ottoDbusdriver June 8 Share June 8 Wednesday's FTW was dumb. The rest of the show was ok. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8388792
ottoDbusdriver June 8 Share June 8 Thursday's FTW was worse than Wednesday's FTW. Are the writer's just completely devoid of ideas ? Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8388808
AnimeMania June 9 Author Share June 9 S01.E67: June 10, 2024 Comic Scott Aukerman; actor Carl Tart; actress Mary Elizabeth Ellis Premiere Date: June 11, 2024 CBS 12:37am S01.E68: June 11, 2024 Comic Paul F. Tompkins; comic Morgan Murphy; actress Caroline Rhea Premiere Date: June 12, 2024 CBS 12:37am S01.E69: June 12, 2024 Actor Kevin Nealon; actress Jessica Lowe; actor Dave Holmes Premiere Date: June 13, 2024 CBS 12:37am S01.E70: June 13, 2024 Actress Jenna Ushkowitz; comic Kate Micucci; writer Eliot Glazer Premiere Date: June 14, 2024 CBS 12:37am Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8389066
possibilities June 9 Share June 9 Glad to know Kate Micuci is well. She had lung cancer a while back-- which I found shocking at the time. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8389151
AnimeMania June 9 Author Share June 9 4 hours ago, possibilities said: Glad to know Kate Micuci is well. She had lung cancer a while back-- which I found shocking at the time. They caught it extremely early. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8389268
possibilities June 11 Share June 11 Since the show is not really working for us, maybe we should do the games ourselves. My contribution to today's hastag wars: FreakyFriBae Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8390755
SoMuchTV June 11 Share June 11 Since the show is not really working for us, maybe we should do the games ourselves. My contribution to today's hastag wars: FreakyFriBae Bae: Pig in the City 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8390795
ottoDbusdriver June 11 Share June 11 The A-Bae-ss RoboBae EveryBae Everywhere all at Once A Streetcar named Bae #BaeAMovie 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8390802
ottoDbusdriver June 11 Share June 11 The Sweatpants or Jeans game on Monday's episode dragged on and on for a total of 10 and a half minutes (not including the commercial break before the results were shown). It was just bad. 4 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8390967
ALenore June 11 Share June 11 (edited) After Midnight has been renewed for Season Two! https://variety.com/2024/tv/news/taylor-tomlinson-after-midnight-renewed-season-2-cbs-1236033651/ Edited June 11 by ALenore 1 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8391008
ottoDbusdriver June 13 Share June 13 The Tuesday episode with Paul F. Tompkins, Morgan Murphy, and Caroline Rhea Guy Branum was pretty good. I guess Caroline Rhea cancelled, but Guy was a good last minute replacement. The Barktank game was fun. 3 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8391877
possibilities June 14 Share June 14 I don't think I could beat up a pinata. I know it's not real, but it feels like animal cruelty anyway. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8392430
iMonrey June 14 Share June 14 They've dropped Group Chat, they've dropped For The Win, how long before they drop Hashtag Wars? I get that they probably want to make this show their own but every move they make away from the original has been for the worse. Every substitute they've come up with in place of For The Win has been increasingly dumb and pointless. Having the panelists come out one at a time and pander to the audience also seems like a stupid time waster. Still, they got a second season. It's probably a pretty cheap show to produce. 3 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8392664
Unclejosh June 14 Share June 14 I have stopped watching full shows. I dont like the changes personally. I will check out clips on YT every once and a while but it just isnt as fun as it was. Maybe i am too old and used to the original format. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8392694
ottoDbusdriver June 15 Share June 15 Wednesday's show was pretty bad -- if you're going to have a cameo maybe have someone famous or infamous or at least recognizable. I had no idea who Drew was. (The) Dating Game was dumb. The Pinata bashing for FTW was even dumber. 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8393033
ottoDbusdriver June 15 Share June 15 An 'Animal Off' to decide the winner ? It wasn't funny. I want the comedians to earn the win by being creative and coming up with something funny. What's next -- pick a number between 1 and 10 to decide the winner ? This is just lazy. 4 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8393106
