Season 4 Live Discussion Thread

[mtlchick 18.6k]

More clues pointing to Nick Carter as the crocodile- 6 continents in 100 hours is the whirlwind press tour backstreet boys did for the black and blue album (which happened 20 years ago this week.)  he’s also a video game fan. 
 

the “classic cult movie” - he was an extra in Edward Scissorhands.

[laschifosavita 1.3k]

One of the only things I know about Ninja is that he's played with Travis Scott and JuJu Smith-Schuster, who is a Rose Bowl champ. He also has some kind of record about scoring 5 touchdowns before turning 21, which might be what the five dimes was about.

He does sound like 50 with not as good breath control.

[dizzyd 6.3k]

Serpent still Taye Diggs to me. Seahorse for the win.

[The Crazed Spruce 5.9k]

Seahorse was sounding a hell of a lot like Jessica Simpson to me tonight.

[The Crazed Spruce 5.9k]

Ladies and gentlemen, Ken Jeong's annual Only Correct Guess.

[dizzyd 6.3k]

1 minute ago, The Crazed Spruce said:

Ken Jeong's annual Only Correct Guess.

You mean he’s guessed someone right before?

[mtlchick 18.6k]

Yeah definitely did not know who that was (or any basketball player that was mentioned.) 

[LakeGal 5.5k]

Ken guesses the basketball players.

[The Crazed Spruce 5.9k]

Just now, dizzyd said:

You mean he’s guessed someone right before?

Once per season, just to shake thing up. 🙂

[NotChristine 263]

If Nicole is right about Serpent, I have no clue who that is.

[mtlchick 18.6k]

Well she was right. 
 

 

[laschifosavita 1.3k]

This does explain why everyone was crying in the previews.

[vibeology 12.7k]

"Got us through the pandemic"? Someone needs to tell Ken we are very much still in the pandemic. Also, that's not a celebrity. Might as well get the "Wonder What's Inside Your Butthole" kid. I loved that song.

I figured the Cult Classic movie was This is the End but Edward Scissorhands makes even more sense. I still think that's Nick.

Tori Kelly does a mean Britney Spears impression. So I'm still pretty confident she's the Seahorse:

 

[LakeGal 5.5k]

I believe Broccoli will go home tonight.  Robin has already guessed he is Paul Anka.  

[laschifosavita 1.3k]

I'm ready for everyone to be on the same night. I'm having a hard time remembering clues from week to week this year. I can't even keep track of which one I think is Leann Rhymes.

Though, I was thinking that a bull was a good Peter Cetera clue until I remembered that was actually part of Mushroom's clue package so maybe having them all on one night wouldn't help.

[mtlchick 18.6k]

Good lord, how I miss Alan Thicke.  

As soon as Robin said Paul Anka, it clicked for me.  I keep forgetting that Jason Bateman is his son in law. 

[Koalagirl 5.2k]

2 hours ago, mtlchick said:

Good lord, how I miss Alan Thicke.  

As soon as Robin said Paul Anka, it clicked for me.  I keep forgetting that Jason Bateman is his son in law. 

Yes, as soon as he said Paul Anka I absolutely recognized his tone and style.  

[dvr devotee 715]

Oh man, I don't know which three I want to go through the most.

[Josh371982 1.5k]

Not a fan at all of the two remaining singers from each group battling each other. Just reeks of "We don't want all females as F3.

[laschifosavita 1.3k]

I am so glad that this doesn't have actual voting. Nick Carter wanting to give his kids a better childhood than he had would be unstoppable.

[dvr devotee 715]

Nick has always been my favorite in BSB, but I never had any clue of his actual range as an artist. I'm really impressed, and glad he's going through. I hope he wins it all, but he has serious competition in the Sun (much as I love and prefer Popcorn, I don't think she'll outperform Sun tonight). I think whoever wins in the Jellyfish/Mushroom pairing will take 3rd.

