Bunsout4chica

Does anyone else have the theory that jay and possibly Jen killed Hae. Everyone keeps asking how would jay know all of this? Why would he implicate himself of it weren’t true? But if Jay had killed Hae then a lot of those questions will automatically be answered. So January 13th is Stephanie’s birthday Anad got her a gift and her own boyfriend (Jay) didn’t so he (just trying to be a good friend) uses his free period to help/ make sure he gets her a gift because as she had said to Adnan she really hopes her boyfriend got her something, but she feels like he didn’t. Adnan goes to Jay’s house and lends him, his car then gets dropped back off for school. Then they say Hae had originally agreed to give Adnan a ride after to school but something mysteriously takes priority over that and a lot of speculation says someone who wasn’t at school must have paged her and agreed to meet up with her after school before she picked up her niece. Jay very well could have paged her he didn’t go to school there anymore and he could have proposed to her that he needed help with Stephanie's gift or something along those lines because Hae and Stephanie were friends. What’s the motive? It has been said a lot through Serial that Adnan and Stephanie were very close and even dated at the end of 8th grade, but also in middle school Stephanie and Jay dated. Obviously they broke up when Adnan and Stephanie dated at the end of 8th grade and got back together in high school up to the times in question. It is also said that Adnan and Stephanie were very flirty (until him and Hae got together I’m guessing) but it’s said she would give him kisses, sit on his lap,and put her arms around him. It’s never clarified if this was during the time that her and Jay were currently together. Then there is also the prom court which happened to be Adnan and Stephanie. This could have been something that made Jay fester inside because all this time that Adnan and Stephanie have been such close and good friends which is also the time Stephanie and Jay have been dating and they never close for that many years they’re still casual acquaintances. I think he was jealous of Adnan. Mr. cool, handsome, popular, success, the golden boy who his girlfriend is a little too close with while he is the loner, outcast kid who doesn’t fit in and sells drugs kind of a outsider to the group looking in with his only real connection to these people being Stephanie because none of his friends are friends with them and vice versa. Jen openly says she didn't even like Hae and that she thought she was dittsy and stuck up and then lied to claim she didn’t even know who she was having graduated the year before. So after Adnan and Hae broke up, and Adnan was now single maybe he was worried about Stephanie leaving him for Adnan people have said that her parents didn’t approve of Jay but they liked Adnan maybe Stephanie wanted to get with Adnan after they danced breifly at prom but he was with Hae now and then when they broke up it was a possibility so Jay stepped in to make sure he didn’t lose Stephanie. It was said how important she was to Jay that she was his only good thing and he would do anything not to lose her. So maybe that was killing Hae, taking someone that Adnan truly loved and then framing him for her murder.It was probably a lot easier then he expected he just changed some facts around that implicated himself to Adnan and the cops just believed and jumped on the theory and altered it till it backed a believable story that casted enough reasonable doubt on Adnan. And I think Jen would have helped with this Jen and Jay seem to be the two most bizarre people in this case that consistently lie and fail to make sense, they both seem like they’re covering for someone possibly each other also, they both are a huge part of the others story they are each other’s alibi at one point claiming to be at Stephanies but later that shows to be false because Stephanie wasn’t even home like they claimed. Everything the Jay claims Adnan did that just doesn’t make sense would make sense if it was Jen and it would also make sense why the police investigated/ interiagated both Jen and jay first and jay and Jen both came forward first about the murder they have been documented to being together all through out the day that Hae was murder even during undisclosed time. They both are lying, they both we’re together, they were best friends, they both were kinda shady, and jay felt like he could come to Jen about this and she didn’t go to the cops and even helped drive him to get rid of evidence and still seemed like she was holding back evidence during her interrogation playing dumb almost.When this was said about about Jay and Adnan, “why would Jay help Adnan they weren’t even good friends?” it didn’t make sense but when it’s Jay and Jen it makes more sense and Adana is the perfect victim he is Muslim which a lot people have such harsh stereo types about, also the prosecutor brings up a similar case about another boy who is muslim implicating that Adnan might try to flee stating that there is a ongoing problem with Muslim people fleeing back to their country to avoid conviction which simply was a lie. Which she had to redact and apologize for. He’s her ex boyfriend who is charming and seemingly a perfect kid. Jay didn’t go to school with them, Jay wasn’t friends with them, Jay doesn’t have a alibi, he knew what happened to her and where it happened, he knew where her car was, he had the phone, and the shovels,he’s constantly lying and covering up for someone else that’s not Adnan that’s why the story doesn’t make sense think about it. Also years later neither of them want to talk about it except for one brief short interview. Another thing is when Jen came to give her official on the record statement she said she told Jay she was coming to tell the cops and he said just don’t say anything to incriminate her send them to him. If Jen was such a good friend and possibly had feelings for Jay enough to be a accomplice to murder, he probably would risk incriminating himself for her and in the end neither rod the two people who knew the most about this, had the most answers and even aided and abetted to the crime got any jail or prison time walked away Scott free. The perfectly imperfect crime, that they got away with.