'ex' vampire aerobics and 'wellness center' life to "One Week”

Name That Tune: Favorite Credits/Theme Song

  • Winner: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver
  • Runnerup: What We Do in the Shadows - Atlantic City Version

We Go Together: Favorite Ship Pairing

  • Winner: Ted Lasso - Roy and Keeley
  • Runnerup: Brooklyn Nine Nine - Holt and Kevin

No Ro-Mo: Favorite Platonic Pairing

  • Winner: Stranger Things - Robin and Steve
  • Runnerup: Brooklyn Nine Nine - Jake and Charles

Breaking Up Is Hard To Do!: Couple You Wish Would Call It Quits

  • Winner: And Just Like That - Miranda and Che (landslide)
  • Runnerup: The Conners - Ben and Darlene

It Just Wouldn’t Be The Same Without You: Favorite Lead Character

  • Winner: Ted Lasso - Ted Lasso
  • Runnerup: Lucifer - Lucifer Morningstar

Will You Be My BFF?: Favorite Secondary Character

  • Winner: Ted Lasso - Roy Kent
  • Runnerup: Young Sheldon - Missy Cooper

The Newbie: Best New Character on an Established Scripted Show

  • Winner: Ted Lasso - Dr. Sharon
  • Runnerup: Stranger Things - Eddie

Asskicker: Favorite Badass

  • Winner: Hawkeye - Yelena Belova
  • Runnerup: Lucifer - Maze

The TP Factor: Dispensable Character Who Could Vanish And No One Would Notice

  • Winner: This Is Us - Annie
  • Runnerup: B Positive - Drew

Straight Off The Runway: Character With Best Wardrobe

  • Winner: The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel - Midge Maisel
  • Runnerup: Bridgerton - Kate Sharma

Beyond Honorable Mention: Favorite Character Who Doesn’t Get Enough Screentime

  • Winner: Young Sheldon - Missy Cooper
  • Runnerup: Law & Order - Jack McCoy

Idiot Stick: Dumbest Character Moment

  • Winner: And Just Like That - Miranda getting fingered by Che while she was taking care of Carrie 
  • Runnerup: The Gilded Age - Marian arrives unannounced at the Scott house with a pair of old shoes as a gift

That Guy Used To Suck: Favorite Character Redemption Arc

  • Winner: Ghosts - Trevor
  • Runnerup: Ted Lasso - Jamie Tartt

Over The Rainbow: Favorite LGBT+ Character

  • Winner: Ghosts - Isaac Higgentoot
  • Runnerup: Brooklyn Nine Nine - Rosa Diaz

Who’s a Good Boy!: Favorite Performance By A Live Animal

  • Winner: Brooklyn Nine Nine - Cheddar Cheddar (won again in his last year)
  • Runnerup: Hawkeye - Lucky the pizza dog

Not Just A Prop: Favorite Performance By An Inanimate Object

  • Winner: Stranger Things - The walkman
  • Runnerup: Bridgerton - Lady Danbury's walking stick

I Want To Go There: Best TV Show Home

  • Winner: Grace and Frankie - The beach house
  • Runnerup: Doctor Who - The TARDIS

Aw Yessss!: Favorite Scripted Or Reality TV Moment Of The Year

  • Winner: Ted Lasso - Jamie breaks down in tears as Roy hugs him after a brutal, humiliating scene with his dad in the team locker room
  • Runnerup: Abbott Elementary - Janine telling the busload of rowdy elementary students to "Sit Down!" in the season finale

Pass The Brain Bleach: Least Favorite Scripted Or Reality TV Moment Of The Year

  • Winner: The Masked Singer - The Jack-In-The-Box is revealed as Rudy Giuliani (landslide)
  • Runnerup: And Just Like That - Miranda dumping Steve for Che

Did That Just Happen?!: Biggest WTF Moment From A Scripted Or Reality Show

  • Winner: The Masked Singer - Ken Jeong walks off the set when Rudy Giuliani is revealed
  • Runnerup: The White Lotus - Armond keys in to Shane's room, defecates into his suitcase out of revenge, only for Shane to return unexpectedly and accidentally stab and kill Armond

We Heart Bad Boys: Favorite Villain

  • Winner: Better Call Saul - Gustavo Fring
  • Runnerup: Hawkeye - Yelena

Ugh, Not You Again: Least Entertaining Villain

  • Winner: The Walking Dead - Negan (third win in a row -- hat trick!)
  • Runnerup: Law and Order: Organized Crime - Richard Wheatley

