Not sure which sisterhood you mean, but most posters here find Carrie pretty annoying much of the time. So welcome aboard! And yeah, Carrie with Berger was a disaster-in-the-making from the get-go. She acts like a school girl when she sees him on the street before their first date because she's not wearing "perfect date" clothing (but she was OK inflicting the horrendous get-up she had on upon the unsuspecting public), she complains about their having bad sex when all she does is lie there like an inert piece of codfish, she makes Berger face a verbal firing squad of her "friends" (I would have loved to see the counterpart of Carrie having to pass a similar test with Berger's friends), she doesn't even buy a copy of his book but instead waits for him to give her a copy and then fixates on the one flaw she finds in it, and then the Charlotte incident. Ugh. Berger had his issues, plenty of them, but I ultimately disliked Carrie with him more than I disliked him. They were like two overgrown kids pretending to have a mature relationship.