Though obviously I'm getting way ahead of myself, since there's another like...4 hours to get through before we know who wins. (Next week is a "holiday singalong," then we have a two-hour finale on the 16th.)

[Josh371982 1.5k]

20 minutes ago, laschifosavita said:

I am so glad that this doesn't have actual voting. Nick Carter wanting to give his kids a better childhood than he had would be unstoppable.

This format SUCKS. I think him and Tori Kelly both should be F3 

14 minutes ago, dvr devotee said:

Nick has always been my favorite in BSB, but I never had any clue of his actual range as an artist. I'm really impressed, and glad he's going through. I hope he wins it all, but he has serious competition in the Sun (much as I love and prefer Popcorn, I don't think she'll outperform Sun tonight). I think whoever wins in the Jellyfish/Mushroom pairing will take 3rd.

Though obviously I'm getting way ahead of myself, since there's another like...4 hours to get through before we know who wins. (Next week is a "holiday singalong," then we have a two-hour finale on the 16th.)

Love Nick but it sucks so much they did this format. Tori should be F3 bound as well 

[dvr devotee 715]

I honestly thought Jellyfish's performance tonight was better than Mushroom's, but what do I know.

[Michichick 11.1k]

I missed the first hour because I was watching something else. Has anyone been unmasked yet tonight?

[dvr devotee 715]

@Michichick nope, all three are getting unmasked at the end.

[Fostersmom 12.9k]

12 minutes ago, Michichick said:

I missed the first hour because I was watching something else. Has anyone been unmasked yet tonight?

No, they've just been announcing which is going thru and which is going home. No unmasking quite yet. 

55 minutes ago, laschifosavita said:

I am so glad that this doesn't have actual voting. Nick Carter wanting to give his kids a better childhood than he had would be unstoppable.

Is it wrong I'm hoping Nick's able to use this experience and the calling out of his parents as a therapy of sorts? I knew they really messed up their kids, all of them, but I didn't realize Nick was still holding on to so much of it. I was never into BSB, but I don't remember him as being him the wow, he's an awesome singer, guy of the group, so good on him. He's much more talented than I gave him credit for.

[mtlchick 18.6k]

14 minutes ago, Fostersmom said:

No, they've just been announcing which is going thru and which is going home. No unmasking quite yet. 

Is it wrong I'm hoping Nick's able to use this experience and the calling out of his parents as a therapy of sorts? I knew they really messed up their kids, all of them, but I didn't realize Nick was still holding on to so much of it. I was never into BSB, but I don't remember him as being him the wow, he's an awesome singer, guy of the group, so good on him. He's much more talented than I gave him credit for.

It's interesting that Nick and AJ both competed on reality shows this fall (and using the same set if I'm not mistaken!) and both have major emotional baggage.  At least AJ had his mom and grandma who supported him.  Nick has issues with his parents AND his brother Aaron.  He loves his wife and his babies so I'm hoping this was a nice outlet to get some of it out.  

 

Meanwhile....YES!  I guessed Popcorn correctly! 

 

Edit to add: never would have guessed Jellyfish but for a non singer, she's pretty good! 

Edited December 3, 2020 by mtlchick

[SnideAsides 2.7k]

2 hours ago, Josh371982 said:

Not a fan at all of the two remaining singers from each group battling each other. Just reeks of "We don't want all females as F3.

I think it's more of a Covid thing, like they want to avoid the groups mingling with each other for as long as possible (especially after filming of the Australian version got temporarily shut down after a backup dancer caught it).

They may not have realised everyone is wearing a mask.

[The Crazed Spruce 5.9k]

I've been saying all along that The Sun was Idina Mendzel, but after listening to her in that package, I'm starting to lean towards the conventional wisdom. She does sound a lot like Leann Rimes.

Still convinced that The Mushroom is Billy Porter, though.

[laschifosavita 1.3k]

That Jaden Smith guess is so bad that I don't think Robin has any right to tease Ken about his guesses.

