Jump to content

Type keyword(s) to search

S04.E11: Big Girl in the Big Apple


  • Reply
  • Start Topic

Recommended Posts

My honest opinion is both of them are obnoxious in their own ways.

Has no one told Todd is he NOT a dancer?  His facial grimaces are not endearing, funny or cute.

I think its best they both stay in Greensboro.

This show is fake and fucked up.

  • Love 19
Link to comment
1 minute ago, Cherrio said:

Has no one told Todd is he NOT a dancer?  His facial grimaces are not endearing, funny or cute.

You helped articulate something that I couldn't quite figure but now can. You're right. Todd is not a dancer. He's a flail-er. He can flail his limbs with great vigor, but control? Strength? Not.

  • Love 13
Link to comment

Ok, many years ago when the earth was green I took dance  in high school .  I was..OK,.. to be nice. At no time would  I think being  a bunny was a acceptable  dance move. Is this truly  a thing? What's his face is supposed  to be doing exercise  videos , correct ? It looked like a bunch  of hopping  around to me. But I do understand  that styles  chance so this is a thing now? This is what an exercise  video  looks like?

  • Love 3
Link to comment
1 hour ago, Maggienolia said:

And Twit gettin' all offended because he wants his OWN F*ING BED???? Because she just wants to CUDDLE??? Bitch, that ain't his job. OMG I can't. I can't EVEN.

There's B-roll footage on MBFFL's FB page where Twit forces Tal into "cuddling" by a fire on a rainy day. Why she thinks either gay guy is gonna go straight for a 400# woman is beyond me. A part of how "sen-shus" she is, I guess.

I am 100% with Todd. She was selfish in not insisting he be a part of the video or politely declining since she already had other plans. She probably started in high school: blowing off a prom date if a better one came along. Scripted tho this show be, I think Todd actually does feel that Twit thinks everything has to be about her. He's said that before, just not as emphatically.

I'm rather surprised Twit was not in make-up or hair extensions for most of this episode.

7 minutes ago, crazycatlady58 said:

Ok, many years ago when the earth was green I took dance  in high school .  I was..OK,.. to be nice. At no time would  I think being  a bunny was a acceptable  dance move. Is this truly  a thing? What's his face is supposed  to be doing exercise  videos , correct ? It looked like a bunch  of hopping  around to me. But I do understand  that styles  chance so this is a thing now? This is what an exercise  video  looks like?

Dost thou not remember The Bunny Hop?

  • Love 11
Link to comment

"Having a dance career in Greensboro, North Carolina . . . "

"Having a dance career in Greensboro, North Carolina . . . "

"Having a dance career in Greensboro, North Carolina . . . "

I have to keep repeating it to myself.  Because I still can't fucking believe that she's trying to sell that line.

YOU DON'T HAVE A DANCE CAREER!!!!! YOU DON'T HAVE ANY FUCKING CAREER!!!!!

You know what people with dance careers don't have to do?  They don't have to run all over the place stealing dance moves from other people when they have a choreograph a few minutes of a dance.  You fucking fraud.  

  • Love 21
Link to comment
18 minutes ago, Dot said:

There's B-roll footage on MBFFL's FB page where Twit forces Tal into "cuddling" by a fire on a rainy day. Why she thinks either gay guy is gonna go straight for a 400# woman is beyond me. A part of how "sen-shus" she is, I guess.

I am 100% with Todd. She was selfish in not insisting he be a part of the video or politely declining since she already had other plans. She probably started in high school: blowing off a prom date if a better one came along. Scripted tho this show be, I think Todd actually does feel that Twit thinks everything has to be about her. He's said that before, just not as emphatically.

I'm rather surprised Twit was not in make-up or hair extensions for most of this episode.

Dost thou not remember The Bunny Hop?

Well now that you mention  it yes, I had forgotten  that. So what's  old is new again ?  They did it better  then.

  • Love 3
Link to comment
1 hour ago, tdanaher said:

Here we go, the Fitness Marshall workout with the big group, as filmed by his own people. You can see the TLC cameras doing their work separately. Start at 6 minutes in.

