Most of you won’t remember, but writers didn’t adress something major. First of all in episode 1 Tony is burning a page along with the note Hannah left behind with the tapes and later we found out in the next episodes that Ryan maybe has given it to him. Also when Ryan was on trial we get to see a flashback in which Ryan was at Hannah’s house and he steals 2 pages from her diary, the one is the poem Ryan had published and the other maybe was the page he gave to Tony and burned it. ( It’s not clear if that was the specific page Ryan gave to Tony but we get to assume it ). And most importantly Ryan visits Hannah’s home and Olivia had been reading again Hannah’s diaries in which Hannah mentions the Clubhouse and someone wearing a leather Jacket. Olivia assumes that the guy with the leather jacket was Justin and she asks Ryan about it, and he replies “he could be”. In the same episode Tony says to Justin “don’t you dare puke on my leather jacket because I’ll kick your ass”
I am sure Tony is hiding something and Ryan knows about it, considering the meeting they had after Ryan’s testimony where Ryan tells him that he said nothing about him on court.
What do you think??
