mstaken April 22, 2014 Share April 22, 2014 Hi everyone! This game seems to be more of a fan favorite than the survival game, and I aim to please :) We start with a list of episodes, characters, relationships, scenes, or whatever else we feel like. Once per 24 hour period, you'll just vote on which ones to eliminate. I tally the votes and update the list once a day. Needless to say, the game gets increasingly tough as it goes on, as it's harder and harder to decide which beloved episodes, scenes etc. you're willing to vote out. Let's start out with episodes. Should we go season-by-season or do them all at once? I'm up for either option :) Link to comment
Taryn74 April 22, 2014 Share April 22, 2014 Yay! I think we should do season-by-season. There are some sorta-good eps in the latter seasons that wouldn't have a chance against some of the more stellar eps of the earlier ones. Link to comment
mstaken April 22, 2014 Author Share April 22, 2014 (edited) There are some sorta-good eps in the latter seasons that wouldn't have a chance against some of the more stellar eps of the earlier ones. Good point! Then again, it also means that early episodes we adore will be eliminated a lot sooner than they would have if mixed in with those later seasons ;) How about we do one season at a time and then have a 'best of...' with the top 5ish episodes from each season...? Pilot The Lorelais' First Day at Chilton Kill Me Now The Deer Hunters Cinnamon's Wake Rory's Birthday Parties Kiss and Tell Love and War and Snow Rory's Dance Forgiveness and Stuff Paris is Burning Double Date Concertus Interruptus That Damn Donna Reed Christopher Returns Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers The Breakup Pt 2 The Third Lorelai Emily in Wonderland P.S. I Lo... Love, Daisies and Troubadours How sad is it that I knew this list by heart?! Er, feel free not to answer that... :) For this first round, just choose the THREE you most want to eliminate! My votes: P.S. I Lo... (argh---for your own sanity, don't get me started!) Love, Daisies and Troubadours (way too much Dean and Max) That Damn Donna Reed Edited April 22, 2014 by mstaken Link to comment
lulu1960 April 22, 2014 Share April 22, 2014 Christopher Returns Love Daisies and Troubadors PS I Lo... Link to comment
Taryn74 April 22, 2014 Share April 22, 2014 Paris is Burning Love, Daisies, blah blah P.S. shut up (Hee. I'm feeling feisty tonight.) Link to comment
mstaken April 23, 2014 Author Share April 23, 2014 P.S. I Lo...and Love, Daisies and Troubadours are history, but we have a three-way tie for that final spot among TDDR. PiB and Christopher Returns. First person to come by and cast a vote against one of those three will break the tie! (Taryn and lulu, that person can totally be YOU!) Link to comment
mstaken April 23, 2014 Author Share April 23, 2014 Aaand we're on to Round 2 :) We're still voting against three! PilotThe Lorelais' First Day at ChiltonKill Me NowThe Deer HuntersCinnamon's WakeRory's Birthday PartiesKiss and TellLove and War and SnowRory's DanceForgiveness and StuffParis is BurningDouble DateConcertus InterruptusThat Damn Donna ReedChristopher Returns---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 1Star-Crossed Lovers and Other StrangersThe Breakup Pt 2The Third LorelaiEmily in WonderlandP.S. I Lo... ---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 1Love, Daisies and Troubadours---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 1 Link to comment
lulu1960 April 23, 2014 Share April 23, 2014 The Deer Hunters The Third Lorelai Concert Interruptus Link to comment
Taryn74 April 23, 2014 Share April 23, 2014 Paris is Burning, Kiss and Tell, The Deer Hunters Link to comment
mstaken April 24, 2014 Author Share April 24, 2014 Hmmm...I'll go with Taryn: Paris is Burning, Kiss and Tell and Deer Hunters (I actually like Deer Hunters, but it's clearly doomed anyway, and I'm desperate to save Concertus and The Third Lorelai!) Link to comment
nolieblue April 24, 2014 Share April 24, 2014 The Deer Hunters Kiss and Tell Paris is Burning Link to comment
mstaken April 24, 2014 Author Share April 24, 2014 PilotThe Lorelais' First Day at ChiltonKill Me NowThe Deer Hunters---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 2Cinnamon's WakeRory's Birthday PartiesKiss and Tell---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 2Love and War and SnowRory's DanceForgiveness and StuffParis is Burning---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 2Double DateConcertus InterruptusThat Damn Donna ReedChristopher Returns---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 1Star-Crossed Lovers and Other StrangersThe Breakup Pt 2The Third LorelaiEmily in WonderlandP.S. I Lo... ---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 1Love, Daisies and Troubadours---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 1 Deer Hunters, Kiss and Tell and Paris is Burning is Gone, and the next round is open! We're down to voting against just two :) Link to comment