I think that's the longest I've ever seen Twit move in one continuous shot. Strange that Todd looked just fine.

  • Love 6
Link to comment
(edited)
17 minutes ago, Diamond Dog said:

I'm so bored...

They need to re-title the show, "Everyone Loves Twitney"  (This is what a delusional Twit believes to be true) . Youtubers want to film with her because its FREE publicity, not because she's a fabulous dancer. 

Firemarshall S*** is obnoxiously flamboyant. He reminds me of a gay version of the Slap Chop guy. tumblr_lfps5fygu01qbk15ko1_400.gif

OMG, yes! You've nailed it!

2 hours ago, Brooklynista said:

Well if I were him I wouldn't want her sitting on my whole left side. Friend or not.

And, given he's her BFF, he knows she rarely showers or washes her hair.

Edited by Dot
  • Love 6
Link to comment
Quote

I think one thing I'm not able to tune out? is that Whitney? says everything? like a question? like a 13 year old girl?

Yes!  Thank you.  That is a pet peeve of mine, along with saying the word "like" 12 times in every sentence and completely skipping the letter "t" (as in, "impor-unt"). 

Quote

What did Babs say? I missed it.

Whitney was remembering when she was 15 years old and went to NY on a class trip and Babs made her dress in a navy blue "Hillary" pantsuit, flats and fringe bangs when all the other kids were wearing "pleather and leopard."  Whitney said, "I looked like someone's tour guide.  How embarrassing it was."  To which Babs responded, "Well look at you now and how embarrassing that is to me!"   Yeah, I couldn't believe she said that either!  lol

  • Love 18
Link to comment
2 hours ago, Maggienolia said:

Dude. He makes his money by making people feel like they have a connection with him and therefore want to give him MORE of their money. He doesn't want to date you, cuddle you, bump nasties with you, nor marry you. Get. Over. Yourself. 

Not to mention the fact that the dude is gay...though something sorta interesting I've noticed...fat women tend to fall for gay men disproportionately (just my personal observation, in no way is this necessarily indicative of the behaviors of the general population), because they're safe...the rejection won't be because they're unattractive, it's because they're women period. So it's safe to lust after them and pretend to be interested because there's no chance and rejection is inevitable and it won't have anything to do with your appearance. I did it when I was fat. 

  • Love 8
Link to comment

I think Todd came off looking worse tonight, such petulance.  If it all scripted, he deserves a bonus for making himself look so bad.
It's strange to be on Whit's side, but hey, she got an offer that was now or never, and I thought they were going to have lunch and hang out.
I can't believe that Todd would have turned it down either.

And what's the arch that looks like Marble Arch? 

  • Love 11
Link to comment
2 hours ago, tdanaher said:

Her coat is way too small, I'm not seeing that wrong, right? She can't even close it over her front?

I noticed that as well.  She couldn't zip it or even pull it closed. It was at least 2-3 sizes to small

  • Love 2
Link to comment
2 hours ago, Brooklynista said:

Maybe I blinked but I didn't notice a camera crew or even someone with an iPhone in landscape mode.

All I saw was a very small camera on a tripod. But I looked at a couple of Marshall Earp's videos, and they don't seem to be very professional. So maybe that's all he has in the way of equipment. And no camera operator.

  • Love 2
Link to comment
2 hours ago, LocalGovt said:

I'm calling scripted bs on the whole show. As much as I'd *love* to think that was *really* Todd giving her what for, for real, it was all carefully scripted.

ITA, I think Todd may have been genuinely upset with Twit for not including him in the video because SHE was the one who engineered being in it, not the other way around.  SHE was the one who approached the fitness guy about being in one of his videos in exchange for featuring him on the show and she told HIM it was just going to be her and not Todd, which Todd may have known she did which made him even madder at her and explains his "you made this all about you" comment.   She had to know that Todd would get all pissy and throw a hissy fit over this, and how that would make good TV.  Either that or Todd was in on the whole thing with her and was putting on a big old act, although I'm not sure he's that great an actor to feign such anger.  There is not one thing on this show that isn't scripted or manufactured, IMO, except maybe stuff like what's happening with Babs in the hospital in the previews for next week.

