Jump to content
Forums forums
PRIMETIMER
Athena

S05.E08: Famous Last Words

Recommended Posts

Quote

The Frasers must deal with the aftermath of the Battle of Alamance Creek.

Reminder: This is the No Book Talk topic. No discussion of the books is allowed including saying "in the books..." Posts may be removed without warning.

Share this post


Link to post

So no fakeout, but of course Roger survived.

I did not like the way they filmed the flashbacks. For a serious issue of deep trauma, I didn’t think it worked with the slapstick vibe of silent film. Richard Rankin’s portrayal of Roger’s trauma was superb however. 

Young Ian is back, looking not so young anymore! The scenes with Ian and Roger were the best part of the episode. Two of the best actors in this. Along with Marsali; never enough Marsali. 

One whole line for Fergus this week, they’re going to spoil us. 

 

Edited by ferjy
  • Like 5

Share this post


Link to post

I hated the silent picture device! 
 

I hate the way they are treating Fergus. I actually might not continue to next season because of it. Why not just kill him if they won’t give him any lines? It’s even worse now that Ian is back. They could have easily had him say something at dinner . Plus his history of having been raped and had his hand cut off would have been useful in this discussion of trauma. I am actually quite annoyed by this situation.

Sophie Skelton has a lovely voice. is this the first time we’ve heard her sing?

Nice to see Ian. I am guessing he witnessed some sort of massacre by his Mohawk family. 

Kinda tactless of Marsali to continue tarot after getting the hanged man.

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post

ROLLO!!!!!!

I loved that while everyone was tiptoeing around Roger and Ian, Marsali was her usual self and didn't treat them any differently. It was great to see her coax a laconic Ian into talking by just sitting down next to him on the porch and having a pretty one sided conversation with him until he was ready to start talking. He didn't say a ton, but he seemed a lot less reluctant than when Jamie was talking to him the night before.

Poor Bree - months of being supportive and trying to gently encourage her husband to say something, ANYTHING. She must have the patience of a saint.

Lord John continues to be the best.

It did kind of crack me up that Ian and Roger, the two people in the family who clearly don't want to talk to anyone about what happened to them, got sent off together. All the makings of a self made silent retreat! I did like that once it was just the two of them, Ian started talking more. It was probably easier since he knew Roger wouldn't ask him any questions.

Somehow Roger managed to keep Bree's paper airplane uncrumpled or bent while stomping around 5000 acres. I know it was supposed to be all moving and symbolic when he flew it off the side of a mountain but all I could think was LITTERBUG!

Edited by ElectricBoogaloo
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post

I liked the silent movie juxtapositioned with Roger's silence. He lost a big part of himself because of that trauma, and viewing it as a silent movie replay emphasized that he had no voice.  I thought it was a great choice. If they had wanted to make it camp, they would have speeded up the film and heightened the makeup.  All they did was show it in black and white with subtitles. 

One of my favorite episodes, along with last week's.  Really enjoyed the storytelling in this week's show. Once again, the show has become a must see for me and I can't wait til next week.  

 

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post

This episode was weird for me.

I didn't care for the silent movie used for the flashback. That style of filmmaking always makes me think of comedy, so using it as a visual for PTSD felt off. 

Are we going to talk about how Jemmy is aging in dog years? Marsali is still pregnant but he's running and talking? Next episode he'll be married with kids.

Speaking of which, not getting the full story on Ian's time with the Mohawk and his wife was excruciating. I just wanted to shout "Talk, dammit!." Everyone being so cagey was driving me bonkers. 

And yes, Fergus needed a bigger role in all of this. He grew up with Ian and would've been closer to him than anyone, minus Jamie. Seeing his character reduced to smoldering looks and the occasional one-liner is such a disservice. 

 

  • Like 6

Share this post


Link to post

47 minutes ago, BitterApple said:

Are we going to talk about how Jemmy is aging in dog years? Marsali is still pregnant but he's running and talking? Next episode he'll be married with kids.

 

I think that this is Marsali’s third pregnancy. We previously saw her second pregnancy 

Share this post


Link to post

I actually liked Roger's opening scene in the classroom because it showed the character is actually good at something. I'm not particularly invested in Roger and Bree, but the constant harping on how he can't hunt, shoot, whatever 'manly' thing Jamie is awesome at because he's the best at everything, is grating.

