I always thought Paige looked the worst the year that she, Veronica, and Hannah were in trouble for weight. I believe she had actually had the most weight gain at 13 pounds. She was really jiggly in the midsection and her face was noticeably puffy. I know there were rumors that she was going through her divorce so they went a little easy on her. She ended up getting back in shape, and for a while I thought she was actually dangerously skinny.
I can’t comment on whether Paige looked worse than Selina did this year until I see the footage on the show. Honestly I can’t tell that Selina looked as bad as everyone is saying she did from the limited video footage and pictures we’ve seen. Not saying she wasn’t heavier than she should have been, but I just need more video/photo evidence to get a better read on it.