MelissaFirefly

So, in 2005, Ted was 27. This means he graduated high school in 1996. This lines up with him, Marshall, and Lily being freshmen in 1996. However, later, Marshall says that he was most outgoing in high school his freshman, sophomore, and senior years, then it shows he was a junior in high school in 1996. Then Scooter. In the episode of Lily and Marshall's wedding, his name is Bill. The episode where they're all trying to convince each other that they're bad-asses, Lilly calls Scooter Jeff. Any other inconsistencies that stand out to anyone else?

Nora was basically his mother...not a good fit.

I wanted Barney and Robin to stay together. It kind of made me mad that they split them up like an after-thought.