They joked around about starting a university, but there's absolutely no reason he can't, and he's qualified to do it. It's annoying he's being shoved into something he's not when he could easily find gainful work in a city. 

I've said it plenty of times, but I always stop for the theme song. I love the shot of the bison. It's just perfect. 

Huh. I was actually surprised it was Roger hanging. I figured like the rest of you that it was someone else. I actually liked that they went there. 

I think the show is missing out by not flash forwarding enough. 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post

Jocasta singing - as if I didn't like the actor enough already - swoon. 

You may not *need* land, Bree, but you can charge rent on it and make some serious money. It's 1772 or whatever, get some perspective. 

Also Jamie, Roger is working on the house. Can you not be so pissy about everything he's doing. 

I'm leaning toward liking the silent film device. I'll give them credit for trying a little something creative. It's a time travel show (sort of) you can do things like that. 

I tend to think that most tv is over-written in terms of tons of dialogue. Actors can act whether I like the characters or not. Let them do their job. So I liked the actor not talking. He was hung from a tree and only survived because his mother in law is from 1969. I didn't need anyone to tell me he's needs some therapy. I think he did a great job. I'd love some behind the scenes with him and the director how they crafted it all. 

Also Bree, get a fucking grip. Claire, *the war veteran*, correctly understands what ptsd is. How about not harping on Roger to actually talk? Given what he's been through it's probably good that's really it. That's great you were able to deal with your trauma (which was not your fault at all in any way) but it's Roger's fault he can't deal with it the same, so, please do yell at him more. 

Edited by DoctorAtomic
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
1 hour ago, BitterApple said:

Marsali is still pregnant

She’s pregnant again. 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
12 hours ago, nara said:

Kinda tactless of Marsali to continue tarot after getting the hanged man.

Also kind of obtuse on the show's part. The hanged man got hanged and gained wisdom. 

I'm amazed Ian could find their house. I mean, sure, I got around before google maps, but there were actual signs posted on the road. 

Edited by DoctorAtomic
  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post

12 minutes ago, DoctorAtomic said:

Also kind of obtuse on the show's part. The hanged man got hanged and gained wisdom. 

I'm amazed Ian could find their house. I mean, sure, I got around before google maps, but there were actual signs posted on the road. 

Ian helped Jamie survey Fraser Ridge last season for protecting the legal title, so he would know how to get back to the cabin, but he ran into Jamie Claire and Jemmie and killed the boar.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post

I'm not calling bs. Just making a jovial quip. 

Them singing over the credits was cute af, but wow nursery rhymes are dark.

Edited by DoctorAtomic
  • Laugh 3

Share this post


Link to post
19 hours ago, ferjy said:

Young Ian is back, looking not so young anymore! The scenes with Ian and Roger were the best part of the episode. Two of the best actors in this. Along with Marsali; never enough Marsali. 

One whole line for Fergus this week, they’re going to spoil us. 

Richard Rankin is quite a fine actor and this episode really highlighted it. 
 

I liked that Marsali spoke of how she missed her Mom and sister. I’m sure she thinks about them. Making the choice to marry Fergus and go the Americas was a huge decision, even with a husband and kids it’s only natural to think of her Mom and sister. 
 

Fergus should have more of a storyline than he’s been given. I want Cesar (the actor that plays him) to keep getting a full time paycheck🤣

1 hour ago, Haleth said:

She’s pregnant again. 

No I think this is the same pregnancy. She was visibly showing when the battle happened and 3 months later she’s very large and the child almost due- that’s the same pregnancy. This is her third child with Fergus. 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
2 hours ago, BitterApple said:

This episode was weird for me.

Speaking of which, not getting the full story on Ian's time with the Mohawk and his wife was excruciating. I just wanted to shout "Talk, dammit!." Everyone being so cagey was driving me bonkers. 

And yes, Fergus needed a bigger role in all of this. He grew up with Ian and would've been closer to him than anyone, minus Jamie. Seeing his character reduced to smoldering looks and the occasional one-liner is such a disservice. 

 

Not sure I liked it either. It was such a depressing episode! I was so excited Ian was back, but he's not the old Ian, (which brought much needed joy to season 4). I hoped he'd bring back a wife! Guess not. Fergus needs more than 1 line per episode! Perhaps we will see Ian & Fergus in an upcoming episode? Roger's time in the 1700's has sucked, I think I would have been heading back to 1970something, with or without the wife & kid! I know I say that I understand Claire going back, because come on- that is where she belongs, she is capable, & resilient. I hope he finds success soon. Rik gets the actor of the week award! 