iMonrey June 15 Share June 15 They're spinning out of control trying too many things. I get that the writers feel compelled to come up with new games all the time to justify their salaries but they should hone in on the games they know work. They should have stuck to the formula with Group Chat first, Hashtag Wars second, then picked a few new games that have worked really well and stuck with those. By now they've come up with enough good ones and too many bad ones to keep trying new ones. 5 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8393201
AnimeMania June 16 Author Share June 16 S01.E71: June 17, 2024 Comic Sherry Cola; actor Solomon Georgio; comic Debra DiGiovanni Premiere Date: June 18, 2024 CBS 12:37am S01.E72: June 18, 2024 Actor Terry Crews; actor Joe Manganiello; comic Patton Oswalt Premiere Date: June 19, 2024 CBS 12:37am S01.E73: June 19, 2024 Comic James Davis; comic Ashley Nicole Black; comic Laurie Kilmartin Premiere Date: June 20, 2024 CBS 12:37am S01.E74: June 20, 2024 Comic Lisa Gilroy; actor Reid Scott; actress Kimia Behpoornia Premiere Date: June 21, 2024 CBS 12:37am Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8393527
iMonrey June 19 Share June 19 I don't understand how Jeremy Allen White has a "rat face." His eyes are big. They're droopy but they're big. Same with Timothee Chalamet. Rat face? Now, Barry Keoghan? Yeah, rat race. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8395797
ottoDbusdriver June 21 Share June 21 Just catching up on this week's episodes -- the 'Find Croatia' game from Monday's episode was just dumb. Like really, really dumb. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8397221
possibilities June 21 Share June 21 Fruit surgery account https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=emikoo7 Part of me thinks it's genius and very funny and part of me thinks it's the creepiest thing I've seen in a while. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8397261
iMonrey June 21 Share June 21 11 hours ago, ottoDbusdriver said: Just catching up on this week's episodes -- the 'Find Croatia' game from Monday's episode was just dumb. Like really, really dumb. Not as dumb as the spin cycle game. Two of them wouldn't even get on it. 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8397426
SoMuchTV June 22 Share June 22 Oh wow, I just saw frequent guest Paul F. Tompkins on an episode of Frasier from 2003. Pretty sure I wouldn’t have recognized him if it weren’t for the Amazon “X-ray” feature. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8397741
ottoDbusdriver June 22 Share June 22 Tuesday's episode with Patton Oswalt, Terry Crews, and Joe Manganiello was a lot of fun. The 'People vs.' game was pretty good. FTW game was at least something the comedians had to come up with an answer -- still wish Taylor would read the answers so as not to give away who wrote what, but in this case the shortest answer won so it didn't really matter. 3 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8397900
iMonrey June 22 Share June 22 (edited) I think the changes from the original show just demonstrate that this works much better in a half hour format. Each episode started with Group Chat, followed by Hashtag Wars, and then one new game, and then onto For The Win. It was consistent, because if the one new game didn't really work they still had the other reliable ones. All of the padding they've added to the hour-long version doesn't work. And with them constantly tinkering with the format it's more hit-or-miss than ever. Edited June 22 by iMonrey 3 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8398000
Chyromaniac June 24 Share June 24 (edited) For me it’s not necessarily the format or length - it’s the guests. I just enjoy the show more when the comics are funny and likable - and I think it works better with actors and improvisers rather than stand-ups or (god save us) podcasters. Like, I didn’t mind watching an hour (or 40-ish minutes) of Tuesday or Thursday’s shows- but Wednesday dragged a bit, and Monday was a slog. Granted, some of this just comes down to personal taste, and ymmv when it comes to what’s funny - but I think overall, with the stand-ups it’s much more dependent on their personality -while the performers can just go with the game premise. I will say, the thing they’ve lost structurally with no FTW, is that it gave the show a natural crowd pop to go out on, because they always cheered when their favorite was announced. With an essentially arbitrary winner, you don’t really get that, and sometimes the show falls flat at the last moment. Edited June 24 by Chyromaniac 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8399105
AnimeMania July 7 Author Share July 7 S01.E75: July 8, 2024 Comic Baron Vaughn; actor Rhys Darby; comic Rory Scovel Premiere Date: July 9, 2024 CBS 12:37am S01.E76: June 9, 2024 Actor Colton Dunn; actor Jason Sklar; actor Randy Sklar Premiere Date: July 10, 2024 CBS 12:37am S01.E77: June 10, 2024 Model Chrissy Teigen; actor Adam Pally; film producer Sandy Honig Premiere Date: July 11, 2024 CBS 12:37am S01.E78: June 11, 2024 Actor Richie Moriarty; actress Betsy Sodaro; actress Punam Patel Premiere Date: July 12, 2024 CBS 12:37am Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8407212