  • Love 4
Link to comment
1 hour ago, auntjess said:

And what's the arch that looks like Marble Arch? 

Are you talking about the arch in Washington Square Park in NY's Greenwich Village?  NYC is my hometown, although I don't remember seeing that arch in this episode unless I missed it.

  • Love 3
Link to comment

The fact that she almost couldn't get into the pedicab spoke volumes.  Then Todd asked her if that was her "good knee".  So she has a "bad knee" we don't even know about?  That explains the lack of great choreography in her "dance" routines.  She may be the real reason her group didn't win the dance battle and why she is so stumped for choreography if she has to work around a knee injury/disability plus who knows what other disabilities she may have related to her weight.

Also, she referred to herself as "350 lbs."  I thought in the previous episode the scale said 364 or something like that.  Did she lose more weight or is she just rounding it way down?

Last week I predicted a lot of cab taking while in NY, which judging from what was shown was the case.  No way was she going to go up and down stairs to the subway, or even to get up on a city bus, especially with a "bad knee".  It's no wonder she has a bad knee with her weight and with all the activity she engages in.  She is a disaster waiting to happen.

  • Love 7
Link to comment
3 hours ago, LocalGovt said:

I'm calling scripted bs on the whole show. As much as I'd *love* to think that was *really* Todd giving her what for, for real, it was all carefully scripted.

Totally agree - if you show up at a Youtube Famewhore's "class" with a camera crew for your own show, how is it a surprise when you're "asked" to be in his "video"?  

And if they WERE two aspiring dancers, who just happened upon this class, and Whitney just happened to be ask to dance in it and Todd wasn't, then he WAS being a little bitch, because she DID ask about him being in it, and was told no.  But they're NOT, and this whole storyline is BULL.

3 hours ago, Cherrio said:

Has no one told Todd is he NOT a dancer?  His facial grimaces are not endearing, funny or cute.

But his blue eyes are gorgeous - I'd never noticed them before :)

  • Love 4
Link to comment

Twit is such a fucking hypocrite!  Because she's fat and Todd's skinny, he should let her win?  She, of her own no body shaming movement is essentially guilting him that because she's fat, she doesn't get any opportunities (based on this show, "opportunities" happen every week for her), so when she gets asked to participate in a lame ass You Tube video to hop around like a bunny (this is a serious "dance career", y'all), he should be happy for her rather than be upset that she's wasting precious time to go site seeing.  This is supposedly the fat fabulous life she's living?  When TLC put this crap on air, the premise was this 380 pound person enjoying life and doing things in spite of her weight.  Something has changed this season because every fucking episode so far has seemed to show her limitations because of her weight.  I don't think this episode cast Todd in a bad light.  I think it shows what we all here already know... how much of a narcissist and self-involved Twit is and he's just about had it.  I can't believe she's walking around NYC looking like a drowned rat.  If TLC has a makeup team to make her talking heads look like a million dollars, they don't have a team to make her look representable before the cameras roll?

  • Love 11
Link to comment
6 hours ago, Maggienolia said:

And Twit gettin' all offended because he wants his OWN F*ING BED???? Because she just wants to CUDDLE??? Bitch, that ain't his job. OMG I can't. I can't EVEN.

Once again a "friend" of Whitney's shows how hard it is to fake it with her.  You could tell Todd was really grossed out from her just touching him.  Kind of like the way Boo Bear was grossed out having to escort her out of the shower and rub medicine on her back.  I think the only one's on this show that really and truly care about Whitney are her parents.  She's just too full of herself to accept that nobody wants to be touched and handled by her.  It's not cute and we already know she's not embarrassed to fart in someone's presence.  I imagine Todd was really not looking forward to sharing the intimate space of sleeping in a bed with her.

  • Love 12
Link to comment

Didn't she say on FB that if she travels for business she gets two seats on a plane for herself? I would consider this trip business - TLC business and they probably paid for it anyway especially since they obtained video of her talking about the seatbelt extender.

Someone else said that Whitney has no boundaries. It was a minor thing but when she was driving to the dance battle she had her hand on Todd's neck in a really proprietary way. It's no wonder that she expected to snuggle with him in that shared bed.