Edited by Cdh20 · Reason: adding a thought!
  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
13 minutes ago, Scarlett45 said:

Richard Rankin is quite a fine actor and this episode really highlighted it. 
 

I liked that Marsali spoke of how she missed her Mom and sister. I’m sure she thinks about them. Making the choice to marry Fergus and go the Americas was a huge decision, even with a husband and kids it’s only natural to think of her Mom and sister. 
 

Fergus should have more of a storyline than he’s been given. I want Cesar (the actor that plays him) to keep getting a full time paycheck🤣

No I think this is the same pregnancy. She was visibly showing when the battle happened and 3 months later she’s very large and the child almost due- that’s the same pregnancy. This is her third child with Fergus. 

I liked that Marsali missed her ma & sister but I love that she loves this family she has now! 

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post

I have no concept of time on this show (to be fair, I don't know that the show has a concept of time).

I keep thinking Ian lost a child, with his comment to Marsali about bairns, but I have no idea if enough time has passed to make that a possibility. 

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post

1 minute ago, sab85 said:

I have no concept of time on this show (to be fair, I don't know that the show has a concept of time).

I keep thinking Ian lost a child, with his comment to Marsali about bairns, but I have no idea if enough time has passed to make that a possibility. 

I think Ian has been gone for 12-18 months

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
41 minutes ago, sab85 said:

I have no concept of time on this show (to be fair, I don't know that the show has a concept of time).

I keep thinking Ian lost a child, with his comment to Marsali about bairns, but I have no idea if enough time has passed to make that a possibility. 

The timeline is really wonky.  In S4, Ian was left with the Mohawk right before Brianna gave birth. Assuming Jem is around two and a half, that would leave enough time to marry and have a child. 

 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post

We know from 607 that the battle of Alamanac was in 1771, and referencing Jamie’s 50th birthday it was in May. The PTSD scenes shown began three months later, but not all in a day, with Aunt Jocasta and Lord John having both visited. So young Ian likely returns in the autumn of 1771.

The Fraser’s trip to rescue Roger took several months each way last season, And Roger took a detour on the return trip plus there are the events of this season before the battle. My educated guess given distances and times, is those events wow in 1769 to 1770. 

So I think Ian was with the Mohawk around two years.

  • Like 2
  • Useful 1

Share this post


Link to post
9 hours ago, Cdh20 said:

Roger's time in the 1700's has sucked, I think I would have been heading back to 1970something, with or without the wife & kid! I know I say that I understand Claire going back, because come on- that is where she belongs, she is capable, & resilient. I hope he finds success soon. Rik gets the actor of the week award! 

I keep thinking the same thing, how is Roger not insisting on going back after all he has lived through? The past has not been kind to him and the war is coming. I think their kid is old enough to tell them if he hears the stones' buzzing. Time to go!

 

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post

Initially, I was pulling a face at using a silent film motiff to illustrate Roger's obvious PTSD, but as the episode unfolded, I think it was a quite brilliant choice.

Someone going through the kind of trauma Roger experienced - literally almost losing his life - and losing his voice, tends to compartmentalize their trauma or make it something more palatable for their brain to comprehend.

He used his memories of the silent film festival he went to with Bree in the then-present to help shape and massage the near-death so he could try to begin to cope with what happened.

And as time wore on, more details appeared in that silent film "footage" (memory) until eventually, as he became more distanced but still traumatized from the immediacy and began to find his voice again, the film changed from its initial incarnation as silent and black and white to a very vivid film with sound and color

It was only then that that he really, truly began to process all that had happened and might have happened and began the real unpacking that it takes to heal (not get over) from something of this magnitude.

I absolutely loved seeing Ian back again. He has been missed. He was exactly the perfect person to be paired with Roger on the surveying expedition. One of my favorite moments of the entire series was when Roger, correctly deducing that Ian was suicidal, having brought himself back from the brink of that cliff and the longing to heave himself over it, kicked that can of hemlock off of the fire. 

I enjoyed Marsali's conversation with Ian and agree that her talking to Ian like she always has made him relax and open a tiny crack. I still want to know what the hell happened during his time with the Mohawk. And I want more of Fergus dammit!