ottoDbusdriver July 7 Share July 7 I wonder if Adam Pally is going to be obsessed over the confusing name of the show like he did on his first appearance on March 6. :) Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8407252
ottoDbusdriver July 11 Share July 11 Monday's show with Baron, Rhys, and Rory was pretty funny. Got to credit Baron Vaughn with the Billy Ocean reference in one of his responses. It was Rhys Darby's first time on After Midnight -- he was on @Midnight pretty regularly. Baron Vaughn's first time on after Midnight as well. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8410036
possibilities July 11 Share July 11 I also enjoyed Monday's show. I thought maybe they decided to actually write good material and not just figure insomniacs will watch anything. But the I thought Tuesday's show was a return to dudsville. It had some funny moments but overall, meh. So I guess I credit the guests on Monday, or maybe the writing team used all their ideas up on Monday.. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8410062
iMonrey July 11 Share July 11 I thought Tuesday's show was awful, but then I have never found the Sklar brothers funny, ever. I don't know how they have a career as comics. And when the comedians are that bad it makes Taylor's fake laugh ten times worse. She shouldn't be in hysterics over every little thing they say when the audience sits there stone-faced. And the lamp game was just about the dumbest thing they've come up with yet. 2 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8410274
possibilities July 11 Share July 11 I did like the sweater one of the Sklar bros was wearing. It kind of creeps me out how they never appear anywhere except as a pair. I haven't watched last night's show yet. I'm kind of dangling by a thread with respect to watching. Maybe reading a book would be a better use of my insomnia. Makes me sad because I liked the original show and I could use some humor before bed. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8410322
ottoDbusdriver July 13 Share July 13 The Hashtag the Magnificent FTW on Wednesday's show was pretty lame. 2 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8411567
AnimeMania July 13 Author Share July 13 S01.E79: July 15, 2024 Actors Danny Tamberelli, Lori Beth Denberg and Kel Mitchell Premiere Date: July 16, 2024 CBS 12:37am S01.E80: July 16, 2024 Actress Kristen Schaal; actor Flula Borg; comic Leo González Premiere Date: July 17, 2024 CBS 12:37am S01.E81: July 17, 2024 Drag queen Alaska 5000; actress Gillian Jacobs; comic Chris Fleming Premiere Date: July 18, 2024 CBS 12:37am S01.E82: July 18, 2024 Actress Mandy Moore; actor Chris Sullivan; actress Milana Vayntrub Premiere Date: July 19, 2024 CBS 12:37am Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8411685
iMonrey July 17 Share July 17 (edited) Monday's show was painful. And the "teach the kids" game had potential if they had better comics. I'm pissed that Tuesday's show was delayed because it was much better and my DVR only caught the first half of it. Kristen Schaal and Flula are great. Edited July 18 by iMonrey Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8414030
AnimeMania July 20 Author Share July 20 S01.E83: July 22, 2024 Actor Joe Mantegna; actor Zach Gilford; comic Laci Mosley Premiere Date: July 23, 2024 CBS 12:37am S01.E84: July 23, 2024 Actress Anna Faris; comic Melissa Villaseñor; comic Andy Richter Premiere Date: July 24, 2024 CBS 12:37am S01.E85: July 24, 2024 Comic Dustin Nickerson; comic Reggie Watts; comic Irene Tu Premiere Date: July 25, 2024 CBS 12:37am S01.E86: July 25, 2024 Comic Pete Holmes; comic Maria Bamford; actor Vinny Thomas Premiere Date: July 26, 2024 CBS 12:37am Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8416140
possibilities July 20 Share July 20 I think Taylor is the best thing about this remake. Her pesonality is refreshingly different than what we get from most other people who get to be on tv. At this point, I'm watching for her. I also think that if I stop comparing it to the original, and just try to think of it as a totally different thing, it doesn't irritate me as much. That show was for people who like clever writing and a rapid pace of jokes. This show is for people looking for a kind of chaotic hang out goofiness. I am more the former than the latter, but if I don't think of it as a failed knock off, I can appreciate what they are doing, for what it is. It feels lazy to me, and often kind of boring, like hanging out sober with a bunch of people who are drunk or high-- they think they are having a good time but their joy is disproportionate to what is actually happening. But I don't think there's anything wrong with it. Having a junk food snack is fun sometimes. This show is like a junk food snack before bed. Loose. 2 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8416224