Head Rekt: Most Shocking Plot Twist Of The Season

  • Winner: Squid Game - Player 001 is running the game
  • Runnerup: What We Do in the Shadows - Colin Robinson reborn as a creepy baby with his face

Whaaaat? Are You Effing Kidding Me: Biggest Plot Letdown

  • Winner: Young Sheldon - 17 year old Georgie knocks up 29 year old woman
  • Runnerup: This Is Us - Kate and Toby break up with just a few episodes left in the series

That Nearly Killed Me: Saddest Death Scene

  • Winner: This Is Us - Miguel
  • Runnerup: Loki - Classic Loki

Variety Is The Spice Of Life: Most Diverse Cast In A Scripted Show

  • Winner: Abbott Elementary
  • Runnerup: Ghosts

We’re All in This Together: Best Ensemble Cast (Member Category Winner)

  • Winner: Ghosts (US)
  • Runnerup: Brooklyn Nine Nine

Golden Oldie: Favorite Off-Air Show Of All Time

  • Winner: M*A*S*H
  • Runnerup: The West Wing
  • Like 1
  • Love 1
Link to comment

2022 (Winter)

Best Drama
Winner: The White Lotus
Runnerup: All Creatures Great and Small

Worst Drama
Winner: New Amsterdam
Runnerup: The Crown

Best Comedy
Winner: Only Murders in the Building
Runnerup: What We Do in the Shadows

Worst Comedy
Winner: The Santa Clauses
Runnerup: Blockbuster

Best Genre Show
Winner: Andor
Runnerup: Wednesday

Worst Genre Show
Winner: Tales of the Walking Dead
Runnerup: House of the Dragon

Best Writing
Winner: Only Murders in the Building
Runnerup: Last Week Tonight With John Oliver

Worst Writing
Winner: New Amsterdam
Runnerup: House of the Dragon

Best Talk Show
Winner: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver
Runnerup: Late Show with Stephen Colbert

Worst Talk Show
Winner: The View
Runnerup: Watch What Happens

Best Reality Show
Winner: The Great British Bake Off
Runnerup: The Amazing Race

Worst Reality Show
Winner: The Kardashians
Runnerup: Sister Wives

Best Animated Show
Winner: Star Trek: Lower Decks
Runnerup: Archer

Best Stunt
Winner: The Boys - Homelander vs Butcher, Hughie and Soldier Boy 
Runnerup: Ms. Marvel - Vehicle chase through the streets of Karachi, Pakistan

Seasonal Special: Favorite Christmas TV Special
Winner: A Charlie Brown Christmas
Runnerup: How the Grinch Stole Christmas

Seasonal Special: Favorite Traditional Christmas Movie
Winner: It's a Wonderful Life
Runnerup: A Muppet Christmas Carol

Seasonal Special: Favorite Non-Traditional Christmas Movie
Winner: Die Hard (surprising absolutely no one)
Runnerup: Nightmare Before Christmas

Ow, That Hurt: Most Painful Cancellation
Winner: Full Frontal With Samantha Bee
Runnerup: Stanley Tucci: Searching for Italy

Bye, Felicia: Most Joyful Cancellation
Winner: Chad
Runnerup: N/A (no other entries submitted)

LMFAO: Funniest Scene From a Scripted Show
Winner: What We Do in the Shadows - Trying to get young Colin into private school, the vampires use hypnotism to redo the interview with the principal over, and over, and over, and over, and over, and over...
Runnerup: Only Murders in the Building - The glitter bomb trap for the killer goes off in the background, while Charles, Oliver, and Mabel are having a serious conversation, missing it going off

My New Happy Place: Favorite New Show of the Season
Winner: Wednesday
Runnerup: Andor

That Anticlimax Tho: Anticipated New Show That Failed Miserably
Winner: House of the Dragon
Runnerup: Tales of the Walking Dead

Long in the Tooth: Show That Still Airs Long Past Its Expiration Date
Winner: The Walking Dead
Runnerup: New Amsterdam

Name That Tune: Favorite Credits/Theme Song
Winner: Only Murders in the Building
Runnerup: What We Do in the Shadows

Books, Schmooks: Favorite Adaptation of Existing Source Material
Winner: All Creatures Great and Small
Runnerup: Wednesday

The Book Is Always Better: Least Favorite Adaptation of Existing Source Material
Winner: House of the Dragon
Runnerup: Interview With the Vampire

I Just Can't Quit You: Favorite Show to Hate Watch
Winner: Sister Wives
Runnerup: The Crown

Music to My Ears: Favorite Musical Moment
Winner: Only Murders in the Building - Everyone in the Arconia spontaneously sings "The Sound of Silence" during the blackout
Runnerup: What We Do in the Shadows - Laszlo and Nadja's wedding song for Nandor and Marwa ('Who'll Come First on the Wedding Night?')