mstaken April 24, 2014 Author Share April 24, 2014 L&W&S (just too much icky Max) Hee---any amount of Max is usually too much Max for me :) Love and War and Snow is a weirdly mixed episode for me---there are a few scenes that I really, really love, and a bunch that I really, really don't! My votes: That Damn Donna Reed and Star-Crossed Lovers Link to comment
Taryn74 April 24, 2014 Share April 24, 2014 (edited) Hee---any amount of Max is usually too much Max for me :) Love and War and Snow is a weirdly mixed episode for me---there are a few scenes that I really, really love, and a bunch that I really, really don't! My votes: That Damn Donna Reed and Star-Crossed Lovers Yep. (It bugs me that it won't let me take the last line off inside the quote box, btw.) Edited April 24, 2014 by Taryn74 1 Link to comment
lulu1960 April 24, 2014 Share April 24, 2014 Concertus interruptus Star Crossed Lovers Link to comment
mstaken April 25, 2014 Author Share April 25, 2014 Waiting for another vote or two... :) Link to comment
mstaken April 26, 2014 Author Share April 26, 2014 (edited) PilotThe Lorelais' First Day at ChiltonKill Me NowThe Deer Hunters---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 2Cinnamon's WakeRory's Birthday PartiesKiss and Tell---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 2Love and War and SnowRory's DanceForgiveness and StuffParis is Burning---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 2Double DateConcertus InterruptusThat Damn Donna Reed---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 3Christopher Returns---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 1Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 3The Breakup Pt 2The Third LorelaiEmily in WonderlandP.S. I Lo... ---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 1Love, Daisies and Troubadours---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 1 TDDR and Star-crossed are history, and the next round is open! We're still voting against two :) My votes: Kill Me Now and Cinnamon's Wake Edited April 26, 2014 by mstaken Link to comment
mstaken April 26, 2014 Author Share April 26, 2014 It's funny how relatively few S1 episodes I'm attached to as compared to S2-S3. I like most of what's left but love only a few of them. By contrast, when we move on to S2 next, I'll be reminded of how pathetically attached I am to about 18 of the 22 episodes! Link to comment
mstaken April 28, 2014 Author Share April 28, 2014 Thanks for voting, nolieblue! PilotThe Lorelais' First Day at ChiltonKill Me Now---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 4The Deer Hunters---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 2Cinnamon's Wake---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 4Rory's Birthday PartiesKiss and Tell---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 2Love and War and SnowRory's DanceForgiveness and StuffParis is Burning---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 2Double DateConcertus InterruptusThat Damn Donna Reed---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 3Christopher Returns---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 1Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 3The Breakup Pt 2The Third LorelaiEmily in WonderlandP.S. I Lo... ---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 1Love, Daisies and Troubadours---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 1 It's time to hold a wake for Cinnamon's Wake and Kill me Now has been, er, killed by the voters. *cringe* The next round is open! We're still voting against two :) Link to comment
nolieblue April 29, 2014 Share April 29, 2014 The Third Lorelai The Lorelai's First Day at Chilton Link to comment
mstaken April 30, 2014 Author Share April 30, 2014 My beloved The Third Lorelai is gone (I'll take heart in knowing that it survived longer than I'd expected!), and Love and War and Snow has, er, been frozen right out of the game. The next round is open! We're still voting against two: PilotThe Lorelais' First Day at ChiltonKill Me Now---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 4The Deer Hunters---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 2Cinnamon's Wake---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 4Rory's Birthday PartiesKiss and Tell---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 2Love and War and Snow---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 4Rory's DanceForgiveness and StuffParis is Burning---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 2Double DateConcertus InterruptusThat Damn Donna Reed---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 3Christopher Returns---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 1Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 3The Breakup Pt 2The Third Lorelai---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 4Emily in WonderlandP.S. I Lo... ---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 1Love, Daisies and Troubadours---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 1 My votes: Rory's Dance and (sorry!) Forgiveness and Stuff Link to comment