ottoDbusdriver July 20 Share July 20 I thought the Tuesday show and Thursday show were the better episodes this week. Flula's energy and enthusiasm is great to watch. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8416271
possibilities July 25 Share July 25 I liked Taylor saying "Don't interrupt me when I'm talking" on Wednesday's show. Lots of studies show men interrupt women at a migh higher rate than they interrupt each other. I know she was kidding around, but I still liked it. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8419634
iMonrey July 27 Share July 27 I've been able to tell by the end of the first segment whether or not the panel is any good. When they are not - such as Wednesday's show with Dustin Nickerson, Reggie Watts and Irene Tu, I just skip right to Hashtag Wars and then turn it off. No point in wasting my time on any of the rest of it. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8421134
ottoDbusdriver July 30 Share July 30 Catching up on last week's shows. Monday's FTW was just .... odd. It was basically a Price is Right pricing game. Not really a good demonstration of comedic skills (and Joe Mategna got screwed in FTW by thinking it was an annual Paramount+ subscription instead of a monthly subscription). Tuesday's FTW was a playdoh sculpture contest, which was ok I guess, but I really did like Tuesday's show with Anna, Andy, and Melissa. Been an Andy Richter fan going back to the Late Night with Conan O'Brien show on NBC. Fun Fact: Anna and Andy were both in Scary Movie 2. June Squibb's cameo was fun. 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8423397
ottoDbusdriver July 30 Share July 30 Wednesday's show was painfully not funny. And the FTW was literally "guess this random staffer's name from 2 name options ?". How lazy is that ? 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8423434
ottoDbusdriver July 30 Share July 30 Thursday's show with Vinny Thomas, Maria Bamford, and Pete Holmes was pretty funny. It was the last show of the season -- back in September with new episodes. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8423535
iMonrey July 31 Share July 31 So basically we had two shows that were quite good, and two that were really, really bad. Hence my formula for watching the first segment just to see if the panel is any good - you can tell pretty quickly. Then skipping to the end if they suck. 1 1 Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8424395
AnimeMania September 3 Author Share September 3 (edited) This is the start of Season 2 although listed as a continuation of Season 1. S01.E87: September 3, 2024 Actor Thomas Lennon; actress Kimia Behpoornia; film producer Sandy Honig Premiere Date: September 4, 2024 CBS 12:37am S01.E88: September 4, 2024 Comic Guy Branum; actress Mary Lynn Rajskub; comic Kate Micucci Premiere Date: September 5, 2024 CBS 12:37am S01.E89: September 5, 2024 Comic Jordan Temple; actor Will Miles; comic Greta Titelman Premiere Date: September 6, 2024 CBS 12:37am Edited September 3 by AnimeMania Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8448130
possibilities September 3 Share September 3 (edited) My DVR picked them up as new, but when I saw the guest list I thought it was repeats and cancelled them. Now I've put them back. We'll see if the break gave them a chance to revamp some of the stuff folks have been complaining about, or if they've decided that stuff is really their best effort. Edited September 3 by possibilities Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8448303
AnimeMania September 3 Author Share September 3 I didn't really think it was important at the time but: J.D. Amato Joins ‘After Midnight’ With Taylor Tomlinson As Co-Showrunner For Season 2 J.D. Amato (Desus & Mero) has joined After Midnight with Taylor Tomlinson as a new co-showrunner on the upcoming second season. He’ll join Jack Martin who will continue to serve as co-showrunner on the CBS late-night show. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8448408
iMonrey September 12 Share September 12 It looks like they've dropped "For the Win" and eliminating a panelist. Now whoever wins Hashtag Wars is just the winner. Also the talk portion now has a real couch they sit on. The show continues to move further and further away from the original format, leaning into the talk-show hybrid formula. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8454467
Unclejosh September 12 Share September 12 I stopped watching due to the changes. Just not what I am looking for. Link to comment https://forums.primetimer.com/topic/142955-season-1-discussion/page/4/#findComment-8454542
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.