We Go Together: Favorite Ship Pairing
Winner: Miss Scarlet and the Duke - Eliza and William
Runnerup: She-Hulk - Jen Walters and Matt Murdock

No Ro-Mo: Favorite Platonic Pairing
Winner: Only Murders in the Building - Charles and Oliver
Runnerup: Wednesday - Enid and Thing

Breaking Up Is Hard to Do: Couple You Wish Would Call It Quits
Winner: Interview With the Vampire - Louis and Lestat
Runnerup: The White Lotus - Tanya and Greg

It Just Wouldn't Be the Same Without You: Favorite Lead Character
Winner: Wednesday - Wednesday Addams
Runnerup: Andor - Cassian Andor

Will You Be My BFF? Favorite Secondary Character
Winner: Wednesday - Enid
Runnerup: The Sandman - Death

Straight Off the Runway: Character With Best Wardrobe
Winner: Only Murders in the Building - Mabel
Runnerup: The Crown - Diana

The Newbie: Favorite New Character on an Established Scripted Show
Winner: What We Do in the Shadows - The Djinn
Runnerup: The Boys - Soldier Boy

Back, Show Killer! Least Favorite New Character on an Established Scripted Show
Winner: Only Murders in the Building - Amy Schumer as herself
Runnerup: The Orville - Charly Burke

Beyond Honorable Mention: Favorite Character Who Doesn't Get Enough Screentime
Winner: Only Murders in the Building - Big Bunny/Rose Cooper
Runnerup: The Boys - Queen Maeve

Idiot Stick: Dumbest Character Moment
Winner: House of the Dragon - Rhaenys takes her dragon into Aegon's coronation, but then doesn't do anything but murder some helpless bystanders
Runnerup: Umbrella Academy - Allison doesn’t anticipate her daughter not existing in the altered timeline

That Guy Used to Suck: Favorite Character Redemption Arc
Winner: Only Murders in the Building - Theo Dimas
Runnerup: She-Hulk: Attorney at Law - Emil Blonsky

Over the Rainbow: Favorite LGBT+ Character
Winner: What We Do in the Shadows - Guillermo
Runnerup: Only Murders in the Building - Mabel

Who's a Good Boy! Favorite Performace by a Live Animal
Winner: Only Murders in the Building - Mrs. Gambolini
Runnerup: The Crown - Brandy, Sherry, and Rum

Not Just a Prop: Favorite Performance by an Inanimate Object
Winner: What We Do in the Shadows - Laszlo's cursed witch hat
Runnerup: The Orville - time travelling sandwich

I Want to Go There: Favorite TV Show Home
Winner: Only Murders in the Building - Mabel's apartment
Runnerup: The White Lotus - Quentin's estate in Palermo

Aw Yessss! Favorite Scripted or Reality TV Moment of the Season
Winner: Andor - the prison break
Runnerup: The Orville - the uplifting Dolly Parton program on the environmental simulator

Did That Just Happen? Biggest WTF Moment From a Scripted or Reality Show
Winner: The Great British Bake Off - The taco technical for a baking challenge
Runnerup: Only Murders in the Building - Alice stabs Charles

Asskicker: Favorite Badass
Winner: Only Murders in the Building - Mabel
Runnerup: Wednesday - Wednesday

We Heart Bad Boys: Favorite Villain
Winner: Interview With the Vampire - Lestat de Lioncourt
Runnerup: House of the Dragon - Daemon

Ugh, Not You Again: Least Entertaining Villain
Winner: The Walking Dead - Negan
Runnerup: Only Murders in the Building - Becky Butler

Whaaaat: Are You Effing Kidding Me: Biggest Plot Letdown
Winner: Only Murders in the Building - Oscar and Mabel randomly breakup offscreen and he is never mentioned again
Runnerup: The Walking Dead - Negan is getting redeemed and still ain't dead

That Nearly Killed Me: Saddest Death Scene
Winner: Dead to Me - Judy Hale
Runnerup: House of the Dragon - Lady Laena Velaryon

Variety Is the Spice of Life: Most Diverse Cast in a Scripted Show
Winner: Reservation Dogs
Runnerup: The Umbrella Academy

Head Rekt: Most Shocking Plot Twist of the Season
Winner: Only Murders in the Building - Poppy White is really Becky Butler, faked her death, and masterminded Bunny's murder
Runnerup: The Boys - Soldier Boy is Homelander's father

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...