Taryn74 April 30, 2014 Share April 30, 2014 The Breakup Part 2 and Rory's Dance It's getting hard though! Link to comment
nolieblue April 30, 2014 Share April 30, 2014 The Lorelais' First Day at Chilton Emily in Wonderland Link to comment
mstaken May 1, 2014 Author Share May 1, 2014 PilotThe Lorelais' First Day at ChiltonKill Me Now---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 4The Deer Hunters---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 2Cinnamon's Wake---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 4Rory's Birthday PartiesKiss and Tell---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 2Love and War and Snow---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 4Rory's Dance---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 5 Forgiveness and StuffParis is Burning---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 2Double DateConcertus InterruptusThat Damn Donna Reed---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 3Christopher Returns---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 1Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 3The Breakup Pt 2---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 5The Third Lorelai---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 4Emily in WonderlandP.S. I Lo... ---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 1Love, Daisies and Troubadours---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 1 Rory's Dance and The Breakup Pt 2 are history! (I'm always so torn on Breakup Pat 2---I love some scenes beyond the telling of it, but then there's the unwelcome return of Max, which...ugh.) The next round is open! This is the last time we'll vote against two... My votes: Pilot and Forgiveness and Stuff Link to comment
Taryn74 May 1, 2014 Share May 1, 2014 Yep, I guess it's come to it now. Pilot and F&S from me too. (I'm always so torn on Breakup Pat 2---I love some scenes beyond the telling of it, but then there's the unwelcome return of Max, which...ugh.) I know, right? I always have to remind myself when I'm thinking about the ep (and whether or not I like it) that it's really supposed to be more about Rory, not Lorelai and Max. Blah. Link to comment
lulu1960 May 1, 2014 Share May 1, 2014 Concertus Interruptus Emily in Wonderland. You guys are going to kill me with your F&S votes. Link to comment
cantbeflapped May 2, 2014 Share May 2, 2014 Can I jump in? Pilot Concertus interruptus Link to comment
mstaken May 3, 2014 Author Share May 3, 2014 Great to see you here, CBF!!!! Just waiting a little longer for nolieblue before ending this round :) Link to comment
mstaken May 4, 2014 Author Share May 4, 2014 Okay, so the Pilot is history, but we have a tie between CI and F&S! You know the drill... My tiebreaker vote: F&S Link to comment
cantbeflapped May 4, 2014 Share May 4, 2014 I was glad to find you guys after I'd written a sad goodbye at TWoP. I'm a little rusty on my GG episodes, but it's all coming back to me. It's Just Like Riding a Bike. :). My vote...CI Link to comment
mstaken May 4, 2014 Author Share May 4, 2014 Pilot---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 6The Lorelais' First Day at ChiltonKill Me Now---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 4The Deer Hunters---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 2Cinnamon's Wake---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 4Rory's Birthday PartiesKiss and Tell---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 2Love and War and Snow---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 4Rory's Dance---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 5Forgiveness and Stuff---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 6Paris is Burning---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 2Double DateConcertus InterruptusThat Damn Donna Reed---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 3Christopher Returns---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 1Star-Crossed Lovers and Other Strangers---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 3The Breakup Pt 2---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 5The Third Lorelai---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 4Emily in WonderlandP.S. I Lo... ---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 1Love, Daisies and Troubadours---ELIMINATED IN ROUND 1 We're down to just five! Vote for the ONE of the remaining five that you most want (or, er, least DON'T want) to be eliminated :) Link to comment
mstaken May 5, 2014 Author Share May 5, 2014 CI is history, and the next round is open! Our final four: The Lorelais' First Day at ChiltonRory's Birthday PartiesDouble DateEmily in Wonderland Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.