I was coming on the site to comment on the horrible costuming, but I see folks have beaten me to it. After looking forward to the Season 2 premiere, I was dismayed to find that the costuming took me out of the program so much that I could not enjoy it.
In many scenes, it appeared that they had taken some care with the costumes of the leads, but other characters were dressed as if someone had gone thrift shopping. In the scene in which the three sisters were descending the stairs---the BIG moment---Elizabeth was wearing a dress from the time period. Julie was clothed in a prom dress from the 2000's----like all of the ones on the rack at Goodwill. Elizabeth's mother's dress had a deep slit in the back of the skirt, and when she walked, her leg was visible--no petticoat or boots, just stage shoes like any high school production would have issued. The overcoats of the women in Coal--Hope--Valley were so terrible that I found myself fixated on how Hallmark could mount a production with such low production values. This is touted as their 'much-anticipated return of their epic series.' It looked like someone sent out an email that said, 'bring your long dresses and coats, we'll take it from there.'
I know it is a silly thing to fixate on, but it took me so far out of the program that I couldn't enjoy the two hours. When Elizabeth and her sisters sauntered down the streets with their shopping bags, complete with the stickers on the outside, it was too much.
The hair has been covered elsewhere. The choice to have the women of Coal Valley sport a casual hairstyle is appropriate, I imagine, but putting up her hair was a girl's rite of passage, and the Thatcher girls would have had people to dress their hair each day, especially for evening.
OK, enough. Enough. Down from the soapbox. Urgh...