Doesn't Josh have a life and interests outside Liza and her friends? Surely he had them before they met? Isn't he in a band? Certainly two epic relationship breakdowns of those proportions would do a number on you, but Liza can't be his only friend in NYC.
7 hours ago, thesupremediva1 said:
Perspectives vary on this, to be sure, but I think he went back on this in last season's finale. He and Liza addressed that at the hotel ("I can't give you the life you want") and he told her he wants any life that includes her. Was it vague and poorly timed? Yes. But that's how I read it. And he is still, 5 seasons in, the only man to accept and love Liza for who she is - while knowing the extent of her lies. I could get behind another love interest, maybe, but the show has given us Josh and Charles as the only real menu options. One is filet mignon on screen and one's a hamburger.
When he first told Maggie that he didn’t want to lose Liza and that he only wanted Liza, he said that while the relationship was rocky and he was scared of losing Liza. Deciding to change your mind on something that is so big in a relationship while it is not going well, is not the way to do it. And then when he gave her the drunken speech in the hotel, was not great proof that he meant what he was saying, especially since he then went on to marry Clare. How can you believe him after that.
S05.E05: Big Little Liza
in Younger [V]
When he first told Maggie that he didn’t want to lose Liza and that he only wanted Liza, he said that while the relationship was rocky and he was scared of losing Liza. Deciding to change your mind on something that is so big in a relationship while it is not going well, is not the way to do it. And then when he gave her the drunken speech in the hotel, was not great proof that he meant what he was saying, especially since he then went on to marry Clare. How can you believe him after that.