caitmcg
-
Posts
940 -
Joined
Content Type
Blogs
Gallery
Downloads
Discussion
Posts posted by caitmcg
-
-
50 minutes ago, OnMatchPoint said:
David Murphy got wind that he would be receiving a villain edit and declined to participate in LCK, so they had to recruit the closest backup (Soo being 45min south of Milwaukee).
Do you have a source for this intel? There's been a lot of wondering about conflicting accounts about why David Murphy didn't compete in LCK and whether the Soo twist was long-planned. Also, in recent seasons they've begun with 16, but this time they did not, and yet they brought two back in, so it's still an uneven number (for now)...
-
4
-
-
13 hours ago, Quilt Fairy said:
I don't understand the Matthew situation, either. I know he wasn't a businessman like his father, and the tenement buildings were an issue, but the family obviously had personal wealth. And he managed to lose everything, just like that? To the extent that they need to live on Trixie's salary?
He was managing the family business (badly), and its board of directors relieved him of his position, therefore eliminating the income he earned from his job.
-
1
-
-
6 hours ago, tv echo said:
(On Episode 1), the decision was made relatively quickly. It was obvious who had the weakest performance and it was the person who did not respond to our feedback. I feel bad, because I want everyone to succeed, but you could tell he was joking a little more than he focused on his food. I felt like it was a defense mechanism for the fact that he was overwhelmed by the experience. And in the end, neither of his dishes was very good.
That's pretty much how he (David "Hat Guy" Murphy) came across on the show.
-
3
-
-
2 hours ago, Shermie said:
I hate how they wrote Lucille out because it made no sense to the character. Cyril and Lucille were a strong couple, clearly in love, and the minute they get married she takes off? No. I’d rather they killed her off right after her wedding, soap-opera style.
The Lucille departure has been handled badly, but I wonder if they didn't want to kill her off soon after her marriage, having previously done the same thing with Barbara.
Matthew was earlier complaining that Trixie was continuing to work, even as he knew the business was failing. How does that look now that her modest salary is their only household income? And of course we find out that not only is he only a leaseholder for his flat (not his fault if that's how the property's structured), he never signed the deed over to Nonnatus House. Trixie exerts her usual competence, and he's angry she embarrassed him by making it known he needs a job. Does anyone remember what his position was before he took over seeing to his father's properties in Poplar?
-
3
-
-
On 4/22/2024 at 9:33 AM, buttersister said:
Soo could take his whole thing. But introducing him through the back door? I wonder if executive producer Padma would have had something to say about that? As in, how disrespectful.
Isn't Tom also an executive producer, though? And since he is the LCK judge, presumably he has an opinion, whether or not he has any real say,
-
2
-
-
2 hours ago, Ancaster said:
Thanks @Bastet. I cross-posted I think, though it posted the whole URL (?) rather than a handy little "There's a thread" type phrase to click on like you had - I'm not tech savvy either!
You can use the little chain link icon in the top row (next to the quote mark) in the top row to create a link with text in your post if you want, rather than paste the UR: into your post.
-
22 hours ago, Steph Sometimes said:
And finally, everything I (a Southern Californian) really know about supper clubs comes from this novel that I enjoyed and recommend - Saturday Night at the Lakeside Supper Club.
I also liked this one. All of J. Ryan Stradal's novels concern families and their food-related businesses in the Midwest.
-
2
-
1
-
-
48 minutes ago, buttersister said:
Manny has gone downhill since his mole. How do you screw up a tenderloin?
Manny had the tough beef, it was Kévin who vastly undercooked the tenderloin. When it was served to the judges, he said "medium rare," even as they only had to look at it to remark, "still mooing" (and it was apparently pretty much raw, at that).
-
2
-
-
9 hours ago, dleighg said:
I forgot to add above, I thought that Rasika should have deferred to Michelle to make what she wanted, given that Rasika had immunity. I know that since Rasika is on a roll, it makes sense to have her do something strong for the team's sake, but Michelle hasn't been a slouch so far either.
And yet, they disliked Rasika's dish, because every component — the fish and both sauces — was very salty. I noticed that at Judges' Table, every time they showed Rasika, she had a kind of sour look. We didn't see them address her, but we know they edit way down for time, so I assume they told her her dish was kind of a fail for its saltiness. As it happens, Michelle's dessert, even with not enough pineapple (second thing she gave up for the team) was more successful with the judges.