  • Love 5
Link to comment
(edited)

Damn you Todd, for making me defend the Twit, who I cannot stand, but you acted like a bitchy little mean girl.  You were all pissy because Twit was making googly eyes at your stupid Fitness Marshall "idol", so when she told you she was making a video*, you just couldn't handle it.  

I'm sure that informal video took all of an hour out of their "fabulous" day.  So, nope I can't side with Todd on that one, and boy how I wanted to.

I did laugh out loud, when Todd was explaining in his TH how they were making eyes at each other.  He can be so funny.  Don't ever try to "outbitch" a gay man, not gonna happen.

Poor Todd looks so awkward and gangly when he's dancing, he has no grace whatsoever.

*Yeah, I know the video was a set-up, just go with me on this.  I actually think the whole fight was a set-up.  When they were fighting in the cab on the way to the video "shoot", they could barely keep a straight face.

Edited by Honey
  • Love 18
Link to comment
11 minutes ago, Honey said:

Poor Todd looks so awkward and gangly when he's dancing, he has no grace whatsoever.

yes, and what's with the gym class outfit of mid-calf black socks, fashion sneakers and gym trunks?

  • Love 7
Link to comment
6 hours ago, auntjess said:

I think Todd came off looking worse tonight, such petulance.  If it all scripted, he deserves a bonus for making himself look so bad.
It's strange to be on Whit's side, but hey, she got an offer that was now or never, and I thought they were going to have lunch and hang out.
I can't believe that Todd would have turned it down either.

And what's the arch that looks like Marble Arch? 

The one that was shown last night was the Washington Square Arch.  It looks like the Arc de Triomphe, in Paris.

  • Love 2
Link to comment
6 hours ago, auntjess said:

I think Todd came off looking worse tonight, such petulance.  If it all scripted, he deserves a bonus for making himself look so bad.
It's strange to be on Whit's side, but hey, she got an offer that was now or never, and I thought they were going to have lunch and hang out.
I can't believe that Todd would have turned it down either.

And what's the arch that looks like Marble Arch? 

 Todd was an embarrassment to sophisticated and classy gay men, everywhere.

  • Love 7
Link to comment
7 hours ago, Mistyfee said:

I noticed that as well.  She couldn't zip it or even pull it closed. It was at least 2-3 sizes to small

I guess that's why she was carrying her coat most of the time instead of wearing it.  Speaking of clothes, what happened to all those clothes she made a big deal of packing?

Did anyone else notice she barely made it walking up the incline on the ferry?  She said it felt like Mt Everest, or something similar.  I wonder how many times they had to stop & start filming so she could catch her breath? 

  • Love 6
Link to comment
(edited)

 Well, I think she has sunk to a new low. She ended that episode the quintessential victim! I loath victims. Todd has everything because of his fit,  fine body and she has nothing because she's fat.   Why can't Camille have this one thing???

Wait, did I miss something? The title of the show is my big fat fabulous life.   If she gets no respect, it's because she earns no respect. Yes, there are people that are going to judge her without knowing her because of her weight. That is reality.  You can't change reality, you can't  change them, the only thing you can change is yourself. The other reality is that, if this is her real personality everyone is seeing, she will get no respect once you get to know her either and that is not based on her weight!

 As I commented last week when they showed the promo  of this scene at the end, there is nothing about her situation that she cannot change. PCOS may make it difficult to lose weight, PCOS may make it easy to gain weight, but all that poundage is a result of the thousands of calories a day she has to consume to maintain it. That body is not the result of a reasonable diet.  Trust me, I know. I track my food and consume 1400 cal a day, and I still weigh 180 pounds at 5 feet 5.  Showing her nibbling on rabbit food every time they show her eating is not reality which I find ironic because supposedly this is a reality show.

She needs a big attitude change from victim to victor. Then, maybe, she can get down to a reasonable, healthy size.

Edited by Kid
  • Love 15
Link to comment
(edited)
9 hours ago, tdanaher said:

Her coat is way too small, I'm not seeing that wrong, right? She can't even close it over her front?

