Margaret
-
Posts
6 -
Joined
Content Type
Blogs
Gallery
Downloads
Discussion
Posts posted by Margaret
-
-
Where you see rating?
English is not that good for me. Anyway, this is cleary positive review. I don't see rating?
-
It's good to see some positive ones out there.
That Den of Geek one didn't seem all that positive to me, ratings wise especially.
Not Positive?
It sounds like it really shouldn’t work.
But it does.
This first episode expertly blends everything that made The X-Files what it was with a series of elements that bring it into today’s world.
And at the heart of it, of course, are Mulder and Scully. Older but not necessarily wiser, their dynamic is, like the episode itself, the same and yet different. In some ways, their interactions are the same as ever, and one or two conversations could even be taken verbatim from a number of other episodes over the years. But there is a lived-in, and a rather melancholic, quality to their relationship that is a reflection of all the years that have gone by.
Like the original pilot, this episode sets up the basics of the show in a compelling and effective way.
The X-Files is back, and that is a very, very good thing.
I've read more positive reviews than negative.
-
-
Here antoher very positive review http://pop-break.com/2015/10/15/nycc-15-the-x-files-panel/
It would be a crime to give you a spoiler review of the episode, but I will tell you that it was very well received from audience resulting in a standing ovation, and for good reason. I am very happy to say that the premiere does a great job getting us back into the world of these characters and doesn’t hold back. It comes back very strongly like a swift punch in the face. The structure of the season will revisit the two big themes that the show was built upon. Certain episodes will revolve around the alien mythology as well as stand alones that many consider to be the best of the series.
And another http://spinoff.comicbookresources.com/2015/10/15/review-the-x-files-makes-a-welcome-return-with-my-struggle/
And another http://film-book.com/tv-review-the-x-files-season-10-episode-1-my-struggle-fox-nycc-2015/
This is all new reviews :)
-
Hey guys. Sorry for my english, i'am not that good.
Look, be positive. 95% review is positive. Remember when film come out and 95% review negative or meh.
Look this http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2015/10/10/the-x-files-debuts-stellar-new-episode-and-makes-us-want-to-believe-again.htmland this http://observer.com/2015/10/the-x-files-what-we-learned-from-chris-carter-david-duchovny-and-mitch-pileggi/ and this http://www.tvguide.com/news/the-x-files-season-10-premiere-review/ and this http://www.usatoday.com/story/life/tv/2015/10/10/x-files-chris-carter-david-duchovny-new-york-comic-con/73732430/ and this http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/tvandradio/tv-and-radio-reviews/11922976/The-X-Files-first-look-review-A-fresh-take-on-this-classic-really-is-out-there.html and this http://www.mtv.com/news/2345770/the-x-files-new-episode/
Look at Cannes and reactions. 99% positive. Tv critic said is amazing. Overall, reviews/reactions is great.
My point si that even best episodes like Bad Blood or Jose Chung have negative review. Some people think that this episodes is overrated.
It will be great. Biggest mystery to me is episode 5 by James Wong. Why? Because everbody talking about Chris, Glen and Darin episodes but not Wong episode. Episode name is Founder's Mutation and nobody talking about it. Not on twiter or facebook. Where si James Wong, why not one single text said to?
Again, sorry for my english :(
-
3
-
The X-Files Revival: The Truth is in Here
in The X-Files [V]
· Edited by Margaret
Ok, let me tell you something and i hope you don't threat like CC :D again, my english is not that good.
Anyway, i don't hate anyone in real life. I'm shipper and yes, i'm angry on CC but really, this negativity on this forum is just wrong. Yes, we all don't like what CC doing in this new season but to me in my opinion CC is third best writer on show. Vince Gilligan, Darin Morgan and CC. Glen and Wong i love them but in fourth and fifth place.
In prime when CC wrote mythology, Anasazi, Duane Barry, Two Father, One Son, Paper Clip, Nisei, Redux II. To me, this all episodes is masterpieces. Bad writer can't write this episodes. Yes, he has downs in writing but he prvoe that he is great writer. Monster of the week episodes The Host, The Post Modern Prometheus, Triangle, Iresisstible. Again, to me this all episodes is masterpieces and bad writer can't write this episodes. He is not wrote only one great episode, he is wrote plenty briliant episode. On Millennium also. First season is pure gold and second season also (Morgan/Wong).
So, i don't hate CC. I'm angry on him because he split Mulder and Scully but again this is not anger when hate something.
And more thing. Mostly reviews of first episode is positive. This is fact. https://sites.google.com/site/xfrevival/
Overall, 37 positive reviews and 9 leaning towards positive.
This is review from critic who never watched series http://www.seat42f.com/the-x-files-review.html
Then from Keith, critic and fan https://twitter.com/keithuhlich/status/691332689018916864