4 hours ago, Rai said:I don't know why both chicken chefs went with katsu, but okay.
I think it was because, as Amanda said in a talking head, they both cook Japanese (or Japanese-inspired) food, so I assume they were both heeding Kristen's advice to "cook your food." Anyway, nice to see Amanda distinguish herself with a widely praised dish. She hasn't been very successful so far.
-
6
-
-
46 minutes ago, CatWarmer said:
It was disappointing that all three moved to the second round of LCK, but I'll bet they planned all along to have Soo and one returnee win.
At the very least, it was obviously set up that two would return, regardless of how Tom worked to make it seem spontaneous.
-
2
-
-
4 hours ago, AriAu said:
By the way, would Rashika have pulled out that Rasam (indian sauce that I had never heard of) if Padma had been there?????
I don't see why not, given that Rasika herself is Indian-American, and was cooking food that reflected her own regional (Tamil) heritage in an elevated way. She even said the rasam was her grandmother's recipe. She's probably at least as familiar with and competent at the cuisine as Padma.
-
7
-
1
-
-
9 hours ago, iMonrey said:
We've never had one pupil midwife before much less four of them.
Nancy was a pupil midwife during her first season.
-
3
-
-
3 hours ago, Notabug said:
The other kid survived. He had a tracheotomy, a feeding tube and a mental age of 2 months afterwards. There are things worse than death. There is no amount of caution that is ever enough when it comes to kids and water.
This happened to a couple my mother knew (in fact, theirs was possibly the first wedding I attended, when I was around five). Their son was around three when it happened. I don't think he needed a trach long term, but definitely a feeding tube due to the brain damage. He died at a fairly young age. The parents blamed each other for allowing it to happen and it led them to divorce, and eventually the husband committed suicide. It was terrible all around.
-
2
-
5
-
-
38 minutes ago, Ancaster said:
From what I understand this isn't quite right because several LCKs are filmed back to back.
Right, I understand that's how it works from a time perspective: Soo came in and started filming LCK, which is like doing a bunch of QFs in a row; whoever comes to LCK after being eliminated may or may not be doing it without much of a break, depending on how close to their elimination is to the filming of LCK.
When I mentioned their exhaustion, I wasn't just thinking physical, but also mental/psychological. It's clearly a lot to go from challenge to challenge, always thinking on their feet.
-
1
-
-
40 minutes ago, ProudMary said:
It made me laugh when Buddha said he'd learned how to use liquid nitrogen to make ice cream, from a YouTube video!
What can't you learn from a YouTube video these days?
I wouldn't be too surprised if it were part of his TC prep. We all know by now that he closely studied the show before competing, so he doubtless realized that liquid nitrogen is the only reasonable way to produce ice cream within the competition, and I can imagine him thinking, "Okay, I need to learn to do that."
-
4
-
-
12 hours ago, Yeah No said:
But was it me or did Kristin's voice quiver when she said PYKAG? If so that was sweet and she's more emotional than I thought!
I'm not that surprised, in that it usually took at least a third or halfway into each season before Padma started getting emotional delivering the PYK verdicts. Like the viewers, it presumably takes some time before the host gets to know and feels invested in the contestants, or sad to let them go.
2 hours ago, avecsans said:And mushroom cheesecake?
When Kaleena first mentioned it during their planning session, I assumed it was meant to be a savory dish, not a dessert, and it made sense (and sounded potentially good) in that context. I've certainly never heard or thought of putting mushrooms in sweets, with the exception of candy caps.
-
2
-
-
23 hours ago, susannot said:
Buddha's Napolean Guggenheim was stunning.
I liked its look much more than I did his fussier plating complete with fancy-shaped tuiles during his seasons.
-
1
-
-
18 hours ago, Bastet said:
The only suspense was which of the two would win immunity, but Rasika is on such a roll, my money was on her
I didn't think there was any suspense there; just as it was obvious which pair would win, I thought it was obvious Rasika would come out on top. While the judges complimented the pair and their concept and didn't really have any criticism, it was Rasika's dish they couldn't stop talking about.
-
7
-
-
On 4/7/2024 at 3:14 PM, Mittengirl said:
Instead of regular Hershey’s Cocoa, I used their Special Dark in both cake & frosting. It was really chocolatey.
