Jump to content
Forums forums


  • Content Count

  • Joined

Posts posted by db2202000

  1. Vendetta being one of Briscoe's last episodes, Orbach already being sick, I am wondering if they wrote the lack of interaction that way deliberately to reduce his screen time. Daniels was Green's friend as well, and we know Green has done (and will do) some ethically questionable things himself over the course of the show. So yes Green was likely not hard enough on him, but probably a combination of the personal relationship and understanding the instinct as a cop (if not condoning it). I'm trying to remember Amends, I believe the case in Amends was re-opened independent of the detective, Brannigan just happened to get a chance to rectify things. He could have taken the secret to his grave and let the killer go free forever without that intervention. He still denied justice for almost 20 years, 20 years of pain for the victim's family, that can't be ignored. What I think is the stronger mitigating factor is that it was the corruption of his superiors that sparked the subterfuge. He may have even felt fear for his safety from them and/or the Sarno family had he decided to continue to pursue the original case despite their objections (in addition to torpedoing his career). So of course the situations are not identical, but it's the closest parallel I could think of on the show with Briscoe involved.

    • Like 1

  2. Interesting point, what that reminds me of is Amends, where Briscoe eventually forgives his cop friend who acquiesced to his superiors and concealed evidence to let the killer go free for almost 20 years in exchange for a promotion. Initially as I recall, yes, Briscoe was angry when he deduced this is what had happened, so he pressed the cop to come clean, and when he did he forgave him. 

  3. 5 hours ago, Xeliou66 said:

    Greevey was a douche period. He acted superior to Logan, was extremely condescending, his moralizing was very irritating, and I wanted to punch him in Life Choice for his obnoxious comments on abortion. It was good that Greevey was killed after 1 season and was replaced by the much better Cerreta, Greevey dragged down the show.

    What's your ranking of the senior detectives? 

  4. 36 minutes ago, Xeliou66 said:

    Privileged was another episode with a very boring and predictable second half, and yeah in Act of God the detectives and DA’s didn’t seem to be properly prepared and any decent defense attorney should’ve gotten Hank Chappel acquitted. Like I say, I did find the plot of Virtue interesting and thought it had some of season 5’s best courtroom stuff, and I liked Competence for Van Buren. 

    I don’t care for Damaged either, I disliked the whole plotline about Briscoe’s daughter and Judge Wright enrages me, but it isn’t my least favorite ever. The episode that I curse it’s existence is Aftershock.

    Ha, yes, I recall from the other board that you hate Aftershock. I do not like Aftershock either, it was much more effective when they weaved in elements of characters' personal lives into the stories rather than focusing on the characters' lives as the story. Like when Swann mocks Ben Stone's divorce in American Dream and angers him, that was a good way to note Ben's personal life in a way that didn't become the plot itself, but furthered it. 

    • Like 3

  5. 5 hours ago, Xeliou66 said:

    I’m not a big fan of season 5 either, a lot of the episodes felt very boring for some reason, there didn’t seem to be as much courtroom stuff in this season, and the stories just seemed rather boring and bland, predictable and uninteresting. I thought McCoy’s intro was fine and I liked him just as much as Stone, but I just thought the stories were a bit weaker this season.

    Purple Heart is the best of the season I agree, great vintage L&O with some awesome legal maneuvering, but I agree Switch sucked, nothing happened in the second half at all. I don’t like Second Opinion either, it’s portrayal of alternative cancer treatments was laughably negative and over the top, Seed was incredibly boring and didn’t feel like an L&O case, I usually don’t watch it either. I liked Virtue, I thought the case was unique and interesting, I loved McCoy’s closing argument (the first closing argument we saw from McCoy in the series BTW) and there were some funny lines from Schiff and McCoy. White Rabbit was pretty cool in how Bill Kunstler played himself, only time they ever had a real defense lawyer play himself, some good legal stuff in that one. Competence was a good episode for the always awesome Van Buren. Why did you dislike those episodes?

    Competence and Virtue I wouldn't say I actively disliked, I just wasn't interested in the plots. They're not an episode like Damaged where I curse that it was ever brought into existence. White Rabbit I will agree with you that having Kunstler there was interesting (sadly he was dead by the next season) and they had some interesting elements of the plot. I'd say I more actively dislike Privileged and have issues with Act of God (defense lawyer had to be completely incompetent not to create reasonable doubt in the first trial).

    • Like 1

  6. Perhaps unpopular opinion: I dislike Season 5. It's my least favorite of the first 10. I'm a Ben Stone guy, it feels like he should still be there and I am not a fan of the ladies man version of Jack McCoy. Yes, it was subtle with him and Claire for 2 seasons, but it did nothing for me. Logan was getting stale in the junior detective role and it was the right call to go another direction (feelings about the Curtis character notwithstanding). But mostly the episodes were really not that strong in my opinion. Purple Heart's my favorite, but then it's followed by Switch, which I hate. Second Opinion, White Rabbit, Competence, Virtue, Seed, all episodes I don't watch if they are on. 

    • Like 4
  • Create New...

Customize font-size