"Fat girl in a little coat, fat girl in a little cooaat."

Added for anyone who hasn't seen Tommy Boy: 

Edited by TurtlePower
  • Love 9
Link to comment
(edited)
9 hours ago, Me from ME said:

Someone else said that Whitney has no boundaries. It was a minor thing but when she was driving to the dance battle she had her hand on Todd's neck in a really proprietary way. It's no wonder that she expected to snuggle with him in that shared bed.

And that is the boundary issue I was previously referring to. You hit the nail right on the head. She's done it with Buddy, she did it with Lenny, and  does it constantly with Todd.  The cuddle scene last night was a prime example of it.  I thought her pathological need to cuddle went beyond the pale.

Edited by Kid
  • Love 8
Link to comment
(edited)

I have no respect for her because she has an addiction, and is not trying to get better.  If she were a heroin addict and currently shooting up, I wouldn't respect her either.  It has nothing to do with her being fat.  If she were anorexic, and refusing to get help, I would feel the same way.

Like any addict she can only deny it for so long.  She either gets help, or she dies.  It's as simple as that.

1 minute ago, Kid said:

And that is the boundary issue I was previously referring to. You hit the nail right on the head. She's done it with Buddy, she did it with Lenny, and  does it constantly with Todd the cuddle scene last night and what you pime examples of it.  However, I thought her pathological need to cuddle went beyond the pale.

I think she's searching for something she didn't get in her childhood.  Her mother is not exactly the warmest person.  When I see Babs, I feel like I am looking at the exact cause of all of her problems.

Edited by Honey
  • Love 10
Link to comment

I have not watched yet, but your comments have given me life! Bless you all! So Whitney is desperate to cuddle with Todd? Doesn't she stink to high heaven, though? She is sweaty and never showers and has sleep apnea (read: snores) so I bet she is a real gem to cuddle with all night. All I could think when reading your comments is "that bitch is THIRSTY AS FUCK and DESPERATE FOR COMPANIONSHIP." It would be sad, if she weren't so full of herself.

Maybe that's why she can't help her size, maybe she is literally overflowing with being so full of herself that it isn't fat at all. Conspiracy theory!

  • Love 11
Link to comment
5 minutes ago, Honey said:

I have no respect for her because she has an addiction, and is not trying to get better.  If she were a heroin addict and currently shooting up, I wouldn't respect her either.  It has nothing to do with her being fat.  If she were anorexic, and refusing to get help, I would feel the same way.

Like any addict she can only deny it for so long.  She either gets help, or she dies.  It's as simple as that.

I think she's searching for something she didn't get in her childhood.  Her mother is not exactly the warmest person.  When I see Babs, I feel like I am looking at the exact cause of all of her problems.

Anorexia nervosa is a psychiatric illness, not an addiction. Sorry to be particular about this but I have  a history of this illness and it's always lumped in with drug and food addicts. It has less to do with food than people think, that's just the way the disease manifests itself and keeps itself alive. It also takes over your brain to the point where it becomes its own personality within you. It has much to do with "control" issues and sustenance is a very easy thing to control--no one can force someone to eat (very simplistic explanation). Sorry to digress. Just a teeny annoyance of mine, AN is very misunderstood. Back on track.........

Whit does have some serious issues going on that probably need to be dealt with in order for her to make healthy changes that will stick.

  • Love 10
Link to comment
(edited)

Sharing a bed with her would be vom. Anyone lighter than she is (read: 99.9% of the world population) would be pulled by gravity over toward her for senshus cuddle time. Add in the lack of hygiene and what to her is heavy physical activity, and ugh. 

If the ramp to get onto the ferry is wheelchair accessible, then it can only rise one inch for every foot of length. Hardly climbing Everest. 

And big whoop, she gets picked to be in a fitness video. Didn't she make her own fitness DVDs last season? With her name on them and everything? The whole thing was two famewhores engaged in mutual masturbation. 

I liked Todd telling her off,but it looks like next week the barnacles smack him down. 