The Special Dark is Dutch processed, which generally is darker and richer tasting than natural (like regular Hershey's cocoa).
-
2
-
-
2 hours ago, JudyObscure said:
I'm so old I can remember when the doctor kept the records for us and told us when things were due.
Honestly, this was true not so long ago. Twenty years ago, my primary care doctor was still charting on paper and would let me know.
-
3
-
-
1 minute ago, Rammchick said:
No, I realize that -- I should have been clearer. I meant that perhaps the judges wanted to give the win to someone else, given thhe at Rasika had immunity.
But the judges didn't choose the winner this time, only the loser. The win was determined by the crowd and went to the contestant who got the highest score from the diners, who wouldn't know anything about Rasika's immunity.
-
6
-
-
9 hours ago, Bastet said:
He said he'd set aside enough for the judges -- the diners were picking who was going to win (so he risked losing enough votes not to win if he gave too many people incomplete dishes), but the judges were picking the bottom three (so if he served them incomplete dishes, having used up all the accompaniment on the diners by the time the judges got to his station, the result could be much worse than not being a contender, it could make him a candidate for elimination) -- and we may even have seen a shot of that setting aside (I can't recall and am too lazy to check). And the judges said he was shoveling something on as he served them, which made for a soggy mess. So I think he did give them complete dishes, they just weren't good.
But apparently he didn't. It was pretty far into the serving period when we saw Kenny say he realized he was running out of his relish and hadn't yet served the judges, so he was setting aside some of what was left. Yet, Tom specifically complained that instead of getting the cherries in the cherry relish, they got the vinegary liquid from the relish, which just made the dish wet, and said he should have known to set enough aside for the judges at the start.
2 hours ago, Yeah No said:I just wanted to say that having them cook cheese outside in the extreme heat was not the best choice. I get it that this is "Top Chef" so they should be able to handle obstacles like that, and that TPTB probably make these choices way in advance and can't predict the weather, but knowing it was a warm time of year and that the chefs had limited time to complete the challenge should have made them rethink that.
Reminds me of how, on GBBO, the chocolate challenge, or anything involving ice cream, is invariably on the hottest day in the tent.
-
5
-
-
- Popular Post
- Popular Post
52 minutes ago, The Solution said:Something isn't right here. You can't even do the prep work for eggplant in 20 minutes, let alone create an entire dish that tastes good enough to beat something else. Soo seems like a nice enough guy - it's not his fault - but there's some behind-the-scenes manipulation going on here.
We watched him do the work. He took a few whole tomatoes and roasted them fast at high heat, then puréed them in the powerful blender and seasoned them with yuzu and some umami-rich condiments to make the sauce. He sliced the eggplant fairly thinly and dropped in in the fryer, and melted the cheese in the high-heat wood burning oven before sliding it onto the dish and browning it with a torch. None of what he did was traditional for eggplant parm (no simmering tomato sauce, breading and pan-frying eggplant, or baking the assembled dish), but it was a strategy that allowed him to get it together quickly.
I do not see anything sketchy going on here in the actual competition that makes me want to reach for a tinfoil hat. Soo may seem like a ringer, but perhaps he's actually just a very talented chef. He did come into LCK with one major advantage over contestants newly arriving from the main show, which is that he hasn't just gone through the exhausting marathon of the QF and elimination challenges.
-
26
-
31 minutes ago, Quilt Fairy said:7 hours ago, Rammchick said:
Considering what was said about Rasika's dish, I was also surprised she wasn't on top, but I thought it might've been because she had immunity.
Her immunity in this challenge protects her if she's at the bottom, but it doesn't prevent her from winning again.
Besides, the top three were selected based on the guest crowd's ratings of the dishes, and they had no idea who had immunity (or even, presumably, that the show changed up how immunity was awarded vs. previous seasons).
-
3
-
S21.E06: Chaos Cuisine
in Top Chef
They did have a chyron at least for the woman who appeared at judges' table, Sophia Roe, with her business name, but it was so fleeting I rewound the DVR a few seconds when I saw it go by. So I assume there was one just as fast for the other guy, though I missed seeing it altogether.
You'd think they wouldn't be flying past or editing out so many little things with a 75-minute episode every week.