Elsewhere, loved Jocasta's song for her departed lover, Murtagh. She has a lovely voice as does Bree.

Speaking of Bree, Sophie continues to grow on me, she has ever since the rape episode and its aftermath. I could feel the desperation in her voice as she pleaded with Roger to come back to her. And her reminder that she, too, went through hell and wanted to die (and sometimes still does). 

I also enjoyed the cuteness of Claire and Jamie playing hide and seek with Jem.

3a40ce2471fff06d90237ed6b3799be160bd44f4

And Claire and Jamie getting ready for bed. 

d7fc0b5ecf120be1d584c8429c7f4e8db3646304

Sometimes, it's the quiet moments that really resonate.

  • Like 7

Share this post


Link to post
11 hours ago, sab85 said:

I have no concept of time on this show (to be fair, I don't know that the show has a concept of time).

I noticed too, but they have 'real life' things happening, like the battle last week to fix points in time on the show, so I thought it was deliberate on the show's part. 

3 hours ago, Lola82 said:

I keep thinking the same thing, how is Roger not insisting on going back after all he has lived through? The past has not been kind to him and the war is coming. I think their kid is old enough to tell them if he hears the stones' buzzing. Time to go!

I'd give him a little slack for a few months because, but I would think he's got to bring up the issue. At the least, just confirm whether the child can hear the stones because that's going to inform the decisions. If he's not going back (forward), I'd like to see him take some agency and try to find gainful employment (opening a school, whatever). 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post

12 hours ago, sab85 said:

I have no concept of time on this show (to be fair, I don't know that the show has a concept of time).

I keep thinking Ian lost a child, with his comment to Marsali about bairns, but I have no idea if enough time has passed to make that a possibility. 

Yes enough time has passed. When Ian went to live with the Mohawk Brianna was in the last days of her pregnancy. That baby is now 18months-2yrs old. From Ian’s words I too thought maybe he fell in love and lost a wife/child in the birth. He then went on to tell Roger than he fell in love, maybe she had to marry someone else (cause he said she isn’t dead but lost to him). 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
16 hours ago, DoctorAtomic said:

I'm not calling bs. Just making a jovial quip. 

Them singing over the credits was cute af, but wow nursery rhymes are dark.

lol Or lullabies. Just listen to the lyrics to Rock-a-Bye Baby. Dollars to doughnuts it was written by a parent who was up all night with their sweet little devil for the past week. 😀

 

  • Laugh 2

Share this post


Link to post
On 4/12/2020 at 6:54 AM, ElectricBoogaloo said:

Somehow Roger managed to keep Bree's paper airplane uncrumpled or bent while stomping around 5000 acres. I know it was supposed to be all moving and symbolic when he flew it off the side of a mountain but all I could think was LITTERBUG!

And all I could think when she was making the paper airplane was that the sheet of paper looked way too much like your typical 8 1/2 x 11 sheet of printer/copier paper from an office supply store.

  • Like 7

Share this post


Link to post
3 hours ago, CarpeFelis said:

And all I could think when she was making the paper airplane was that the sheet of paper looked way too much like your typical 8 1/2 x 11 sheet of printer/copier paper from an office supply store.

I thought that too!!!

Share this post


Link to post

I really like the opening music this season.  McCreary does an excellent job with the music.  I liked the device of using a silent movie for the flashbacks.  

Honestly, for awhile I thought Claire was going to be running an insane asylum for Roger and Ian.  Glad Roger saved Ian from himself, and in doing so, helped himself begin to heal.  Like others must have, I first thought Roger had taken the hemlock to use.

Oh My Darling Clementine took me out of the time period.  The gold rush of 1849 is a good 75 years or so after the colonial period.  Did like the sweaters for jumpers exchange.

Share this post


Link to post

On 4/12/2020 at 9:54 AM, ElectricBoogaloo said:

Poor Bree - months of being supportive and trying to gently encourage her husband to say something, ANYTHING. She must have the patience of a saint.

Five minutes with that nimrod, pathetic Roger and ANYONE is a saint. I am so bummed he walked out of his ordeal. Ugh.

Share this post


Link to post
On 4/19/2020 at 11:49 AM, DoctorAtomic said:

Yes, but Bree and Roger would know the song from growing up in the 20th century. 

I’d love it if someone overheard the song and asked “what’s a forty-niner?” 

Share this post


Link to post

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...

Customize font-size