[dizzyd 6.3k]

Everyone’s known who the sun and croc are, but mushroom has really been hard to guess. I initially guessed Billy Porter but he doesn’t have a daughter. I’m guessing Aloe Blacc. 

[retired watcher 1.6k]

1 hour ago, The Crazed Spruce said:

I've been saying all along that The Sun was Idina Mendzel, but after listening to her in that package, I'm starting to lean towards the conventional wisdom. She does sound a lot like Leann Rimes.

Still convinced that The Mushroom is Billy Porter, though.

The Mushroom has a daughter....

Crocodile is Nick Carter.

 

[retired watcher 1.6k]

Sun is Leanne Rimes.

Mushroom I have no idea.

[Kromm 28.6k]

1 hour ago, The Crazed Spruce said:

I've been saying all along that The Sun was Idina Mendzel, but after listening to her in that package, I'm starting to lean towards the conventional wisdom. She does sound a lot like Leann Rimes.

Still convinced that The Mushroom is Billy Porter, though.

Nobody would have ever referred to Idina as a Pop princess. Leann?  I suppose, if you're liberal about the use of the word "pop". 

Edited December 17, 2020 by Kromm

[Fostersmom 12.9k]

Am I nuts to think Broccoli is Lionel Ritchie? 

Edited December 17, 2020 by Fostersmom

[retired watcher 1.6k]

Just now, Fostersmom said:

Am I nuts to think Broccoli us Lionel Ritchie? 

You mean Mushroom?

 

[Fostersmom 12.9k]

1 minute ago, retired watcher said:

You mean Mushroom?

 

Oops, yes! LOL!

 

[retired watcher 1.6k]

I don't care who wins they are all so good.

[laschifosavita 1.3k]

They really aren't trying to keep LeeAnn a secret now. She released a cover of The Story as a single a few years ago.

[mtlchick 18.6k]

Now that we know that it's Nick, funny story.  

During the NKOTBSB tour, Nick's girlfriend (now wife) became BFF with Donnie's girlfriend Natalia at the time who were on and off for years.  

Then Donnie met Jenny, and dumped the girlfriend who was piiiiiiiised.  In the first episode of I Heart Nick Carter, Natalia sort of went off on Donnie, even though she never mentioned him by name.  It seems that Donnie and Nick aren't as close since then.  So for Jenny to get this one right....I have absolutely no point to this, other than "small world." 

Edited December 17, 2020 by mtlchick

[laschifosavita 1.3k]

17 minutes ago, Kromm said:

Nobody would have ever referred to Idina as a Pop princess. Leann?  I suppose, if you're liberal about the use of the word "pop". 

My guess is that she was referring to her Coyote Ugly era.

[mtlchick 18.6k]

20 minutes ago, Kromm said:

Nobody would have ever referred to Idina as a Pop princess. Leann?  I suppose, if you're liberal about the use of the word "pop". 

She got a LOOOOOT of mileage out of "Can't Fight The Moonlight" and broke a lot of Billboard records as a result. 

[retired watcher 1.6k]

I have no idea who Aloe Blacc is.

[Kromm 28.6k]

2 minutes ago, retired watcher said:

I have no idea who Aloe Blacc is.

His real name is Egbert Dawkins.  Does that help?  Heh. 

[The Crazed Spruce 5.9k]

Probably helped them about as much as it helped me....

[Fostersmom 12.9k]

4 minutes ago, retired watcher said:

I have no idea who Aloe Blacc is.

I've heard the name, but I honestly don't know who he is either. I'm off to Google, especially since he said we hear his songs in the grocery store. 

 

[The Crazed Spruce 5.9k]

Gotta say, this year, the right person won.

[mtlchick 18.6k]

Aloe is best known for this song.  Avicii was the DJ but Aloe is the one singing on the track.

 

Edited December 17, 2020 by mtlchick

[retired watcher 1.6k]

Ok then until the spring.

[laschifosavita 1.3k]

The whole grocery store thing is a bit of an exaggeration, but I think "The Man" still plays at football games sometimes.