Edited by Tinfoil Hat
Clarity
  • Love 9
Link to comment
38 minutes ago, Kid said:

And that is the boundary issue I was previously referring to. You hit the nail right on the head. She's done it with Buddy, she did it with Lenny, and  does it constantly with Todd the cuddle scene last night and what you pime examples of it.  However, I thought her pathological need to cuddle went beyond the pale.

ITA, it's even creepy.  Why would she need to cuddle with her platonic friends in bed all the time?  It speaks to some unmet need she has to have fulfilled.  Todd's revulsion is natural.  She is like a bottomless pit of need with food and human contact.  She doesn't get much physical affection because she has made herself too disgusting for most people to want to go near, so she keeps eating to "compensate".  I suppose she's hooked on endorphin release, but nothing seems to satisfy her need, which sounds like it comes from some pathology, like not getting enough real affection in childhood or even PTSD from some kind of childhood abuse.  It becomes like a craving that can never be fully satisfied.

11 minutes ago, Cherrio said:

Yes!  I have been saying this all along.

Re: Babs being the cause of all her problems - This has pretty much been my mantra every week too!

  • Love 16
Link to comment
11 hours ago, Brooklynista said:

Wow, Whitney's hair is really thinking on top. Are there any treatments for some of the side effects of PCOS?

The hair thinning was really apparent last night.  I'd be totally freaking out. I know that she covered this problem in an episode in a previous season.  It looks like things are not working out with her hair care strategy.  I can't imagine.  

Okay.  From last night, I was really torn.  I kinda see it from both points of view.  I get how Todd must have felt.  No good deed goes unpunished and all that......HOWEVER, I can also see if from Whit's point of view.  It's hard to say who was really right.  I think that if you commit to your friend to do things with him, then that's what you should do.  But, if something unexpected comes up that can really benefit you, what are you supposed to do?  It's a tough call.  I would view it as a career opportunity.  That type of thing is how Whit makes her money.  That's how she got her tv show, which is her primary income.  Can she afford to ignore that?  It indirectly effects Todd too, because, he's certainly getting a paycheck from TLC AND tv time.  He was a SERVER in NY and now he's on a weekly tv show.  Not bad for someone who isn't that good at acting or dancing. lol  (Same goes for Whit.)  I think we saw Todd struggling to act as he played upset with Whit.  lol Kinda funny.  I'll just say that as a person who supports myself and has to maintain income on my own, I can't afford to forfeit business opportunities, even if my friend gets upset with me.  HOWEVER, Whit should have explained it that way and poured her heart out to Todd about how that works.  I'm not sure she understood it that way or not though.  lol She just seemed entitled.  Whit is spoiled that way.  

I believe the scenes are either re-enactments or totally staged, as I haven't heard anyone with a genuine vomit.  It has a distinctive sound and theirs are fake, imo.

With Whit's feet, I can't imagine that she would be able to enjoy much on foot in NYC.  Too painful.  She could just admit that.

My pet peeve was getting into NYC and lying in the bed!  OMG.  The same thing happened to me years ago with my then fiance.  His FIRST trip to NYC and we arrived to have him go to our hotel room and want to nap!!!!!!! Please! I don't get it.  

  • Love 7
Link to comment

Haven't seen this yet but wondering why Babs is the source of all her issues? Why is it always only the mom? She has a dad - a dad who has never been able to say no to her. A dad who thought her nude rolls jiggling around in her 'belly dancing' routine was 'beautiful'.

I think there's a team effort of dysfunction there.

  • Love 23
Link to comment
11 hours ago, okerry said:

Does she really believe that people get respect because they have a "perfect" body, and she gets no respect because she's fat? Does she really think that's why people don't respect her?

It would sure explain a lot.

She 'll get Respect when she Earns Respect. In short, Never.

  • Love 5
Link to comment
19 minutes ago, gonecrackers said:

Haven't seen this yet but wondering why Babs is the source of all her issues? Why is it always only the mom? She has a dad - a dad who has never been able to say no to her. A dad who thought her nude rolls jiggling around in her 'belly dancing' routine was 'beautiful'.

I think there's a team effort of dysfunction there.

Oh, I agree. Both parents are to blame.  

  • Love 6
Link to comment

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...